Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

OT - Touchy Septic Tank Question

Posts

OT - Touchy Septic Tank Question

#1

OT - Touchy Septic Tank Question

Brian in Sandusky, OH

>OK. My question is in regards too....

(ahem, I'll just say it....tampons.)

My wife and I have been in our new house for the last year, and our previous house was public sewer. No issues with (...ahem...) Our new house has a septic tank and field.

I never really even thought about this until recently.

Should there be any concern with my wife flushing these down the toilet?

I have a septic tank and a field. These things have to end up in the tank, obviously. Do they break down, or are they collecting and possibly creating a problem over time?

Another question. How often, if ever, does the tank need maintenance, pumped, etc? I have no idea if it's even necessary, but I know that I've seen my neighbors with trucks in their lawn pumping their tanks.

Sorry about the touchy subject. Not sure how else to word this.

Re: OT - Touchy Septic Tank Question

#2

Re: OT - Touchy Septic Tank Question

Kneale Brownson in sunny N. MI

>Do you know if you have a two-tank system or just the one tank?

The former is a much longer-lived system.

Regardless, you should have the tank(s) pumped after your year's use and ask the pumper how often it should be pumped thereafter.

Re: OT - Touchy Septic Tank Question

#3

Re: OT - Touchy Septic Tank Question

Virgil Johnson

>1'st Rule of thumb for septic systems...If you haven't digested it don't flush it. Pump it out every 5-6 years if there are only two of you. Cheap insurance.

Re: OT - Touchy Septic Tank Question

#4

Re: OT - Touchy Septic Tank Question

Jim Dillon

>Brian,

Can't give any credible advice regarding the tampon question, but every 5-10 year maintenance of the septic tank is not out of the question. A lot depends on the service conditions (a nice way to put it 8-)). If you are just one or two people, the "load", so-to-speak, is not great. However a family of 13 is a different question. A plumber recommended to us to forget about all these advertised "magic" enzymes to add to the septic tank, and just add a tablespoon of ordinary bakers yeast to your commode every few months or so to keep things working OK. Getting back to the tampon question, I would be more worried about clogging, than any impact on the septic tank or field itself.

Jim (who has lived with a septic tank/field system for 30 years.)

PS Hey, does the Put-in-Bay ferry still dock in Sandusky?

Re: OT - Touchy Septic Tank Question

#5

Nope, probably should not do it.

Ray Thompson - Middletown,IN

>Read the package and if it does not say septic system safe then do not flush it down.

As to pumping, every soil condition is different and local conditions will determine what you need. Even two houses next door to each other may have different requirements.

I have had a septic system for close to 40 years now and rarely have I had to pump it out. I pulled the cover every year and made sure the bacteria was working and only if it wasn't did I pump it. My sister on the other hand has to pump hers out regularly, to much clay and to little drainage and evaporation.

Ray

Re: OT - Touchy Septic Tank Question

#6

no problem

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Should there be any concern with my wife flushing these down the toilet?

No I have a wife and two grown daughters worth of experience and never a problem in 30+ years of use.

We pump about every 10-15 years but we don't abuse the system either. garbage disposals abuse the system, for example

Re: OT - Touchy Septic Tank Question

#7

Re: OT - Touchy Septic Tank Question

Keith Newton

>There are greater things to worry about. I am sure you know not to be sending any grease down the system, and I have heard that it is not a bad idea to have the washing machine on a separate line, that the soap may hinder the bacterial action.

The product Rid-X claims to break down cellulose products, and I would guess that the cotton in your wife's uh, you know. probably wouldn't make much difference in a 500 ~ 1000 gallon tank.

Re: OT - Touchy Septic Tank Question

#8

Lots of info here...  *LINK*

Bri in Mtl

>


Info

Re: OT - Touchy Septic Tank Question

#9

Re: OT - Touchy Septic Tank Question

Barry Irby

>Don't anything about your system or the design. Locally, systems usually have a 1000 or 1250 gallon tank. Either as the only tank or the first tank that then dumps the fluids into a second pump tank. I am going to assume that if you had a pump in the system you would know. (There would be a breaker for it and an alarm)

There are two issues about dumping undigested waste into the tank. Things that did not go through your system might effect the bacteria in the tank and kill or damage it's effectiveness. The other question is bulk. If you fill up the tank with solids, they begin to migrate into the pump tank or drain field, either ruining the pump or filling and clogging the drain field.

So don't dump anything in the system that might damage the bacteria. Grease, phosphates from detergents, chemicals (antifreeze, paint thinners, photographic, mad scientist, garden chemicals, whatever.)

As for food waste disposers, the concern was that undigested stuff like salad scraps would not be on the bacteria's diet. That stuff does not seem to have much effect. Meat and grease are not good.

OTOH, anything that adds bulk is not good. So, if you are making Cole slaw for the navy, compost the scraps or otherwise dispose of them. As far as tampons go, probably harmless except for the bulk and that would be fairly small. You need to empty the tank occasionally so the tampons would shorten the interval to occasionally minus ten percent.

Locally, systems are designed to be pumped every five years. In fact, the local county has a monitoring tax. You pay them $15 a year to remind you every five year to pump the tank. If you fail to prove you have done it, they have it done and bill you. (Their interest is they don't want you to ruin the system and start demanding public sewer.) All of this is based on the soil conditions and the "average" occupancy and use. They calculate off the number of bedrooms, assuming an occupancy rate from that. So, as others mentioned, if your house is lightly occupied you might not need to pump often, but if you have high occupancy, maybe more often.

Pumping the system is cheap. Locally it used to be about $100. I have not checked lately, but it should be $200 or more, its still cheap. Its the best money you can spend on your system. If you did not get it pumped when you moved in and you don't have proof it was done, do it. No system has ever been ruined by pumping it if it did not need it, but plenty have been ruined by waiting. If you fail to pump it and ruin the system the cost could be thousands or even tens of thousands. Or in rare cases you might have to abandon the house if there are no alternatives (very rare, but I know of two). This is like changing the oil in your car, do it and you are out of $39.95, skip it a few times and you could be out an engine. So your assignment for today is to get ahead of the curve on this.

PS, don't let the people pumping it tell you the tampons will ruin their pump. Their setup is a giant vacuum pump. They drop in a hose and suck the air out of the tank on the truck and slurp up the contents of the septic tank. nothing but air goes through their pump. The small amount they leave behind provides the bacteria to get the process going again.

And, modern laundry detergents do not have phosphates. Have not for thirty or forty years. They are compatible with the system. Older systems often had a separate line for the laundry to keep he detergent out of the tank and to avoid the heavy volume of water from the laundry.

Re: OT - Touchy Septic Tank Question

#10

Steven Antonucci

If you have a doubt, then don't

steve antonucci

>We have septic in our house, and I do almost nothing to maintain it. We've been in the house for 11 years, and I just had it pumped for the first time. The guy couldn't believe it when he saw how well it functioned.

That said, I occasionally remember to add some ZEP, but not religiously. I used to run a darkroom, and I'd flush my spent chemicals from B&W and Cibachrome processing. We've had 4 kids, and have flushed too many baby wipes to count. Remember, my tank was flawless and my field was clean...

Will it hurt the system? Maybe... but by not doing it, I don't incur that risk any longer. Only 2 things go in my tank these days- #1 and #2.

Steve

Re: OT - Touchy Septic Tank Question

#11

Re: OT - Touchy Septic Tank Question

Tony - Memphis

>Those can be bad for city systems too! My old neigbor worked for the water dept and had some good stories. One in particular was related to your concern. Seems as though a family had a real bad clog (just beyond their property) and that was the problem. He brought the homeowner out and showed it to him. yucchhhh.

Tony

Re: OT - Touchy Septic Tank Question

#13

Put the sewer mice in the trash..

Tim Greif - West of Chicago

>My day job is an engineer in the water and wastewater industry. I've seen what I refer to as sewer mice in wastewater systems for my whole career. Why do I call them that? If you've ever had your sewer line rodded out to remove a clog caused by invasive tree roots, you know what I'm talking about. These little tampons come out looking very similar to a little brown mouse.

The image attached and the following text is taken from a colleague's web publication about his treatment plant. You may not ever have a problem, but my advice is to put the sewer mice in the trash, not into the septic tank.



We literally have tens of thousands of these beach whistles lying in the rip-rap around our sewage lagoons. And tens of thousands more get screened out of the composted biosolids when we dredge the lagoons. Ladies, these aren't biodegradable, and they belong in the trashcan, not the toilet. The basics of what should get flushed distills down to this: if you haven't eaten it, or used it to wipe off something you've eaten, it goes in the trash. That also applies to the little cotton device that these applicators are designed to insert. Wrap 'em with a wad of Charmin if you are embarrassed by them, but please, please, please don't flush 'em.


Re: OT - Touchy Septic Tank Question

#15

Sewer mice were banned in my house

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>We had numerous problems when we first moved into our house with the sewer system. We had it pumped and it still stuggled. I snaked the drains several times and removed a quantity of sewer mice that were snarled around the snake. A plumber friend reccomended a last ditch attempt before replacing the system. His recommendation was to treat the system with a product called Bio-sure, a dehydrated sewer bacteria. We dumped several containers directly in the tank and some down every drain in the house. About a month later we noticed everything was flushing every time. My wife, daughter and I agreed that if they flushed em they woudl do the next snake job. Haven't had a problem in tover 20 years other than a collapsed drain field pipe.

We still feed every drain in the house twice a month with Bio-sure.

Lee

Re: OT - Touchy Septic Tank Question

#16

Re: OT - Touchy Septic Tank Question

Dick Coers

>Just had this little discussion a month ago with my wife. We have two soft maples in the front yard, one on each side of the sewer line going to the city street. Tree roots bring out the Rotor-Rooter guy every couple of years. We used to have the tampon discussion too often. Now menopause took care of that but it's now those heavy duty cleansing wipes that come in the plastic tub. Guess we have to get international like and put in a bidet.

Women sure got the short end of the stick on these type of functions.

Re: OT - Touchy Septic Tank Question

#17

WOW ! I just learned more in this thread . . .

SteveM

>about sewers and septic systems than a TOH segment ! Just goes to show the power of pooled knowledge !

Re: OT - Touchy Septic Tank Question

#18

Re: OT - Drain Field / Dry Well Clog from Lint

Paul Leuba

>Washing machines, particularly top loaders with agitators, creat a substantial amount of small lint that is suspended in the waste water. This lint remains suspended for some time does not drop to the bottom of the septic tank. It finds its way past the septic tank baffle and into the drain field or dry well, whichever is the case, and will eventually stop the leaching of waste water into the soil. Even thought modern detergents do not contain phosphates, it is still a good idea to not exhaust washing machine waste water into a septic/dry well/drain field system because of this lint clogging problem. Several loads of wash create an amazing volume of tiny lint fibers in the waste water.

Paul in Hunt Valley

Re: OT - Touchy Septic Tank Question

#19

Steve, in this case...

John in NM - and AZ

>Pooling is definitely NOT good!

Re: OT - Touchy Septic Tank Question

#20

In general....

John in NM - and AZ

>As others have said, when in doubt, don't. Look for products that claim to be septic compatible, if you can believe the labeling.

Don't bother with all the additive products like enzymes or whatever, the marketers claims are not based on much... considering how many thousands of gallons a month you're running into that tank, such a small volume treatment is likely to be far too diluted to do much. By all means use the yeast if it makes you happy - couldn't hurt and the stuff hardly costs anything.

Re: OT - Touchy Septic Tank Question

#21

ROFL ! I guess you're right !

SteveM

>

Re: OT - Touchy Septic Tank Question

#22

Re: OT - Drain Field / Dry Well Clog from Lint

Dick Krieger

>In Michigan, septic tank outlet filters are becoming popular and in some counties, mandatory. It is a plastic T fitting that takes the place of the outlet elbow connecting to the header and thus the field. Inside the Tee is a removable plastic layered filter consisting of vertical slots that keep out lint and other small particles. For the best installation, you remove the tank access cover, install a special plastic corregated pipe and attach it to top of tank. Pipe cuts off at yard grade and is fixed with a removable cover for easy access without digging. To check/clean filter, simply remove cover, reach down with a "hook" device, grab onto filter, and remove for cleaning with a garden hose sprayer. Simply put it back in and you are good to go. What destroys a septic system is "solids" getting into the field and/or raw grease or other liquids that can permeate the soil under the weep tile and prevent the ground from absorbing the "grey water". I have a filter on my system and my wife washes at least 2-4 loads a day for just the two of us. Filter clogs up with coagulated soap scum and lint and I clean it about every three months. Without the filter, all that junk would be going into the field. Septic tank information is available on line or I can refer.

Re: OT - Touchy Septic Tank Question

#23

Murphy must have been a plumber

Bill from Montreal

>In our area north of montreal, we are required by the municipality to pump out our cottage septic tank every two years if the house is occupied full time, and every four years if part time.

As far as the tampons, or indeed anything else solid, we have been informed that in general the septic tank is a separator for liquids and solids - ours has dividers forcing stuff to alternately float and sink. The solids generally sink to the bottom in the first section, and a little in the second section. The soap floats in a similar manner.

If the solids build up to the point of going out with the liquids, you will have a problem...

Remember that what comes out of your tank goes into the weeping field, and should solids get into that area, it needs to be RIPPED OUT AND REPLACED AT A MAJOR EXPENSE - about 6k to 12k - they will dig out the earth to about two to three feet deep, and replace it with new fresh gravel and earth and weeping pipes.

Compare the dirty looks from the feminine household members to the sizable expense of weeping field replacement and make your own choices.

I for one had to dig up a plugged septic tank (very old technology - 55 gal drum vs 900 liter concrete tanks today) and shovel out the solids from the top layer into holes we dug in the bush -- all this in the middle of my aunt's Labour day lake party - when these things go bad, its always when they are under stress - ie lots of people to watch and comment (from a distance) while you are trying to get the stuff flowing again so the toilet will drain at all....

In our cottage, we put up a sign

Kotex, Tampex, Kleenex like such,

Put it in the basket, We'll appreciate it much.

We pump our tank religiously - $125 every 4 years vs $5k per 15 years... Nothing else goes down the drain that we did not digest. Cheap Insurance.

P.S. Laundry detergent has NOT phosphates, but (at least in Canada) automatic dishwasher soap has up to 12% phosphate - 1-2% for gels. Dishsoap for the sink has NO phosphates. Our cottage is beside a lake (300ft) and wh get lectures from a research biologist every year if we want it.

Liquid transport from septic tanks through soil gets into the lake in days to weeks, not months to years.

My neighbour told me solemnly to me for the last ten years since he moved in that all he ever did was flush those bacteria pills down the toilet every two month - Never A Problem.

That was until last winter, when the whole thing backed up.

He had to have the line and tank excavated to just find the access hatch, and then the weeping field had to be replaced...in the winter.(Murphy must have been a plumber)

And then it was all re-landscaped in the spring.

11 thousand dollars.

It turns out that his tank was about four times the necessary size for a house - he has no idea why the people who built it 40 years ago did that but they did. It just delayed the inevitable, and gave him a false sense of security.

Make your choices. You will live with the results.

Re: OT - Touchy Septic Tank Question

#24

Re: WOW ! I just learned more in this thread . . .

Lee Brubaker

>We built & lived on an acreage for 14 years. We separated gray water from the laundry,dishwasher,bath tubs & showers. Tied into the gray water discharge line was the iron filter & water softner backwash discharge which piped by gravity into a small open depression at the back of the property. None of it went into the septic. After 5 years we had the septic tank pumped & the cleaning of the tank did not require entry, merely a washing down with a hose.In those days the pumper charged $60.00 if he did not have to enter the tank.

The neighbor made very little provision to safeguard his septic system until one hot summer when the scent became somewhat putrid.Even then I had to tell him what was wrong. Next day out came the pumper, two days later he had a clean two part tank and was lighter by $300.00. The neighbor got an education the hard way.

Lee