Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

"old growth" lumber

Posts

"old growth" lumber

#1

"old growth" lumber

Tom Sontag - St. Louis

>What does that term mean to you?

I've had the phrase "old growth" thrown at me several times and I think it mostly means "desirable slowly grown wood". I could be wrong about this. But I think it is important to understand what slow growing trees mean for lumber.

Slow growth and tight annual rings means greater strength for softwoods (~trees with needles). This is where I believe the reputation for old growth comes from: doug fir or SYP that is grown in a dense forest will have tight annual rings and greater strength from the higher proportion of late wood in the lumber. In softwood, the earlywood varies with rate of growth: more earlywood in faster growth yields weaker lumber. Earlywood is the spring growth with larger cells and larger pores versus the latewood cells with smaller pores. (Look at the end grain of pine and oak to see the differences). Result: slow/old growth is desirable for softwoods.

But guess what? Hardwoods are WEAKER when slowly grown. Open field or urban oak yields much stronger lumber than the slowly grown forest tree because the width of large pored early wood does not vary much in hardwoods, so the rate of growth is reflected in the amount of denser latewood. More latewood per inch = stronger.

My point is that the term "old growth" has taken on an almost mystical and magical significance which is larger than its true value since it should be considered a derogatory slam against a hardwood (which is what most furniture makers use). So the term has little meaning by itself unless you qualify it with a species or at least "softwood" or "hardwood" since it can yield opposite strength characteristics one way versus the other. Hoadley spells this out on p. 97 of "Understanding Wood", a must read for anyone who found this post the least bit interesting.

Anyhow, it came up in conversation and now I feel better.

Re: "old growth" lumber

#2

Re: "old growth" lumber

Lee Ohmart

>Up here in Maine, "Old Growth" usually refers to trees in areas that have never been cut. During the heyday of the lumber barons of the 1800's, very few places in the state escaped the 2-man saws and double-bitted axes of the lumberman. Trees growing in these forests were usually straight as a string with no limbs for 20-30 feet up. Lumber from that era can still be found in old barns, houses and factories. Most of the stuff that is sought after are wide pine boards completely clear of knots. Old baloon construction homes have 2x4's that go from the foundation up to the peak of the house. My first house was like that. While taking out a chimney, I followed one of these wonders all the way to the cellar. I don't think you could find a spruce in this state nowadays that would yield something like that. The hardwood from this era can be found primarily in old barns. My brother-in-laws father took down a barn with hand-hewn oak beams that spanned the entire structure. Amazing.

Re: "old growth" lumber

#3

I find slow growth better

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>For any hardwood species I can think of slow growth yields more pretty grain and easier working lumber. Slow growth white oak is nearly as light as poplar and as easy to work. The tight rings make for more grain features and in the oaks the wood is not as coarse. I think today "old growth" gets used when "slow growth" is what they should say.

Re: "old growth" lumber

#4

Re: "old growth" lumber

jcousins

>i'm in far northern CA - actually the pacific northwest area - "old growth" usually refers to 1st generation trees - as someone said - trees that have never been harvested before (not sure if that really makes sense - cause you can't cut it but 1 time). there are not many left around here. i can remember in the late 80's watching a local county fair parade where the sawmill had a truck with a single log load - they said it would be the last one anyone would ever see - now that was an old growth tree.

jerry

Re: "old growth" lumber

#5

Re: "old growth" lumber

Don Pierson

>I recently salvaged some kitchen cabinets that were made in the 1940's. They are probably douglas fir and they remained flat all these years. The picture is a piece that is 1.06" wide having 25/26 growth rings depending how you count. Back in that era a log that required a single truck were called "peelers" and went to the plywood mill where they brought top dollar.


img

Re: "old growth" lumber

#6

Re: "old growth" lumber

Larry Clinton

>Here in Indiana, I have always understood the term to indicate timber that had originated in the area (first cutting of the trees on that property). As far the "value" of the hardwood. I, and most other woodworkers in this area value the "old growth" far more that the fast grown, open straight grain, found in the replacement trees grown in the open. I guess if I were building ladders, using the wood for barn or house walls, I would prize the "new growth" but in furniture the strength of the material is rather irrelevant. Any of the woods I use are far stronger than is necessary in my furniture applications. The "figure" of the close grain in the "old growth" is far more appealing to me, (and about everyone I know in the area) than that in the wide straight grain found in "farmed" trees. IMHO, the old growth also has far more heartwood which will wear much longer in flooring, tabletops etc.

Re: "old growth" lumber

#7

Hardwoods may be weaker.....

SanMan

>.....but they will be a more stable material than a fast growing or stressed tree that grew in the wide open. A stressed tree in a windy area will cup alot more acrost its width when sawn/dried than one grown in a dense forest.

To me *Old Growth* means both its slow grown and tight ringed....then that *OG* statement is valid in my book.

In terms of years for describing *OG*, when does this kick in?

50yrs -100yrs -200yrs -?

Re: "old growth" lumber

#8

Re: Hardwoods may be weaker.....

Robin Corell in Atascadero Ca

>Last year on our vacation one of the many tings we did was visit Ladybird Johnson Grove. It is located in the northern portion of Humboldt county, Californis and is a tract of virging old growth forest. when a tree falls it is left to decay. If a tree falls across a trail or road a minimal section is cut and rolled to the side and it too is left to decay. At first it made me cringe to see this valuable wood being left to rot, but after you see and understand what an old growth forest is it starts to make sence that some of this needs to be preserved.

In a redwood forest, such as those in the mountians around Santa Cruz CA that has been logged the second growth trees are now aproaching 3 -4 feet in diameter with an ocasional 6 footer. These were the trees that were considered too small to cut when the area was first logged. These second growth forests are beautiful places with an ocasional streem of light making beautiful patterns on the forest floor. In an old growth redwood forest the trees are 10-15 feet in diameter and sunlight never reches the forest floor. there is good reason for an almost mystical quallity attached to these areas. while we were there we encountered people from all over the world hikeing in the forest. I would estimate that a 50% of the other tourists were non english speeking, seems big trees are quite an international tourist attraction.

Robin

Re: "old growth" lumber

#9

Rick L

Re: Old growth can mean Antique...

Rick L

>Old harvested lumber actually gets harder over time. We sell antque lumber and old heart pine is tougher to mill than fresh cut oak. Antique lumber is quite spectacular in color, grain and more.

Re: "old growth" lumber

#10

Re: "old growth" lumber

geary

>Here in New Jersey we have no trees,just MDF. geary

Re: "old growth" lumber

#11

understanding wood

JohnKJordan in East TN

>>Hoadley spells this out on p. 97 of

>"Understanding Wood", a must read for anyone

>who found this post the least bit interesting.

I second the motion recommending this book. It was one of the first I bought when researching wood processing before getting a sawmill. I found his insight on drying and shrinkage as well as cellular structure took much of the mystery out wood, from the tree to the finishing.

A most excellent book for anyone who works with wood.

JKJ

Re: "old growth" lumber

#12

Means something very different and specific here

Michael Dresdner

>Old growth western red cedar has some pecular characteristics. The wood develops chemicals that make it resistant to bugs and rot, but the loggers here say that starts to generate only after the tree is about 100 years old. After another two hundred years you have what they call old growth wood. Oddly, when you look at one of these trees once it is felled, the core, the first hundred years worth of growth, often rotted clean away so that the tree cross section looks like a donut, but the remaining wood is very desirable.

Incidentally, you are not allowed to cut old growth in most areas of Washington without a permit for it. Of course, because most of this area that is accessible was already logged once, it is quite hard to find old growth. One friend who has a bunch of it took me on a walk through his stash, and it is like nothing I've seen before.

As for the first time an area is cut, out here that is called virgin cutting as opposed to old growth.

Re: "old growth" lumber

#13

Ellis Walentine

Re: "old growth" lumber

Ellis Walentine

>Tom, I have a first edition copy of Hoadley and I'm not finding what you're talking about on p.97. What chapter and subheading should I be looking for?

Ellis