That's Not Correct
Rick Christopherson
>This question hasn�t come up in a few years, so I can�t find the original supporting graphics I created years ago. Nevertheless, the simple answer is that any efficiency you may experience on the 3-phase side is lost when you convert from single phase, and that includes VFD�s.
The efficiency of 3-phase is that at any instant in time, the power output is always constant (this is the graph that I can�t find). Regardless where in the power cycle (i.e. 60 Hz cycle) if you took the current times the voltage from all three phases and added them up, they would always equal 1.5 times the peak current and voltage values. The missing graph would have shown this as a horizontal straight line across the top (as opposed to the sinusoidal-looking line shown in the graphic below).
This is the reason why converting 3-phase AC power into DC power is so efficient. You don�t even need any filtering capacitors to smooth out the resulting DC power.
On the other hand, the instantaneous single-phase power fluctuates from a peak value, down to zero, and for a short period, even goes negative due to a phase shift on motors. (This negative phase shift is not present on resistive loads, nor on AC to DC rectifiers.) This means that for a split second, the motor is giving some of its energy back into the system as the magnetic field collapses during the cycle.
The part that Forest Addy overlooked is that, yes, VFD�s are very efficient converting to DC when you give them 3-phase inputs, but when you give them single phase inputs, they suffer the same inefficiency as a single phase motor would have.
VFD Efficiency
Because the output from a VFD is a variable frequency square wave, a lot of the electrical efficiency of a 3-phase motor is lost in the square wave. The corners of the square wave are not producing work in the motor when they occur at the start of the magnetic cycle of the motor. During these periods, you would have full current flowing through the windings that was not cutting through magnetic lines of flux, and therefore, not producing any mechanical work. I don�t have a graphic for this, but if you overlaid a graph of a square wave on top of a sine wave, everything on the square wave that was outside of the sine wave would be wasted power.
Summary
A 3-phase motor is more efficient than a single phase motor, and it will run smoother. However, in terms of electrical efficiency, this efficiency is lost when the power is converted from single phase into 3-phase. While there are benefits to using 3-phase motors, electrical efficiency is not one of them when the power supply originates as single phase. The bottom line is that if you don�t have 3-phase power, then do not get 3-phase motors with the expectation that they will be more efficient, or will reduce your power bill.
