What size breaker?
Tom Norton
>What size breaker and wire should I use for a 4 hp. motor on a planer?
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
What size breaker?
Tom Norton
>What size breaker and wire should I use for a 4 hp. motor on a planer?
Re: What size breaker?
Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach
>You should start by looking at the plate on the motor. Look for a parameter that says “Amps,” “FLA” (full load amps), or the like. You would make your determination based on that value. HP numbers usually aren't helpful because they vary according to the fantasies of the marketing department of the manufacturer.
It also makes a big difference whether this motor requires a 120V supply (not likely) or a 240V supply. Your question is unanswerable without that information.
Rod
Re: What size breaker?
Al Stokka - Cambridge, Iowa
>Tom,
Four HP is a bit odd these days. My reference lists three and five HP, so I'll give you the data for a five HP, 230 VAC, single phase:
Full load current - 28 amps
Minimum copper wire size - 8
Circuit breaker -60 A (themal-magnetic breaker trip rating)
Al
Re: What size breaker?
Chad Pearson
>I have a single phase four horsepower 16 inch jointer/planer that I run on a 30 amp 240 volt dedicated circuit. The circuit has never tripped.
Re: What size breaker?
Rick Christopherson
>As Chad stated, your planer should be on a 30 amp circuit with #10 wire. Even though the planer will draw 20 amps, or slightly less, you are right on the edge of the capacity of the circuit. However, if you couldn't get a new run of #10 wire to the planer, then you could get by with a 20 amp circuit.
Re: What size breaker?
Rick Christopherson
>Al, What reference is telling you to oversize a circuit by over 200%?
If the motor is not for continuous operation, and most woodworking tools would not fall into the continuous operation category for a home shop, then it is not required to derate the circuit. However, even if this was a 5 hp motor and at continuous duty, it certainly wouldn't need 60 amps. Moreover, #8 wire is only rated for 40 amps. Add to this, most 5 hp motors draw less than 24 amps, so even with an 80% derating, they still fit onto a 30 amp circuit.
Re: What size breaker?
Al Stokka - Cambridge, Iowa
>Good afternoon Rick,
You're the last guy I want to butt heads with when it comes to matters electric but, the data came from a motor data calculator (slide rule) published by Square D Company. The data is "Single Phase Motor Data (60 Hz.), copyright 1990 and "based on 1990 NEC".
I thought the breaker amperage size was too large but, who am I to argue with Square D...or you, for that matter.
Al
Well....
Bill Howatt
>I have seen references that say you can use a breaker that is up to 250% the FLA.
See table at bottom of P9 on this document for a NEC reference.
Bill
Re: Well....
Al Stokka - Cambridge, Iowa
>Bill,
Not exactly sure what you're trying to say but, it appears you wanted to include a link and didn't. In any case, your statement "I have seen references that say you can use a breaker that is up to 250% the FLA." is confusing me. Could not one also say "...you can use a breaker that is up to 500% of the FLA" and be just as correct (assuming that the wire gauge is up to the task)?
Not trying to start (or continue) an argument, just confused.
Al
Re: What size breaker?
Larry Clinton
>Tim, I'm not trying to argue with anyone. I do want to clarify one or two points. In your case I would wire the circuit with a 30 amp breaker and # 10 gage wire. The breaker size used on a piece of equipment needs to be a MINIMUM size only. A 40 amp breaker and # 8 gage wire would be perfectly acceptable - but would be overkill and obviously unduly expensive. The breaker does NOT protect the equipment. It is only rated to protect the PERMANENTLY installed wiring and receptacle. This is the same as the breakers in your house. The breakers in most homes are at least 15 amp. The wiring on your normal table lamp (or light gage extension cord) will heat and may burn if you actually carried a full 15 amp on the circuit for a length of time. (I have seen that happen when I was a volunteer fireman). That said I would suggest a 30 amp breaker - wired with 10 gage wire. I have installed over a dozen 220 V. circuits at various and sundry places in my shop ~ all but one are wired with #10 wire and are on 30 amp breakers. I have a 1 hp surface grinder and lathe, 3 hp dust collector, Unisaw, and jointer, - 5 hp jointer, and a moderate size air compressor all on these circuits. The only exception is the welder circuit, I have a 50 amp breaker on that circuit (I believe I used some number 4 wire for that circuit cause I had it on hand). The other issue is that the fixed / permanent wiring may have a smaller breaker than the wire is rated for (as long as the breaker connection will accept the wire properly), the whole purpose of the breaker - wire rating is to prevent overheating and fires in the structure.
My experience: I wired residential, commercial and a lot of Industrial equipment - Retired about 2 years ago as a Manufacturing Engineer, worked as a contractor and subcontractor for over 20 years as a second job. I have seen some wiring that would make your hair stand on end during that time.
Re: What size breaker?
Rick Christopherson
>Hi Al,
I am not familiar with the specific data calculator you mentioned, but I have seen similar guides. However, I would suspect that it was referring to a maximum breaker size as opposed to a required breaker size. Notice that 250% of 24 amps is 60 amps. (I plan on discussing this further in a reply to Bill's posting.) However, I am not sure where the wire gauge specification came from.
Over the past couple of years I have begun to notice the growing trend in internet advice to advise people to oversize their 240 volt circuits without regard to the actual requirements or the needs of the person asking for the advice. This has gotten to such extreme proportions that I am finding myself having to take a balancing stance on circuit size. The worst case of this is that so many people blindly advise others that all of their 240 volt circuits should be 30 amps. This gets repeated to such a great extent that some people are beginning to believe that it is required that all circuits are 30 amps, or more.
In this particular case, I learned after my previous posting that the reason why the OP was asking the question was because he already had an existing circuit he was trying to use for his 4 hp motor. So in this particular case, even though it would not be advisable to install a new 20 amp circuit for a 4 hp motor, he is perfectly within code to use the existing circuit for his application. This information has gotten obscured by the number of people that automatically advise others to oversize their circuits.
Re: Well....
Rick Christopherson
>Al and Bill,
Yes, there is information in the NEC to permit oversizing a breaker on a motor circuit. For some reason this information has started cropping up on the Internet over the past couple of months. The first time I saw this referenced came from a knowledgeable friend, and was in reference to a specific situation. Since that time, someone else quoted his response in an answer to a question where it was less applicable. Now it has begun to snowball, and I am seeing it repeated without regard to the situation, and more specifically, in situations where it cannot be used.
The problem is that other people (not referring to you Bill) that are not familiar with code or the appropriate applications read this information in one posting, and they latch on to it as though it was an absolute fact, and then they also repeat it with even lesser clarifications. When you couple this with other misinformation, and you are suddenly off in some sort of amperage black hole.
I recently saw a discussion where the ubiquitous statement of a 3 hp Unisaw "required" a 30 amp circuit (which is not true), and then this was followed up by the assertion that you could then re-up this "required" amperage by 250%. The result is that people assumed that you could put a 12 amp Unisaw, with a NEMA 6-15 plug, on a 75 amp circuit with 10 gauge wire. This is a fire hazard waiting to happen. More importantly, it no longer fits code.
The bottom line is that this type of discussion should not be mentioned on hobbyiest woodworking forums, because in 99% of the situations, it is not applicable, but people will get the wrong impression nevertheless. First and foremost, this entire concept gets thrown out the window as soon as you install an outlet on the circuit. Once you do that, you are no longer permitted to oversize a circuit, regardless what size wire you use or regardless what other aspects of code might seem applicable.
As long as I am on this topic, the same regulations also throw out 75% of the cases of wiring 30 amp circuits for smaller tools. People keep advising this, yet they fail to tell people that they must also install 30-amp outlets. As I have mentioned many times before just as an example, a Delta Unisaw comes equipped with a NEMA 6-15 plug, so unless you are willing to cut the cord and throw it away, you are not even permitted to install this saw on a 30 amp circuit, let alone consider it to be a requirement.
Whew...I got a little dizzy way up there on my soap box for such along spell. I hope that neither of you took this in a negative way, as I have the utmost respect for you both.
Re: Well....
Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach
>What ices the cake in my mind in that 30A sizing scenario is that the proponents suggest wiring with 10 ga (for the future) and then later putting in the 30A breaker, as if there is some great savings involved. If they're going to put a breaker in the circuit (hard not to), why wouldn't they just put in the 30A to begin with (setting aside the illegal receptacle considerations)? The cost for the breaker is usually within pennies of the same at 20A or 30A.
Rod
Missing Link *LINK*
Bill Howatt
>Here is the link and I agree that posting stuff like this could lead people into doing improper things given the numerous qualifiers that often exist in the code rules. My intent was to show that Al wasn't completely off the mark with his post.
The document referenced in the link is not an official NEC document but it does provide a NEC mumber which I thought would be helpful if someone were to investigate further.
Re: What size breaker?
Larry Clinton
>Rick, I'm not quite certain why you have the view you do. But I have been "guilty" of advising people wiring their shop for 220V with number 10 gage wire and with all 30 amp circuits. This was in regard to new or replacement wiring (general shop wiring), not wiring for a specific fixed machine. I have wired many businesses, homes, farm buildings, industrial machines in the 25 + years I contracted. I stand by my statement that if you are installing in a new shop or generally replacing the wiring in a shop to add 220 circuits, I would do it all in 30 amp breakers and 220V wiring. The reason I advise this is that many woodworkers, including myself, often upgrade their equipment. The 220 volt 20 amp circuit may have been fine for my old planer, but my new 5 hp 20" requires the 30 amp circuit. I also have all my equipment on mobile bases, and have re-arranged my shop several times. The popularity of mobile bases suggest many others also practice this. With 30 amp outlets at each location my planer can be exchanged for any other smaller piece of equipment. Plugs can be installed on the Unisaw allowing it to plug into any 30 amp outlet in a few minutes for less than $10. I have a number of extension cords made up with 10 gage wire and a plug to fit the 30 amp receptacle with a 20 amp socket on the end to fit the smaller equipment (as far as I remember this is acceptable according to the temporary wiring codes and certainly can cause no safety issues as a larger draw device cannot be utilized). The 10 gage wire and larger breaker do cost a little more. But the benefit of having the versatility of moving equipment, upgrading equipment without rewiring the shop, less voltage drop on the longer runs etc. far outweigh the initial cost in my opinion.
I may be one....
Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie
>I may be one of those that has been misinterpretted as saying a 3HP Unisaw needs a 30A circuit.
I will often recommend that people install a 30A circuit when they are asking about a new circuit for their Unisaw.
But I try to make it clear that it's not for the Unisaw, but for their next tool. Since they have to put in a new circuit for the saw, and if it will likely be the only 240V circuit in their garage/workshop, then for a little more money it makes sense to put in a 30A rather than a 20A circuit to avoid having to redo the whole thing later if they (or the next owner) needs a 30A circuit for another tool.
I put a 20A circuit in for my Unisaw, and was frustrated 2 years later when I got my small Lincoln wirefeed welder and I found that I needed 30A circuit. I had to take out the 20A and replace everything (breaker, wire, outlet) for 30A. I wish I had thought of that when I was putting in the circuit 2 years earlier ;)
I'm sure a recommendation like that could sound like "you need 30A circuit for a Unisaw" as it's echoed. I agree that for a 3HP Unisaw you only need a 20A circuit. But since some of the tools that may wind up in our home workshop might require 30A, it mention that it may make sense to make it a 30A circuit if if you're installing a new 240V circuit and if it doesn't cost a whole lot more.
I wasn't planning on getting a welder when I got the Unisaw, and when I got the new welder I was surprise to see it needed a 30A circuit. I had a small welder years ago and it only needed a 20A circuit, but this Lincoln WeldPak-155 required 30A.
I'm sure that you didn't misunderstand my comments, but I hope others didn't misunderstand. I'll try to make sure people understand what I mean.
Happy Woodworking!
Icing
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey
>Rod,
If one has only a 20amp breaker (but not a 30) which from the ampacity rating on the motor should be enough (like for a 3hp motor pulling 13 amps), it is, in my view (and the way I was taught), safer to fuse closer to the motor's actual rating with some allowance (50%) for momentary current spikes as in starting or very heavy load. Putting too much extra current on the circuit with a big breaker defeats the purpose of the breaker except in extreme circumstances.
My 220 circuits that feed my cabinet saw (3hp), DC (2hp), band saw(3hp) and lathe (3hp) are all 20 amp breakered. They have never tripped. My 3hp compressor was just fine on 20 amps until it got real cold in the garage and started overdrawing the circuit in the start phase. I then went to the next highest breaker which I could not have done without rewiring the whole circuit with heavier wire. Meanwhile, with #10 wire, the circuits run more efficiently from what I've been told, so the benefit, while slight, is real.
mm
Re: I may be one....
Rick Christopherson
>
Mark (and Larry), Forgive me, because this is not intended to be argumentative, but I know that it will sound like it is. However, this statement really strikes me as odd. If you had to rip out the circuit for the tablesaw to upgrade it for the welder, why not just run the new circuit to the welder without tearing out the old circuit? I am assuming your breaker box must have been completely full, and this is not uncommon, but the specific situation is not terribly common in and of itself. Yes, if someone has a full load center and can only put in a single circuit for all of their current and/or future 240 needs, then in most cases I would automatically suggest a 30 amp circuit myself so they could run multiple small loads from the single circuit. But then again, when people get to this point, they are typically advised to use that last open slot to install a subpanel.
Mark Goodall:
I put a 20A circuit in for my Unisaw, and was frustrated 2 years later when I got my small Lincoln wirefeed welder and I found that I needed 30A circuit. I had to take out the 20A and replace everything (breaker, wire, outlet) for 30A.
I have asked the following question before, and the responses have been almost non-existent. (�How many woodworkers that buy and wire in a 3 hp saw, later decide to upgrade to a 5 hp saw?�) Yes, there will be some exceptions such as your welder, but for the typical woodworker whose workshop is half of a garage, they will have very few, if any, 5 hp tools. The most notable exception for a garage workshop is upgrading to a 5 hp compressor for use with both woodworking and automotive tools.
For the typical garage or basement workshop that is less than 600 square feet, space is too much of a premium to be able to put in 5 hp tools. Most woodworkers with this size shop space can't even afford the space for a 15� planer, let alone one of the massive 20� planers requiring 5 hp.
As I said previously, I am just trying to balance the information out a little. I am not opposed to installing 30-amp circuits. Except for one 15 amp and two 20 amp circuits (powerfeeder, tablesaw, and dust collector, respectively) all of the circuits in my shop are 30-amp. The difference is, is that I have 1800 square feet, and the likelihood of installing 5 hp tools in the future was very high.
When a woodworker asks what size circuit they need for a specific tool (not this thread, but in past discussions) the automatic answer is 30-amps. This misinformation has become so prolific, that even the tools editor for FWW stated on their forum that all 240 volt circuits needed to be 30 amps, and he was expected to be an authority on the subject. More thought needs to be given to this advise.
To reiterate, most of the time when people tell others to use 30 amp circuits, they make no distinction between what is �needed� versus what they �may� want to do, and even when they do mention that it is just for future upgrades, they generally make it sound like it is an extremely common need in the future. Again, this also gets coupled with the misinformation regarding oversizing circuits. When these two pieces of information get repeated so much, most woodworkers begin to think that their commonly desired future tools are going to require 30 amp circuits.
Re: What size breaker?
tim_in_michigan
>I have a related question-
Can I install a 30 amp receptacle on a 12 gauge wire with a 20 amp breaker?
The reason I ask if because I have a bunch of 30 amp twistlock receptacles and plugs but my wiring is 12 gauge with a 20 amp breaker. I have several 220 volt tools and they each have a different plug on them. I'd like to make them all the same.
Re: I wouldn't
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey
>Code guys can jump in here but putting that receptical on would invite someone (after you) to plug a 30 amp machine into that receptical and either start a fire or damage the machine (or both).
mm
Re: I may be one....
Larry Clinton
>Rick - I have a 900 square foot shop - 30' X 30' (downstairs) with 300 sq/ft room upstairs. I have installed all the breakers my service entrance can hold - It is the largest 100 amp service box available in my area - I believe it is the largest period for 100 amp. I have a finished shop with 5/8" fire retardant drywall on the walls and ceiling. I did not desire to either run conduit on the interior walls or remove drywall for additional circuits so when I built the shop I wanted to install all the circuits I planned to use. I have 4 switched light circuits - all utilizing duplex receptacles on the ceiling. I have an outlet every 32" minimum on all interior walls. I installed 220 V receptacles for the fixed equipment - dust collector, large arc welder and compressor, then installed about 10 more at various locations on the walls. IMHO, many woodworkers will end up using some equipment which draws more than the 20 amp circuit provide. My 20" Yorkcraft planer takes up about 2 or 3 square foot more space than a 15" stationary. Many shops are installing the 3 hp cyclone dust collectors which require more than the 20 amp circuit. When a person is finishing the interior of a shop, I will still recommend that all 220 outlets be installed with #10 wire and 30 amp breakers. The ONLY downside is the minimal cost difference in wire and breaker and possibly receptacle (although in this area they are within $1 for 20 or 30 amp) - I am sure it would average less than $15 per outlet. As I said you have less voltage drop, and the advantage of moving any equipment to any outlet. Even if they only buy one 4 or 5 hp tool, it would be money well spent. In my experience many of the woodworkers finish their shop walls. It is a pain and expensive to install a new or replace an undersized circuit. If an Electrician installs a circuit the cost of installation (excepting the possible $15 for material) would be the same for either 20 or 30 amp. Replacing or adding an additional larger circuit would be at least as much as the initial install. I just cannot see why anyone would put a 20 amp circuit in a shop and would never recommend this to anyone.
What "may" happen in the future
Chad Pearson
>Rick,
I am a hobbyist working in the 3rd stall of my garage. All of my tools are on wheels so that I can back the cars out and set up the entire garage as a shop. My first 220 volt tool was a 5hp Powermatic 66 that I found in a classified advert. At that time (maybe two years ago) I had no intention of buying any other 220 volt tools as my Ridgid jointer and Jet bandsaw were serving my purposes well. Shortly thereafter an almost new Mimimax 16 with 4.8 hp motor popped up on Craigslist for a good price. That was my second 220 tool. About 1 year ago I purchased a 16 inch J/P with a 4 hp motor.
At the time I first got my tablesaw I never had any intention of getting another large tool; I was only interested in a cabinet saw so that my outfeed table could be mounted without separate supporting legs. I was fortunate in that the first 220 tool happened to require a 30 amp circuit.
My only point is that planning for potential upgrades doesn't seem all that speculative. Is there any reason not to wire a 30 amp circuit for a 3 hp unisaw other than the incremental cost of thicker wire and more expensive plugs?
Re: I wouldn't
tim_in_michigan
>But it wouldn't start a fire or damage the wire unless they also put in a bigger breaker.
Re: I wouldn't
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey
>Tim,
I haven't checked "code" on this, but I believe you "can't" put a fixture in a circuit that does not match that circuit's ampacity. (* was hoping one of the resident sparkies we have around here would give you a better or at least more authoritative answer.
mm
Re: I may be one....
Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie
>You assume correctly. The breaker box was full, the walls were full, and there was no place to put another outlet box. The only option was to replace the 3' of wire and put in new wire, new box, etc. My garage workshop is cramped to say the least, both electrically, floor space and wall space.
Neighbors who have the same size garage (2-car) laugh at how cramped everything is in my shop, cause all they have in their's is a car or two and perhaps a few shevles to hold a few things. But when I see other garage workshops of peers here, I'm releived to know that I'm not the only one cramping too much into a small workshop.
I certainly didn't think that I'd ever need a 30A circuit when I got the Unisaw.