Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

Qujestion on Sharpening devices

Posts

Qujestion on Sharpening devices

#1

Qujestion on Sharpening devices

Robert R Clough - Thorncraft

>I am interested in a motorized tool sharpening system. I presently have the Lee Valley waterstones, et al. I made my own dry wheel device which was ok. It worked off the drill press at low speed. But I dislike hollow ground tools, except for kitchen knives, which is why I don't want the Jet or Tormek systems - plus the price.

The two devices I have considered are the Work Sharp WS3000 Tool Sharpener which is a low speed dry device. The other sharpener is the Delta Industrial Model 23-170, a low speed wet device. Both are at the Rockler site. The Delta at $200 and the Work Sharp at $100. I have seen a video on the Work Sharp - obviously an ad video. The price is fine.

Has anyone any experience with either of these?

Re: Qujestion on Sharpening devices

#2

Re: Qujestion on Sharpening devices

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>Is it possible that you have the prices mixed up?

DC

Re: Qujestion on Sharpening devices

#3

Prices Mixed Up?

Robert R Clough - Thorncraft

>What? Wrong? Me? But I was mistaken - as you thought.

The Work Sharp is $199.99 and the Delta is $159,99

Re: Qujestion on Sharpening devices

#4

If it were me...

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>I'd go with something like this:

http://www.leevalley.com/wood/page.aspx?c=1&p=44884&cat=1,43072

I actually bought this sander/grinder, and put a reversible motor (with switch) on it. Like you I'm not fond of hollow bevels, I just haven't had the time to play with this machine (been using a 6" grinder until now). I know people who are very satisfied with this setup.

Beyond that, a 1000 and an 8000X stone is all you need to produce a razor edge...

DC

Re: Qujestion on Sharpening devices

#5

A strong case FOR hollow grinds

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Let us take a dull plane iron as an example. Furthermore, realize as a fact that the steel one encounters in a modern tool can be greatly more abrasion resistant than a Stanley plane iron.

Sharpening can be considered a two step process. The first step involves removing the comparatively large amount of metal to be rid of the dull rounded cutting edge. Indeed, some kind of power grinding can vastly speed this process, especially on one of the more abrasion resistant metals, A2 or even O-1 compared to Stanley plane iron metal. If this step results in a hollow grind, the amount of metal that must be removed to refine this edge is minuscule. Because it is minuscule, any abrasive technique will quickly do the job and maybe in one step. It may be possible to refine the edge one or more times before another hollow grinding is necessary. On my lathe tools I will hone them maybe 5 or more times before hollow grinding them on a bench grinder again.

A bench grinder uniquely establishes a hollow grind. The machine is cheap, multi tasking (good for lawn mower blades or any tool in the shop that needs abrasion), and fast. It doesn't have any disadvantages. I follow bench grinding one step with a 1 micron diamond honing. I am using diamond because I am using a very highly abrasion resistant steel for my homemade tools, CPM 3V. If I was using O1 a water stone or abrasive sheets like 3 M film would do fine.

Re: Qujestion on Sharpening devices

#6

Re: A strong case against hollow grinds

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>A hollow grind removes metal near the cutting edge, therefore lessening the support the cutting edge receives. All other things being equal, a hollow ground blade should be more prone to chatter.

Maybe you're getting away with it because you use CPM3V...

One can get the same amount of edge to work on by grinding a flat bevel and doing a micro-bevel for the honing part. That edge will be stronger.

Never done any measurements or tests, just working by logic here.

DC

Re: Qujestion on Sharpening devices

#7

Hollow grinds verses flat grinds

Jim Swank

>A lot of our talk about flat verses hollow is simply parroting what we've been told or have read. Let's stop and actually think for ourselves - how long are the bevels and how big are the wheels we're grinding with?

If we look at wheels, we can see that an 8" wheel is curved less sharply than a 6" and much less sharply than a 4". How long are the bevels? In most cases, they will be less than 1/2". How much the wheel curves over the length of that bevel will be the difference between the hollow grind and a flat grind.

Draw a circle the size of the wheel on paper, then use a ruler to strike off a chord the length of the bevel. In most cases, with a modern larger wheel, the difference is insignificant.

Most of us will be better served putting our efforts to refining the edge itself than chasing the obscure 15th decimal points of curvature.

Re: Qujestion on Sharpening devices

#8

Re: Hollow grinds verses flat grinds

john lucas

>I can't make a case for plane irons because after my test with chisels I haven't gone back to a flat bevel. I had just purchased a set Marples chises to replace my older chisels and decided I would put flat bevels on some of my matching chisels and stick with my hollow grind on the others. Needless to say it took quite a while to get a really flat long bevel. Then I added a mico bevel to both the flat and hollow blades.

I cut various things from dovetails and mortises to just shaping things like a carving tool. I could not tell on lick of difference. My conclusion. If you use a large wheel that runs reasonably slow (1750 rPM white wheel) and take light cuts so you don't heat up the metal, then a hollow grind works just fine. Look at the Japanese chisels with hollow backs.

As far as plane irons go I've been grinding mine with a hollow grind. Don't grind all the way to the tip, you'll sharpen that part with your favorite hand sharpening rig. Unless your using really worn out 6" wheels I don't think there is enough difference in a flat grind and hollow grind, but then I haven't tried it and don't even claim to be in the same leaque as the guys with $700 planes cutting a 500 burl.

Re: Qujestion on Sharpening devices

#9

Re: A strong case FOR hollow grinds

Steve Schoene

>An advantage of the hollow grind that I see is that it makes free hand honing more practicable. With the hollow grind the bevel seems to "snap" down on the honing surface, reducing the risk of rocking. Just concentrate downward pressure over the bevel, as close to the tip as possible.

Re: Qujestion on Sharpening devices

#10

Exactly

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>The hollow for even a 7" wheel (what I use because 7" surface grinder wheels are available in a multitude of varieties) is so shallow that I can grind it away after a few honings with only 1 micron diamond.

Re: Qujestion on Sharpening devices

#11

works for all steels

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>"Maybe you're getting away with it because you use CPM3V."

I have everything from butter soft Stanley plane irons to M4 lathe tools. They are all hollow ground- O-1, A2, M2, M4, 3V, S7, Japanese chisel metal.

I think if one were to draw a large scale replica of a hollow ground edge it would be obvious that the "support" argument is unfounded. If "chatter" was an issue would we all not observe it.

Re: Qujestion on Sharpening devices

#12

A most significant observation

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Those that have not tied it, take note. Hollow grinds enabled me to successfully free myself of sharpening jigs.

Re: Qujestion on Sharpening devices

#13

Re: Hollow grinds verses flat grinds

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>John, hollow bevel grinds are in no way analogous to the hollows on the back of Japanese tools (note, this terminology is all wrong for Japanese tools, but I wanted to speak western toolese here). The only simularity is that less metal is easier to grind.

Pam

Re: Qujestion on Sharpening devices

#14

Re: Hollow grinds verses flat grinds

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>A lot of our talk about flat verses hollow is simply parroting what we've been told or have read. Let's stop and actually think for ourselves - how long are the bevels and how big are the wheels we're grinding with?

.

.

.

Most of us will be better served putting our efforts to refining the edge itself than chasing the obscure 15th decimal points of curvature.

I did actually stop and think before posting, in case you're wondering...

While I can see that hollow grinding a thin, let's say 3/32" blade at 40 degree bevel with an 8" wheel probably makes little difference compared to a flat grind, doing the same to a 1/4" thick chisel (or plane blade) ground at 20 degree with a 6" wheel does make a difference. It's a matter of geometry, and how close to the tip of the blade one hollow grinds.

DC

Next time, try to use a less arrogant tone...

Re: Qujestion on Sharpening devices

#15

Re: Prices Mixed Up?

Jesse in New Mexico

>Actually, I saw that Worksharp has a new model thats only $99. What you give up is the ability to do angles other than 25 degrees.

Re: Qujestion on Sharpening devices

#16

Re: A strong case FOR hollow grinds

Thomas S Stockton

>I think the point that gets lost in all these discussions about various techniques is that a person should find out which way works best for them and gets the results they like and want. Using techniques that don't work for you leeds to frustration and sloppy results.

One of my pet peeves about woodworking these days are the amount of gadgets and gizmos that are sold to people. Some are very useful but a lot you don't need and end up in a box.Look through any catalog and see how many sharpening gizmos there are it's pretty silly and it seems like the fancier they get the more of a pain they are to use and they make it look like sharpening is real complicated.It is a very simple process at a minimum all you need is a few stones, to make it easier add a grinder of your choice and maybe a honing guide. That's it.

I think Michael Dunbar's scary sharp is a great example of this, he started using the system at his school because it was cheap, easy to teach ,dead simple and gave good results. He writes an article about it and suddenly it becomes an industry and much more complicated with all these dodads people are selling where the origanal was a piece of plate glass and a couple pieces of sandpaper.

All I'm saying is find out what works for you and work on refining your technique and at some point pretty quickly you'll figure out how to tweak it and make it work even better for you

I'm done ranting and go back to my shop and work

Tom

Re: Qujestion on Sharpening devices

#17

AMEN to That!

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>

Re: Qujestion on Sharpening devices

#18

Re: Calculations on hollow grind effects

Dave Mount

>I did some calculations that don't resolve this issue, but they put some real numbers into the mix. I calculated the actual reduction in angle at the sharpened arris for several bevels and wheel diameters. The wheel diameters were 4", 6", 8" and 10", the latter being what the Tormek wheel is if memory serves. I used bevel widths of 5/32", 1/4", and 1/2". If the nominal grind is 30 degrees, then the width of the bevel is basically 2x the thickness of the iron/chisel. The 5/32" bevel corresponds to the thickness of a stock Stanley plane iron. The 1/4" and 1/2" would be for 1/8" and 1/4" thick metal, respectively.

The data below show what I calculated. These are based on degrees *below* the nominal grind that will exist at the cutting edge.

I can't make the editor do a table properly, so I'll just list the values individually:

For a 10" wheel: 5/32" bevel = 0.9 deg, 1/4" = 1.4, 1/2" = 2.9

For an 8" wheel: 5/32" bevel = 1.1 deg, 1/4" = 1.8, 1/2" = 3.6

For a 6" wheel: 5/32" bevel = 1.5 deg, 1/4" = 2.4, 1/2" = 4.8

For a 4" wheel: 5/32" bevel = 2.2 deg, 1/4" = 3.6, 1/2" = 7.2

So if you are grinding a 1/4" bevel at a nominal 30 degrees on a 6 inch wheel, that means that right off the grinder, the actual arris is at 30-2.4 or 27.6 degrees. While I based this initially on a 30 degree grind, the numbers are relative to the bevel width and wheel diameter; therefore the table values can be applied to other grind angles, as long as the bevel width matches what's in the table. So, a 1/4" bevel ground at 20 degrees on a 6" wheel ends up at 20-2.4 or 17.6 degrees.

This does not tell the whole story of course, because the next step following hollow grinding is to hone a bevel which will actually be at the nominal grind angle. Therefore, the actual angle at the cutting edge is not affected by a hollow grind; the only thing that is affected is the arrangement of metal further back. When would this matter? It should matter most when the tool is being pushed into wood in angle that is not in line with long axis of the tool, such as in a bevel down plane (not I'm not saying it will make a *meaningful* difference necessarily, just that under these conditions is when it will have the greatest effect). When force is applied in line with the tool, such as in a paring chisel, this should have little effect. The effect should also be much smaller in low angle bevel up planes because they have better support for the iron.

So, I think the answer is, like most things, it depends. Bigger diameter wheels obviously reduce the effect, as to shorter bevels. As the secondary honing bevel increases in width, the effect is also reduced. Finally, the edge is used will affect the impact a particular hollow grind will have.

I suspect everyone involved in this discussion will point to the data and be able to use it to support their viewpoint. Bill is right that for many situations the effect is very small. Denis is right that for thick irons with low bevel angles, and small wheels, the difference is more substantial.

Everyone will interpret these variables differently. I hollow grind on a Tormek and hone freehand on waterstones. I find the Tormek gives me very even and reproducible initial grinds, which I like, and the hollow, small as it may be, allows me to freehand hone with relatively little error, which is fast and easy.

Dave

Re: Qujestion on Sharpening devices

#19

Nothing like running numbers!

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>Thanks for that, that helps clarify the whole issue!

DC

Re: Qujestion on Sharpening devices

#20

Robert, Getting back to your original question...

Don in Northern Arizona

>Robert,

I would definitely go with the WorkSharp 3000. Garret Lambert did a great review of it and he is a believer. I hope to get one at some point. Ease of use and no water mess are pluses. Also if you carve or do wood turning, the slotted wheel for sharpening while looking at the blade bevel is a nice feature. Here is Garrett's review.

http://www.woodcentral.com/cgi-bin/archives.pl?noframes;read=319234

Don

Re: Qujestion on Sharpening devices

#21

Re: Robert, Getting back to your original question  *LINK*

Don in Northern Arizona

>


Garrett's review of the WorkSharp 3000

Re: Qujestion on Sharpening devices

#22

However?

Howard

>However has anyone compared the Worksharp with the Veritas MKII?

Howard

Re: Qujestion on Sharpening devices

#23

Hollow Ground

Robert R Clough - Thorncraft

>Well I started something here with an offhand comment.

However, I shall stick by my comment. My reaction to any hollow grind is shaped by early teaching. It was drummed into me that one wants as much "heft" as possible with a blade. I know rationally that a Hock iron at 25 deg is equally usable with either grinds. And I know that a micro bevel changes the geometry of **any** blade. However, my conceits shall remain with me.

Thanks for a good discussion.

Re: Qujestion on Sharpening devices

#24

a comment on your thoughts

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>you said that a person "should find out which way works best for them".

Indeed this goal is why challenges to opinion statements are such a valuable part of this Forum. Of course the challenges should be positive and not be "mine is right", but rather this is why I do it this way or that. Many of us do woodworking in isolated environments. We may only be exposed to one way of doing something, or for one reason or another, have only tried one way.

The original statement was an opinion that the poster didn't like hollow grinds. They may never have tried hollow grinds, they may never have considered trying them because they were unaware of the benefits and/or on-lookers that never tried either might be disposed to never consider hollow grinds because of this opinion.

In the end data was presented that could encourage someone to try hollow grinding that other wise would not, or maybe the opposite. And that will enable persons to make an informed conclusion of what "works best for them".

I had a 6th grade teacher that I despised, at the time. But she taught an important lesson. She lectured to "challenge your prejudices". Others might advocate keeping an open mind, but her approach was more proactive, and hence, more useful.

Re: Qujestion on Sharpening devices

#25

Re: a comment on your thoughts

Thomas S Stockton

>Bill

Good points. Part of what I was trying to say is that if you don't first get a basic grasp of any technique you are going to have a hard time deciding which one works better. Take sharpening I think if you can sharpen a chisel and use it, you will be better able to tell which sharpening technique is best for you. I think the gizmo's can be a trap sometimes in that the thinking becomes I need to buy this thing so I can sharpen well instead of if I practice some more and it becomes second nature I'll be good at it.

I think back to my education and learning to sharpen every school or instructer had a different way of doing things and I found it easiest to use their techniques while I was there. This gave me a good foundation to decide on my own which sharpening method I preferred and I learned a few different ways to sharpen a chisel or plane.

By the way I sharpen with a hollow grind followed up with honing on waterstones freehand which is pretty much the way I was first taught except I use a powered grinder instead of a handcranked one.

Tom