Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

Trouble face jointing birch *LINK*

Posts

Trouble face jointing birch *LINK*

#1

Trouble face jointing birch *LINK*

Dan Mitchell

>I'm having difficulty getting flat surfaces on some birch I am trying to face joint for a glass table base. The boards are about 27" long, by 3 1/8" wide, by 1 3/8" thick. I have posted some pics at the URL below. Basically, I am running the boards through my table saw. The non-faced surface (against the fence) s flat & the edges are 90 degrees to the faces. Since the width exceeds what can be cut w/the 10" blade, I have set the blade a little over half way up the width of the boards, made a cut, then flipped the boards & cut the other half. The cut is about 1/16, so less than the 1/8 kerf. As shown in the 1st pic I have 2 sets of fingerboards pushing the stock firmly against the fence before & after the blade (again, there is no waste due to the thin cut). While the faces look smooth (pic 2) they are in fact slightly convex. As shown in pics 3 & 4, when one edge is clamped, there is a gap of about 1/32" on the opposite side of the joint. I know a planer should be used for this, but I don't have one, plus it seems the saw should be able to pull this off. Blade is exactly 90 degrees to the table, according to several squares. HELP!!! :-)

TIA,

Dan


Table Top Troubles

Re: Trouble face jointing birch *LINK*

#2

Ellis Walentine

I'll take a shot at it...

Ellis Walentine

>I assume when you say convex, you mean across the width (height) of your workpieces. If so, the most likely cause (other than if the fence and/or blade are not square to the table) is the tendency of a sawblade to deflect when the load condition is one-sided as you describe. Birch is a pretty hard wood and the fact that you are not taking a full kerf's worth of material away means that the outside of the blade is free to deflect outward slightly -- probably enough to create this condition. The sharper the blade, the less of a factor this will be, but it will always be a factor.

One workaround would be to incline the blade slightly toward the fence and let this natural deflection process work to your advantage. The far simpler and more rewarding solution would be to trot out your trusty smoothing plane and take a couple shavings off that center hump.

Hope this helps.

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: Trouble face jointing birch *LINK*

#3

Re: I'll take a shot at it...

Dan Mitchell

>Thanks Ellis. Yeah that's what I meant, basically that there's a slight raised area down the middle. I had thought the blade might be deflecting. It's a WWII. Since the error is multiplied X2 when the 2 boards come together, it doesn't take much to cause a gap. Compensating a bit as you suggested might be worth a try, only trouble is the pieces are getting near the point of no return, thickness-wise. I have a very old Stanley jack plane that belonged to my father, now doubt dull as a paint scraper & I have zero experience with it in any case. I have a hand held belt sander which may be more up my alley, in terms of the level of operator expertise required ;-)

Dan

Re: Trouble face jointing birch *LINK*

#4

Re: Trouble face jointing birch

Pat Evans

>There is an article in this month's ShopNotes on face jointing with a table saw. Might be helpful.

Re: Trouble face jointing birch *LINK*

#5

blade choice

Robin Corell in Atascadero Ca

>Along the same lines as Ellis has already pointed out about blade deflection I would also add that I don't think the WWII is the best blade choice for what you are trying to do. not to rag on the WWII but it is a multi-purpose blade which means it is a compromise for many applications. A true rip blade will perform better with less deflection. for truely amazing results and glue line ripping you could try a .150" kerf blade as opposed to the more common .125" kerf. I would definately stay away from any of the thin kerf blades.

As wood workers we tend to want to be frugal with our expensive woods and use thin kerf blades so we waste less wood. The reality is that an additional .025" of sawdust can add a dramatic increase in the quallity of the cut that requires less clean up. there is an added bonus to using a rip blade, actually two. First they are less expensive than a combo blade, and they cost less to sharpen. Since most opperations on a table saw are ripping it should be the blade of choice most of the time.

Also rather than using a square to check for the squarenes of the saw blade a more accurate method is to raise the saw blade as high as it will go and cross cut a couple of pieces of scrap wood that are the maximum capacity your saw will cut. use the two pieces from the same side of the blade and place them end to end on the table surface. if they meet perfectly you are dead on. if there is any gap it is 2x the amount your saw is out of square.

Robin

Re: Trouble face jointing birch *LINK*

#6

Ellis Walentine

Two things...

Ellis Walentine

>First, Forrest blades have a very specialized tooth geometry, with only the slightest tangential taper to the carbide tips. This is what makes these blades leave such a nice surface; the sides of the teeth are in closer contact with the wood and tend to follow through better without wandering and producing scratches. This property would be just what you don't want in your current application. Try a reputable rip blade with normal side clearances and as heavy a plate as possible. Several manufacturers including CMT, Amana, Ridge Carbide and others make heavy blades like this. And expect to have to scrape or sand the cut surface when you're through. A sawblade is simply not a finishing tool.

Second, do yourself a big favor and buy a good bench plane and take the time to learn how to sharpen it and use it. There is simply no more appropriate way to produce the cleanest, flattest surface in a situation like this. In ten seconds, you'd have a crystal clear, flat, straight surface that is ready for finish. We've got plenty of advertisers here who are ready and waiting to help you get started down the slippery slope (and pleasures) of hand tool use. Just ask Jim Shaver.

Cheers,

Ellis

Re: Trouble face jointing birch *LINK*

#7

Re: I'll take a shot at it...

Rob Stokes in North Vancouver

>Dan - I'm a power tool guy, but this is a time when there's no sub for a hand plane. Put the project aside, read up on tuning/sharpening your plane, spent the $$ on sharpening supplies (I use Scary Sharp), snuggle up to the old relic and put the plane to work.

Birch is one of the most satisfying woods to plane. It'll go from junk to "WOW" in one pass and you'll have your stock the way you want it way too fast.

Rob

Re: Trouble face jointing birch *LINK*

#8

Re: Trouble face jointing birch

Dan Mitchell

>Use a tool without a CORD?!? NO NO NO DON'T MAKE ME DO IT!!!!!! ;-)

OK I dug out the old plane. Here's a pic. I was wrong, it's a Dunlop, not a Stanley, FWTW. At the very least, it needs a good clean up. I have a 20 year old Craftsman wet sharpener system (with a cord... whew... ) which works quite well on knives, I'll see what it can do on the plane blade.

Also found a good general planing article http://www.extremehowto.com/xh/printpage.asp?article_id=60341

Thanks for all the suggestions. I'll also look up the Shopnotes article Pat mentioned.

Thanks for the helpful replies!

Dan


img

Re: Trouble face jointing birch *LINK*

#9

Ellis Walentine

Need to free up the budget a bit...

Ellis Walentine

>While I'm a firm believer that you can tune up any plane to work beautifully (or at least acceptably), I hate to see you start from so far behind. If you could spring for a new Lee Valley or Lie-Nielsen plane and a progression of sharpening stones, you'd be off and running a lot sooner. For less, you can get a decent "user" plane at a tool sale or swap meet for under a hundred bucks, maybe under fifty.

Whatever the tab or your available resources, don't fail to learn how to use a hand plane well. I can see from your clean shop and your attention to detail that you would be a natural with hand tools, and they would help you so much.

Regards,

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: Trouble face jointing birch *LINK*

#10

Re: Trouble face jointing birch

albertabob

>I don't think anybody has noticed that you are using 2 feather boards on the work piece.

That's not ideal.

When the work travels to the blade it is proud of the blade by the distance you set your cut. (in your case your are planning it so a few thou.)

After it leaves the surface of the blade at the back you are again pushing it with the extra feather board toward the fence.

The end of the fence is usually set "loosey" 3000 to 5000ths" away from the path of travel.

What you have now is a board traveling at an angle to the blade and That will account for most of the problem with the joint faces.

Try just using feather borads on the feed side of the blade and let the wood travel past the blade on it's own.

p.s. planes are good too, but you should not need them this soon in the process.

Try my suggestion on a piece of scrap and tell me what you see.

Bob

Re: Trouble face jointing birch *LINK*

#11

"I can see from your clean shop... "

Dan Mitchell

>Ha! Wait'll my wife sees that!!! ;-)

Honestly, it's only clean because, other than the outfeed table, I haven't actually BUILT anything! OK yesterday I DID hang up a couple shelves. And I DID make my wife a small jewelry box from some of the wood from the new saw's pallet (cutting staple-infested pallet lumber with your brand new $120 combo blade, what's wrong with that?!?) But this table base goes back about a year, I started it on a Bosch 5412 miter saw. LOOOOOOOONG story!

Seriously, is the plane that bad? Aren't examples of any given type basically the same, in terms of parts & operation? The thing's probably a good 50 years old, so it's not a recent piece of crap (I know, only thing worse than a NEW piece of crap is an old, dirty, rusty, DULL piece of crap ;-).

Can you suggest a couple specific plane models?

Thanks Ellis!

Dan

Re: Trouble face jointing birch *LINK*

#12

Re: Trouble face jointing birch

Dan Mitchell

>Bob-Thanks for the reply. I know it's often suggested that the fence lean away from the blade a bit on the outfeed side to avoid kickback, in my case I set it parallel for its entire length to the miter slot (which I had previously set parallel to the blade) using a dial indicator riding in the miter slot. I'll try what you suggest on a 2x4 though as a test.

Dan

Re: Trouble face jointing birch *LINK*

#13

Re: Trouble face jointing birch

Rob Stokes in North Vancouver

>My favorite #4 is a Dunlop.

Rob

Re: Trouble face jointing birch *LINK*

#14

Re: Need to free up the budget a bit...

Rob Stokes in North Vancouver

>I'm not sure I agree Ellis - while a LV or LN plane and a full compliment of stones would be nice, they're far from required reading.

As I said in another post - my "reach for" plane is an old Dunlop #4 that I bought before I knew any better. Now that I know better, I still reach for it - or for a well used #5c Stanley, or for an old #78. The plane that gets the most use is indeed a LV - but it's the apron plane and it was a gift (though I'd buy one in a heart beat now that I've had the pleasure).

So there's absolutely no need to spend $$ on a "good" plane and in fact - I'd suggest against it for someone who's starting from the ground up. Tuning an old plane and making it work is something I'd consider mandatory learning - theres; no better way to understand what makes a plane tick.

The other area we disagree is in the fleet of stones. Now, maybe it's a case of what I don't know I don't know, but I don't have stones, and I do have sharp tools. I spent $25 on a #2 surface plate from Grizzly and another $25 on what's turning out to be close to a lifetime's supply of automotive wet/dry sandpaper to 2000 grit. Your sharpening station may look cooler than mine, and yours might be "proper", but mine works perfectly well.

However - keep in mind what I said in my first post - I'm a power tool guy and not a hand tool guy. But I do reach for my hand tools a LOT to "tune" work done on power tools, and while none of them would bring any $$ whatsoever at an auction - all of them get the job done and all of them left $$ in the budget for other things.

If I was "the mentor" here, I'd insist that the old Dunlop be made to cut and then used on this project as a first step in the slippery slope that are hand tools.

Rob

Re: Trouble face jointing birch *LINK*

#15

Re: Have to agree with Ellis

Larry Clinton

>Rob, not saying your Dunlap isn't a great plane - but I have found some of the cheaper (and the Dunlap was Sears's cheap plane brand as I remember) to be inconsistent in clearances, bedding and even hardness of the blades. Some are great - next one almost junk. I have refurbished several Stanley's and a few off brands. I do have an old but very accurate surface grinder in my shop so my method is to first finish grind the sole, then grind both sides parallel to the sole. I then grind the proper angle on the blade and if necessary on the chip breaker. I then hand file all parts to be flat and true, finish sharpening and lap the blade and chip-breaker, clean and adjust the plane and try it out. This normally takes me the better part of a day to finish everything, even after doing several and having the surface grinder available. I have only had one Stanley that just won't work properly, the chip breaker & blade has way too much clearance on the sides and doesn't hold adjustment well. I have had a couple of the off brands that work pretty well but also have 2 or 3 that don't perform well at all. Two have very poor blades either due to the steel or the heat treating process and won't hold an edge on hardwood. The other just drifts in adjustment - if I tighten any more I will crack the casting. I would recommend a beginner at least start with a Plane that has been tuned up by someone with some experience. Then it is not too hard to keep it sharp and adjusted. By observation a beginner can see where the chip-breaker should set, how much clearance for the blade etc. I am an old codger and have tried many sharpening methods. I really agree with Forrest Addy in that a new woodworker should learn one method and stay with it. However, I am teaching my son what little I know about woodworking and I have a good set of stones and a Lee Valley Mark 2 honing guide I taught him to use. Granted I don't use it much - but he has some problems keeping chisels and plane blades flat and this allows him to sharpen properly. I am sure in another year or so he will be free-handing most tools. To start out a man who wants to flatten a board, I think the shorter method suggested by Ellis is best. After a few projects are completed most woodworkers do become more adapt at sharpening and tuning tools, but first they really should know how a properly tuned tools performs.

Re: Trouble face jointing birch *LINK*

#16

Re: Have to agree with Ellis

Rob Stokes in North Vancouver

>I guess I didn't get my point across - I'm not defending the Dunlop per sei, I'm stating that buying a LV or LN and a set of stones is not a prerequisite to learning about hand planes. I just happened to use the Dunlop I have as an example. And my the sounds of it, I've got an oddball (but a good oddball).

Your son is lucky - he's got a mentor who can teach how to tune a plane. I learned from books, a few who shared knowledge and mistakes. And I'm certainly no where near adept at it. But I know what I need to know to make a hand plane a useful tool for me, and none of my planes cost more that $10 (except my Steve knight smoother - but that's a different animal).

Would I like a set of fancy planes and fancy stones? Sure I would - but I sure don't need them and I'm certainly not going to recommend to someone starting out with hand tools that buying a basket of goodies like that is the first thing they should do. In fact such purchases are not even close to being on the horizon - I just don't see the need for them (with my budget).

Rob

Re: Trouble face jointing birch *LINK*

#17

Re: Have to agree with Ellis

Dan Mitchell

>Thanks for the continued opinions on this. I have taken the Dunlop apart and cleaned it, I'm going to sharpen the blade & play around with it a bit. At this time I personally am more interested in the "machine tool" approach to this discipline. I'm not sure how much a set of truly fine planes and the requisite bits to keep them sharp would set me back, but right now I would rather put the money toward a router table or jointer, a seemingly nice used example of the latter I may have located ;-)

Thanks again everyone.

Dan

Re: Trouble face jointing birch *LINK*

#18

Re: Trouble face jointing birch

Al Stokka - Cambridge, Iowa

>Dan,

A longshot suggestion here. You say the blade is precisely 90� to the table but, what about the fence? If the fence is not perpendicular to the table, you'll never make that cut work.

Forget the hand planes and find a planer.

Al

Re: Trouble face jointing birch *LINK*

#19

Re: Agree with Ellis too

Jay St. Peter - Southern, MD

>When I started I was very frustrated by hand planes. I had bought a bunch of decent old Stanley planes (Bailey and Bedrock), but didn't really know how a plane should work or how to make it work as it should. I hadn't really ever seen one work correctly or used one before. I don't think any amount of reading really helps as much as either having someone physically help you, or buying one really nice plane and using it for a while without having to worry about what is wrong with it. Since picking up a few LV planes and using them for a while, I have tuned up most of the old planes into nice users.

Dan, I understand your desire to use power tools ... BTDT. But, hand tools will take your work to another level. They really are the way to get the tightest joinery.

That said, if you do get a nice jointer this problem can be solved. Better yet, just run them through a planer and shave the convex part off. That's actually how I'd do it. I'm assuming you don't have a planer or jointer at this point or you probably wouldn't be using the TS to do this. Personally I'd pick up a planer first so you can make wood the thickness you need. But they are both necessary (without hand tools :)) and the which first debate has occurred many times.

Jay

Re: Trouble face jointing birch *LINK*

#20

Re: Trouble face jointing birch

Dan Mitchell

>Al-When I got the saw I set it up with a dial indicator riding in the miter slot. Fence is parallel to the slot, which is parallel to the blade.

I'd like to have a jointer & a planer. I'm going in stages, 1st the table saw, and next week they're delivering the Penn State dust collector I got feedback on here. I was thinking my next purchase would be a router table, but lately I've been looking at used planers & jointers on Craig's List. etc.

On this project, the 2 surfaces will simply be glued together. At this point I'm thinking of just running my belt sander down the middle of each & being done with it.

Dan

Re: Trouble face jointing birch *LINK*

#21

Ellis Walentine

You're right. Any plane can do the job...

Ellis Walentine

>...if it is properly "fettled," as Kirby would say, and sharpened. That old Dunlop is capable of a fine job if the sole is flat and the blade is sharp and the chip breaker is properly ground and seated. Its only deficiencies, compared with today's fancier models, are the relatively thinner iron, the flatness tolerances of the sole, and the construction and machining of the frog, none of which are dealbreakers here.

But, a lot of people don't have the chops or the experience to tune up a plane. These skills are valuable and should be learned, but there's a lot to be said for starting with one that will reward and encourage you from the get-go. And, no plane, old or new, will be very rewarding unless the iron is sharpened properly; so some kind of sharpening stones or systems are in order.

Ellis

Re: Trouble face jointing birch *LINK*

#22

Re: One more time.

Al Stokka - Cambridge, Iowa

>Dan,

I understand that the blade, slot and fence are parallel...in a horiaontal plane (the tabletop). What I'm talking about is ensuring that the fence is perpendicular to the table in a vertical plane. In other words, check that the top of the fence is not farther away from the blade than the bottom edge of the fence.

Al

Re: Trouble face jointing birch *LINK*

#23

D'oh!!!!!

Dan Mitchell

>Al-Well I had checked that on set-up. Really, I did! But it's off, top is just about half the total error amount canted to the right - in other words, exactly what would be expected. I haven't re-run the boards yet, but I'm guessing after adjusting this, the trouble will be at the very least, greatly reduced.

This setting is THE obvious cause of the problem, yet it hadn't even occurred to me. THANKS!

Dan

Re: Trouble face jointing birch *LINK*

#24

Re: Trouble face jointing birch

Francisco

>Dan,

I have been building my workbench for two months now, it is in Hard Maple. This wood is like Birch, I have never worked with Birch but for sure is a relly Hard wood.....If you are planning to plane that wood with that plane in particular, You will need lots of patience, time and handplaning skills (including tunning)

Many folks are using a handplane and they are saying in their minds: "A nice Martin Planner would set this board in a brief!!!".....just think in those times when handplanes were so popular, the life was slower......I do not have $23K bucks to pay for a Martin Planner, neither for a good Minimax or a similar GOOD planner, so I do not have other choise than use Handplanes.

Using them in the right way, involves other items like Water Stones (1200 and 6000) a good Honing guide and a glass plate 1/2" thick to flat back the stones and sporadicly flat the planes' soles with carbide sand paper.