Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

have radial arm saws outlived their usefulness?

Posts

have radial arm saws outlived their usefulness?

#1

have radial arm saws outlived their usefulness?

geary from nj

>About six years ago I invested in a compound draw miter saw. Before the purchase,I used a radial arm saw for all my crosscuts(I have agreat table saw thats the work horse for all other sawing) Point being....what an improvement my draw saw over the radial arm. A lot of woodworkers must feel the same way cause I can't give my radial arm away! Am I missing something? geary from nj

Re: have radial arm saws outlived their usefulness?

#2

Individual preference.

Don Henthorn Kyle, Texas

>Newer saws are probably the best for the average woodworker who wants convenience and accuracy and is probably a little gun shy about safety. For many older experienced workers who cut their woodworking teeth back a few years the radial saw works just fine and will do few things that the modern saw won't. Neither one is better than the other. As I said it depends on the skill and prior experience of the individual.

Re: have radial arm saws outlived their usefulness?

#3

Re: Individual preference.

geary from nj

>Man don, when my dad & I started our shop 30 some years ago the craftman radial arm saw was the cat's meow! Learned real fast to use the kick back guards or GET EATEN ALIVE!!!But all in all, with proper safetyrules in use it was then the woodworkers dream saw. geary from nj

Re: have radial arm saws outlived their usefulness?

#4

Re: Individual preference.

Ron Hildreth, Alta, Iowa

>Geary,

I have both an RA and a CMS, and love both. True what Don said, both have their place and function, but I wouldn't be without either. I must really be attached to my RA, as I'm fighting a space problem in my shop, and yet every time I move machines around to gain floor space, everything evolves around the RA and the TS!

Ron in Iowa

Re: have radial arm saws outlived their usefulness?

#5

Re: have radial arm saws outlived their usefulness

mattank

>Love my RAS, I leave a dadoe blade in it and cut crosscut ones flawlessly on it!! Matt

Re: have radial arm saws outlived their usefulness?

#6

I wouldn't give mine up for anything

Mike Circo

>Properly tuned, it crosscuts wider and more accurately than a SCMS.

Much more quiet than the screaming universal motor on a CMS.

The large table makes it easier and (I believe) safer to cut on. I just don't get the danger aspect of a RAS. Just put a negative hook blade on it and keep your hands away. The same rules you have on ANY saw.

Great for short dados, half laps and even some quick tendons.

I've tried various CMS and SCMS and they are nice, but I'll never give up my RAS. In fact, I'm looking for an upgrade.

Just an individual preference and what you are used to.

Re: have radial arm saws outlived their usefulness?

#7

Freudian slip

Randy Johnson Connersville, IN

>Great for short dados, half laps and even some quick tendons.

Re: have radial arm saws outlived their usefulness?

#8

Portability is more the issue!

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>I think the popularity of the SCMS is largely due to the portability factor. Most builders (carpenters)can easily tote around an SCMS or CMS; whereas it takes at least two people to move a radial arm saw. The other key is tune ups. If you don't tune up your RAS reularly, then your cuts will be anything but accurate. The SCMS is pretty accurate right out of the box and doesn't take a long time to tune up.

My Dad had a RAS and my first power saw was a RAS. There are things I like about it and it still occupies space in my shop, but honestly it gets used less than a dozen times in a year because the TS can do almost all the same jobs quicker and more accurately.

As far as safety is concerned, it can be frightening to have the saw come at you as it cuts and grabs a bit. Negative hook angle helps, but not completely. I've cross cut, ripped , cuit dadoes (cross wise adn ripping), and even used the three bladed molding head cutters on it. Yes, I've had kick backs, but used with care it is safe enough. It is certainly not a tool for all beginners and wouldn't be my recommendation for a first power saw in the shop.

Lee

Re: have radial arm saws outlived their usefulness?

#9

Re: have radial arm saws outlived their usefulness

Dave Bair, Eaton Rapids, MI

>My Sears RAS was probably the worst tool purchase of my life. The table is difficult to impossible to adjust, the saw wobbles in it's carrage rails (which are just 2 half-round soft steel rods) and the column fit is sloppy. It has been converted into a drum-sanding station where it is somewhat useful.

Re: have radial arm saws outlived their usefulness?

#10

Me Too

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Afternoon Geary,

My RAS was only 18 months old when I sold it for about half what I paid for it. It was a lousey tool, and continuous tune ups were a pain. I was never satisfied. It did do dados and half laps. Insufficient justification, in my opinion. Got a SCMS and put the dado head in my table saw. Have lived a happy life since.

George

Re: have radial arm saws outlived their usefulness?

#11

Re: have radial arm saws outlived their usefulness

JEB

>Someone ask this question a few years ago. As stated now, back then the concensus was woodworker preference.

I purchased a Delta RS830 in 2004 at Lowes. They had it marked down really cheap. I thought they were just selling off the beat-up floor model, but after I told the guy I wanted it, he said he'd go get one. Got a brand new one for half the (Lowes) original price.

Why? Two reasons-- 1) the price. But mostly 2) because I hated cross cutting and cutting dado's in my table saw. Even with a long sled, I always ended up having something slip and not getting a good crosscut.

At first I was dissapointed in it. On some of the rips, the saw would tend to try to get a way from me (actually run TO me). But, later on, after I had 220 run into my shop, I switched it over and it works much better now.

I even have it setup pretty well to eliminate a good bit of saw dust. I put a floor mount HVAC vent on the back end behind the blade (just to the left of the arm base). I cut a hole in the top for a 1 1/2" pvc pipe and connected it to an old shop-vac hose, and into the top of the blade shroud. Does pretty well.

I was supprised recently to see Norm Abrams using one on his show last Saturday. It looked like he had an older model one, but don't recall ever seeing him use it. He always cut his stock with his table saw.

Personally, after working without one, and now working with one, I can't see how anyone would not want to have one. But, that just my preference.

L8R...JEB

Re: have radial arm saws outlived their usefulness?

#12

Re: I wouldn't give mine up for anything

geary from nj

>Hey Mike C, ya wanna buy my craftman RAS? Its in good shape and currently residing in my garage next to the almost new treadmill; both going for CHEAP!!!geary from nj

Re: have radial arm saws outlived their usefulness?

#13

Hall of Fame

Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach

>> I was supprised recently to see Norm Abram using one on his show last Saturday. It looked like he had an older model one, but don't recall ever seeing him use it. He always cut his stock with his table saw.

Apparently you've not been watching close enough. Norm has used the radial arm saw in 50 projects (in 247 episodes)—enough for me to have installed it in my Norm's Tools Hall of Fame.

His principle use of it, I believe, is in cutting dadoes. He's never ripped with it and although he has done some angled cuts, it's primarily left at 90°.

Also, he's had two. In the early years (Seasons One and Two) he used a Craftsman electronic version in 18 projects. Between it and the Delta, that's pretty good representation in a shop which has had a Unisaw since Day One.

Rod

Re: have radial arm saws outlived their usefulness?

#14

Re: have radial arm saws outlived their usefulness

jmohnike

>Questions

Can you cut a dado or rabit on your cutoff saw?

Can you rip saw on it?

Can you attach a shaper head to it?

Can you rotate the head 90 and attach a chuck and router bit and use it as a shaper or pin router (slow but does work)?

Can you get an attachment for it and use it as an edge joiner?

Can you cover the table with paper and set things on it while the glue dries;-)

Can you attach a rotary planer to it?

All of the above and more are possible with a RAS.

Re: have radial arm saws outlived their usefulness?

#15

Re: Hall of Fame

Dan Mitchell

>Rod - So that ancient looking gray TS with the round tubular fence rails & narrow metal fence & no extension table that he uses in the 1st season is an old Unisaw?

Dan

Re: have radial arm saws outlived their usefulness?

#16

Re: Hall of Fame

Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach

>> So that ancient looking gray TS with the round tubular fence rails & narrow metal fence & no extension table that he uses in the 1st season is an old Unisaw?

Yep. Morash' wife bought it (a Rockwell, which owned Delta at the time) for him as a present—in the '60s, according to one source I had. It served as the foundation of The New Yankee Workshop, which first aired in 1989. In 1994 (real years), it was replaced by a newer version (now simply a Delta)—in the 7th season (TV years—aired in 1995, Episode 713), which is still in use. And by the way, that fence was called the Jet-Lock by Delta and was standard issue, in one form or another, for many years.

All this information and more is in the Norm's Tools section of my website.

Rod

Re: have radial arm saws outlived their usefulness?

#17

Re: Hall of Fame

Dan Mitchell

>"Yep. Morash' wife bought it (a Rockwell, which owned Delta at the time) for him as a present�in the '60s, according to one source I had."

OK your knowledge of these people's personal lives is beginning to freak me out a little ;-)

Cool site!

Dan

Re: have radial arm saws outlived their usefulness?

#18

Re: have radial arm saws outlived their usefulness

geary fron nj

>Hey jmohnike! You really like to live dangerously! In 30 years I've tried most all those things on a RAS.....it took me a split second, on most all those experiments,to figure out an alternative method sos to keep all my body parts in their proper condition. Do you really use a RAS as a router? geary from nj

Re: have radial arm saws outlived their usefulness?

#19

Lee Gordon

Re: Hall of Fame

Lee Gordon

>"All this information and more is in the Norm's Tools section of my website. "

Did I just hear some "shameless whoring?" ;-)

Re: have radial arm saws outlived their usefulness?

#20

Re: Hall of Fame

Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach

>> Did I just hear some "shameless whoring?" ;-)

Yes you did. Thanks for noticing.

Rod

(to those not understanding this exchange, Lee and I are old usenet buddies on the wreck—rec.woodworking—something about “shamelessly whoring” is in my tagline)

Re: have radial arm saws outlived their usefulness?

#21

Re: have radial arm saws outlived their usefulness

Bob Wilkerson

>I'd say that there is a use for both. The SCMS have an advantage in being smaller and portable as well as being a good tool. The RAS's are the Big Brother in that it can do many things that can't be done on the SCMS. Long cross cuts, dado's, etc. are their forte. RAS's get panned for problems that are often the result of poor setups and inadequate design (ie: Craftsman/Delta late model home shop versions). The newer light weight home RAS's just don't have the mass to avoid flex in the arm. This is the problem that I had with my old (70's) Powr-Kraft (Toolkraft) RAS. If the blade caught it would ride up and try to chase me....

OTOH I have a couple of old Dewalt RAS's ( 9" MBF and 14"GA) that are work horses. After tuning them up they are accurate and cut well. There will always be at least one in my shop.

That said, I have and use both as they are complimentary in my use for working at home and building houses. If the RAS was easy enough to move I'd load it up for use on the site building houses.

Bob

Re: have radial arm saws outlived their usefulness?

#22

Re: have radial arm saws outlived their usefulness

Greg Deavers

>I wish I had one.

I have the big Dewalt 12" slider. You can't put a dado on any of todays sliders that I have found. Certainly a lot easier, and more accurate in making shelf dados in side panels, etc.

Re: have radial arm saws outlived their usefulness?

#23

Re: have radial arm saws outlived their usefulness

Danny Comsa

>I used to have a 12" Sears RAS and it cut straight, dadoed, sanded, etc. BUT the BEST part was that I could see the line and the cut edge at the same time. Can't do that with a table saw. I could move the wood cut line to the blade and know exactly where I was cutting. And dadoing "upside down" so that I could actually see what I was doing was much better and easier. Really wish I could get it back, but my SCMS Dewalt 12" will have to do (and it does). As I often cut 1x12's.

Personally, If you have the room, get a good Radial Arm Saw and you will be happier as it can do so much with one tool.

Re: have radial arm saws outlived their usefulness?

#24

Re: have radial arm saws outlived their usefulness

Geary from NJ

>Dear Danny,Here we go again! If you keep on reading,you'll see I asked the same question back in october. Learned two things.....#1,it's a matter of personal preference. #2, If you have a sears RAS, it needs to be one of the earlier models, so the arm doesn't flex and allow the blade to crawl on top of the work piece, AND GETTCHA! I just happen to have ONe for sale CHEAP! Call or write me... drop me an email Geary

Re: have radial arm saws outlived their usefulness?

#25

Re: have radial arm saws outlived their usefulness

Al

>It soubnds like your machine was abused. I have on from the early 80's and it is tight and smooth. If you read a book on RAS then you would find they are easy to tune up and if done properly will stay tuned. My get used for almost everything as it is the only saw besides a BS in my shop. The cuts are square.