Re: Calculations on hollow grind effects
Dave Mount
>I did some calculations that don't resolve this issue, but they put some real numbers into the mix. I calculated the actual reduction in angle at the sharpened arris for several bevels and wheel diameters. The wheel diameters were 4", 6", 8" and 10", the latter being what the Tormek wheel is if memory serves. I used bevel widths of 5/32", 1/4", and 1/2". If the nominal grind is 30 degrees, then the width of the bevel is basically 2x the thickness of the iron/chisel. The 5/32" bevel corresponds to the thickness of a stock Stanley plane iron. The 1/4" and 1/2" would be for 1/8" and 1/4" thick metal, respectively.
The data below show what I calculated. These are based on degrees *below* the nominal grind that will exist at the cutting edge.
I can't make the editor do a table properly, so I'll just list the values individually:
For a 10" wheel: 5/32" bevel = 0.9 deg, 1/4" = 1.4, 1/2" = 2.9
For an 8" wheel: 5/32" bevel = 1.1 deg, 1/4" = 1.8, 1/2" = 3.6
For a 6" wheel: 5/32" bevel = 1.5 deg, 1/4" = 2.4, 1/2" = 4.8
For a 4" wheel: 5/32" bevel = 2.2 deg, 1/4" = 3.6, 1/2" = 7.2
So if you are grinding a 1/4" bevel at a nominal 30 degrees on a 6 inch wheel, that means that right off the grinder, the actual arris is at 30-2.4 or 27.6 degrees. While I based this initially on a 30 degree grind, the numbers are relative to the bevel width and wheel diameter; therefore the table values can be applied to other grind angles, as long as the bevel width matches what's in the table. So, a 1/4" bevel ground at 20 degrees on a 6" wheel ends up at 20-2.4 or 17.6 degrees.
This does not tell the whole story of course, because the next step following hollow grinding is to hone a bevel which will actually be at the nominal grind angle. Therefore, the actual angle at the cutting edge is not affected by a hollow grind; the only thing that is affected is the arrangement of metal further back. When would this matter? It should matter most when the tool is being pushed into wood in angle that is not in line with long axis of the tool, such as in a bevel down plane (not I'm not saying it will make a *meaningful* difference necessarily, just that under these conditions is when it will have the greatest effect). When force is applied in line with the tool, such as in a paring chisel, this should have little effect. The effect should also be much smaller in low angle bevel up planes because they have better support for the iron.
So, I think the answer is, like most things, it depends. Bigger diameter wheels obviously reduce the effect, as to shorter bevels. As the secondary honing bevel increases in width, the effect is also reduced. Finally, the edge is used will affect the impact a particular hollow grind will have.
I suspect everyone involved in this discussion will point to the data and be able to use it to support their viewpoint. Bill is right that for many situations the effect is very small. Denis is right that for thick irons with low bevel angles, and small wheels, the difference is more substantial.
Everyone will interpret these variables differently. I hollow grind on a Tormek and hone freehand on waterstones. I find the Tormek gives me very even and reproducible initial grinds, which I like, and the hollow, small as it may be, allows me to freehand hone with relatively little error, which is fast and easy.
Dave