>Just make sure you can get a new 5' tub in the space. I replaced one once and we had to remove a door hinge and muscle it in. I put in a 3-piece wall unit and I'm not crazy about mine. It just doesn't feel solid. I'm planning to remove it and tile a new surround this coming year.
I put a new bathroom in my basement this past year and I tiled the surround. It was certainly cheaper material-wise and it's a whole lot nicer looking.
My neighbor (a plumber) advised putting mortar underneath the new tub to make it feel solidly planted........but not a bed of mortar, he thinks its too hard to seat the tub and it has a tendency to float upwards. He advised dollops of mortar every 6-8"
In the new bathroom, I used the fiberglass tub by Sterling (a Kohler Co.) sold at Lowes for about $225. I like it.
>I gutted my bathroom this past summer. I installed a Sterling tub and matching 3-piece surround.
Here's my advice:
1) The floor under the tub needs to be dead flat and level. I ended up shimming (hardwood only!) to make sure all of the "feet" of the tub were level.
2) The walls need to be plumb and square for the surround to fit correctly. Again, I ended up adding shims and spacers to get my horrible walls into shape.
3) Absolutely do put mortar under the tub. The instructions said that this was optional and so I didn't do it. Now, the tub squeaks when I use it. I have injected mortar (don't ask how) under the front half (access plate side) and still need to cut a hole in the drywall of my living room to inject the other side.
I've replaced my tubs a couple times in different houses. I used a steel tub which was enameled. It looked great until a kid chipped the enamel. The last time I did it we went with a fiberglass shower enclosure which has all the handgrips and shelves molded in. Also has a couple seats as needed for an older user to choose from. Or a younger user who enjoys company. :<) The enclosure replaced the bathtub entirely. We really like it. Its mounted on a wet bed, and was installed by my #3 son who is a contractor. We had to bump out a bedroom wall to accommodate the depth of the enclosure. I need to re-do the 2nd floor bath and am going with a molded tub and shower enclosure out of fiberglass. Its practical for me as it eliminates all the hassle of tile work and never ending caulk and grout work.
>You can get the tub refinished in place. I don't recall the cost, but the tub my mother had done looked great and is still going after about 8-9 years.
If you bust up the old tub use a 20# sledge and wear hearing protection and goggles as the ceramic chips will fly. And your neighbors 3 doors away will hear the noise. DAMHIKT.
>One piece tubs are better to look at and clean, but normally are the first thing on the floor of a new house, then walls are built up around it. Might have a problem getting it in without major house tear up. I think that's where the 2-3 piece units become usefull.
When breaking up the old tub, remove any carpet, cushions & other fabric stuff. You'll have a lot of flying enamel to contend with. Did one several years ago. Found the weak spot to be the drain. Start pounding there to split the tub in half. Goes easier after that first "incision".
>My neighbor replaced a fiberglass tub with a cast iron one and a tile surround. Locally considered much classier than fiberglass. He decided to squirt some Great Stuff foam under it to spread the weight out across the floor a bit. Just a dab here and there. it picked the tub up and tipped it out of level. Took us several hours to cut the foam out. So, don't do that. I bet it would warp the bottom in a fiberglass unit and break it.
>I have replaced a few tubs and I always put insulation between the tub and the wall that gets no heat and on the ends. This does 2 things, 1. Deadens the sound 2. Keeps the water warmer.
>I can't speak to putting a new one in, but I do have a one off experience in “dismantling” a cast iron one. As Lee said, it's noisy. And the first few hits won't do much (plus, watch for bounce-back—sledges in shins are no fun), but once you have a fracture, things go quickly. Get yourself good and worked up about something (go read a few of my posts) then go to work—it's great therapy.
You will also be amazed at how heavy even one square foot of cast iron can be. Don't even think you're going to load up a 26 gallon garbage can to transport!
I also agree with a mud bed for the new tub. I would think the traditional dry mix mud job ought to be just the right material (about a 1-1 mix of a sand-mix concrete and plain sand, and very dry). Load the tub with water after setting it in to apply even pressure.
I've put in fiberglass tubs, acrylic, cast iron, enameled, and a clawfoot or two (way too heavy but very sexy). I'm really not a fan of the synthetics. They go in very easily if you've done your prep work correctly. As others have said, everything dead level and plumb, set in a mortar base (put down felt paper to protect the subfloor before you pour the mortar). My problems with them are twofold. One comes with maintenance. Can't really give'em a good scrubbing and if you happen to drop something like a screwdriver or wrench on an unprotected surface it's a guaranteed chip. Synthetics also don't hold the heat so if you want to soak in a nice hot tub you have to keep adding hot water.
Kohler makes an inexpensive and relatively lightweight cast iron tub. I believe it's the cadet. I've installed several and can handle it by myself and I'm not that big. For shims you need to use metal. Wood will crush over time. I usually don't smash the old tub to pieces (cover with an old moving blanket and relieve your frustrations with a 16lb sledge). Since I work alone, I find it easier to deconstruct the bathroom/tub area and then slide it out on a moving blanket and hardboard.
When it comes to surrounds I'm a bit of a purist and almost always go for ceramic tile. Pulled down way too many f-glass and acrylic surrounds to find rot, despite people's best intentions to keep the thing well caulked. You've also got to make sure you can get the thing into the room. If you don't want to deal with cement board there is a great waterproofing system made by Schluter that installs directly over regular drywall. You then tile over that.
Hope my ramblings helpful. Sorry for the length and feel free to contact me off-list if you like.