Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

3 phase power?

Posts

Re: 3 phase power?

#26

You're over-reacting Rick.

Forrest Addy

>There's no need to abuse me for ignorance. I understand engineering and scientific principles as well as anyone and that includes conservation of mass-energy. You don't get something for nothing. I didn't claim that such a thing was possible. Re-read my posts and you will see that I made no assertion of power for free.

My position on this topic has nothing at all to do with free power and everything to do with application of theory to real life. Please allow me credibility enough to assert differing results based on watt hour meter data from those you postulate from your analytical methods.

If you disagree with my assertions then do what any student of scientific method does: Disprove them using my own methods. I don't dispute yours.

Two motors identical for ratings and frame except for one being three phase run from a suitable VFD and the other a single phhase, a controllable mechanical load. Run them both on a watt hour meter at 25% mechanical load. If I am correct you will see the VFD/motor offers several precent improvment in electrical economy over a single phase motor across the line.

The motors I used were both Baldor 3/4 HP 1750 RPM motors, one single phase, one three phase, both 1.0 service factor, both 56 frame, ODP. The VFD was a Yasawa GPD 315 CIMR V7AM20P7. The fixed load was a proney brake of my own devising consisting of a spring, a length of V belt, and a V belt pulley.

Load sensing was by mounting the motor on a large strap hinge were torque compressed a small engine valve spring and a dial indicator senced the amount of deflection. Load force application was anchored to the motor frame itself to eliminate external forces from acting on the admittedly crude sensor and the brake tension passed vertically through the hinge pin centerline.

The load sensor was calibrated using a spring scale and a 1 ft lever arm. A mist of water from time to time was necessary to cool the pulley. A table of dial indicator readings Vs motor torque was developed. An observer equipped with a stop watch was stationed at the watt hout meter. The motor was run up to speed and the motor loaded to a load sensor reading equal to 25% full load motor torque.

I'm quite certain you will be forced to condlude that a three phase VFD combo draws about 6 or 7% less power at 25% rated motor load than a single phase motor running across the line. I'd repeat the experiment but I have no such motors in my inventory at the moment.

So, Rick, I challenge you to duplicate my experiment of several years ago using comparable equipment. It's quite possible for empiracle data to differ a bit from theoretical so don't become outraged if it does. I'll send you the VFD on condition of return if you'd like but you'll have to reset its parameters.

Re: 3 phase power?

#27

Looks to me...

John in New Mexico

>like you guys are talking about different comparisons.

Forrest is comparing single phase to VFD "3 phase", while Rick is comparing true 3 phase to VFD "3 phase".

I may have missed something where you guys started discussing details though, so I'll now go back to my own business :)

John

Re: 3 phase power?

#28

Not Really

Rick Christopherson

>Unfortunately, your setup was even worse than I expected. Your heart was in the right place, but what bothers me is that you presented your results as though you had sound scientific data, and with your good reputation for information on other matters, people will have automatically believed that you did have sound data, when in fact you left too many holes.

Without even delving too deeply into your setup, the first thing that struck me is that you were measuring torque, but you made no mention of measuring rpm. If you didn�t simultaneously measure rpm, then your torque readings are meaningless, as the tourque could have varied significantly during the test. You might have been able to get away with this if you had use something other than a frictional brake to load the motors, but with your frictional brake, you left too many additional variables in play to ensure that you could have consistent power at a given torque.

The biggest issue is that frictional forces on a V-belt are going to be higher with more heat, which implies higher rpm. If the load increases with rpm, and all you are measuring is torque, then for the same torque reading, you could have significant changes in power, especially when you periodically wetted the system. If anything, you should have used a continuous mist so that you didn�t have a varying load versus time.

I couldn�t tell from the description of your setup, but did you remove the difference in weight of each motor from your torque measurement? If I read it one way, you did, and if I read it another way, you didn�t.

Forrest, you have a sound reputation for good information in a lot of areas, so when you state something like this, people will take it as a fact without question. You drew absolute conclusions from a test that had flaws in its basis, but the average reader wouldn�t have seen this.

Re: 3 phase power?

#29

Well Rick if you think I failed to consider and

Forrest Addy

>Well Rick if you think I failed to consider and eliminate the influences you listed you must think I'm not much if an investigator. No I didn't mention RPM as both motors were running at 60 Hz and the strobotac I used ensured the motors to be identical in RPM. I even dialed in the slip on the VFD so both motors were tested at equal loaded RPM. Tedious attention to routine factors didn't seem to be called for. RPM considerations are a gimmie in casual experiments except for those who seek to pick nits. I didn't refer to Volts, Amps, power factor, and temperature either because they were extraneous to the goal of the experiment: economics of operation.

Weight of the motor affecting torque readings? Of course they can if the experimental apparatus is poorly deisgned. How would I not consider this? Since when is a proney brake anything but a glorified scale. Weight and torque readings are quite easily separated. Did I not mention calibrating the motor brake using a known lever arm and a spring scale? Do I have to mention everything in what was a essentially a unitless comparison of merit? Did I submit a formal scientific paper for a juried presentation? Did I consider I'd face an adversarial clime? No, I made what I though to be a well supported assertion assuming those knowledgeable would make the small leaps necessary to bridge the gaps.

As for the other factors I didn't discuss exhaustively, I submit you know how to procede with them as well as I do. It doesn't take a million dollars of lab equipment and a Nobel Lauriate to obtain credible data valid to two significant figures. Shop expedients will do very nicely.

Re: 3 phase power?

#30

Re: Well Rick if you think I failed to consider an

Rick Christopherson

>

Tedious attention to routine factors didn't seem to be called for.
This is the attitude that causes me to question what you do when you make your claims. For you to take such an attitude while publishing your results is irresponsible.

You dismiss engineering principles when they don�t fit your model, yet you invoke them when you want to justify your means. This is not proper testing protocols.

You are right, it doesn�t take a million dollar lab to get credible results, but your results are not credible in any event. You want to dismiss the procedure you used as not important, but that is exactly what I am calling into question.

Just like the last time you and I tangled, it was the aspects that you assumed were trivial and unrelated that actually turned out to be the significant facts that you omitted from your initial postings. Detailing these facts are what separates proper testing from backyard experiments.

Re: 3 phase power?

#31

What you suggest is almost impractable.

Forrest Addy

>What you suggest is almost impracticable. For one thing space is too limited peck out detail by exhaustive detail of every fiddling event and write a heavily nuanced exposition for what was intended to be more illutrattive and informative. The economies of partial loading VFD/motor Vs single phase motors is only about 6%; not crucial but interesting so why are we arguing the point? For another I'm computer challenged when it comes to posting photos and sketches on the web.

You are right that this is not the first time I etc. I recall another session involving "center feeding" a 460 volt connected motor of a phase conveter with 230 to combine in a single unit a step-up transformer and a rotary phase converter. You as much as accused me of reckless endangerment. As I recall you insisted such an arrangement would overheat and cause a fire. I abandoned the point rather than escalate a pointless arguement with a man whose mind was made up against me. Funny, I've built three such 230 single phase to 460 three phase converters in the past and one of them is still running in utter defiance of your direst prognostications.

Just so there no confusion in my phase converter design suggestion, the motors leads are connected for high volts that is leads 1, 2, 3 are the line and leads 7-4, 8-5, and 9-6 are connected. In my 230 to 460 converter the 230 single phase is fed to leads 7-4 and 8-5 and either 3 or 9-6 is used for the start depending on the user's preference. Once the motor is spinning, 460 converted three phase is taken from 1, 2, and 3 and doctored by means of capacitors etc to better balance. It is true this arrangement runs a trifle warmer at idle than if connected for low volts but increasing load doesn't seem to make it warmer.

Rick, I've noticed that whenever you encounter something outside of your experience "it won't work" or "insufficient" seems to pop to your lips. By arbitrary decree you condemn me for failure to follow scientific and engineering procedure. To my knowledge you've never tried to prove/disprove them by conducting a simple experiment. "I just know" has never stopped heresy, progress, or elopement.

Please understand I'm not discounting your professional qualifications and expertise in the things you know. I'm suggesting you'd rather denounce regardless of merit something out of your usual ken than try it and see. I suggest you conduct in good faith the physical experiments I proposed and report on their success or not as densely as you insist I should.

Re: 3 phase power?

#32

Re: 3 phase power?

Pierce Butler

>Don't be too quick to state that a table saw has no need for variable speed. Depending on what you do, a VS tablesaw can come in quite handy.

Re: 3 phase power?

#33

Re: 3 phase power?

Dan Donaldson

>Guess I never really thought about it for a tablesaw. What operations would you use it for? Might have to keep it in mind if I ever get a chance to buy one.

Re: 3 phase power?

#34

Re: Just to clarify

Pierce Butler

>The machine is unused. It was purchased and never wired up so what does that make it? NOS? I can't say for certain but it certainly isn't used.

Re: 3 phase power?

#35

Re: 3 phase power?

Robert Garon

>I am a registered Electrical engineer. VFD's are the way to go. Baldor makes very good ones- buy them on Ebay at a reasonable price. I have them on every major power machine in my shop.

Re: 3 phase power?

#36

Re: 3 phase power?

Steve Jenkins

>Martin,

When I moved my shop into the county I bought a rotary phase convertor since most of my machinery is 3 phase and it wasn't available at the pole. I fed a seperate 3 phase panel off the convertor and ran all my machines from it. I sized the rotary convertor to handle the largest combination of machines I might use.

Steve

Re: 3 phase power?

#37

What, Rick, abandon the cat fight?.

Forrest Addy

>I'm just as glad. The way to resolve these things is to work them out on the test bench.

Re: 3 phase power?

#38

Re: What, Rick, abandon the cat fight?.

Rick Christopherson

>It didn't seem to be going anywhere. I am not sure you understood why the information you presented was misleading, but here it is in a nutshell:

You drew a blanket generalization about a broad topic, which was based on a very limited set of circumstances, which moreover, may not have had a solid foundation to begin with. The only proper conclusion you should have drawn from that limited test was that given those two specific motors, the VFD driven motor was more cost effective when loaded at 25%. But even this conclusion is potentially flawed, because given the setup, you did not have a known and repeatable load, and you overlooked many variables.

Doing an experiment such as this for your own edification is fine, but when you publish the broad, generalized conclusion on a forum, then it becomes a problem. In order to properly draw the conclusion that you drew (for public consumption) you would have had to go through many more scenarios, such as a full range of motor loads (0-100%), additional motor sizes, and most importantly, some type of benchmark for beginning.

Consider the broad reach of the improper handling of the Fine Woodworking joint failure tests recently. You hear people repeating the data from that test all over the Internet, when the data was based on a flawed test and even more flawed conclusion. In this case, FWW rated joint strength for the various joints, when most of those joints didn�t even fail. The substrate failed outside of the joint area. The only conclusions that should have been drawn from that test were for those joints that actually failed. For those joints that failed outside of the joint area, the only thing that could be concluded is that the mechanical joint was stronger than the substrate. But instead of stating this, they put numbers to the non-failed joints. It's like getting a full-pull in a tractor pull. Once you reach a full-pull, that's it; no other measurement or number can be assigned, because the results went out of range.

Unfortunately, because they published their results, and they are well respected, now people are repeating false results as though they were scientifically factual.

Re: 3 phase power?

#39

Quote me the words you object to. I

Forrest Addy

>Quote me the words you object to. I can't seem to find them. Did something jump at you out of context? I been down that road.