Re: My Humble Opinion (very long)
Larry Clinton
>"I want to figure out what the "Cut off point" is. I want to work wood reasonably efficiently, not devote my life to sharpening to the point the tools never touch wood. Unless there is something to be gained I don't want to get into the moment of Zen between me and the stones."
First - congratulations, you have already came to the right decision as to the amount of sharpening required. I have heard some people that think a chisel or plane can't be used unless they can get a very close shave with it. I do not find this at all necessary for most (if any) woodworking tasks.
First, the only thing you are trying to do is to remove material from the tool to bring two adjacent sides to an invisible point. A few years ago (ok, about 55 years), I watched a good craftsman working on our home sharpen his chisel on the concrete step then finish it on an Arkansaw stone. Guess no one had told him he needed waterstone's, grinders, or special tools. He did this in less than 5 minutes and the tool worked very well. I am an old FaXX, and have tried just about every method (Scary sharp, waterstone's, oilstone's and the concrete step). Guess what? All of them work pretty well. Some are faster, some messier, some more expensive, some take longer, but all work. Also it depends on what your going to do with the tool. I have a set of LN chisels I use for paring only. I do keep those very sharp as the surface I am paring often affects the appearance of the item I am building. If I am just roughing out a hole I may use a chisel right off the grinder.
"There seems to be a spectrum of sharpening opinions here. Some people throw away small dull drill bits and buy new ones. Some buy a Drill Doctor and some learn to sharpen them on a grinder."
I do a little of all three, I have an old B&D drill sharpener (bought at an auction for about $10), I do use it on some small bits (can't see quite as well as I used to). Unless they just wanted the tool I doubt a woodworker could really justify the cost of the drill doctor. You don't need the high quality bits to drill wood, and you can buy several sets of bits for the cost of a drill doctor. larger bits I will often hand grind. Some smaller bits I toss. (I go to a lot of auctions and have a real large supply of bits). Try hand grinding some of your dull bits and see what your results are - what do you have to lose? Look at some new bits and try to match the profile and relief areas. If you want to take the time to learn proper grinding look around your area for some old machinists or tool makers. Many are more than happy to show off their skills and teach someone. One warning, the wheels that are furnished with most bench grinders are really not suited for sharpening tools. They are sold with very hard wheels that generate a lot of heat on the tool. Several places (Lee Valley is one) sell softer, courser wheels that make it a lot easier to sharpen without overheating the tool. It takes a light touch and a little time to sharpen, don't push a drill bit or chisel into the wheel expecting to grind it to shape in 5 - 10 seconds, you will, but it will get hot enough to remove all the temper and will only be good to make more holes in or shape swiss cheese. I keep a container of water near the grinder and try to never get the tool hotter than I can hold comfortably (at the cutting edge).
Some people sharpen a chisel on a grinder and if it's lucky give it a pass or two on a stone of some description. Some buy water stones or pieces of granite milled flat (very flat). I'm trying to sort this out. I am largely self taught and have little experience outside my own shop. Some of the sharpening advice makes sense to me and some of it seems over the top, with some of it being "under the bottom" if I may coin a phrase for the opposite of "over the top".
My findings on Water Stones vs Oil stones vs scary sharp. I have a good set of all three (not necessary but I have reached the time in my life I can afford it).
(A) Water stones have some advantages - They break down easily, this exposes a "new" surface constantly while you sharpen. This makes them remove material quicker than an oil stone. The disadvantages are that 1) This "break down" removes grit from the stone making them less than flat. This requires that you flatten the stone often to keep a straight edge on your tools. The second issue is that the many water stones must be "soaked" prior to use and must be used with water while sharpening, this takes time and is a problem if the shop is unheated - freezing a soaked water stone may break it into little pieces. The water stones are messy as I get the slurry (water mixed with grit)all over the place. I really end up with a mess after I have sharpened a few tools. Another disadvantage is that the tool is wet after sharpening and must be cleaned, dried and (I personally either oil or wax the tool to prevent rust). Initial cost of the stones, container, flattening stone etc. is fairly high ($150 ~ $250 or more for a reasonably good set). Also waterstones wear somewhat rapidly so you may have to replace them in a few years.
(B) Oil Stones: These were used for many centuries, and can provide exactly the same results as water stones. The advantages are that the oilstones are hard and stay flat much better. A set should last your lifetime. (You can flatten worn ones with a diamond stone or abrasive powder on glass). The tool, after sharpening is coated with oil and just requires wiping with a rag before use. The oil will help prevent later rust. The disadvantages are 1) The oil is kind of messy (although IMHO much less so than the Waterstone method)and 2) the stones are quite hard so cut quite a bit slower than the other methods. Again the initial cost is fairly high ($150 up to $250 or more.) I have a ceramic ultrafine stone I use after the oil stones to shine the back of the tool and use it to put a "mico bevel" on the edge.
Scary Sharp: I used this method for a year or so. I didn't purchase a piece of ultra flat granite however. I purchased a few pieced of scrap 1/4" thick plate glass from a local glass shop. (cost around $.50 a piece). IMHO this is plenty flat for this application and having extra pieces allowed me to attach more grits to the glass. This is a pretty good method of sharpening on a budget (actually as good as the oil or water stones) and initial cost for me was between $20 and $50). I used the 3M spray adhesive to stick the sandpaper to the glass - I think I used acetone to remove / replace sheets as I remember. You can use wet dry Emery paper available at the local auto parts store. If you desire a "high shine" to the tools you can get grits that will do this. The abrasives stay "flat" if properly adhered. I did have some problems flatting the back of blades if I used the "cloth backed" abrasive (I think it "gives" and abrades material - not an issue with the "paper" backed abrasive. Really no big disadvantage to the method except you have to keep buying abrasives, and it is messy to remove the adhesive and replace the sheets. If I were just starting out I would use this method.
"Also, I don't have a lot of money to invest. I guess what I am looking for is the "Dummies Guide to Sharpening". Does anyone have or know of such a thing?"
Although I do not own it, many have recommended Lee Valleys "The Complete Guide to Sharpening" by Leonard Lee. It is available on VHS or DVD (around $15 to $22)
Also, what have you tried that worked for you and continues to work for you. What are your "go to" sharpening methods. Not the fad of the moment but what you actually use.
I actually currently use several methods dependent on the tool issues. If I am sharpening my paring chisels or plane blades, I normally use the oil stone method as I don't need to remove much material, just touch up the edge. Sometimes all I need to do is hit the "micro bevel" using my ceramic stone. If the tool requires a lot of material to be removed due to a small chip etc., or I really have to flatten the back I will set up the water stones - normally I wait until I have several tools to sharpen, as this makes such a mess and I have to soak the stones. If I have really damaged the edge I will regrind it on either the bench grinder with a "cool wheel" or use my surface grinder (no, you probably don't want or need one of these).
As an addendum, I did use the Scary Sharp method for over a year and obtained excellent results. I just got tired of buying abrasive paper and messing with replacing the sheets. T
I'm thinking of plane irons, chisels, card scrapers, Drill bits, or all those things you need to sharpen. Is there a common thread?
Not really, Plane Irons and chisels are similar, I would recommend a beginner purchase a Veritas MK 2 honing guide ($60). This can be used to sharpen all your chisels and plane blades using any of the sharpening methods. It will allow you to hold the same angle on your tools and makes learning a whole lot easier. As you gain experience, you probably will learn to "hand hold" many tools and sharpen without the jig. I still use it for narrow chisels and plane Irons as I find it saves me a lot of time. It allows you to Micro bevel the edge without effort. Card scrapers are a different bird. I have tried many methods. I currently use a file and homemade jig to square / clean up the edge, then use the edge of my oilstone to hone it. I have the Veritas burnisher (used to put the "hook" on the edge) and scraper holder. Drill bit sharpening was discussed above.
One of the most common errors in sharpening chisels and plane blades is not completely flatening the back first. This is one of the two surfaces required to make the edge and is the very first and IMHO most important steps. I normally spend several minutes on a new tool getting this edge flat and polished. (You only need to have the last 1/16 to 1/8" of the surface perfectly flat). Once a tool is properly shaped and sharpened (barring a chip), I normally can resharpen the edge in 2 or 3 minutes to a usable state.