Re: Finally, something to report�
Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach
>Thanks, Bruce. Good thought on some hints while they're fresh in my mind. My router table setup is your basic table with an Hitachi M12V router installed. I used three bits: ½" solid carbide, 5/16" solid carbide, and 14° dovetail (½" shank).
Hogging out the bulk of the material with the ½" bit was relatively straightforward, with one big exception—these are inside cuts. If you try routing as you would normally do against the fence, you'll wind up having to pick the plate up off the floor on the other side of the table. You might have to do it two or three times, if you're slow, like me. Pay attention to the rotation of the bit and set the fence and the work so you're feeding against the rotation of the bit. My table is real easy to work from either side (front/back, I mean). Therefore, it was no problem to change sides when I needed to.
I wish I had paid more attention to this, but it didn't occur to me until after the accumulated experience(s) of the preceding paragraph—establish one reference edge, and then always machine with that edge against the fence. It's very important that the two dovetailed edges be absolutely parallel. This means really paying attention to your setup. The funny thing is, I've always been conscious of reference edges—I just got caught up in the project this time.
It should come as no shock that you probably shouldn't try to hog out the full depth of the slot in one pass. I went about 1/8" at a time, which worked well. My final depth is about 5/16", but there's nothing magical about that—I wasn't trying to duplicate the exact dimensions of the original (which I couldn't anyway, without one at hand). Since I'm going to be the one machining replacement inserts, it can be any depth I wanted—5/16" seemed like a nice dimension.
But I wouldn't go to that depth with the ½" bit. First, it leaves too rough a surface—something like an engine turning, but rougher. I found the dovetail bit left a very nice surface—still visible, but smoother. And I think I wound up maybe taking .020" or so. The principle adjustment in cutting the dovetail is sideways, anyway, so don't raise that bit too much when you go to it.
There is one critical dimension I found by accident. You can't go too far toward the short side of the insert—the point of the dovetail gets perilously close to the setscrews and isn't immediately obvious as you look down at the edge of the groove. If you see a slight spark, you'll know you shouldn't take any more off that side.
I hogged out the major slots using my 5/16" carbide bit. It didn't plunge nicely like the ½" and at first I couldn't figure out why. Upon examination, it turned out to be a down spiral bit, which doesn't have any aggression at all in the bottom cutting edge. I wound up having to cut a couple of clearance holes in the slot and then hogging the whole thickness of material at once. Slow feeding and an additional fence on the other side of the plate to prevent any kicking out to the side made it work okay.
There was one humorous side story—when I got the initial sizing done and had a nice fit—probably just a few thousandths of slop—I was relating it to a friend and mentioned that I wanted to wait until another 90° day (we still have some coming) before deciding the fit was good enough due to the differing coefficients of thermal expansion between aluminum and steel. So I went to the next step, which was cutting a groove in the plate by running the blade up through it (you'll need a smaller diameter blade than 10" to do that). After just a few fractions of an inch into the cut, I went to adjust the plate and recoiled from the heat. I figured I'd better get the plate out of the hole but it was jammed tight. Coefficient of thermal expansion, indeed. It would not budge.
After cooling down for a while it popped right out. Frankly, I don't think 90° will be a problem—it was sure hotter than that from the blade friction. That happened again when I hogged out the blade slot to a full kerf dimension prior to using the router bit. It made me laugh again.
I hope this helps. Feel free to ask if anything else comes to mind.
Rod