Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

Table Saw Thoughts

Posts

Table Saw Thoughts

#1

Table Saw Thoughts

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ontario

>Hi,

I have been rethinking some of my shop lay out and also equipment over the last few months. The one machine I have that takes up most of my precious space is my table saw. It was the first major shop purchase I made 10 years ago, it was a big moment for me as a hobbiest.

Now these years later I am starting to think maybe I can live with out it, replacing it with a second bandsaw that I could dedicate to rip cuts etc, the same primary cuts I use the table saw for now. I make all my other cuts with hand tools now or other power tools.

I was wondering if any one else out there has made this choice and how it worked for them,

Take care,

Jim

Re: Table Saw Thoughts

#2

Re: Table Saw Thoughts

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>You will find lots of company on the hand tool forum. But the bottom line is up to you. People that build stuff own table saws and other key power tools because it enables them to build more stuff. But there are those that just enjoy tinkering with wood/hand tools and their primary motivation is not to build stuff. If the table saw is not helping you, be rid of it. I don't see that outside advice is very helpful to make the decision. If your real question is whether there are like minded people the answer is yes, over on the hand tool forum.

Re: Table Saw Thoughts

#3

Re: Table Saw Thoughts

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ontario

>Thanks Bill,

I do read every post on the HT side every day.....the joy of moderating the HT forum with Wiley is that I learn a great deal there as well.

Take care,

Jim

Re: Table Saw Thoughts

#4

Re: Table Saw Thoughts

Ron Hildreth, Alta, Iowa

>Good Evening, Jim

There's been times that I've considered getting rid of my table saw, especially when I've taken on too big of a project than my basement shop allows for. My wife complains when I force her to park the car outside in the winter, just to have a large assembly room (garage), temporary as it might be. But then, if I do get rid of it, there goes my other assembly table when the first one is full and occupied! What's a space challenged man to do??

I know I didn't come close to answering your question, but I might have given you some more brain fodder! I don't think it will ever be as impressive to say "I have wall to wall table saw" as it was to brag about "Wall to Wall Carpet!

Ron in Iowa

Re: Table Saw Thoughts

#5

My space solution--

Joanne Adler in Pt. Pleasant, PA

>I moved so I could have a bigger shop! :-)

But didn't Denis just do this? Or get a small benchtop saw to replace his tablesaw? You might consider one of those.

My first tablesaw was the Bosch benchtop saw. It did most everything I asked it to do, was very accurate, and definitely took up less space than my PM contractor saw does. I built a little cart for it so I could add dust collection and utilize the space beneath it for storage.

Re: Table Saw Thoughts

#6

Re: Table Saw Thoughts

Paul Waddle

>Well, I want a table saw. I think I even need to keep my radial saw too! I have every thing on rollers,can push back when not using. Sometimes for convenience,sometimes for accuracy and sometimes for other work(sanding disk,etc). Handwork IS most satisfying,sometimes more accurate,sometimes more safe-BUT lets keep the table saw.pw

Re: Table Saw Thoughts

#7

Re: Table Saw Thoughts

R. Lance in GR, Michigan

>I've been an admirer of your work over the years...you know best what you need or don't need...but I went to shop tours and looked at your setup and you have/had a table saw with a 50" side table...I'd suggest that you consider losing that side extension in the interest of gaining some breathing room which I assume is your goal...this gains you 50% of what you are seeking and place the saw on a mobile base so you can easily move it to a corner or against the wall if needed...my own shop is small and I've forgone adding any tables to my unisaw...wish I had those extensions when I cut plywood but there are ways and I make do...one day, if I ever become computer literate, I'd like to show you some pictures of a workbench I made which is very close to the dimensions of the one you built a few years back...good luck with your decision.

Re: Table Saw Thoughts

#8

Re: Table Saw Thoughts

Phil Joines Krum, Tx

>The size of the saw is a problem for me too. I have been toying with the idea of modifying the fence rail so it pivots up out of the way and have the table extension/ router table a separate piece.

Re: Table Saw Thoughts

#9

Bart Goldberg

Re: Table Saw Thoughts

Bart Goldberg

>I guess each of us has a different focus when it comes to woodworking. For me, I could not live without my cabinet saw. I use it on just about every project, from making cabinets to cutting pen blanks to size with a TS sled. The accuracy and repeatability of cuts cannot be replicated by a band saw (IMHO).

Best of luck

Bart

Re: Table Saw Thoughts

#10

Wow...

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>You remembered that! I'm impressed...

I did it almost two years ago, I sold my contractors saw and replaced it with the Ridgid jobsite saw.

In all honesty, I miss my contractors saw because it was more massive and smoother than my jobsite saw, but the space savings were and still are worth it. I just don't like having to "unfold" the saw every time I need it... Need to work on the shop layout...

I did buy a second bandsaw, used for curve cutting, and set up my Delta strictly for ripping/resawing. I'm happy with that so far.

I did however hint to my wife at the possibility of moving some tools in the garage from the shop, and while in the past she didn't show any enthusiasm at the idea, she seems more receptive nowadays (the fact that the garage is stuffed with projects in progress (some long term) got her used to the idea of not hoping to use the garage to host cars anytime soon, I guess...)

In the end, the tablesaw is a space hog, and I wish there was a way out of this predicament... The Festool saw and guide seem interesting these days...

DC

Re: Table Saw Thoughts

#11

Re: Table Saw Thoughts

Garrett in Victoria

>Hi Jim

I had a similar problem, too many big tools in too small a shop. I down-sized the lathe (General 2060 to Nova DVR), changed the layout, but nothing worked until I and got a MastRslide. Then I realized I could use its fence extension arm to work off the left side of the saw for big pieces, and thus eliminate most of the saw's right side extension table. It's still bigger than a bandsaw, but has gkven back a huge chunk of space. And, it's now actually somewhat mobile.

Cheers, Garrett

Re: Table Saw Thoughts

#12

Never ;-)

Dan Donaldson

>I can't get rid of mine because it is the largest flat surface in the shop and If it went away, I wouldn't have an assembly table or temporary storage anymore. ;-)

Re: Table Saw Thoughts

#13

Re: Table Saw Thoughts

Chuck in ND

>Like some have said, you know what you need. For me I couldn't do without a tablesaw. I have a 20' X 22' garage that I do my woodworking in, and I park two vehicles in it when I'm not. It's kind of a hassle moveing vehicles out, then wheeling machinery out from the wall, then when I'm done for the day clean everything up, wheel the macinery up to the wall, and then park the vehicles back in the garage. It would be nice to have a dedicated woodshop, but for now it's all I have and it works.

Re: Table Saw Thoughts

#14

Re: Table Saw Thoughts

Mike Schwing from Md.

>Jim, there is no way I would get rid of my tablesaw. It is unbelievably useful. I could never get the same quality cuts from a bandsaw, joint ready and perfectly straight. I use mine constantly. I also use the bandsaw just as much, but not for the same kind of work. My tablesaw, the cabinet variety with a 50" fence, sadly, is on a mobile base. It still works just as well but it is not as rock solid for obvious reasons. It pushes over into a corner easily when not in use. Were I to make a decision to get rid of a big tool it would be the chop saw as I can't live without the jointer, planer, tablesaw, and bandsaw.

I do however wish that I had a right tilt saw instead of a left tilt. I prefer to stand on the right side of the fence.

Re: Table Saw Thoughts

#15

Feedback

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ontario

>Hi,

Some very good responses and great ideas, Thank You. I appreciate that we all come from a variety of backgrounds and base skills and using a table saw seems to be one of those machines that is a basic in any shop, it is in mine. About 7-9 years ago Fine Woodworking featured an article by Oregon Furniture maker Gary Rogowski, it was titled the 10 Must Have Shop Machines. I remember reading it and being surprised that he did not include the table saw. I could not understand then why he did not include it but I understood that he was clear on why it was not chosen and why he used a bandsaw. His process for cutting rough and finished boards was accomplished with other means and it was a paradigm shift for me to understand his motivations. Now here I am 10 years later, thinking that he was pretty smart in his methods and knowing what I can do now with my other machines and tools this now seems a greater possibility to be true for me.

I have also discovered as my skills have developed over the years that doing things by hand is not doing things slower or less accurate, I have found that doing things by hand has added a controlled process as well with finished results. When I was a raw novice doing anything by hand was taboo in my mind and not something I wanted to cross into if I could use a machine to do it in a second. But like many of us know, set up is everything with a powered cut or process, often taking longer than the actual transformation...but that is a whole different post topic.

Oh and I am motivated to get a cool bandsaw like a Laguna to compliment the General I have, but not for that reason of "want" only, something with a resaw greater than 6" would be nice. My saw is set up at 52" and I am considering cutting it down to 32" or so. I do enjoy my table saw but in the process that Chris Schwarz of Popular Woodworking Magazine describes as Course-Medium-Fine, I consider the table saw a Course tool and in that I am looking at other Course tools that can accomplish the same results. I started using my bandsaw about three years ago to make rough cuts on all my undimensioned boards, rip cuts on a rough board are much safer that way for me. I also found that I did not realize the potential of my bandsaw really till I started to use it more in that way as well. I built a few cross cut jigs for the bandsaw and started to wonder why I had waited so long to understand how to use it like I do now. I do use my table saw to cut final dimensioned widths still, I still use it to cut and dimension tenons and also as a flat assembly table.

When I revisit the article that Gary Rogowski wrote in Fine Woodworking I see it with different eyes now. I think considering what options are available to accomplish cutting and sizing wood that it's important to review what we do and how we do it every so often. Perhaps it's not every ones choice but I have been amazed how many serious hobbyists and professional furniture makers I have spoken with who seldom if ever use a table saw. I was interested in hearing what thoughts on this topic others have experienced and I appreciate the feedback and exchange of ideas.

Take care,

Jim

Re: Table Saw Thoughts

#16

Re: Table Saw Thoughts

David Yoho

>Interesting question, Jim! For the type of work I do, I NEED a table saw. The main reason it's a necessity for me is the amount of cabinetry work I tend to get, which requires the accurate cutting of sheet goods.

That said, it's entirely possible you could work fine without a table saw. If cutting sheet goods isn't an issue, I don't see why your idea of a second band saw wouldn't work. Plus, as long as you have an accurate way to crosscut stock, cut dadoes, tenons, and miters, I'd say you might not NEED a table saw.

If cutting sheet goods was a possibility now and then, the Festool circular saw and guide would probably do the job very well and take up little space.

You're the only one that can determine your needs. I don't think it would be a crazy idea if you decided to ditch the table saw if you don't have an overwhelming reason to keep it.

David

Re: Table Saw Thoughts

#17

Multi-Task its Footprint

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>Jim,

Before you do anything make sure you think it through when you are off of the medications! ;-) Just kidding.

Have you considered multi tasking your saw footprint? Remove the extension table and reduce it to a 30". If it isn't already, put it on a mobile base. Then make a removable work surface top that can fit over the saw table. Maybe even use bench top tools like a grinder or something atop the saw. Then, should you need the saw simply remove the work surface and Voila! In other words, use the saw as a base for other things. That way you are doing multi-duty with its footprint.

Tom

Re: Table Saw Thoughts

#18

Re: Feedback

Thomas S Stockton

>Jim

One thing I feel about some articles in woodworking magazines is that they write them to get a reaction out of people and create controversy. It would be interesting to take the table saw out of Gary Rogowski's shop and see what he thinks after a month or two.

One thing to do is put your saw in storage (if possible) and see if you like not having it. If you don't have room to store it loan it out to someone who needs it that you trust.

I couldn't survive and make a living without my tablesaw or my bandsaw and if I had to choose between the two I'm not sure what I would do.

The idea of making your saw as small as possible and putting on a rolling base is the most workable to me if you find you need a table saw . it doesn't take up much more room than a second bandsaw.

Tom

Re: Table Saw Thoughts

#19

Re: Feedback

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>I could easily imagine an alternative way to handle most of the operations I currently do with a tablesaw, except the repetitive precision cutting: tenons, etc. Looking at your Morris chair, I cannot imagine trying to do all those tenons on anything other than a tablesaw. I just finished a set of mission-style night tables, with 34 square spindles. Just thinking about doing those without a tablesaw makes me break out in a cold sweat.

OTOH, things like panels are better done on a panel saw anyway.

Bruce

Re: Table Saw Thoughts

#20

Convince Your Next Door Neighbor

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>to buy your table saw, and grant unlimited visitation rights,Jim.

Good Morning Jim,

Then buy the Laguna or another BS of choice.:<) FWIW, my #3 son Ken uses his Ridgid job site saw in his home shop, and that is augmented by a Bosch portable saw as needed. The Bosch is accurate, but a little wimpy. #1 son George replaced my old Crapsman table saw with the portable Ridgid. We find it to be surprisingly good in comparison to decently tuned contractors' saws. I'm like some of the others, my table saw is the last thing I'd get rid of and the first thing I'd upgrade had I enough space.

George

Re: Table Saw Thoughts

#21

Re: Table Saw Thoughts

wilbur

>Hi Jim,

Glad to see that you're back on your feet again!

After seeing pictures of what you've built, I feel really weird trying to give you advice. Anyway, I don't have a tablesaw in my shop. I do have a bandsaw. I've found that using a 3/4" 10 tpi blade with a fence set up to accomodate blade drift gives a remarkably clean and straight cut if you are cutting sheet goods.

For cuts in solid wood, I'll go bandsaw --> jointer --> hand plane, which gives you a much cleaner surface than a tablesaw will, as I'm sure you already know.

Re: Table Saw Thoughts

#22

Re: Table Saw Thoughts

Verne in NJ

>I've been rough-ripping thick ash on my bandsaw, and actually I surprised myself in how straight a cut I could get by following a simple pencil line - kind of like aiming a gun.

I like my tablesaw, but I prefer my bandsaw. I cut curves, joints and I resaw on it too.

I'm not sure I could wean myself off the tablesaw because it's quick and accurate. But in thinking about it, I always handplane anything I cut on it anyway...

Re: Table Saw Thoughts

#23

Glad I'm not alone with that scheme.

Eddie Pacheco: San Jose, Ca.

>

Re: Table Saw Thoughts

#24

Ellis Walentine

My take

Ellis Walentine

>Over the years, in my shop, the tablesaw has been indispensible. It has been a breakdown ("coarse," in Schwarz's parlance) tool about 90% (SWAG) of the time, and that includes ripping parallel to a reference edge once the board has been jointed and thicknessed. Finish ripping is a handy operation to have if a lot of your work involves equal-width pieces, such as rails, stiles, legs, cabinet parts, shelves, etc. It's not that you can't rip to width with a bandsaw, but you need to follow that with some kind of jointing or planing operation if you want clean edges, and you also need to gauge the width accurately to make sure you have parallel edges. In this department, the tablesaw lets you get the dirty work done so you can move on to the fun stuff.

The tablesaw's other abilities are many and valuable, such as dado work, molding, tenoning, beveling and tapering -- not to mention sheet goods breakdown as David mentioned. With a sled and some cool shopmade jigs to go along with it, you can do very accurate crosscutting, grooving, finger jointing and other sophisticated operations that aren't possible with a bandsaw.

It's pretty hard to shrink the "actual" footprint of a tablesaw, which is the width and length of the space needed to rip or crosscut your longest and widest pieces. That is the same regardless of whether you're using a jobsite saw or a 12" cabinet saw.

On another note, Frank Klausz never rips anything thicker than 2" on his tablesaw; those jobs are strictly bandsaw chores. It's not as accurate, but you have less teeth in the cut and you can take your time without jockeying or burning your TS blade.

I have a 12" cabinet saw on permanent loan to me since my shop fire claimed my last Unisaw, and I love it for getting stock prepared. I wouldn't be without it. It doesn't dado, by the way, and I've learned to live without that ability, too, although I used to use my Forrest and CMT dado heads quite a lot when I had them.

Occasionally, I'm torn by this same sort of question, Jim. I'd like to scale back, have a smaller, more manageable shop, get more pleasure out of the little things, like the personal satisfaction that comes from planing a perfect edge or surface, or dovetailing the sweetest drawer. You can do that stuff without expedient breakdown machines, but it takes longer and the journey becomes the destination. Both approaches are perfectly valid. You only need to justify them to yourself.

Best,

Ellis

Re: Table Saw Thoughts

#25

Re: My take

Rob Stokes in North Vancouver

>All good points Ellis. And Jim, one more thing I'd like to point out is that the table saw footprint doesn't have to be single purpose.

I've got a small shop (11' x 25') and the (1955 Boice Crane cabinet) saw takes up the middle. But I've built the router table into the outfeed table, I use the right extension wing (I filled in the area between the fence rails) as a stock staging table most of the time (the saw rests it's right side aganst the wall and I have a 30" fence on it), it's where I clamp my benchtop planer when I use it and because my jointer is beside the saw it's also a staging table for stock that I'm jointing.

Oh - the the area under the right extension wing is also the "garage" under which the shop vac lives.

So the saw's always being used, but not always for cutting. This leaves my workbench open for working on (instead of having a planer clamper to it) and with a bit of though I can even have "organized clutter" on top of the saw and still use it (safely) for the odd cut.

Rob