Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Polishing Machine Table Tops?

Posts

Polishing Machine Table Tops?

#1

Polishing Machine Table Tops?

Ted Owen, Pittsburgh

>I've seen cast iron machine table tops that really shine. My 3-phase machines reside in my unheated garage, so over the winter season they accumulate light surface rust. Occasionally I remove the rust and protect with Top-Cote. But they continue to look extremely dull.

It must be my technique. To remove the rust, I use Boeshield and Abralon sheets, up to 600-grit, run on a random orbit sander. I've tried Menzerna 3-step polishing compounds to achieve some semblance of shine, but they're forumulated for automobile paints or furniture finishes, and there was no discernable effect on the cast iron.

A friend suggested using a wire wheel, but I don't understand--wouldn't that just accentuate the scratch patters?

What do you folks use to bring up a somewhat mirror finish on cast iron?

Best, Ted

Re: Polishing Machine Table Tops?

#2

Re: Polishing Machine Table Tops?

Lee Ohmart

>I used a wire wheel on a drill after applying copious amounts of Marvel Mystery Oil to the top of my tablesaw that lived in the garage. That got the rust off and wiping it off seemed to keep the rust off during the winter when it was cold and dry. The top was always nice ans shiney except for the machine marks when Sears flattened the casting. In the spring when the temerature and humidity fluctuated, I had to keep a light coat of oil on it or it would rust up again. Nowadays I use Boeshield but happily all my equipment lives in a dry heated basement.

Re: Polishing Machine Table Tops?

#3

Re: Polishing Machine Table Tops

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>I use wood, as in the best polish is using the machine.

If you're going to let a machine sit, most anything other than cosmolene is still going to allow condensation rusting to occur. You could try to "bag" them with a couple cans of silica gel in the bag, but I've not heard of any coating that will prevent rust in your situation.

mm

Re: Polishing Machine Table Tops?

#4

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Re: Polishing Machine Table Tops

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

>I would think that covering the machines with canvas after treating the cast iron should prevent most, if not all, rust.

Jason

Re: Polishing Machine Table Tops?

#5

Re: Tarps

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Jason,

Actually, my experience has been that without a moisture absorber present, tarps tend to increase and worsen rust because they seem to trap moisture and promote condensation on the metal surfaces. Traps are fine for dust, but not for rust. That's why I suggested "bagging" with the dessicant inside the "sealed" bag.

mm

Re: Polishing Machine Table Tops?

#6

I'm not trying to prevent rust...

Ted Owen, Pittsburgh

>just trying to learn how others achieve more shine on cast iron after removing the rust.

Best, Ted

Re: Polishing Machine Table Tops?

#7

Re: High Speed Buffer?

Brian in Brighton

>Ted, How about a high speed buffer with metal polishing compounds or car polish compounds?

I just ran over mine over the weekend and did some wet oil sanding with 400 grit, then a cleaning with simple green, then a thick coat of Boeshield T9. They are not perfect, but they are slicker.

If you are looking to get a polish like a new PM-66, you will have some sore elbows, but can get there.

Brian in Brighton

Re: Polishing Machine Table Tops?

#8

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Re: Tarps

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

>That's why I suggested canvas--it breathes as compared to a polyethylene tarp or other plastic. The canvas should also absorb and release some moisture, acting like a buffer.

Jason

Re: Polishing Machine Table Tops?

#9

Re: It's cast iron, not chromed steel.

Kneale Brownson awaiting snow in N. MI

>It ain't supposed to shine like a car bumper used to when they used metal car bumpers.

I treat my tables with TopCote a couple times a year. They reside in an unheated barn in Michigan's northern Lower Peninsula, where we have all kinds of seasonal change humidity and rapid temperature swings. Since I discovered TopCote maybe 20 years ago, I've had no significant rusting of cast iron tabletops.

Re: Polishing Machine Table Tops?

#10

Hi Ted

Dominic Greco in Richboro PA

>Ted,

I understand exactly what you're trying to achieve. The cast iron surface on my Unisaw is a good example of the kind of polished surface you would want (not that it's exactly like that anymore!).

I started of with a Green Scotch-brite pad backed up by a nice flat 2x4. Then I got an cast iron wing from an old 8" tablesaw. I attached some 220 grit wet dry sand paper to it and used it like a super flat sanding pad to lap the top of my tablesaw. I lubed with WD40 and then moved up to 300, 400, and finally 600 grit. After that it got a coat of T-9.

Just to show that I'm not pulling your leg :>), I've attached a photo that shows the surface I achieved.

For those of you that feel this is a waste of time. I understand your point of view. I know that this surface will eventually develop a patina. And trying to keep it pristine is an exercise in futility. But then again, it sure looks pretty and it makes me feel like I accomplished something by achieving this high shine.

See ya around,

Dominic


img

Re: Polishing Machine Table Tops?

#11

Don't Table Dom's Suggestion, Ted

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>

Re: Polishing Machine Table Tops?

#12

Ellis Walentine

That's rich, Dominic, but...

Ellis Walentine

>...it may not be the same thing Ted is trying to achieve. Abrasive progressions will ultimately refine the surface to something like yours, or even shinier. The really shiny surfaces like Powermatic and other manufacturers put on their tablesaw tops, though, are only practical if they can come straight off a machine process, notably Blanchard grinding, which can be refined to a really fine surface. Ted might need to send out his top to a specialized Blanchard mill for the kind of surface he's looking for.

I think of it as the difference between a sanded wood surface and one that has just been shot with a really sharp smoothing plane. The planed surface has depth and clarity; the sanded surface has a uniform luster but not a specular reflective quality.

Ellis

Re: Polishing Machine Table Tops?

#13

Thanks, everyone...

Ted Owen, Pittsburgh

>for the suggestions. I'm not so committed to it that I'll send it out for Blanchard grinding--too lazy to lug the 300# bandsaw table top around, anyway.

This afternoon I used some new Abralon pads, from 500-grit up to 4000. Didn't notice any difference at all from the 600-grit Abranet or the 600-grit wet/dry sandpaper where I had ended the process a couple other times. In all cases using Boeshield as the lubricant.

So I think I'll totally ignore Colonel's advice and "table" the matter. : )

BTW, after applying Top-Cote, the table top is not as slippery as quitting after the Boeshield. Wondering whether the Top-Cote is worthwhile.

Best, Ted

Re: Polishing Machine Table Tops?

#14

How shiny is too shiny?

JohnKJordan in East TN

>My new PM66 is still in the box, but I've been told the extra shiny surface might cause a problem with glare from bright overhead lights. Has glare proven to be a problem for others? If so, is a non-specular luster preferred?

JKJ

Re: Polishing Machine Table Tops?

#15

Re: Polishing Machine Table Tops?

Robin Corell in Atascadero Ca

>i don't live in an area with high humidity but I do have an ocasional leak over the end of the ways of my lathe. I have found the best rust preventative is a layer of fine sawdust. not making this up it realy works.

Robin

Re: Polishing Machine Table Tops?

#16

Re: How shiny is too shiny?

Robin Corell in Atascadero Ca

>I am one of those who does not care for a shiny tablesaw top for the very reason you mentioned. When I got my new saw I couldn't stand the glare and ended up wipeing it down with a bit of water to get a patina started.

for me the tablesaw is a tool to be used and it happens to be one of the largest dead flat surfaces in my shop. I tend to use it for glueing up rub joints. for perfectly flat panels I weight the freshly glued panels on my tablesaw top with angle plates. the result of all this is that there is a pattern of stains on my tablesaw top from all the glue lines.

cleaned up with a fresh coat of wax over all the stains and my saw still cuts wood like the day it was brand new. the patina makes it easier on the eyes and I have more dead flat glued up panels than I can count and no tendonitis in my elbows from polishing.

Robin

Re: Polishing Machine Table Tops?

#17

Re: How shiny is too shiny?

Kneale Brownson awaiting snow in N. MI

>I use the tablesaw top for glue-ups too, but I throw a chunk of 1/4" hardboard onto it before doing any gluing.

Re: Polishing Machine Table Tops?

#18

Re: Thanks, everyone...

Kneale Brownson awaiting snow in N. MI

>I'm wondering if your TopCote is maybe spoiled? Don't know how that could be, but it sure sounds like it's not performing for you like it does for me. TopCote prevents my tables from rusting and makes them very slippery. Maybe yours is reacting to whatever you've been polishing the table with??? When I first started using it many years ago, I had rusty tables from sitting in my unheated barn. I cleaned them all off with steel wool/abrasive pads and mineral spirits. When derusted, I flooded each with mineral spirits again and wiped repeatedly with toweling. Then I applied the TopCote. I recoated every month for a while and then went through a period when I used the machines very sporodically and didn't recoat for quite a while. Now I just wipe/blow off all the sawdust and respray each spring and each fall.

Re: Polishing Machine Table Tops?

#19

Ellis Walentine

It goes without saying...

Ellis Walentine

>... to make sure it's dry sawdust. Wet chips from turning have the opposite effect on lathe beds. DAMHIKT :-)

Ellis

Re: Polishing Machine Table Tops?

#20

Re: It goes without saying...

JohnKJordan in East TN

>>Wet chips from turning...

Ha! A few hours into turning wet white oak and I had to scrape the fresh rust from my lathe bed with an old cabinet scraper. And I had waxed it earler.

JKJ