"old growth" lumber
Tom Sontag - St. Louis
>What does that term mean to you?
I've had the phrase "old growth" thrown at me several times and I think it mostly means "desirable slowly grown wood". I could be wrong about this. But I think it is important to understand what slow growing trees mean for lumber.
Slow growth and tight annual rings means greater strength for softwoods (~trees with needles). This is where I believe the reputation for old growth comes from: doug fir or SYP that is grown in a dense forest will have tight annual rings and greater strength from the higher proportion of late wood in the lumber. In softwood, the earlywood varies with rate of growth: more earlywood in faster growth yields weaker lumber. Earlywood is the spring growth with larger cells and larger pores versus the latewood cells with smaller pores. (Look at the end grain of pine and oak to see the differences). Result: slow/old growth is desirable for softwoods.
But guess what? Hardwoods are WEAKER when slowly grown. Open field or urban oak yields much stronger lumber than the slowly grown forest tree because the width of large pored early wood does not vary much in hardwoods, so the rate of growth is reflected in the amount of denser latewood. More latewood per inch = stronger.
My point is that the term "old growth" has taken on an almost mystical and magical significance which is larger than its true value since it should be considered a derogatory slam against a hardwood (which is what most furniture makers use). So the term has little meaning by itself unless you qualify it with a species or at least "softwood" or "hardwood" since it can yield opposite strength characteristics one way versus the other. Hoadley spells this out on p. 97 of "Understanding Wood", a must read for anyone who found this post the least bit interesting.
Anyhow, it came up in conversation and now I feel better.




