Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Question on Tools

Posts

Question on Tools

#1

Question on Tools

Robert R Clough - Thorncraft

>I have no intention of purchasing any of the tools advertised in WWJ by Heartland, but is this a reputable company. I always have my doubts when a 19v cordless drill sells for $40. My guess is that it is ok as long as one is willing to discard the tool when and if it fails after a few uses.

And a second question. I shall be purchasing a new table saw, probably a hybrid, by Spring. If the saw comes with either cast iron or steel wings, is there a good reason to pay extra for cast iron? My current Delta Contractor has steel wings and they appear to have worked well.

Re: Question on Tools

#2

As Always ...you get what you pay for

Scott in Eastern Iowa

>.....any new drill for 40 bucks will give you some service, but dont rely on it to compare to a dewalt or equiv type of drill/driver.

I picked up a cheap 18 v delta driver at Sams Club auctions and while it has turned a few screws for me, its definatlely light duty only...batteries also need recharged if left alone for a few days.

As far as a TS goes, Id go with the cast iron over the stamped wings simply because I use my TS at times as a catch all for stacks of magazines to a stack of lumber on it. To me the CI gets the nod for its durability and misuse on my part.

Your mileage may vay of course.......

Re: Question on Tools

#3

Re: Question on Tools

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Evening Robert,

I too am seriously considering buying a new hybrid table saw, and based on recent reviews, have decided on the Jet. I will probably get the saw with cast iron wings, only because it looks better. I'm not so sure they have anything to do with how well it operates! My current Jet contracdtor's saw has one iron wing on the left of the blade, and a torsion box birch plywood wing on the right extending to the rails. I've been more than satisfied with the saw. I will say that items like C-Clamps dropped inadvertantly on the cast iron wing, have caused no damage. A lighter steel stamping would have dented or distorted. However, in my case the decision is mostly an ego thing.

George

Re: Question on Tools

#4

two reasons to go with CI

Robin Corell in Atascadero Ca

>There are two main reasons to opt for CI wings. First would be the ability to adjust the CI wings flush with the main table. the rolled edge of the pressed steel provides a gap for sawdust and chips to acumulate in, as well as a place for things to catch as you slide them across from the side. the other reason is just to have more mass. this is not a frivilous thing as more mass will translate to less vibration and give you better performance.

Robin

Re: Question on Tools

#5

Re: Question on Tools

Tony - Memphis

>My saw has stamped wings too. I can't see that there is anything wrong with them. Been using them for 10+ years. I wouldn't pay extra for them myself.

Tony

Re: Question on Tools

#6

Re: Question on Tools

Pete in Holland, MI

>I upgraded my JET 10" contractors with cast iron wings several years after owing it.

When cross cutting large pieces of wood, the wood would touch off on the left-right beads in the stamping and cause slight hick-ups in the cutting action. After the upgrade, I've never looked back.

Depends if your work involves building bird houses or dressers. Stamped wings were a cost reduction to keep costs down. You normally don't see them on upper end saws for good reasons.

My JET is one of the old blue ones and cast iron wings were only an option, and not a package, back then. They are available as a package now in the white machines.

Re: Question on Tools

#7

Re: Question on Tools

Don Bullock

>After having a table saw with stamped wings and now having cast iron I can say that the cast iron is worth the "extra" cost.

Re: Question on Tools

#8

Re: Agree, get the CI

Brian in Brighton

>I hated when sawdust used to build up in the stamped steel wings. I have cast iron and love it. I can also use it to help assembly. I would not opt for the webbed wings, since they look like finger crunchers.

Brian in Brighton

Re: Question on Tools

#9

Re: Agree, get the CI

Norm Thomas

>I also have had both steel & cast wings. Cast is heavier and in any statioary tool, heavier is better! It is more stable and less vibration.

Re: Question on Tools

#10

Re: Question on Tools

Derek

>George,

So you are saying "wherever ego u go"? :>)