Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

Straight Edge Accuracy

Posts

Straight Edge Accuracy

#1

Straight Edge Accuracy

Jeff H. - Oregon

>I am in the market for a straight edge and have been looking at the Veritas at Lee Valley. My question is how accurate do I need my straight edge? I have found 0.003", 0.002", 0.001" over entire length. Of course the price goes up the more accuracy you have.

Do I really need 0.001"? Will 0.003" be okay for setting up table saw top and jointer?

Re: Straight Edge Accuracy

#2

Re: Straight Edge Accuracy

Garrett in Victoria

>You're going to buy only one during your lifetime - unless of course, you drop it - so why quibble over a few dollars. Get the best and longest(!) you can afford and avoid buyer's remorse later.

Cheers, Garrett

Re: Straight Edge Accuracy

#3

Re: Straight Edge Accuracy

Robin Corell in Atascadero Ca

>This is one of those areas where machinest acuracy has crept into woodworking. straight edges are often described with two tollerances, one for total length and another per incrament ie. .001/inch and .003 over the total length. which do you need? neither.

The one wood working trade with perhaps the highest need for acuracy is patternmaking. As a paternmaker I worked in half a dozen shops and not one had a straight edge. we always relied on rules, mostly starrett. In strict machinest terms a rule is not the same as a straight edge and is not calibrated as such. to a machinest a starrett rule is not straight enough to use as a straight edge. In the real world a 2',4' or 6' starret rule is plenty straight and is much more useful to a woodworker.

If you are in need of a straight edge with more heft so it will stand on edge I would suggest a pair of 1-2-3 guage blocks and some rare earth magnets. and here again ther is no need for the high dollar guage blocks.

Robin

Re: Straight Edge Accuracy

#4

Re: Straight Edge Accuracy

john lucas

>I'm one of those people who fusses over accuracy but when I need a straight edge I use my old 12" craftsman machinist square. For my other needs I use a pair of aluminum yardsticks that I check against each other accasionally. I'll put the edges against each other and look for light. Then flip one and look for light. If I can't see any then that's good enough for me. I have no earthly idea what the accuracy is. the same is true with the Machinist square. I bought a ruler from Bridge city tools and I simply place the two together and there's no light between.

I love high quality tools and have drooled over the Lee Valley straight edges. I just haven't been able to convince myself that I need one just yet.

Re: Straight Edge Accuracy

#5

Great advice

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>

Re: Straight Edge Accuracy

#6

Re: Straight Edge Accuracy

Steve Mackay

>Every word above is true BUT . . . you gotta admit . . . those Starret straight edges are cool as all get-out !

Re: Straight Edge Accuracy

#7

Now here's a thought...

Bill Hammond, Oregon Coast

>If you make something out of wood that is too perfect it no longer looks like it is hand made.

bill, who makes things that really look hand made

Re: Straight Edge Accuracy

#8

Re: Straight Edge Accuracy

Tony - Memphis

>I'm a mechanical engineer by day. I used to make race car parts. From that background, I like for my standard to be as good as I can afford. I use a 36" Starrett. I've never bought into the argument that "you don't need that accuracy level for woodworking." I'm not using it on my wood, I'm using it on my tools. I'm not fussy with my woodworking and it shows, but a standard is a standard. Economics comes into play as well. A 36" Starrett is not that much money. I have considered getting a Lee Valley to use as a working straight edge. Just never got around to it. For me, its also one of those things you find all sorts of uses for once you get one. I use real nice machinist's squares too. I do use those for daily use as they aren't very expensive these days. If your pennies are short and the price of the Starrett is too high, don't buy it. I really don't use mine that much and could never justify the cost (Santa brought it anyway!), but I sure do like having it.

Tony

Re: Straight Edge Accuracy

#9

Re: Straight Edge Accuracy

JohnKJordan in East TN

>>I have considered getting a Lee Valley to

>use as a working straight edge.

For a working straight edge, I got one from Home Depot, seems like about 20 years ago. It is extruded aluminum and came in two 4' sections. I don't think I ever used them together. This is perfect for drawing lines down a board or across plywood, setting up outfeed support, etc.

JKJ

Re: Straight Edge Accuracy

#10

Don't borrow my Dad's

Mike Schwing from Maryland

>I absolutely could not get my jointer beds properly lined up till I decided to check on the "straight" edge my Dad loaned me. Not even close! I guess you get what you pay for. I'll be buying two of the best ones I can find - and giving one to him for Christmas.

Re: Straight Edge Accuracy

#11

Kill two birds with one rock!

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>Buy a 3' or 4' level and it will not only provide a straight edge, but can also come in handy as a level at a fraction . If youneed to measure, then use a tape measure. It's a cabinet, not a swiss watch.....

Lee

Re: Straight Edge Accuracy

#12

Amen to Starrett. Now if my skills just matched!

Chicago Bob

>

Re: Straight Edge Accuracy

#13

I zigged while others zagged

Grant in Iowa

>back when I began "tooling up" my shop, I decided I wanted a nice long straightedge for tool setup purposes. I think someone here recommended a flooring installers straightedge.

These straightedges, such as the 6' one from Crain that I bought are guaranteed straight to within .005" at the time of sale, are made of 3" wide steel, and ground flat and straight on both edges. While a machinist might turn up their nose at such a loose tolerance, I have found it straighter than anything else in my shop...trust me, I have no flat cast iron... I checked when I got it home.

I have used mine quite a bit for setting up new machinery, or recently moved machinery, in and outfeed tables, and for checking the results of jointing for the purpose of tweaking the jointer for a perfect fit.

When I built a table top, I was able to check the edges of each board after jointing to make sure they were straight. This repeated checking and rejointing served to hone my technique at the jointer such that I could make 6' boards that mated together perfectly.

Anyway, I'm not sure what you are needing a straightedge for in your shop, but if you want a long one that is tough, straight, and reasonably priced, visit your local flooring supplier and pick one up. Mine was about $40 for a 6 foot Crain. Just google "flooring straight edge".

FWIW,

Grant in Iowa