Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

Drill chuck falling out

Posts

Drill chuck falling out

#1

Drill chuck falling out

Mike Huber

>Recently I picked up a used, cheaper drill press, probably my problem right there, but I needed/wanted one to remain set-up to perform a certain task that I do quite often. The problem is that the drill chuck (tapered) falls out quite often.

Does anyone know what would cause this but better yet, how do I fix it. Just drilling wood at slow speeds.

Thanks

Mike

Re: Drill chuck falling out

#2

Re: Drill chuck falling out

john lucas

>Mike Remove the drill chuck and clean both the inside and outside morse tapers. Use a good grease remover like Naptha or mineral spirits. Let is dry real good. If there is rust apply some kind of rust remover and if necessary hit it really lightly with 4/0 steel wool. don't use anything more abrasive than that. Clean it again to remove all the oil.

Install the chuck. Then put a scrap of wood on the table and crank it up to where it almost touches the chuck. Now pull down on the feed arms to press the chuck into the morse taper. This has always worked for me, even on a mill/drill that has much worse vibration than a straight drill press.

Re: Drill chuck falling out

#3

Re: Drill chuck falling out

Larry in NW Ohio

>Mike If what John says don`t work, try putting some Loctite on the taoer and pressing it together. Worked for me years ago. Larry in Ohio

Re: Drill chuck falling out

#4

Re: Drill chuck falling out

Barry Irby

>What you should do is turn the drill press on at low speed and lick the Morse taper. Have your wife photograph you doing this. (She will be happy to have this picture.) Then Post the picture on Wood Central. We will all laugh and David will turn it into a SHOP SHOT. Way more than 15 minutes of fame.

Sorry, Couldn't help it. Don't listen to me. John and Larry gave you good advice.

Re: Drill chuck falling out

#5

Here's how from the Jacobs people

Forrest Addy

>Here's how to install a Jacobs chuck direct from the Jacobs chuck people. I attended a little talk at a machine tool show a few years ago (20, now that I think of it). There the Jacobs factory guy went all through the repairs, replacement, extraction, and cleaning of Jacobs chucks - and especially the installation of their famous general purpose taper fit chuck on their stub tapered shanks.

Clean the spindle taper and the socket. Lightly stone the tapered fits to remove raised metal from burrs - or the crests of annular scoring should it be present. The object is to get a smooth conical surface on the taper and the socket.

Heat the chuck to 350 degrees (no more) in a cheap foil pan the oven. It will smell a little bit the heat will not draw the taper or affect the chuck's performance or lubrication. The Jabobs guy used a plain old toaster oven with a cheap oven thermometer in it.

Grab the hot chuck in an oven mitt and hurry it out to the drill press and put it on the taper. Hold it in position by forcing the chuck against a handy wood block you cleverly pre-placed for that purpose. Hold the chuck in place for a minute or so and it will stay put. Allow it to cool to safe handling temperature before you put in into service.

When the chuck cools it will grip the taper as though it was forced on with a 2 ton press. That's about 6 times what you can get by forcing it on cold with the feed lever or by using a wood mallet. LocTite works well as a thread locker but hasn't the shear strength of an interferance fitted taper. It will eventually fail.

This process is called variously: shrink fitting, differential thermal expantion, or shrinking-on. It's used on a widely in industry to install ball bearings, ship's propellers on their tapers, and bushings in their housings. The object is to secure temporary clearance by heating the external fit, cooling the internal fit, or both.

I've installed a couple hundred Jacobs chucks on their shanks over the years by this methd and never has a failure that wasn't attributable to a hols saw's chatter.

Re: Drill chuck falling out

#6

This reminds me…

Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach

>…of a lot of spam I've been getting recently.

If you haven't gotten some of it (not spam, but specific spam) you won't understand and the explanation is definitely not family forum material. If you have gotten some, no explanation is necessary.

Rod

Re: Drill chuck falling out

#7

Hey David Yoho

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Hello Dave,

Are you paying attention?

:<)

George

Re: Drill chuck falling out

#8

Forrest, How would you get the chuck off?

Barry Irby

>

Re: Drill chuck falling out

#9

Re: Hey David Yoho

David Yoho

>I'd say we'd have it licked in no time!

Tongue in cheek,

David ;-)

Re: Drill chuck falling out

#10

To Expand On An Outstanding Idea, Barry

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Afternoon Barry,

Were Mike to wear his Wood Central hat while salivating on the morse taper as his wife took the pix, it would make one hellova sighting.

George

Re: Drill chuck falling out

#11

Re: Uh, Forrest...

Al Stokka - Cambridge, Iowa

>I think your instructions are in error. Sound to me like your describing how to mount the chuck on its taper rather than installing a Morse taper into the drill press spindle.

If Mike has a large enough oven in which to put the drill press, heat that, and then install the tapered shank, it might work, but he's probably have to buy a new belt.

Al

Re: Drill chuck falling out

#12

Re: Here's how from the Jacobs people *LINK*

JKJ in East TN

>>...Heat the chuck to 350 degrees

Would that not depend on which taper was not holding? (My drill presses both use spindles with dual tapers - a morse taper which fits into the head of the drill press and a JT (jacobs taper) that fits into the chuck body.) Since Mike said the chuck was falling "out" rather than "off", it may be that the upper (longer) taper is not holding which is a different issue. Which is coming loose, Mike?

The spindle (with chuck attached) kept falling out of one of my drill presses. I cleaned the tapers, inside and out, and tapped it into place with a mallet. It has held tight for the last 10 years or so.

I'd personally be less inclined to use heat to assemble. We've learned that if you use heat to assemble something, you will probably need to use heat again to dissassemble it if ever needed. Sometimes the latter is more difficult to effect than the former.

This link is from the Jacob's web site.

http://www.jacobschuck.com/pdf/s1.pdf

I think the link below has better info.

John K Jordan


Jacobs Drill Chucks

Re: Drill chuck falling out

#13

My instructions are spot on for

Forrest Addy

>Was the chuck's Morse taper falling out of the drill press spindle socket? I didn't read it that way. Maybe Mike will clarify. My instructions are spot on for mounting a Jacobs chuck to its Morse taper shank - which is how I read Mike's original post. My understanding was the chuck was coming off its Jacobs taper.

A clean smooth Morse taper will hold every time but it requires some thrust to keep is seated. Ordinary drilling feed force is sufficient. Some operations producing little thrust may allow the taper to slip or pull out. High torque, low thrust operations like circle cutters, break-through when drilling thin sheet metal, hole saws, and chattering countersinks on wood are notorious for pulling the Morse shank from its socket or even spinning it and twisting off the shank's driving tang.

When the tapered shank is clean and dry, and its conical surface is not interrupted with raised metal from dings, burs, and annular score its grip is very reliable.

Dirt, chips, raised metal, and lubricants are all ingredients for unreliable holding of a Morse taper. Lightly stone the male taper with a fine India slip stone to remove defects that raise the metal includung minor rust patches. Stone the internal taper with a stone from a brake cylinder hone affixed to a dowel or brake line. With the spindle under slow rotation apply the stone to the tapered bore, rapidly oscillating it from top to bottom. You may over-run the small end of the taper and catch the stone in the drift slot. That's why you run the spindle slow and use easly bent or broken materials for the stone holder.

Stop when you see a cross hatch appear on the taper's wall. You'll need a dental mirror and a flashlight to follow progress. Stone lightly. Your object is to remove raised metal not adjust the taper fit.

Re: Drill chuck falling out

#14

Why would you wish to remove the chuck

Forrest Addy

>Why would you ever wish to remove the chuck from its taper shank? It's a semi-permanent connection and routine removal was never intended.

If you wish to remove the chuck from its shank for some reason use the Jacobs pair of extraction wedges as in the PDF. Or if the shank has no suitable shoulder, slam it into the end of a stout piece of pipe solidly backed up with concrete or steel. Inertia will extract the shank from the chuck socket but it has to be squarely struck with fair velocity.

I see the current Jacobs orthodoxy reccommends a drive to seat the shank in the chuck. Notice in the link photo how the operator is backing up the chuck with a sizable anvil and striking the driving tang with a middling ball peen hammer - in other words a solid, heavy shock; much more than a drill press spindle bearing can survice without damage.

They reccommend against a press for fear of swelling the chuck body. The heat shrink method limits the enlargement to the amount of dininsion change due to thermal expansion. In a #3 JT this amounts to about 0.0012" just short of yield for the body core.

In older days when lawyers and litigation weren't so much part of the landscape the Jacobs people reccommended the shrink-on method.

But hell. What do I know? I've only been in the machinist trade in a succession of increasingly technical roles for 48 years.

Re: Drill chuck falling out

#15

Re: Why would you wish to remove the chuck

Barry Irby

>A friend gave me a really nice Jacobs chuck that was clearly better than the on that came on the drill press. I stared at it for a while and savored it. Eventually, I worked up my courage and decided to install it. Being a completely ignorant savage, not a machinist, I knew nothing of how to install it or remove the old one. The old one had been on there for fifteen of twenty years. Eventually, I invented the opposing wedges. Made my own. The shame is that someone beat me to it by fifty or a hundred years. (All my best Ideas were stolen by the Ancients.) I even had sense enough to stone the taper lightly and clean it up and I pressed it on and it seated and stayed.

Getting the old one off was tough and I was wondering how hard it would be to remove one that had been heat set?

Re: Drill chuck falling out

#16

I dunno Barry.

Forrest Addy

>I dunno Barry. My view is to have a chuck for each machine exch with the needed shank. I'm a selfish bachelor and I keep forgetting most people have responsibilities and can't run out whenever the whim strikes and squander money on shop toys. Thus I have several drill chucks (somewhere...) in my crowded and messy shop.

Your re-invention of the chuck removing wedges is no less an invention even though unbeknownst to you someone else got there first. Imagine my sorrow when at age 9 or so I noticed the water level in the bathtub rose with my immersion. I later mentioned it to my dad and he told me about that damn Greek who got there first.

Re: Drill chuck falling out

#17

Re: My instructions are spot on for

Mike Huber

>Forrest,

Sorry I wasn't clear enough. It was the taper coming out of the drill press spindle not from the chuck. Bad choice of words on my part.

I appreciate all of your suggestions. I have cleaned up the spindle including with a stone and also the socket socket and it appears to be holding for now. Keep your fingers crossed

Again, thanks for all the help.,

Mike

Re: Drill chuck falling out

#19

I thought it was kinda drafty.

Forrest Addy

>