Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

WC Weekend Accomplishments...

Posts

WC Weekend Accomplishments...

#1

WC Weekend Accomplishments...

Dennis E Peacock

>Good Morning

12 Nov 2007

With the weather getting cooler and a bit more "damp" for some, I hope this finds each of you healthy and prosperous.

Nothing much for me except that the kitchen table project is finished and delivered (previously posted last week).

I'm working on 1 of 2 small wine cabinets for a friend of mine and gearing up for my neighbors kitchen table project that will be made of 42 year old, barn dried Black Walnut. This is going to be some nice stuff.!!!

Other than that? I go oncall for the day job as of this morning and will officially pick up the oncall duty at 5PM today. I'm hoping for a not so busy week for oncall.

Well, that's it for me.

So what did YOU do this weekend??

Best of weeks to you all.

Dennis

Re: WC Weekend Accomplishments...

#2

turned a carrot  *LINK*

JohnKJordan in East TN

>


carrot

Re: WC Weekend Accomplishments...

#3

Re: WC Weekend Accomplishments...

Jay St. Peter - Southern, MD

>I've officially started the garden bench I'm building my mother for Christmas. Bought the lumber on Saturday and surfaced the leg and top parts on Sunday. I'm hoping to have all the blanks ready for joinery by next weekend.

Jay

Re: WC Weekend Accomplishments...

#4

Finally, something to report…

Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach

>

Replacable Insert Throat Plate





















I've been wanting one of these for a long time:


That's the insert with a replacable insert (what I call an oak insert insert) that Norm has had for some time. The guy that makes (made) them doesn't appear to be marketing them any longer and has the business up for sale.


I always thought they were a little pricey and longed to craft one of my own for some time. Can't be too hard, I thought, and it wasn't.












The first thing you need is a source for ½" thick aluminum plate. I'm very fortunate to have an excellent scrap aluminum yard nearby and got some stock. I don't imagine I have to show you a plain old piece of aluminum plate, so I'll jump right to an interim shot.


After rough cutting the plate into the general shape of an insert (band saw, table saw), I spent some time filing and fitting, filing and fitting, filing and fitting. Eventually, I wound up with a blank plate (center, left). I also used my jig saw and drill press to size the finger hole, and finished it up with a roundover bit in my trim router.


A little layout time (to make sure they were located properly), and a trip to the drill press yielded the pilot holes for the adjusting set screws you can barely see here.


The insert at the top is the OEM insert which came with the saw. It still has its uses. At the bottom is one of the Baltic birch inserts I've made (I have probably a half dozen in inventory).





I'm sorry you're going to be disappointed that I don't have any live shots of the machining. Suffice to say there were several sessions at the router table.


The insert here is a piece of walnut. It just happened to be an already thicknessed piece at hand and I was in a hurry once I had the dovetail groove ready to get something in there. Eventually, I suspect I'll use a piece of maple, birch, or ash. To follow Norm, of course, I could make one of oak, but it doesn't really strike me as the appropriate zero clearance insert wood.


Incidentally, I agonized for some time over the angle to use for the dovetail. My first thought, naturally, was the traditional 14° used in the dovetailing jigs. Then I thought 45° would be better. Finally, not having a 45° bit, I opted for 14° and in retrospect, there shouldn't have been any question. It's just right.



Not quite so visible are the enlarged and tapped holes for the adjusting set screws. I'm so pleased. This thing sits in its place rock solid and with a satisfying heavy metallic “clunk” as it goes in.








Here is a view with the insert removed so you can see the machined substructure. With the exception of a plough cut with an 8" blade in the table saw to establish the initial groove, all of the machining was done on the router table.


The through openings in the plate are essentially the same as the OEM insert, so I may be able to fit inserts for miter cuts as well, although probably not for a full 45° angle. Still, I did make a BB insert for 45°, so I'm covered there.


The through openings will also accommodate the OEM splitter/guard and an aftermarket splitter, so long as I cut the insert at the back for clearance.






Rod




Re: WC Weekend Accomplishments...

#5

Re: Finally, something to report�

Bruce, a MN galoot

>Thanks, Rod. That's really helpful, and congrats on a great result! I'd appreciate a little exposition on routing the aluminum. You indicated you did it all at the router table, and while I've heard it's possible (obviously), I've never done it myself. How did it go for you? Any hints you'd care to pass along?

Bruce

Re: WC Weekend Accomplishments...

#6

Re: WC Weekend Accomplishments...

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Morning Dennis, and a Happy Monday to you.

I've cut back to "flight idle" in the shop, trying to get healed for the next great adventure. I started making toy race cars for the smallest grandchildren, and also began experimenting with coil;or matching a railing for installation in a client's home. I'm working for my #3 son, Ken on this one. I also turned a blank for a bowl and began the finish on it. So, as Onslow would say, I've been bone idle.

Went to Silver Spring on Saturday for #3 grandson Luke's 5th birthday celebration and had a ball. I drove down and SWMBO drove back. WE had a few kids and grandkids for the weekly Sunday dinner party, which I enjoyed immensely. So, it was a full weekend, not entirely shop related. Enjoy your time "on-call", Dennis.

George

Re: WC Weekend Accomplishments...

#7

Re: Finally, something to report�

Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach

>Thanks, Bruce. Good thought on some hints while they're fresh in my mind. My router table setup is your basic table with an Hitachi M12V router installed. I used three bits: ½" solid carbide, 5/16" solid carbide, and 14° dovetail (½" shank).

Hogging out the bulk of the material with the ½" bit was relatively straightforward, with one big exception—these are inside cuts. If you try routing as you would normally do against the fence, you'll wind up having to pick the plate up off the floor on the other side of the table. You might have to do it two or three times, if you're slow, like me. Pay attention to the rotation of the bit and set the fence and the work so you're feeding against the rotation of the bit. My table is real easy to work from either side (front/back, I mean). Therefore, it was no problem to change sides when I needed to.

I wish I had paid more attention to this, but it didn't occur to me until after the accumulated experience(s) of the preceding paragraph—establish one reference edge, and then always machine with that edge against the fence. It's very important that the two dovetailed edges be absolutely parallel. This means really paying attention to your setup. The funny thing is, I've always been conscious of reference edges—I just got caught up in the project this time.

It should come as no shock that you probably shouldn't try to hog out the full depth of the slot in one pass. I went about 1/8" at a time, which worked well. My final depth is about 5/16", but there's nothing magical about that—I wasn't trying to duplicate the exact dimensions of the original (which I couldn't anyway, without one at hand). Since I'm going to be the one machining replacement inserts, it can be any depth I wanted—5/16" seemed like a nice dimension.

But I wouldn't go to that depth with the ½" bit. First, it leaves too rough a surface—something like an engine turning, but rougher. I found the dovetail bit left a very nice surface—still visible, but smoother. And I think I wound up maybe taking .020" or so. The principle adjustment in cutting the dovetail is sideways, anyway, so don't raise that bit too much when you go to it.

There is one critical dimension I found by accident. You can't go too far toward the short side of the insert—the point of the dovetail gets perilously close to the setscrews and isn't immediately obvious as you look down at the edge of the groove. If you see a slight spark, you'll know you shouldn't take any more off that side.

I hogged out the major slots using my 5/16" carbide bit. It didn't plunge nicely like the ½" and at first I couldn't figure out why. Upon examination, it turned out to be a down spiral bit, which doesn't have any aggression at all in the bottom cutting edge. I wound up having to cut a couple of clearance holes in the slot and then hogging the whole thickness of material at once. Slow feeding and an additional fence on the other side of the plate to prevent any kicking out to the side made it work okay.

There was one humorous side story—when I got the initial sizing done and had a nice fit—probably just a few thousandths of slop—I was relating it to a friend and mentioned that I wanted to wait until another 90° day (we still have some coming) before deciding the fit was good enough due to the differing coefficients of thermal expansion between aluminum and steel. So I went to the next step, which was cutting a groove in the plate by running the blade up through it (you'll need a smaller diameter blade than 10" to do that). After just a few fractions of an inch into the cut, I went to adjust the plate and recoiled from the heat. I figured I'd better get the plate out of the hole but it was jammed tight. Coefficient of thermal expansion, indeed. It would not budge.

After cooling down for a while it popped right out. Frankly, I don't think 90° will be a problem—it was sure hotter than that from the blade friction. That happened again when I hogged out the blade slot to a full kerf dimension prior to using the router bit. It made me laugh again.

I hope this helps. Feel free to ask if anything else comes to mind.

Rod

Re: WC Weekend Accomplishments...

#8

Re: WC Weekend Accomplishments...

Mike Fitterling

>Got away to Florida Flywheelers this Saturday. Had a great time with my dad and brother. For once, we got to see every row of the flea market area. I did pretty well for myself, I believe. A #10 for $72, a #80 for $20, and a wooden skewed rabbet plane for $10. Saw them put a model T together in four minutes from a pile of parts on the ground and watched the steam powered sawmil at work, cutting up some large southern yellow pine.

Sunday, I got a little shop time in cleaning up my finds and working on the rails and stiles for the bottom doors on a pair of built-in maple bookshelves I have been building for my borther and sister-in-law.

Cheers,

Mike


img

Re: WC Weekend Accomplishments...

#9

Wow, Rod! Great Work!

Mike Fitterling

>I have always like that style of plate but the price has kept me from getting one. Yours looks every bit as nice as the commercial one. I might just have to try that.

Thanks for posting.

Mike

Re: WC Weekend Accomplishments...

#10

One more hint.

Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach

>I was asked on the back channel about router speed and melting:

I did lower the speed. I don't know if I had a particular reason to, but it seemed prudent. I can't give a quantitative value but it was down near the panel raising speed. I didn't have any melting. Some of the chips were tenacious, however, particularly in the dovetail recess, and needed to be pried out with a pointy tool.

I have a great collection of files and rasps (inherited largely from an uncle who was a foundryman at Ellison Bronze in Falconer, NY, for those who may know something about that sort of stuff), which facilitated several aspects of the project.

Rod

Re: WC Weekend Accomplishments...

#11

Re: WC Weekend Accomplishments...

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Afternoon Mike,

I'd say you did wuite well with your planes/prices. That #10 is lovely. I have a 10 1/2 with adjustable mouth which my #3 son got me from a flea market. Around $10. Ken had no idea of what he was buying, or its value. It was actually a consolation prize because he had previously called me about a #7 Bailey for $20. I told him to pass that one up because I had just bought a #8, and didn't think I needed another jointer! I sure know differently now. Congratulations.

George

Re: WC Weekend Accomplishments...

#12

Re: One more hint.

Bruce, a MN galoot

>That's good to know, Rod. I have a fixed-speed router and I'll bet 20K rpm might be a bit high. However, I do have access to a mill here at work.

bruce

Re: WC Weekend Accomplishments...

#13

Question

Dan Donaldson

>Did you have any issues with the aluminum chips getting into the router? It would seem that with the router upside down, The chips could fall into the router and let the smoke out.

Re: WC Weekend Accomplishments...

#14

Re: Question

Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach

>I was concerned about that in the planning stages, even to the point of thinking of placing a thin piece of plastic (milk bottle gauge) with a snug slip fit on the shaft of the router bits. In the end, when I got to the routing stage I just threw caution to the winds and let 'er rip. There were certainly no fireworks, and with two intermediate bit changes, I expected to see at least some debris falling out of the bottom, but there was little or none, even with banging the router about a bit.

Rod

Re: WC Weekend Accomplishments...

#15

Brilliant piece of shop work, Rod!

Eddie Pacheco, San Jose, Ca.

>Doing that amount of metal work with woodworking tools, and not getting hurt, is a feat in itself.

Re: WC Weekend Accomplishments...

#16

cutting speed

john b. southwest Chicago burbs

>The cutting speed for aluminum is about 3000sfpm.using carbide cutters. That just mean that you can spin a 1/2" carbide cutter at 24000rpm. john b.

Re: WC Weekend Accomplishments...

#17

Re: cutting speed

Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach

>Thanks. I was well below that—probably in the 12-14K range. But that'll be good information to include in the article, if we do one.

Rod

Re: WC Weekend Accomplishments...

#18

What do you mean IF you do an article?

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>

Re: WC Weekend Accomplishments...

#19

Re: Yeah 'IF' an article?

john b. southwest Chicago burbs

>

Re: WC Weekend Accomplishments...

#20

Re: cutting speed

Carol Reed - in Nebraska

>Hey Rod,

When I was using a CNC to rout aluminum, I had a discussion with the Unsrud people about cutters, speeds, lubes, etc.

Upon their advise, I used 17,000-19,000 RPM on the router, moving about 2-3 inches per second, and lubed with aluminum cutting fluid. I simply painted it on the cutting path with an acid brush before cutting and then every other pass or so. The cutter was an up-spiral solid carbide two flute, right hand twist end mill. Before that, I had galling and busted cutters.

Worked well. Kept things cool and the cutter lasted.

Re: WC Weekend Accomplishments...

#21

Darrell in Oakville

Used up some wood...

Darrell in Oakville

>Unfortunately not on anything constructive!

It was the Pyromaniac Dream Weekend up at our cottage. I had cut a pile of scrawny hornbeam last spring, and a huge insect-riddled basswood came down in a windstorm over the summer. The tree was about 30 inches in diameter at the base, and it literally shattered when it came down, most of it in the lake. I tried to save some of the basswood for carving but it was shot through with so many checks and cracks it was worthless. Dang. Should've cut it down and had it milled before the bugs got into it.

The water level drops in the Fall, so we were able to get at the rest of the tree on the weekend. The weather was awesome, cool and clear, with a moonless night with so many stars it was hard to find the constellations.

Darrell

Wood Hoarder, Blade Sharpener, and Occasional Tool User


img

Re: WC Weekend Accomplishments...

#22

Due to popular demand…

Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach

>Heh, heh, you guys are great. Garrett already gave me the go-ahead (or push, depending on how you look at it) for conversion to an article, so it'll be put in queue. Right now I'm working hard on Bob Tindall's Where Hardwood Lumber Comes From, and I know you don't want me to set that aside…

I'm no Bob Smalser or Derek Cohen (they have some of the best step-by-step pictures in their articles), so there really aren't a whole lot more pictures, but I'll consolidate all the comments from here and try to make it a little more readable with all the additions.

Thanks for all the kind remarks.

Rod

Re: WC Weekend Accomplishments...

#23

Well, if I hadn't stopped for dinner...

Joe Pack

>If I hadn't stopped for dinner on the way home, I would have only lost $2 after paying entry fee, lodging, gas, meals and materials costs for a really disappointing 2 day craft show in Maumee, OH. Veteran vendors said, "I don't understand it. This place was shoulder to shoulder last year." I saw more people in the McDonald's drive-thru than I saw at the Lucas County Recreation Center. Many blamed the price of gas, but I don't buy that, as the area shopping centers were filled to overflowing.

Anyhow, in for a penny, in for a pound. I stopped for dinner.

Re: WC Weekend Accomplishments...

#24

Make it 893 ;-)

Dan Donaldson

>Added and uploaded

Re: WC Weekend Accomplishments...

#25

Re: cutting speed

Bruce, a MN galoot

>Carol,

did you rout the aluminum with the router in a table?