Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Another wood movement question

Posts

Another wood movement question

#1

Another wood movement question

RickS

>The setup: A chest of drawers in curly maple. Drawers are 18" deep, Inset with Cockbead. Chest is solid wood, long grain veritcal (Movement will be front to back). The drawer bottoms will project past the back of the drawer to act as drawer stops and expand and contract with the case sides to control the reveal at the front.

The question: I want to use unfinished aromatic red cedar as my drawer bottoms. The case will be finished with dye stain, tung oil and then shellac. The wood movement should be about 3/32 for the drawer bottoms and 3/16 for the case sides (from my limited calculations) if both are left unfinished. By finishing the sides and leaving the drawer bottoms unfinished will the movement just about equal out or will there still be a big enough difference in the movement to show poorly or am I over-obsessing about this?

Re: Another wood movement question

#2

Ellis Walentine

You're being too optimistic

Ellis Walentine

>This is the kind of question that engineers like to chew on, while missing the larger point that you want a stop arrangement that stops the drawer face itself, so that the depth of the cabinet and moisture transfer are not part of the equation.

Calculations of seasonal wood movement are unreliable at best, because of the inconsistencies of individual pieces of wood and all the other variables you contemplated here: width, finish, construction, etc., not to mention how dry the wood is to begin with and what type of environment it will live in when the piece is done.

If you enjoy the mental gymnastics of this, you could make one drawer your way and another with just a simple stop behind the drawer front and see what happens over the first two years.

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: Another wood movement question

#3

Re: You're being too optimistic

RickS

>I like this idea of a stop for the front of the drawer, but am having problems with the design elements. Due to the wood that I have to work with for the drawer faces my smallest drawer heigth is going to be 5 1/4". I was going to have the bottom only 1/16 above the drawer sides. with a 7/16" drawer bottom I only loose 1/2 inch in drawer depth for a drawer depth of 4 3/4". I don't like the idea of a drawer stop hanging down in the front of the top drawer opening. This would possibly snag on things in the drawer during opening and closing. I can't use the sides because the drawer is inset. So the only place left is the bottom. I only have 1/16" clearance in the current design. I would probably need to move the bottom up at least 1/16" above any stop that I put in. Just how tall a stop would be appropriate? I would think a 1/16" stop would get beat up pretty bad and not be useful. 1/8" probably isn't much better. What stop height would you use remembering that every bit of height in the stop reduces my drawer depth.

Re: Another wood movement question

#4

Re: You're being too optimistic

Robin Corell in Atascadero Ca

>Find a dresser that has been around for a hundred years and is in good shape. preferably something that still sees daily use. pull out a drawer and look how the drawer stops were applied. sometimes there is no better teacher than the history of a succesfull design.

The stops Ellis sugested are traditional and attached to the frame streatcher on the underside of the drawer.

The traditional approach I like is to leave the drawer sides long and let those be the stops. this only works if there is a solid back and is best used on small drawers such as jewelry and silver chests, or small letter drawers in desks.

also you are forgetting that one of the original purposes of cock beading is to provide a shadow line around the drawer to obscure any inacuracies in seasonal movement. one of the most dificult things to make is modern style flat fronts with inset drawers.

Robin