You're over-reacting Rick.
Forrest Addy
>There's no need to abuse me for ignorance. I understand engineering and scientific principles as well as anyone and that includes conservation of mass-energy. You don't get something for nothing. I didn't claim that such a thing was possible. Re-read my posts and you will see that I made no assertion of power for free.
My position on this topic has nothing at all to do with free power and everything to do with application of theory to real life. Please allow me credibility enough to assert differing results based on watt hour meter data from those you postulate from your analytical methods.
If you disagree with my assertions then do what any student of scientific method does: Disprove them using my own methods. I don't dispute yours.
Two motors identical for ratings and frame except for one being three phase run from a suitable VFD and the other a single phhase, a controllable mechanical load. Run them both on a watt hour meter at 25% mechanical load. If I am correct you will see the VFD/motor offers several precent improvment in electrical economy over a single phase motor across the line.
The motors I used were both Baldor 3/4 HP 1750 RPM motors, one single phase, one three phase, both 1.0 service factor, both 56 frame, ODP. The VFD was a Yasawa GPD 315 CIMR V7AM20P7. The fixed load was a proney brake of my own devising consisting of a spring, a length of V belt, and a V belt pulley.
Load sensing was by mounting the motor on a large strap hinge were torque compressed a small engine valve spring and a dial indicator senced the amount of deflection. Load force application was anchored to the motor frame itself to eliminate external forces from acting on the admittedly crude sensor and the brake tension passed vertically through the hinge pin centerline.
The load sensor was calibrated using a spring scale and a 1 ft lever arm. A mist of water from time to time was necessary to cool the pulley. A table of dial indicator readings Vs motor torque was developed. An observer equipped with a stop watch was stationed at the watt hout meter. The motor was run up to speed and the motor loaded to a load sensor reading equal to 25% full load motor torque.
I'm quite certain you will be forced to condlude that a three phase VFD combo draws about 6 or 7% less power at 25% rated motor load than a single phase motor running across the line. I'd repeat the experiment but I have no such motors in my inventory at the moment.
So, Rick, I challenge you to duplicate my experiment of several years ago using comparable equipment. It's quite possible for empiracle data to differ a bit from theoretical so don't become outraged if it does. I'll send you the VFD on condition of return if you'd like but you'll have to reset its parameters.



