Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

Sorta OT: Impact Drivers...

Posts

Sorta OT: Impact Drivers...

#1

Sorta OT: Impact Drivers...

Rob Hix - King George, VA

>Hey all,

We are about to put down some new carpet, and LOML wants me to screw down the sub-floor when we have the carpet up to help eliminate squeeks.

Being the good husband I am, I agreed but used the "I will need a new tool to make this happen." line. The tool I want is an impact driver. To me, cordless or corded does not matter (although I tend to lean toward cordless). Main use will be for putting screw in, but it will definately see some use this spring building a play set for the kids in the back yard (lots of lag screws).

Air powered is out as I am not ready to upgrade my air compressor to handle it.

What are your suggestions? I have a couple of weeks to decide and I am starting now to get my research done.

Thanks in advance,

Rob Hix

Re: Sorta OT: Impact Drivers...

#2

Re: Sorta OT: Impact Drivers... *LINK*

Grant in Iowa

>Rob,

I have owned two impact drivers. The first was a DeWalt 12V, and I now own a Makita 14.4V. While it is true that the more voltage the drivers have, the larger the fasteners they'll drive...they are both great tools.

They are, as far as I'm concerned the "tool of the year", for the past two or three years. I won't launch into a diatribe about how and why, since you seem to already know.

I have used a DeWalt, Makita, and a Milwaukee impact driver. They are all great tools, with the edge going to Milwaukee and Makita over the DeWalt.

I would say that a 14.4V tool is more than enough oomph for all but the largest fasteners, and it isn't too heavy. Heck, even the 12V DeWalt I have will drive screws faster and more easily than an 18V drill/driver.

My new Makita is part of the 6935FDWDEX kit, which contains an impact driver, drill, and handy flourescent worklight (which I use MUCH more than I thought I would). Also has new(er) battery technology than DeWalt offers widely. A GREAT tool set at a good price.

I have found that Makita usually has a good price on this combo kit. Check Amazon and your local tool dealers before committing.

Regards,

Grant in Iowa


price grabber search for Makita driver set...

Re: Sorta OT: Impact Drivers...

#3

"Tool of the year"

Charles R. Smith from Victoria

>I agree with Grant's statement that they are the "tool of the year". I have several cordless drill/drivers (DeWalt), but they get nowhere near the use that my Bosch impact driver gets. I love the fact that they substantially reduce cam-out on screws. (I use square-headed or Robertson screws, living in Canada.)

There are a number of good products on the market, such that price/ features/ battery type may be the deciding factor which is dependent on your individual situation. Just be sure to purchase a reliable brand-name.

By the way, make sure you use ear protection when you use it.

Charles (who is saving his hearing for the joy of music)

Re: Sorta OT: Impact Drivers...

#4

Review - Little Dated *LINK*

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Rob,

Link is to a 2004 review of impacts. Worth the read.

I have several friends with these tools; 2 Dewalts, a Makita, and an 18v Hitachi. I've used each of them in several jobs my group has done, and have to say that while the Dewalts would have my preference as a homeowner/occasional user, the Hitachi Lithium blows them all away. Even with its 18v box, it's lighter and better balanced than any. It's drawback is price ($250 street) which puts it about $60 above the others.

mm


T-O-T Review

Re: Sorta OT: Impact Drivers...

#5

Re: Sorta OT: Impact Drivers...

Barry Irby

>I have a Makita 12 volt. Got it because I already had a Makita 12 volt drill and wanted matching batteries. Bought the set with a new drill and driver and Charger. Now have two chargers and whatever. Had them long enough to wear out all the batteries and have them rebuilt. I agree that the impact driver is the "Tool of the Year". And I agree there is no need to get one bigger than 12 or 14.4 volts. This is a case where bigger is not better. This thing has enormous torque compared to driving a screw with a drill. I just used mine to in stall risers in two sets of deck steps. (the local Building Inspector demanded "toe kicks"). I unscrewed 63 3" screws, removed the treads, Installed the risers with 42 2" screws and reinstalled the treads with the 63 screws, all on a single charge and without predrilling the holes. The battery was pretty spent, but I still managed about a half dozen other screws. And it does it without torquing your wrist and shoulder the way a drill does.

My other Tool of the Year is a ROS. If you don't have one in your mix of tools you need one. Don't know how you can justify one trying to prevent floor squeaks, but it would look good sitting there supervising while you screw the floor down.

PS, You may have to "step up" when you buy screws. The impact driver will snap drywall screws like nothing.

Re: Sorta OT: Impact Drivers...

#6

Re: Sorta OT: Impact Drivers... *LINK*

Jim

>Rob,

I've attached (or at least tried to) a link to my inquiry last week. I ended up ordering the Panasonic kit, which is currently at a great price through all pro tools.com...with no shipping.

Although I cannot speak much for it, as it arrived only last night, but I couldn't help but try it out with a long screw here at work...what can I say, but "I wish I had one when I built my deck a few years ago!"

I have had the Panasonic line previously, and been extremely happy with it. I went with the Lithium-ion, which upped the price a bit...hopefully worth it.

Good luck,

Jim


http://www.woodcentral.com/cgi-bin/messages.pl?frames;read=333912

Re: Sorta OT: Impact Drivers...

#7

Re: Ridgid impact driver - long

Larry Clinton

>I purchased the 14.4 volt Ridgid impact driver (and a 12 V drill) from Home Depot late this spring. I went with the Ridgid as they are the only cordless tools that have a lifetime service agreement (free replacement batteries and tool repair / replacement for life). I am tired of discarding cordless tools when the batteries die and the cost of battery replacement is as much (or very close) to the price of a new tool with batteries. My son & I have used the impact driver quite a lot. Drove many (few hundred) self drilling screws into 1/16 and 1/8" steel, installing siding on a semi trailer my son converted to a storage building. I really like the tool since using it, have used it in the shop on a few small projects. There is virtually no cam-out with Phillips screws. I purchased an extra large capacity battery when I bought the unit. The charger is a "smart charger" with (as I remember) 15 min charge capability. This is somewhat misleading as the charger apparently detects the battery and will not start charging a "hot" battery until it cools off. There were a couple times when siding that we ran out of charged batteries due to waiting for a battery to cool. This was in continuous use installing the heavy 1/4" self drilling screws into the fairly thick metal - probably as hard use as any impact driver will ever see. The ergonomics of the driver are very good, it is pretty light with the standard battery, a little "tail heavy" with the extended capacity battery but not a deal breaker for me. I did have a long wait for the extended service agreement to be registered - (about 5 months between sending in the information and having Ridgid acknowledge the registration), but they did extend the service agreement to the extra batteries I purchased. When I inquired after purchase, they said the only batteries that would be covered in the lifetime service agreement were the ones included with the tool. When we received notice that the agreement had been accepted, the web site shows the extra High capacity batteries also covered. I would purchase the impact driver (and the drill) again.

Re: Sorta OT: Impact Drivers...

#8

Re: Sorta OT: Impact Drivers...

John Cotten

>I have two Dewalt 18V, all of my cordless are Dewalt 18V with the XTR batteries. Keep in mind, I build and install cabinets and woodwork full time so I have to depend on my tools daily. I can confortably say that there are many days my two drivers will do over a thousand screws with building and assembling cabinets and drawers.

I used to have two or three different brands and it was a pain in the posterior to keep up with chargers and batteries. KISS. Since the Dewalts are easy to get anywhere, I decided on the 18V and stuck with it.

I will say, if you don't have alot of other cordless, the Bosch impact driver is an excellent tool, and has the added feature of a light above the trigger which lights the screw and driver which is really handy when installing cabinets. My one oddball tool is the small Bosch impact driver which is great for install door and drawer hardware or screws in 7" or 9" wall cabinets.

We use square drive almost exclusively, with the exception of some installs which we use #25 torx head deck screws for really heavy wall units.

My drills are new religated to actually drilling holes instead of driving screws.

Another tip, when assembling cabinets or pocket hole screws with an impact driver, use short bursts. You don't run the risk of breaking screws in harder woods that way, or splitting plys in some cheaper grades of plywood.

Re: Sorta OT: Impact Drivers...

#9

Re: Sorta OT: Impact Drivers...

Howard Norman-Prescott, AZ

>I bought the 14v Makita impact driver along with the 14v drill driver about two and a half years ago. I have been extremly pleased with the impact driver. It came with a built in light which I considered a gimmick. However, it turns out to be very useful.

Howard

Re: Sorta OT: Impact Drivers...

#10

Re: Ridgid impact driver - long

Craig Frasa

>Rob,

I agree with Larry, the Ridgid right angle driver is a great tool, I've used it to build everything including disassembly and reassembly of a kids playset.

It has handled all the jobs I've given it so far and as a bonus it works as a right angle drill so its like a 2 for 1.

Craig

Re: Sorta OT: Impact Drivers...

#11

I agree

Neal in San Jose

>That bigger is not necessarily better. I have the Makita 12V impact and a matching drill, flashlight, etc. In a moment of weakness, I bought the Makita 18V Lithium impact and matching drill. The 18V units usually sit around gathering dust while I use the 12V because they are smaller, lighter and easier to get into small places. Both of them will set 3 inch galvinized multi-purpose screws WAY below the surface in redwood decks with almost no effort. The 18V will drive the nuts onto the bolts on your new wheelbarrow so tight you can't get them off with an 8" Crescent wrench!

For a homeowner with only occasional uses for it, the 12V is plenty.

Re: Sorta OT: Impact Drivers...

#12

One thing...

Dan Donaldson

>If you are screwing it down to eliminate squeaks, pull out the nails first, don't just put in screws. I know several people that have just screwed it down and in time the squeaks come back. I have also done it by pulling the nails and never had one return. It is a bit of a pain, but the nails are what causes many of the squeaks. I just used a cats paw and some time ;-)

Re: Sorta OT: Impact Drivers...

#13

Re: One thing...

Rob Hix - King George, VA

>Thanks for the info Dan. I will Have a bear of a time becuase mine is stapled down and the staples are countersunk about 1/4". I will try to get them out, but I will probably be somewhat hurried. With a two and four year old in the house, we do not want the subfloor exposed any longer than necessary.

We have had to do this before in the house, and in five years the squeeks did not come back. Granted, there is a screw every three or four inches, but no squeek.

Rob Hix

Re: Sorta OT: Impact Drivers...

#14

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Re: Sorta OT: Impact Drivers...

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

>I have the 14.4V DeWalt, and really like it. It's my "go-to" tool anytime I need to install or remove a screw - or bolt, too.

I got the 14.4V mainly because I already had two drills and a recip saw with the same batteries. I got mine as a 'reconditioned' tool from Tool King, with two batteries and a charger. It was significantly less than 'new.'

Jim D.

Re: Sorta OT: Impact Drivers...

#15

Re: Sorta OT: Impact Drivers...

Scott Greaves in Blackfoot Idaho

>Hi Rob,

I have to join the chorus on this! I have two Makita 14.4v impact drivers, and one Hitachi 12v impact driver. They are the best thing since white bread! I have driven 3" lag screws with the 12v and it didn't break a sweat. My Wife and I built a huge deck, almost 1000 sq/ft, driving the screws through Trex with the Makita drivers, without one problem. The chargers seemed to get the battery charged up about time the other one ran out, so there was really no down-time. The 14.4 Makita seems much better balanced that the 18v units, and it doesn't beat you up to use it. The only advantage I can see to the 14.4v over the 12v is that the battery seems to last longer, but they are both bruisers when it comes to the work they can do! Your Wife may even like the impact driver - my Wife loves hers! Enjoy the new tool!

Scott.

Re: Sorta OT: Impact Drivers...

#16

Re: Sorta OT: Impact Drivers...

John in Calgary

>I used to have a B&D 12V impact (the power was great, the batteries were not!) and now have a Makita 14.4V impact/drill kit that I picked up when my last drill died. Both the Makita and the B&D will drive screws with the same abandon, but I figure the 14.4V batteries will last longer, since you aren't drawing as many amps as the 12V for the same torque.

On batteries - make sure you check out what the Ah rating of the batteries is. In the cheaper kits, you will find that the batteries are only 1.5 - 2.0 Ah, while the more expensive kits (like my Makita) come with 3.0 - 3.5 Ah batteries. My old B&D came with 1.2 Ah batteries and wouldn't last for many screws. When I rebuilt one of the packs with 3.0 Ah batteries, the B&D would last forever.

My father-in-law connected all the rafters for the cottage style roof on his RV garage using one charge of my Makita and driving what felt like a million 3" screws.

John

Re: Sorta OT: Impact Drivers...

#17

Re: One thing...

Robin Corell in Atascadero Ca

>It is true that the squeeks are caused by the nails/staples becoming loose. It is not necessary to remove the nails to eliminate the squeeking as much as eliminate the possibility of the subflor to move and therefore squeek against the nail. One of the potential problems in screwing down a squeeky sub floor is that if the sub floor has any slight gaps between the floor and joist the gap will most likely be there with the screw driven home. over time screw threads in the plywood subfloor that are holding it suspended above the joist will fail and allow the subfloor to again squeek against the nails. this tends to happen when standard construction screws are used that are threaded the entire length of the shank. to eliminate this possibility and end up with a truely squeek free floor you should use a screw with a smooth shank that is as long as the thicknes of your sub floor. this will allow the flooring to be tightend down without hanging up on the screw threads.

I screwed the floor of my 1918 vintage home using stainless deck screws 5 years ago and have not had any problems, and we had a 6.4 earthquake since then as well. I chose stainles only because it was the only screw I could find locally at the time with the required smooth shank that was less than 2" overall in length. not to squash your new tool justification logic but I easily drove all the screws for my very old and hard douglas fir floor with my 15.6v Panasonic drill.

To add to the info regarding your initial question, I have used the dewalt 18v and a very old makita 12v or it may have even been a 9.6v. While the dewalt is a very nice tool and very capable and deserving of respect it is also very hevey and not particlularly ergonomic. the makita I used was very capable even at the reduced voltage it had the power to drive the screws I needed. I have not used it but based on my experiance with my panasonic drill I would definately look at a panasonic driver. My 15.6v drill is as powerful as the dewalt 18v and much better ballanced and significantly lighter.

Robin

Re: Sorta OT: Impact Drivers...

#18

Re: One thing...

Dan Donaldson

>Will have to remember that. So far, in my house, every time I have pulled out carpet, I have aso pulled the nails and screwed the floor down. Never thought about the thread issue, but it makes sense now that you mention it.

Thanks for the tip.