Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

Workbench top / new shop space

Posts

Workbench top / new shop space

#1

Workbench top / new shop space

Mike Schwing from Md.

>Hi guys.

I'm building out a small workspace in a corner of my basement and am looking for some suggestions/advice on the workbench tops. I'll need two, both 96" x 30". The supporting structure I've got covered.

This is not to be my real "shop", ground is yet to have been broken on that, but a temporary space that will stay in place permanently just the same.

Obvious preference for benchtop material would be laminated maple, but I just can't bring myself to spend upwards of $500 on bench tops for this project. The cheapest I can find what I'm looking for is at Grizzly but including shipping thats just too much $$$

Secondarily I'm considering doubling up on 3/4" plywood, and finishing it off with Formica for durability. I was happy with this sort of a bench top in my previous house, but someone brought up a point about Formica being too hard and it would/could ding/burnish projects, something I'd not considered nor experienced. Others have suggested simply leaving the faced side of plywood exposed and wrapping the corners in a hardwood. I'm a little concerned about durability of the exposed face in such a situation.

What do you think? What would you do? Thanks in advance for your help.

Re: Workbench top / new shop space

#2

Re: Workbench top / new shop space

Mark Mcc

>I have the double plyuwood topped with 1/4" hard board. I wouldnt use formica or a laminate as it would be too slippery I would think. I edge treated mine in 1 x 3 maple. I use it as a secondary ( mostly junk collection) bench.

Sturdy and no worries about dings etc. Plus its cheap and easy to replace the top when (I dount it ever will) become damaged or unsightly.

Re: Workbench top / new shop space

#3

Re: Workbench top / new shop space

Ron Hildreth, Alta, Iowa

>Would something like an old recycled solid core door work? Could probably pick one up pretty cheap.

Ron in Iwa

Re: Workbench top / new shop space

#4

For what will turn into " all-round " bench . . .

s.mackay@worldnet.att.net

>I went with that Melamine (sp?). That white stuff from HD. NUTH'N sticks to it or won't clean off it ! I can use it as a " surface plate " for glue ups and " tap-tap " it loose then just scrape off whats on the surface. Paint don't stick. And its ten feet of FLAT-ness I've come to count on. AND . . . did I mention the best part ? NUTH'N sticks to it !

Re: Workbench top / new shop space

#5

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Re: Workbench top / new shop space

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

>My main workbench top is three layers of �" plywood laminated to make a 2�" thick top, and wrapped in oak. I left the ply face - no other covering - and sealed it with whatever varnish I had on hand at the time (probably Varathane), knowing that it was going to get badly dinged over time.

It's about ten years old now, and is definitely dinged up, having been hammered on, sawn on, chiseled one, etc.

I've also drilled into it and installed threaded inserts as hold-downs for various tools and jigs - something I would have never even considered with an expensive maple top.

The ply surface has held up amazingly well. I've yet to wear through the face veneer, which has pleasantly surprised me, in spite of running a #80 scraper over it a couple times.

I will say that, when I do need to replace it, I'll revert to tradition and probably use maple - or maybe cherry - for a new top. That's actually an economic decision, though, since I now live in an area where I can get maple or cherry for about $3.00 a board foot instead of the $8.00 or $9.00 it would have cost me in California. I figure I can build a new maple top now - at 30" X 96" and 2" thick - for under $150.00. That's only about 50% more than two sheets of decent plywood and the edge banding would cost...

Jim D.

Re: Workbench top / new shop space

#6

Re: Workbench top / new shop space

David

>Mike,

I bought a couple of seconds from Bally block a couple of years ago. Mine are 60 x 30 x 2 1/4. Obviously not long enough for you but three of them comes pretty close. I can't remember what I paid exactly, but it was less than $50 each (actually I think it was about $60 for the two.) Factory in PA.

Re: Workbench top / new shop space

#7

Re: Workbench top / new shop space *LINK*

fred in ct

>i used a $59 laminated countertop from IKEA along with 2 layers of 3/4" mdf for my work bench.i would do the same thing again if i had to.sorry for the poor picture.


img

http://www.ikea.com/us/en/catalog/products/1005776

Re: Workbench top / new shop space

#8

salvaged bowling lane

JKJ in East TN

>Mike,

Salvaged bowling lanes make excellent and sturdy workbench tops. The one I have was a freebee, but I see some offered through Mr Google's "bowling lane salvage" glasses.

It should be fairly quick to build a laminated top. I bought some 2x12 rough cut KD hard maple once (about $2/bd ft) that I'm saving to build work surfaces for my new shop. I still have one I made 35 years ago, held together with resin glue and a couple of embedded 3/8" threaded rod.

I have another workbench top I made very quickly by fastening a piece of 3/4" MDF to a sturdy frame made from 2x4 lumber (laid flat) with plenty of cross support. A thinner layer of MDF on top could be replaced easily if it becomes badly worn. (I do this with my radial arm saw, tacking it down with brads and replacing it as needed.)

JKJ

Re: Workbench top / new shop space

#9

Re: Workbench top / new shop space

Mike Schwing from Md.

>Hey that Ikea idea looks like a winner. They have 96" lengths, too. I'd still put a layer or two of plywood underneath but having a solid wood laminate on top will make me happier than ply veneer or Formica.

Thanks!

(thanks everybody else, too, keep'm coming)

Re: Workbench top / new shop space

#10

2 3/4" plywood and 1 1/4" hardboard

Rich Schneider

>Marc has exactly what I used on all my shop cabinet tops, 2 3/4" plywood sheets glued and screwed with a 1/4 hardboard top simply brad nailed on and the whole works wrapped with hardwood. I had added an additional 1-1/2 frame one the underside for my cabinets, but the 2 3/4 sheets are plently strong alone. This setup allows you to change out the 1/4 smooth hardboard if it gets damaged or crappy looking. Plus you can simply treat the hardboard with tung oil so any glue drops will flick right off.

Re: Workbench top / new shop space

#11

Re: Workbench top / new shop space

Paul Dwight

>A post over at sawmillcreek.org described a benchtop made of "edgegrain" plywood. The guy ripped 3/4" baltic birch plywood into strips and face-glued them together so the edge plys were facing up. He sealed the surface by saturating the top with slow-set epoxy. He said it made a strong, stable and hard work surface.

I believe Jim Tolpin's "The Workbench Book" described a similar benchtop. The gentleman featured in that article had a cabinet shop, IIRC, and built the entire top from scraps of sheet goods he had laying around.

I haven't built a benchtop like this yet, but I probably will. Seems to me that the edgegrain plywood would be harder and more durable than the plywood face grain. I also like the idea of being able to make the top as thick as I want. Finally, the finished top ought to be very stable and resistant to sagging over unsupported sections.

Anyway, it's another option. -- Paul

Re: Workbench top / new shop space

#12

Re: Workbench top / new shop space

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>The key syllable in workbench is "work", so why shouldn't the top be something you're not afraid to work on. If the base is stable, 2x's on the flat with 3/4 ply screwed down on top is all that's needed. The ply can be swapped out when its too beat up, and there's no agony to drill a hole to seat a dog or holdown. My 32x85 2x/ply top serves perfectly.

Clint

Re: Workbench top / new shop space

#13

Norm's shop jig feet.............

MountainMan

>Did you happen to catch Norm Abrams show on building shop jig helpers?? He made a nice set of rollers on a stand to help stabilize wood comming off of a table say... Anyway, he used some sort of laminated 4/4 or 6/4 X 10 or 12 feet long (construction lumber)as legs and feet. Said it was expensive - but looking at the edge of the laminations, they appeared not to have any voids that you might see on a plywood glue-up... Lots stronger - I'd say...Would make a nice looking and durable work table top...

Regards

The MountainMan

Re: Workbench top / new shop space

#14

Re: Workbench top / new shop space

Dave Bair, Eaton Rapids, MI

>I built mine out of "wormy" soft maple...@ $1.20 per BF it was very cheap at my lumber supplier. It dings up easily but I don't have to worry about damaging my work on it. It only cost me $120, though I had to machine, laminate and finish it myself (part of the fun) and there was a lot of waste. But it's 3" thick and weighs over 200 lbs.

Re: Workbench top / new shop space

#15

18 years ago a neighbor who was moving gave me....

Art Silva

>a 32 x 96, mahogany veneered flush door. I figured it would make a decent table for layout and assembly work. That idea changed when I tried to pick it up. Heavy only goes a short way in describing my surprise. My neighbor was into a major giggle. A brass tag on the hinge edge identified it as a product of the Brooklyn Fire Door Co, which meant that the weight was caused by a 2" thick plaster core. I built a frame out of 2x4 stock, installed four locking castors, and covered the door with 1/2" MDF and edged it with 1/2" thick mahogany. I routed two slots to match the miter slots in my table saw, and this has been my workbench/outfeed table for 18 years. It has been a flat surface for glue-ups and whatever. Four years ago I turned the MDF over and swapped it end for end and routed new slots. I have just finished building the first traditional workbench I have ever had, and it will appear in Shop Shots soon, but my outfeed table is still anchored to my Unisaw waiting to take as much use and abuse that I can give it. Good luck.

Re: Workbench top / new shop space

#16

Why not a torsion box? *LINK*

Brian in Sandusky, OH

>A torsion box made of 1/2" or 3/4" MDF would be lighter, just as sturdy, and more resistant to warping than anything solid.

It would, however, be a bit more work.

I built a Festool MFT out of a torsion box concept, and I would never do it again any differently.


Homemade MFT

Re: Workbench top / new shop space

#17

Re: Workbench top / new shop space

Jim Dillon

>Mike,

Wow, you sure got a lot of good responses for building very practical, usable bench tops. I went the route of a torsion box made from 2 x 4s about 2 x 6 feet in size. Top and bottom was 1/2 inch plywood. Then surrounded the whole thing with 2 x 6s made even to the bottom of the torsion box. This left room for 2 pieces of 3/4 inch MDF cut to fit into the "basin". This has worked well for me and the top is replacable. Good luck.

Jim

Re: Workbench top / new shop space

#18

Re: Workbench top / new shop space

les winter

>Hi Mike.

Your question triggered a memory of a Michael Dunbar bench from FWW. If you do your banging and vise hanging on the front of the bench, then a 4" high by 6" deep timber glued to the edge of a solid core door (Dunbar used plywood if I remember correctly) and you are good to go. I use Masonite solid core doors for my desk, over saw horses. Solid as a house. Inexpensive too.

Good luck.

Les

Re: Workbench top / new shop space

#19

Re: Workbench top / new shop space

Francisco

>In a decoration magazine I saw recently a kitchen top made from layers of hardwood flooring (Hard Maple), each layer going in diferent direction,so the final look is a nice surface, with nice grain on top and a colorfull and rich edge area....it could be another wise and low cost option for benchtop building, but a good veneer press could be needed....I considered this particularly for my workbench project but finally I went for the real rock maple.