Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

3 phase power?

Posts

3 phase power?

#1

3 phase power?

Martin from Granbury

>I am considering purchasing a combination machine, but the show stopper (besides moving it) is that it needs 3-phase power.

My garage only has your normal 110 and 220 outlets.

How much of a big deal is a phase converter? How much does it cost? Is it practical to use 3 phase power without it being hard wired into your shop or garage?

I am an electrical idiot, so try to use the small words!

Re: 3 phase power?

#2

Re: 3 phase power?

john lucas

>It's not a big deal and not that expensive. Since your not into electronics you may need to find someone who can help. I did it my self but one of my friends went to the local motor repair place and payed them to install his converter. Below is a link to give you some idea of prices. These converters change 220 single phase to variable frequency 3 phase. The variable frequency gives you variable speed and maintains power at low speeds as well as sending a 3rd phase to the motor. You will have to get the controller to match your motor and that's where I'm an idiot. I bought the motor and controller as a package.

Re: 3 phase power?

#3

Re: 3 phase power?

john lucas

>

Re: 3 phase power?

#4

don't know why the link isn't working

john lucas

>www.dealerselectric.com Maybe this will work.

Re: 3 phase power?

#5

Re: 3 phase power?

Ray Thompson - Middletown,IN

>If you use a VFD it is fairly straight forward to convert 220 single phase to 220 3 phase. We have done a few machines now with good success. Variable speed probably doesn't bring much to the table with a combo machine but it's there if you want it.

Ray

Re: 3 phase power?

#6

Just to clarify

Martin from Granbury

>Ray, the machine is used...

If I was buying new, it would be single phase.

Thanks for the reply.

Re: 3 phase power?

#7

Thanks John, good link now.

Martin from Granbury

>

Re: 3 phase power?

#8

Another source *LINK*

Phil Joines Krum, Tx

>Thy recomend calling them to get the right unit.


The Surplus Center

Re: 3 phase power?

#9

High Power 3-phase

Rick Christopherson

>You did not give enough details to answer this question fully, but if it is a combination machine, then it is a good chance that it may have a higher power draw than most of the respondents here are expecting.

For motor loads below 3 hp, then the VFD is definately the most economical and versatile solution. However, if this is a multi-motor tool, then you can run into some deep complexities in running it off of a VFD.

For multi-motor applications, or for motors above 5 hp, then it is probably best to go with a rotary phase converter.

Before you take any advise from the internet, I suggest you provide some further details about the proposed tool. Even though many people consider me to be an expert on 3-phase power options, not even I have enough information to give you a solid answer to your question.

Re: 3 phase power?

#10

Re: High Power 3-phase

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>Hi Rick,

Not to try to steal the thread, but I'm looking at a Dewalt 16" radial arm saw with a 5HP 3PH motor. Just wondering about your recommendations regarding a converter. I don't see any advantage to having VFD on this tool and I know that the units for these larger motors start to get pretty pricey, thereby negating the cost savings of buying the 3PH tool.

I'm also looking at getting an older 36" bandsaw with 3PH. I may even go with a 3PH dust collector at some point. What would you advise for this situation? I don't know the HP of the bandsaw, but the dust collector I just ran into has a 7.5 HP motor.

Thanks,

Gary

Re: 3 phase power?

#11

You can run larger motors from smaller VFD's *LINK*

Forrest Addy

>You can run larger motors from smaller VFDs if you can live with the reduced power delivered. Generally these days VFDs 3 HP and smaller are furnished with diodes and filtration to run 3 HP, three-phase motors from single-phase. Naturally, a single-phase-rated 3 HP VFD can't run larger motor than their nameplate ratings. But you can lie to the VFD a little bit when you set up the parameters and get it to run larger motors, but limited to the 3 HP available.

By now you've gathered that VFD's are black boxes capable of complex things. They are, but they are not beyond the use of the average bloke son long as he either puts in a little study or finds a local mentor to walk him through their installation. Once installed they just sit there and run.

Rick rased some good points. You do need to present a little more information on your machine's electrical system before blessing is pronounced. Most of those multi-function machines are multi-motor: you select the function and start the specific motor for the saw, the shaper or the jointer/planer. If the motors are run singly, a VFD might be a good choice, provided the electrical system is rearranged a little to better suit the VFD to its installation.

If you have other three-phase machinery, you are getting beyond what a single VFD can conveniently do. There I suggest a rotary converter, which doesn't care how many motors are connected to it - or a Phase Perfect which is the all-electronic equivalent to a phase converter.

In the archives somewhere, I posted an article I wrote on the topic of VFD's and what they are and what they will and will not do.

Like it or not if you are to succeed in installing three-phase machinery in your shop, you will have to do a little studying about (cue mysterious Theramin music) industrial electrical service. Keep us posted.

I also reccommend you visit PracticalMachinist.com and look in the "hits and favorites" section, searching for "phase converters and VFDs."

Don't despair. My whole shop is single-phase and most of my equipment is three-phase run from VFDs. I have 7 at last count.


Practical Machinist

Re: 3 phase power?

#12

Here's the link to your article, Forrest:

Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach

>



Rod


Re: 3 phase power?

#13

Re: High Power 3-phase *LINK*

Rick Christopherson

>A 5 hp radial arm saw is a bit overpowered for just about anything unless you were cutting railroad ties all day long, but they sure are nice. I rebuilt an old Northfield Unipoint 18 inch, but decided to sell it after rebuilding due to limited real estate.

The most economical solution for you is a balanced static converter. This is not the same as a store-bought static converter, because those are just starters. A balanced static converter will give you nearly as much performance as a rotary converter, maybe about 80%, but more importantly would be reasonably healthy for the motor. You could build one for about $50 using surplus capacitors, or just over $100 using new.

If you later decided to get more tools and wanted a rotary converter, you could reuse the parts from the static converter and just add a motor and maybe a change in tuning capacitors.

Oh by the way, you can also take a store-bought static converter and turn it into a balanced static converter by just adding the balanced run capacitors. It is the run capacitors that are missing from these store-bought units. American Rotary not only has static converters, but they may also have kits to make them balanced (at least that�s what they were planning on doing). They also set up a parts list page so you can order all of the piece parts to build your own. When I get around to rewriting my article on phase conversion later this year, I will rebuild my old converter using parts supplied to me by American Rotary.

To get a better understanding about converters, you can read my article below. This only covers rotary and static converters, but I plan on having the new version (some day) covering VFDs and even electronic converters.


Building a Phase Converter

Re: 3 phase power?

#14

More info:

Martin from Granbury

>http://www.forums.woodnet.net/ubbthreads/showflat.php?Cat=&Number=3186833&page=2&view=collapsed&sb=5&o=

MMCU410K

I am considering purchasing this tool, but I am trying to research the advantages, drawbacks, and costs.

Re: 3 phase power?

#15

Re: 3 phase power?

Kevin Rabenaldt

>OK, I am going to ask the dumb question since I am very weak when it comes to electricity. I know that in larger motors, 3 phase power is more efficient and quite possibily is the only way to run large motors (7 or 10 HP and up??). When ;you "convert" single phase instead of getting 3 phase directly from the electrical company, what is the loss of energy and how does that convert into higher energy costs? Are we talking 10 percent? or larger?

Kevin

Re: 3 phase power?

#16

Re: More info:

Thomas S Stockton

>Martin

I saw that a few days ago and briefly thought a road trip to TX might be fun. The price is pretty amazing for that type of tool I'd do it in a heart beat if I needed it and figure out the power part afterwards. But that's just me. Looks like the older version without the tersa cutterhead but at that price a little more time setting knives would be worth it.

Tom

Re: 3 phase power?

#17

The conversion is pretty efficient

Forrest Addy

>The single phase to three phase conversion is pretty efficient. Larger VFD's (10 HP for example) are so efficient that they might pay a little tiny dividend in the power bill all by themselves given the difference slighlty better efficiency of generic three phase motors over single phase.

But there's another side to the efficiency angle. VFD's have built in econmiser software. It only feeds the motor enough juice to keep it running at setpoint. This makes no savings if the motor serves a pump or a fan or other max when on load. Driving variable loads like a machine tool is another matter but machine tool loads are variable. The motor sees max loads intermittantly for roughling cuts; the rest of the time the motor loafs along when drilling and taking finissh cuts. When the motor load drops, the VFD senses it and cuts back the motor voltage thus reducing the current and other losses saving power. The software that does this is so sneaky you never notice it in the motor's performance.

Taken altogether, a VFD/motor compared to a single phase motor will probably put money in your pocket whenever you pay the light bill. Then there is the power company's billing for three phase power. Some bill you for connected motor HP whether you need it all or not. Some require premiums from small users. Much depends on your three phase utility provider's billing rules.

Given that a VFD runs a three phase motor as smooth as if it was DC and that a single phase motors has intrinsic vibration, and given other benefits like electronic braking, infinitely cariable speed at constant shaft torque over a wide range, and the lower shop electric power cost (a couple bucks is a couple bucks), I would never ever have a single phase motor driven item of equipment in my single phase shop except for the air compressor.

Re: 3 phase power?

#18

Re: 3 phase power?

Dan Donaldson

>They are not going to be 100% efficient as nothing is, but I would guess that unless you are in a business environment where you run a lot of machines for many hours in a day, it won't make any measurable difference in your bill. Forgetting to turn off the lights would probably cost more than the losses in the single to 3 phase conversion.

Re: 3 phase power?

#19

Re: More info:

Rick Christopherson

>For the price he is asking, I wouldn't worry about the details of how you can power it until you get it. The cost of getting 3-phase power is trivial compared to the savings on the machine. It looks like a pretty good deal. If you get the machine, then you can take your time and possibly find a good deal on a used VFD or converter.

The first question you need to answer before buying is whether or not you have enough available power in your workshop. You will need a 30 amp (maybe 40 amp), 240 volt circuit in your garage to power the converter/tool. If your main load center is nearby, then the cost for adding this should be small.

Because only one motor can run at a time, you could use either a rotary converter or a VFD. A rotary converter would wire in just as though it was standard 3-phase utility power, and no modification to the machine is required. For a VFD, you would have to dissable the MiniMax's built-in motor contactor and the VFD would be used as the tool's On/Off function. (If the existing On/Off buttons are low voltage switches, then the VFD could be wired to reuse these buttons.)

If you go with a VFD, the guy brokering the deal (Pierce) can help you get the right VFD and even how to connect it. If you go with a phase converter, Pierce can still help you, but if memory serves me, he will probably try to talk you out of it. Unless I am thinking of someone else, he is kind of single-tracked when it comes to VFDs, so just know that before hand.

Re: 3 phase power?

#20

My only problem...

Martin from Granbury

>is figuring out how to move it to my garage.

Re: 3 phase power?

#21

That's Not Correct

Rick Christopherson

>This question hasn�t come up in a few years, so I can�t find the original supporting graphics I created years ago. Nevertheless, the simple answer is that any efficiency you may experience on the 3-phase side is lost when you convert from single phase, and that includes VFD�s.

The efficiency of 3-phase is that at any instant in time, the power output is always constant (this is the graph that I can�t find). Regardless where in the power cycle (i.e. 60 Hz cycle) if you took the current times the voltage from all three phases and added them up, they would always equal 1.5 times the peak current and voltage values. The missing graph would have shown this as a horizontal straight line across the top (as opposed to the sinusoidal-looking line shown in the graphic below).

This is the reason why converting 3-phase AC power into DC power is so efficient. You don�t even need any filtering capacitors to smooth out the resulting DC power.

On the other hand, the instantaneous single-phase power fluctuates from a peak value, down to zero, and for a short period, even goes negative due to a phase shift on motors. (This negative phase shift is not present on resistive loads, nor on AC to DC rectifiers.) This means that for a split second, the motor is giving some of its energy back into the system as the magnetic field collapses during the cycle.

The part that Forest Addy overlooked is that, yes, VFD�s are very efficient converting to DC when you give them 3-phase inputs, but when you give them single phase inputs, they suffer the same inefficiency as a single phase motor would have.

VFD Efficiency
Because the output from a VFD is a variable frequency square wave, a lot of the electrical efficiency of a 3-phase motor is lost in the square wave. The corners of the square wave are not producing work in the motor when they occur at the start of the magnetic cycle of the motor. During these periods, you would have full current flowing through the windings that was not cutting through magnetic lines of flux, and therefore, not producing any mechanical work. I don�t have a graphic for this, but if you overlaid a graph of a square wave on top of a sine wave, everything on the square wave that was outside of the sine wave would be wasted power.

Summary
A 3-phase motor is more efficient than a single phase motor, and it will run smoother. However, in terms of electrical efficiency, this efficiency is lost when the power is converted from single phase into 3-phase. While there are benefits to using 3-phase motors, electrical efficiency is not one of them when the power supply originates as single phase. The bottom line is that if you don�t have 3-phase power, then do not get 3-phase motors with the expectation that they will be more efficient, or will reduce your power bill.


img

Re: 3 phase power?

#22

Re: 3 phase power?

Kevin Rabenaldt

>From these two responses I take to mean that one should buy a 3 phase 3 or 5 HP tablesaw and using the converter than to buy a similar single phase motored tablesaw. This would also mean that one could pick up a used 3 phase bandsaw or jointer or whatever, buy the converter, and still come out ahead since many do not want a large 3 phase motor machine and one could get that iron cheaper.

Also, I forgot about how a utility company would charge for a 3 phase hookup. I know 3 phase power is available in commerical areas and some older residential areas but not in the new residential areas (at least were I live) without great expense.

Kevin

Re: 3 phase power?

#23

Sorry but it is. But you have to look at the

Forrest Addy

>Sorry but it is. But you have to look closely at the light bill to see the difference in efficiency but it will be there in the small dollars and cents if you run your VFD powered machinery aganst the single phase variety in HP by HP comparison. I stationed my brother in law at my light meter counting revs per minute of the little wheel both on a single phase and a three phase motor on a VFD running against the same test load. There was a slight and consistant improvement in overall electrical demand for the same mechanical load at about 25% of the rated motor HP.

Yeah, I know. I need to get out more.

Charts and graphs and theory are all well and good. They are valid tools for conceptualizing and developing finished products and I have no problem in how you use them to demonstrate your case however like all scientific endevor you have to sooner or later emulate the weatherman who checks his instrumented forecasts by looking out the window.

In the end there is the electric bill and my assertion is there is a small improvement when running three phase motors from VFD's compared to single phase motors across the line under home shop conditions. The savings is small but it is measurable.

Remember my assertions had to do with low duty cycle loads not full loads. I can't determine with my bro in law and stopwatch method if there is a difference at full load. If there is a difference it's lost in the statistical uncertaintly of small percents. That's why I reccommend a single phase motor across the line for compressors in single phase shops.

Re: 3 phase power?

#24

Re: 3 phase power?

Dan Donaldson

>At the moment, I don't have any 3 phase equipment, and for something like a tablesaw which has no use for variable speed, I would probably stick with single phase. However, if I was looking for used iron, or items that would benefit from variable speed, I would not look away if it were 3 phase. Even with a tablesaw, if I found a great deal on a saw, and the only thing "wrong" with it is that it was 3 phase, I don't think that would be a deal killer.

Re: 3 phase power?

#25

Look Ma! Free Energy!

Rick Christopherson

>


Charts and graphs and theory are all well and good. They are valid tools for conceptualizing and developing finished products and I have no problem in how you use them to demonstrate your case however like all scientific endevor you have to sooner or later emulate the weatherman who checks his instrumented forecasts by looking out the window.

Nothing gets my hackles up faster than when someone dismisses engineering principles on no other basis than they don�t understand them. Do you think your VFD's were designed by seat-of-the-pants tinkering, or by engineering principles? If you are going to come out and make statements that contravene electrical principles, then you need to take greater care with your �experiments� to remove unknown variables in your tinkering. Your results may have proven something in your mind, and for that I couldn't care less, but when you present this information to others; then I care.

Surely by now you must have come to realize that the only time you and I tangle is when you present your seat-of-the-pants tinkering to others as though it were factual. If memory serves me, the last time this happened was also related to 3-phase power generation, and you later addmitted that you hadn't actually tried the method you presented to others as fact.



  • First off, any change in efficiency would be so minor that you wouldn�t have detected it by looking at the dial on a residential watt meter. The change in efficiency between a single phase and 3-phase motor is so minor that you would have needed to observe the spinning dial for days before you could see results. Did you happen to disable all other loads on the system first?

  • Secondly, you didn�t have a baseline, or control, for your experiment. You compared two different motors without determining if they were in fact comparable in all other regards except for their phase before beginning. For example, if both motors were delivering 1-horsepower at their outputs, but one motor was rated at 3.9 hp and the other at 4.0 hp, then the smaller motor is actually more efficient in converting real power into work than the larger motor due to an increase in powerfactor. So explain how you elimiated the individual percent-loading of each motor from your experiments? Did you measure the powerfactor of each motor, and if so, how did you account for this in your results?

  • Most important of all, is that you did not send someone out to look at the dial of a residential watt meter with the motors running at 25% load! This I know for a fact, because a residential watt meter does not account for powerfactor, and a motor running at only 25% load has an extremely low powerfactor. Whereas a VFD has a high powerfactor. In other words, the current flowing into the motor (via using an ammeter) would be very high, but according to the watt meter, almost no power is being consumed, so at a low powerfacter, any motor will be more cost effective on utility power versus a VFD, and that includes 3-phase too.

    If you are claiming that you could see an appreciable difference between the two, then it is my belief that you falsified your results and actually used an ammeter and not a power meter like you stated. Either that, or you have an industrial VA meter which penalizes low powerfactor loads. In either event, it is not the same as power consumption on a residential power meter. To say otherwise is to mislead the people that are reading this discussion.

    Even though industrial facilities get penalized for running low powerfactors, hence the common discussions on how VFD�s are cheaper, residential customers do not get penalized. It is therefore a whole lot cheaper for residential customers to use high reactive loads, such as keeping their motors well below rated output power.

  • Most important of all is that nothing is free, and nothing is 100% efficient. If your VFD�s are running at 100% efficiency, then you are first in line for the Nobel Prize. And oh, by the way, you may as well cut the wires on the cooling fan inside your VFD, because if it is running so efficient, then it must not be generating any heat, so surely it doesn�t need to be cooled, because the heat generated inside the VFD is a consumption of real power, and this would be detected by a residential watt meter.

Your posting is reminiscent of the discussions on Mythbusters where viewers were claiming that you can get free energy by connecting a battery charger to a motor and sending power back into the power supply running the motor. The only time you can convert power and come out ahead is if you live in the backwoods, dismiss scientific knowledge, and create �experiments� that overlook sound testing principles. For your assertions to be true, the difference in efficiency between a single phase motor and a 3-phase motor would have to be high enough to offset the power consumption of the VFD, and the additional inefficiencies of sending square wave power into a sinusoidal load.

So if you�ve found some way to create free energy, then great, more power to you, but don't put misinformation into the minds of the readers of this forum.