Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

skylight in the shop

Posts

skylight in the shop

#1

skylight in the shop

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>I'm looking for free light, and, lacking windows, it seems that a skylight would be one way to go about it.

Does anyone have experience with one of these, and if so, do you have any thoughts on placement? I have my workbench against the west wall, and I'm thinking that a good spot would be right over it, but I'm open to suggestions.

Thanks

bruce, working in a dark, wet MN.

Re: skylight in the shop

#2

Re: skylight in the shop

Rob Stokes in North Vancouver

>A bit hard to see, but in the pic (link below), look up and you'll see 3 of four skylights I put in my old 20x20 shop.

They were definitely worth it and allowed me to reduce the windows in the building which gave me added security and a lot more wall space.

http://www.robswoodworking.com/images/panorama_1.jpg

Rob

Re: skylight in the shop

#3

Re: skylight in the shop

JohnKJordan in East TN

>Bruce,

I love skylights and have them in my house. However...

1) My son is an architect and I have several good friends who are architects and builders. There is an old saying in the trade: "Skylights always leak."

2) You will find plenty of people who claim this is a myth, that if you have quality skylights installed correctly they will not leak. Note tha most of these people are trying to sell you a skylight.

3) The timberframe house we live in has four top quality skylights that can be opened for ventilation. They appear to have been professionally installed correctly and the roof is in excellent shape. Two of these skylights occasionally leak in a thunderstorm.

I believe in my case the problem is not in the installation, but in the maintenance. If windblown debris such as leaves and twigs collects on the upper edge, it can create a dam which can prevent proper runoff in a heavy rain and allow some water to build up and leak around the seals. Occasional cleaning prevent this, but in our case the windows are WAY up there on 12-12 a pitch roof so it's not easy.

Any water leak can be very expensive in the long run. More archiwisdom: a huge part of architecture concerns keeping water out of the building, as evident by 90% of building-related lawsuits.

If I were installing new skylights (and if I ever replace these), I would choose non-opening skylights that could be sealed to the roof. I've seen some that look like bubbles. I will probably put a row of these in my new shop. Note however, that these (at least those I've seen) are made out of plastic and after some years the plastic can craze, scratch, cloud, and discolor somewhat. I suspect that UV is rough on them.

JKJ

Re: skylight in the shop

#4

Re: skylight in the shop

jared

>HEllo Skylights make ahuge difference in light. I have a Pella skylight in my kitchen. I put it in about twenty years ago. I used a fixed glass-non venting- because i was afraid of leaks. It has never leaked, not once. It is tempered glass, has stood up to massive hail stones, with no damage. A bigger problem than external leaks may be condensation in the winter on the interior glass. I built a recessed panel that fits in the tunnel that goes from ceiling level to the roof level where the skylight is and that takes care of the condensation. IF I forget to put it in in the fall there is water running off the interior glass all of the time. Jared

Re: skylight in the shop

#5

Another thought....

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>I agree that skylights can pose a leak potential. So if you install them you might want to select locations where a leak would not ruin tools etc.

One other approach is to build dormers. Dormers can be a nice way to get light into a space from above.

Tom

Re: skylight in the shop

#6

Re: skylight in the shop

Robin Corell in Atascadero Ca

>something that can help for water and debris runoff are adding crickets to the upper edge of a skylight. Crickets are something you dont se too often in todays slam bam fram them up construction but they are just small triangular pieces of ply placed on the uphill side of something like a skylight to create a slight ridge to aid in water runnoff.

I had a house in San Jose that was build by an old time carpenter and he used crickets on the two large skylights in the shop. I never had any leak issues, other than having to redo the glazing compound and the shop was built in 1965.

I would add thet you may want to be very carful in your placement of the skylights. in my old shop the sun would come through the skylights and hit my bench top and that created all kinds of problems. In my case the glass was the old laminated kind with chicken wire in it and the newer ones all have an 'E' coating to reduce UV transmission. The great light is worth it.

Robin

Re: skylight in the shop

#7

Re: skylight in the shop

Chicago Bob

>Robin,

I'm curious about the "crikets" - but I'm not sure I understand how they work. Could you provide a little more detai?

thanks

Bob

Re: skylight in the shop

#8

Re: skylight in the shop

Robin Corell, in Atascadero CA

>if the uphill side of the skylight is perpendicular to the fall line of the roof the frame of the skylight creates an area where water can pool a bit. an old time solutuion was to nail a 2x2 on the roof against the skylight frame and then cut two triangle pices of ply such that when naild to the 2x2 one edge is against the skylight frame, one edge creates a 'ridge' and the other edge feathers into the original roof. once it is all shingled the cricket chanels the water such that it is not flowing into the skylight frame and potentially above the flashing in a heavy down pour, but rather to the sides of the skylight.

Robin

Re: skylight in the shop

#9

Re: skylight in the shop

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>Rob,

That shop is freakishly clean! Are you sure you work in there?

The pic sure demonstrates how the skylights help. Thanks.

Bruce, whose shop is jealous of yours.

Re: skylight in the shop

#10

Re: skylight in the shop

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>I'm going for the non-opening version, with glass and then follow up with glass or something at ceiling level to prevent the condensation potential.

Thanks for posting.

Bruce

Re: skylight in the shop

#11

Re: skylight in the shop

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>Thanks for that explanation. That cricket idea sounds like a good one. I'll give it a try.

I was going to ask the question but C. Bob beat me to it.

Bruce

Re: skylight in the shop

#12

Re: skylight in the shop

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>Thanks, Jared, esp for the idea of the glass at ceiling level. I'll do that. After all, that light is already out there, and it's free for the taking. Might as well use it.

Bruce

Re: skylight in the shop

#13

Re: skylight in the shop

Kneale Brownson in sunny N. MI

>Crickets are common uproof from chimneys. From a DIY information page called Home Tips, they look like the shaded part:


Re: skylight in the shop

#14

Re: skylight in the shop

Herb Yost

>I can't remember the technical term for it, but my folks have a kind of skylight in the baths at home. it's a highly polished tube with one end on the roof, and the other in the bath. both have appropriate weather and decorative collars. It's incredible the amount of light those things bring into the room.

Re: skylight in the shop

#15

Re: skylight in the shop

Bruce, a MN galoot

>Herb,

Is it one of these things: http://www.solatube.com/homeowner/

Re: skylight in the shop

#16

Re: skylight in the shop

Rob Stokes in North Vancouver

>That's the old shop I built in Sumner WA. I barely got to scratch it before we moved. It's now a machine shop - looking extremely used - which is perfect.

Rob