Re: skylight in the shop
JohnKJordan in East TN
>Bruce,
I love skylights and have them in my house. However...
1) My son is an architect and I have several good friends who are architects and builders. There is an old saying in the trade: "Skylights always leak."
2) You will find plenty of people who claim this is a myth, that if you have quality skylights installed correctly they will not leak. Note tha most of these people are trying to sell you a skylight.
3) The timberframe house we live in has four top quality skylights that can be opened for ventilation. They appear to have been professionally installed correctly and the roof is in excellent shape. Two of these skylights occasionally leak in a thunderstorm.
I believe in my case the problem is not in the installation, but in the maintenance. If windblown debris such as leaves and twigs collects on the upper edge, it can create a dam which can prevent proper runoff in a heavy rain and allow some water to build up and leak around the seals. Occasional cleaning prevent this, but in our case the windows are WAY up there on 12-12 a pitch roof so it's not easy.
Any water leak can be very expensive in the long run. More archiwisdom: a huge part of architecture concerns keeping water out of the building, as evident by 90% of building-related lawsuits.
If I were installing new skylights (and if I ever replace these), I would choose non-opening skylights that could be sealed to the roof. I've seen some that look like bubbles. I will probably put a row of these in my new shop. Note however, that these (at least those I've seen) are made out of plastic and after some years the plastic can craze, scratch, cloud, and discolor somewhat. I suspect that UV is rough on them.
JKJ