Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Doall bandsaw

Posts

Doall bandsaw

#1

Doall bandsaw

John Foster

>There is someone listing a Doall bandsaw, in our local Kijiji classifieds, at a reasonable price. How do these metal working bandsaws work for wood? I worry that these super heavy duty machines (Doall, Grob) were probably used 24/7 for decades and are worn out. No casual user would pay for these otherwise. Is it worth considering?

Re: Doall bandsaw

#2

Re: Doall bandsaw

Garrett in Victoria

>Metal-cutting bandsaws differ from wood-cutting in several ways: they're much slower; the guides are quite different and usually are designed to twist the blade in order to enable the saw to cross-cut long lengths; the wheels have no tires, and often have a flange on the back side; and the band tensions are very high. In short, probably not a very good candidate for wood-working use.

Cheers, Garrett

Re: Doall bandsaw

#3

depends on if it is horizontal or vertical

Robin Corell in Atascadero Ca

>A horizontal metal bandsaw would have very little application in a wood shop.

a vertical metal bandsaw however might make an excelent wood cutting saw. Most of the Doall vertical machines I worked around all had rubber tires and steel block blade guides. Not sure but I think most Doall's are variable speed and many were equiped with blade welders. Also most are 220 3ph.

depending on how the machine was used and cared for it may need new tires and bearings and will likely benifit from driving through a car wash on the way home, and it will still be pig-dirty. if you have a bit of elbow grease to spare the saw in question may net you a top quallity machine.

I should also add the that one of the biggest diferences between metal and wood bandsaws is the cutting height on metal saws of similar throat sizes are much lower than their wood counterparts.

I would say it is definately worth a call and maybe a look see.

Robin

Re: Doall bandsaw

#4

Re: Doall bandsaw

Larry Clinton

>Totally agree with Robin - If it is a horizontal machine, you would have very little use for it in a woodshop. If it is a vertical, it would make a very heavy duty accurate bandsaw for your shop. The downsides are that it it almost certainly 3 phase and would require either a new motor, three phase converter or VFD drive. I would also check the cutting height as it is quite likely under 8" (and you can't just install a riser block like woodworking bandsaws). Robin is also correct in stating that most of these are pretty dirty due to having cut metal for many years. Depends on the application it was in. The ones in the toolroom where I worked before retirement were not to bad - however the one in the maintenance shop would have required steam cleaning to really make it presentable. You probably would have to replace the tires. Once cleaned and set up it probably would run forever in a wood shop and do very accurate work.