Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

Starting From Scratch

Posts

Starting From Scratch

#1

Starting From Scratch

A.W. Ford

>I'm starting to set up shop from scratch and have been trying to research out the bare essentials needed to get through some initial projects. Would you mind looking at this list, commenting, suggesting additions or removals, etc.? In particular, I'm wanting to start with projects that will help me learn various joint techniques, gluing up, the ins and outs of using a router and table saw. TIA - A.W.

- Circular saw

- Random Orbit Sander

- Router & bits

- Jigs (no idea what jigs are important to start with)

- Full set of clamps

- workbench vise

- saw horses

- chisels

- levels and squares

- plane

- Table saw: on this I've been torn. Due to budget and space constraints I don't know if I should go with something like this Craftsman 10" table saw at about $1000 ( http://www.sears.com/shc/s/p_10153_12605_00922124000P?vName=Tools&cName=Bench+Power+Tools&sName=Table+Saws ) or get the Shopsmith 5-in-1 Mark V combination 10" table saw, 34" lathe, 12" disc sander, horizontal drill, 16 1/2" drill press for around $3000 ( http://www.shopsmith.com/markvsite/purchaseNB.htm )

(Sorry, couldn't figure out how to format the URLs above to display the links)

Re: Starting From Scratch

#2

Re: Starting From Scratch

John Tenhundfeld

>AW,

I started out with a Shopsmith 5 in 1 tool almost 40 years ago. I still have it and occasionally still use it. What I found to be the most limiting was the size of the table saw. The table itself is just too small. Other than that I found it fine provided you thought ahead and tried to work through the project in order: cut to size, drill if needed, sand if needed, etc. That way you tried to make just a set up for a function (and with any luck would not have to return to that set up). I still cherish the disk sander-- one of the largest available and it has the added feature of precise contact and material removal--you advance the disk to the wood and not the other way about.

However, I was ecstatic when, after 25 years I was able to purchase used a Rockwell cabinet saw. What a beauty.

Enough. Have fun and welcome.

Re: Starting From Scratch

#3

What do you want to make?

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>AW,

To get the best responses it would help to tell us what king of thgings you would like to make. Furniture? Boxes? etc. There are some universally needed tools but depending on where you want to go with it might have some bearing on the list and priorities.

Tom

Re: Starting From Scratch

#4

Re: Starting From Scratch (long and rambling)

Dan Donaldson

>As mentioned, it depends a lot on what you want to make. In general, you are probably best of getting the tools as you find you need them for the projects you have in mind. This way, you only get tools that you know that you will use. If you are interested in joinery, I would suggest that you come up with a small project like a box or something, and get a few hand tools to mae it with. That will get you a long way toward understanding the features and functions of the different types of joints, and not a lot of money spent.

The marking tools are always needed. A good square and straightedge. I would also recommend a marking gauge, especially for joinery.

You also need some kind of a bench to put your vise on. It can be very simple, or complex, depending on your budget. Solid core doors can make good tops, and there are a lot of good bench ideas in various threads here at Woodcentral and in back issues of Popular Woodworking.

For a plane, depending on your budget, I would get a #4 size and a block plane. You can find good Stanleys (the old ones, not what they make today) used, but until you know how one is supposed to work, it might be frustrating for you to restore one of them. Perhaps a better idea might be to check out Lee Vally and get ones from them. They will already be set up and basically ready to go. I would also add a decent backsaw and a crosscut saw.

For chisels, again depending on your budget, a set of the blue handled Marples chisels are decent for the money. If you have a lot of money, then there are a lot of opportunities to spend it in this area ;-)

One thing, there is no such thing as a "full set" of clamps ;-) No matter haow many you have, you will always be one short of the number and size you need. One of Murphy's laws. What you buy would depend on what you want to make. For small projects, get some smaller clamps in at least pairs, and probably in fours. Then as you build bigger things, get more as you need them.

Id you do decide to get a tablesaw right away, look at Grizzly, Delta, jet, Steel city, or Rigid. They may be getting a bit better, but Sears saws are generally not well thought of, whether deserved or not. Some of them have non-standard miter slots and other issues for interfacing with the rest of the world. I would not recommend a Shopsmith. The tablesaw is too limited, and the changeover time can be a pain. It is better to get individual tools unless you have REALLY big bucks for something like a Felder or Minimax combo slider.

One thing missing in your list is sharpening supplies. You need either stones (water or oil, your choice) or a good flat surface and sandpaper. (google for "scary sharp") Leonard Lee from Lee Valley has a very good book on sharpening. That is a skill that you will have to learn no matter which way you go.

These are just a few thoughts, mostly based on stuff I did wrong when I started. ;-) I am sure as you start to figure out what you want to make, you will have other questions and then people can get a bit more specific in the answers.

Re: Starting From Scratch

#5

Re: Starting From Scratch

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Afternoon AW,

Of course, tool acqusition is a life long process, and therefore it makes a lot of sense to start early. He, who dies with the most tools, WINS!

That doesn't mean you can't upgrade as your needs warrant. A good table saw is the heart of the shop in the greatest majority of cases. Get a good table saw. From bitter and unjustifyably protracted and putrid experience with Sears, I won't enter any of their stores. So, I won't comment on the Craftsman option. Sears made great tools at one time, and maybe you can pick up a used item. There are extremely good table saws available from a variety of manufacturers. You can see many of them at places like Woodcraft, at Woodworking Shows, and importer's showrooms a la Grizzly and Wilke Machinery. Look in the Yellow Pages for firms who sell woodworking equipment and visit them. It will NOT be time wasted. When I bought my first used tablesaw, a 1950/60's ear Craftsman, the guy who sold it to me was buying a Shopsmith Mark 5. Later, I had the oppertunity to buy one unused from a neighbor's estate. I didn't run any wood through it. From my examination it is a solidly built machine, and may be the answer to somebody's prayers. Nice versitility. It bothered me to make so many change overs, so I let it go. It does have limitations and constraints which stand alone tools have less of. A stand alone 10" table saw allows greater rip and cross cut capacity. You can do both cuts with a top quality combination blade like a Forrest WWII. You can make a cross cut sled for a few bucks. I'd also suggest a good 14" bandsaw. I don't believe the Shopsmith has bandsaw capability. To start out with, the drill press and horizontal boring features of the Shopsmith can be satisfied by a couple good drills. Stand alone drill presses are pretty easy to come by, and need not cost an arm and leg. Mine is a medium sized floor model and I rarely need a larger capacity. You don't need the drill press feature immediately if you have good hand tools. The same can be said for the disc sanding feature of the Shopmate. A portable ROS electric sander should come first.

My tool acquisition followed no predictable pattern. I bought the tool needed for the specific job at the time. Since my budget was always limited from raising 10 children, I always tried to buy a tool which would respond to my needs and not necessarily the best or most expensive or most versitile.

George

Re: Starting From Scratch

#6

Re: What do you want to make?

A.W. Ford

>I guess thats another part of my problem...

In the long run I'd like to do furniture and cabinetry but don't yet know the best things to start with to "crawl, walk, run" so far as skills and techniques are concerned. I do know I have to build my workbenches and want drawers and plenty of storage so that will be a project I can afford to screw up and learn on.

I guess I need recommended starter projects too?

Re: Starting From Scratch

#7

Re: Starting From Scratch *LINK*

Ron Hildreth, Alta, Iowa

>A.W.,

Welcome to the board!

First, You're going to find that there will be a lot of opinions on what to buy first when it comes to tools. I'll not name a specific tool, but rather point you in a direction that hopefully will help you decide what is best, first, for yourself. It really depends on what projects you're interested in building. A word of caution here- start small and simple and work your way up to larger projects as you develop your skills. Nothing worse than buying that expensive lumber and making useless saw dust out of it (makes good yard mulch!).

Don't compromise on tools, especially ones you know you'll use often. Be patient here- wait until you have the money for the tool you really want, rather than making do with something you might not be happy with. Granted, there are cheap tools that do a good job, for a short while! This is where lots of would-be woodworkers get discouraged- they bought inferior tools that won't do a good job, therefore ruining a project. On the other hand, great tools don't make a good woodworker!

I had to chuckle a little on one item on your list- "A complete set of clamps"--Didn't know they made such a thing! You'll find that a wall measuring 10' high X 40' long crammed with clamps will still not be enough clamps, or at least yield the right size needed!

Others of the board will have there thoughts, too. Hope I didn't confuse you more!

Ron in Iowa


RK Woodworking

Re: Starting From Scratch

#8

Dale Lenz

Re: Starting From Scratch

Dale Lenz

>I started out some 27 years ago with a cheap table saw, router and a 10 dollar (1980 cost) hand powered jig saw. Went to the hardware store as other tools were needed, such as: square, clamps etc. As other's have said buy what you need and go from there. Learn to make do with what you have, at least for a while.

Had to make several 2~3" face grain wooden disk once, Purchased a 14 dollar jig, 1983 or so, and made the disk on the table saw. I few of them went flying, while cutting, : ' >. Read books, magazines, internet and go play. If something does not feel comfortable, as in not safe, RE THINK! Have fun and ENJOY.

Re: Starting From Scratch

#9

Re: Starting From Scratch

Jim Dillon

>A.W.,

I like very much your thoughts regarding starting out slowly by building shop stuff like storage cabinets and even a work bench. I did the same thing 12 years ago and learnt a lot, plus if I made a mistake, it didn't hurt anything except my pride. I also made a lot of jigs/sleds etc. for my new table saw. From there, I graduated to several pieces of outdoor furniture that increased my skill level further. Following that, I started to feel comfortable enough (and had acquired more tools based on my needs) to try something for indoor use like a bathroom vanity, a pantry storage area, dog/cat food pull-out storage bins etc. Then to "pay" for the increasing pile of tools (including a new table saw), I built our kitchen cabinets and that was a tremendous learning experience. After that, I felt skilled enough to build a nice china cabinet and look forward to getting back to real woodworking after a spate of home-improvement/repair projects during the past year or so. Speaking of which, a major reason I like woodworking so much is that the same tools that you acquire for fine woodworking, are extremely useful for general home improvemnet type projects. I won't go into all the tools you will need, except to say that you should get the best table saw you can afford. As others have said, the TS is the center of the workshop that you can do so much with.

You've found a super group of people here at WoodCentral who are only too happy to help you get started (and to spend your money 8-)). Thanks for posting.

Jim

Re: Starting From Scratch

#10

Your going about this "starting list" ......

Scott in Eastern Iowa

>.....the wrong way. Most of the younger generation nowadays wants everything RIGHT NOW

I'm confident others will chime in on this thought, being that its takes years...sometimes decades to accumulate all you need to do woodworking.

Heck, I will be the first to tell ya I will likely never be done adding to my shop!? As I progress deeper thru the "needs" and into the "wants" to a sort of completeness....in my mind.

I dont see it happening though, I'm well past the "needs" and scratching the surface of the "wants"

Re: Starting From Scratch

#11

Re: Starting From Scratch

Jesse in New Mexico

>Hey AW,

If you want to learn joinery, then you have two paths - the hand tool path and the power tool path. IMHO, the learning curve on hand tools is much longer (though more rewarding).

Before you can make decent joints, you need to learn how to make each component piece flat and square. With hand tools, thats a few planes, marking gauges, and sharpening tools (and practice, practice, practice). With power tools, its a table saw, a jointer, and a planer.

If you live near a woodcraft store or if your local community college has woodworking classes, I would strongly recommend taking a few classes before investing in woodworking tools. They will help you decide which route you want to pursue and how quickly.

Hope this helps.

Jess

Re: Starting From Scratch

#12

Re: Starting From Scratch

A.W. Ford

>Thank you all for the great responses. They give me much to think about and go off of, both from the tools and the projects standpoint.

Scott from Iowa, I think you may have misunderstood my question. I dont expect to have all I need in one shot, right now, McDonalds-style, or without making mistakes along the way: without the knowledge or experience to instinctively know which tools are most commonly needed, I figure a little faith in some sage advice might be helpful prior to breaking loose the checkbook ;-) That being said, I can appreciate the need for patience and accumulated skill and equipment you recommend.

I can tell I'm very much going to enjoy getting to know all of you. BTW, anyone else from the Pacific Northwest region of the U.S.? I'm in NW Oregon.

A.W.

Re: Starting From Scratch

#13

JL

Re: Starting From Scratch

JL

>First, I'd like to suggest a couple of books - "Classic Joints with Power Tools" by Yeung Chan, "The Workshop Book" by Scott Landis and "The Workbench Book" by Scott Landis.

- Router & bits - I'd suggest 2 routers. One for a router table and one for free hand work. If you get one has the router motor "separate", you can have a plunge router base and a "fixed" router base.

- workbench vise - and end vise and a side vise. Decide after you figure out which workbench that you are going to build :).

- levels and squares - Get the best you can afford (Starrett if you can swing it).

- plane - lots of them, in different sizes :).

- Table saw - I like separate tools. Which does consume the shop space.

Other items to consider - drill press (either bench or free standing one), grinder (I like low speed or variable speed 8"), planer and jointer. These can be future purchases (except maybe the grinder).

Re: Starting From Scratch

#14

oops........

Scott in Eastern Iowa

>.....yes I did

...sorry bout that

Re: Starting From Scratch

#15

As others have said

Don henthorn

>start out slow and buy tools as you need them for a project. You will be less distracted and be able to concentrate more on the job at hand.

Re: Starting From Scratch

#16

Re: oops........

A.W. Ford

>Not a problem at all, it happens. I've done that myself more times than I care to admit ;-)

Re: Starting From Scratch

#17

Re: Starting From Scratch

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>I certainly wouldn't buy the Craftsman table saw. Around here (Central Indiana) you can buy used Craftsman saws at auctions and yard sales for anywhere from $8.00 to $100 - in good shape. I paid $8.00 for one to give to my son. The price you are quoting will buy you a good used cabinet saw, or a major portion of a new one. Many woodworkers who started with a table saw (including myself) end up upgrading to a cabinet saw for the accuracy, lack of vibration, normally much better fence etc. I think many have given you good advice in looking at what you want to build and buying just what is needed for that project. As you advance so will your tool inventory, and you will have a far better idea what you want to make and what tools you need. You will be far better off buying a few pieces of top grade equipment than filling your shop with cheap tools that don't do what you expect or need. That money is normally just thrown away as the cheap line of tools (Craftsman, skill, Black & Decker etc.) have very low resale value, while the top grade tools, Porter Cable, Powermatic, General, Dewalt, etc. hold much of their value for years. Grizzly, Jet and Steel City also have some nice equipment you may look at. I wish you the best in your new hobby.

Re: Starting From Scratch

#18

Re: Starting From Scratch

A.W. Ford

>No fair, you beat me to my next question about best reference books... :p

Off to go think up something different to hassle you all with instead

Re: Starting From Scratch

#19

Where in NW Oregon, if you don't mind saying

Gary Camp Bend, Oregon

>Born and raised in the Salem area, been in Bend 30 yrs this November.

glc

Re: Starting From Scratch

#20

More info

Gary Camp Bend, Oregon

>depending on where in NW Oregon you live you probably have a Western Tool store close by (no affiliation, blah blah blah). They have a reasonable selection of tools, generally at decent prices, often just as good as the Borgs. I have haunted garage sales, estate sales, second hand stores etc. I have not paid new prices for 90% of my clamps or hand tools, and as far as planes go, got better than new (excepting the new premium makers). I newspaper, coffee of your choice and a map can make for an enjoyable Sat. morning with your sweetie. You may buy a few (ok 1 or 2)clamps that are warped or twisted, use those as teaching tools and then you can send your SO out to buy clmaps for you. THERE IS NO SUCH THING AS ENOUGH CLAMPS. Check out the adult education options in your area for Woodworking classes. One friend built a whole house full of furniture over 4 years with out ever buying any tools. He spent all his money on wood. He took the classes just to get shop time. looking forward to "hearing" back from you

gary camp (glc)

Re: Starting From Scratch

#21

Re: Starting From Scratch- another tool choice

Robin Corell, in Atascadero CA

>I would like to suggest a high quallity jig saw rather than the circular saw and posibly even before a table saw. I happen to be partial to the Bosch but the Festool and Dewalt models are also good choices depending on budget. The reason I like a jig saw as a first tool is that with a litle practice or in combination with a straight edge it will make straight cuts as well as curved cuts while despite its name a circular saw is only good for making straight cuts, same with a table saw.

A jig saw is also a great beginners tool as it has a much lower danger factor. Any power tool can cause bodily injury, but the nature of the blade movement makes the jigsaw a much safer tool. with a bit of practice and a bit of finish to the cut edge you can get surprisingly good results with a good quallity jig saw.

I made my first work bench with a cordless drill and a bosch jig saw and there are times when I wish I still had it, the bench not the saw as I still have the saw.

Robin

Re: Starting From Scratch

#22

Re: Starting From Scratch

Tom Berninghausen

>As stated above, what you need depends on what you're going to build.

Starting small but with the best quality tool you can afford is probably the most valuable information I have learned. I have given away tools because no one would buy them (yes, the Craftsman table saw and router table). Not that I'm the lone stranger in this behavior.

One real challenge we face in the PNW is the selection of wood. Here and on all the forums I read the common woods of choice seem to run to cherry, walnut and oak (white or red) which don't grow hereabout and thus fetch a premium price. Red alder and soft maple do grow here (the soft woods like fir and pine are local but aren't suitable for furniture IMHO) and can be found at reasonable prices for "sacrificial woodworking". As in, I am going to screw this up so I shouldn't pay a bunch of extra "tuition".

If'n you want some secret shopping information about the Portland

market send me an email.

And you might want to invest in a piece of strong rope, you are about to start down an extremely slippery slope!

Tom

Re: Starting From Scratch

#23

Buy as you find a need (and room!)

Stephen Kirk in Quakertown, PA

>I started with a pretty minimal set of tools, kind of driven by what I grew up with. I got an old Craftsman table saw and instantly put on a new fence. The fence on a table saw is probably more important than anything else on it. Then I added a router and a drill press. I can really recommend building (or buying) a good table for your router. That table with a good, adjustable fence will open a whole pile of capabilities.

Marking and measuring are always good. Get a good square, a good rule, some small squares are nice (easy to hold, mark). A good tape measure is a must (was a 92 or 94 inch board?). A fractional dial caliper is nice too have.

Hand tools - get some decent chisels and learn to sharpen them (pick just one sharpening method and stick with it - they pretty much all work). Those Marples are a decent set - I have a Craftsman set that took a lot of work to get flat and sharp. Find a nice block plane, old Stanley or new Lee Valley/Lie Nielsen are fine (low angle is probably better). Get/make/find a good mallet, too. Find some decent saws as well, back saw (crosscut is most multi-purpose), a decent crosscut panel and rip saw is nice too. Saws need to be sharpened, so either learn to sharpen or find someone who can do it (not many sharpeners left though). That Leonard Lee book on sharpening is a great resource.

I later added a portable planer which I use quite heavily as I get almost all stock "in the rough" now. Many people have jointers (I don't yet). A nice 14" bandsaw is going to be my next purchase.

If you don't have much space, consider making/buying rolling bases for everything.

Oh, my main bench is a solid core door on a base made from 2x4 lumber joined with draw bolts. Add a face vise, some dog holes. Then grab a Lee Valley wonder dog and a good hold fast (the Lee Valley one works great). If you need more clamping, consider a tail vise (use a real tail vice or just put a face vise on the end - it works) - then you can pinch wood with a bench dog.

A little rambling, but hopefully there's something useful in there.

Re: Starting From Scratch

#24

Re: What do you want to make?

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>Woodworking really isn't a run, walk or crawl thing. You always start out crawling...trust me. But crawling is good. It gives you time to learn proper techniques and more importantly...safety.

Woodworking is a wonderful pursuit but it's not for everybody. There are plenty of folks who have taken on woodworking with the best of intentions and desire but down the road lost interest. So I think it is best to start modestly and give yourself time to find out if you are in it for the long haul. Later, if a passion for woodworking truly takes hold then that's a good time to consider investing in more ambitious tools.

I agree with others who recommend books or DVDs as a place to start. Not only will they teach you the craft, proper techniques and safety, they will also educate you about the tools you will need.

Good luck and have fun!

Tom

Re: Starting From Scratch

#25

There's an SWMBO factor, too

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>It's important, especially when starting out, that you learn this important tool acquisition technique. SWMBO's are, for the most part, resistant to your buying new tools. So it's very important that you explain that the project you're working on absolutely can't be done without whatever tool you want. Then, it's equally important to schedule your next project with a new tool in mind.

Using this technique, you can be pretty far down the road toward a new shop before she catches on. Good luck. You'll need it :-))

Bruce, an old practitioner whose wife is onto him.