Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

Contractor Saw DC IDEA

Posts

Contractor Saw DC IDEA

#1

Contractor Saw DC IDEA

Tom Norton

>I recently posted a note asking about the difference between a contractor saw and a Unisaw. I understand that the Uni being an enclosed base, basically a plenum, makes it more effecient at DC.

I had an idea that I would like some feedback on.

What if I added a box enclosure that surrounded the motor, filled the gaps where the top meets the sides, and then connected a 4-5" duct through the side of the metal side for DC?

I would basically have a large plenum.

So...?

Re: Contractor Saw DC IDEA

#2

JL

Re: Contractor Saw DC IDEA

JL

>I have a similar set up on my old Sears contractor saw.

I mounted a 4" hood in the base of the saw. As the motor hangs off of the back in mine, I blocked off everything except where the belt is. It isn't the prettiest, but it gets most of the sawdust.

The only sawdust that I usually have to worry about is what the blade slings out.

Re: Contractor Saw DC IDEA

#3

Re: Contractor Saw DC IDEA

Larry in NW Ohio

>Tom in my oppinion the best place on a saw for dust pick up is right under the blade. That is where all the dust is coming from. Larry in Ohio

Re: Contractor Saw DC IDEA

#4

above the blade

john lucas

>I think the best place is above the blade. I built an enclosure around my Powermatic contractors style saw. It works pretty well but I have still lose a fair amount of air around the belt drive. I didn't enclose the motor. I jury rigged a hose to hang directly above the blade and most of my dust was gone. Unfortunately that system was in the way of other things that go on in my shop so I'm currently planning on building one of the overarm dust collector parallelgram blade guard systems. I think that's the way to go.

Re: Contractor Saw DC IDEA

#5

Re: above the blade

Tom Norton

>John,

I have a over head pick up and it does catch a lot. But I see so much floating out the back side. I also have it on a base with a drawer underneath.

Re: Contractor Saw DC IDEA

#6

Re: Contractor Saw DC IDEA

Marv

>Most of the sawdust is projected downward. What if you mounted a funnel type device below the blade toward the front or directly below? If you had enough sunction, you would catch most of the dust. Make the funnel device with as small an opening as you can, that way you will create more of a ventorie efect, increasing the velocity of the airflow past the blade where most of the sawdust is generated. My main problem has always been small strips and pieces of wood that drop down and begin to plug up the funnel.

Marv

Re: Contractor Saw DC IDEA

#7

Re: I'm not sure what you're up to...

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>Are you looking to buy a new saw, and not drop $2k?

There was an older edition of PopWood in the 'personal library' this morning, and a quick review of one of Steel City's cabinet saws was in it. $899 with a 1.5 hp, $999 with a 3 hp, IIRC. Cabinet saw, enclosed base, well regarded by the named editorial endorser, who often drops by these parts...

Dust collection wouldn't be a pain or a long extra project, and the extra $1k could be directed elsewhere.

Re: Contractor Saw DC IDEA

#8

Been there, done that

Steve Wilson

>and it wasn't really worth it. Even American style cabinet saws are very anemic at dust collection. To be useful you need to collect dust from the top of the saw and the cabinet. To collect in the cabinet you need to shroud the blade and run hose right up to the shroud, which is how European combination machines, Sliding Tablesaws, and some of the newer American style cabinet saws are designed (Saw Stop IIRC). At best, some dust and chips will be thrown out of the cabinet, some will make it into your DC fittings but only if you run a fairly substantial DC unit. An aftermarket blade guard with DC capabilities will do a fairly good job at collecting dust if you give it enough CFM.

Re: Contractor Saw DC IDEA

#9

Re: Contractor Saw DC IDEA

Chuck Lenz

>These are the mods I built, I also closed the gap between the top and the cabinet with closed cell foam and covered the bevel gauge slot in the front of the cabinet with a piece of magnetic sign material


img

Re: Contractor Saw DC IDEA

#10

Re: Contractor Saw DC IDEA 

Chuck Lenz

>


img

Re: Contractor Saw DC IDEA

#11

Re: Contractor Saw DC IDEA

Chuck Lenz

>

Re: Contractor Saw DC IDEA

#12

Re: Contractor Saw DC IDEA 

Chuck Lenz

>


img

Re: Contractor Saw DC IDEA

#13

Re: Contractor Saw DC IDEA

Chuck Lenz

>And it all works at any blade angle without fussing with anything at the back of the saw.

Re: Contractor Saw DC IDEA

#14

Re: above the blade

john lucas

>I agree, I think you need both sides to capture as much as possible.

Re: Contractor Saw DC IDEA

#15

CS Dust Collection

Howard Acheson

>Keep in mind that you must have at least the same number of square inches of air intake as you have for the exhuast port. Dust collection is air flow (CFM), not suction. If you totally seal up a sawbox, you will have no CFM.

Re: Contractor Saw DC IDEA

#16

Re: CS Dust Collection

Chuck Lenz

>Yeah I dunno Howard, I've posted my setup before and not many get it. I'm just to the point that either they get it or they don't get it. I wasn't even sure that I wanted to post it again. Tired of explaining. I've allready got more time just into the design than you can imagine and haven't made a dime.

Re: Contractor Saw DC IDEA

#17

Re: Contractor Saw DC IDEA

Barry Irby

>I have an older Rockwell/Delta contractors saw and built a chute that wraps around the blade. I also added brushes under the table insert that seal off more of the gap. It gets about 98% of what goes under the table except for the part that the blade slings out the top. I am thinking of an over the blade pickup. Thinking and thinking. Like some others, I don't want the clutter in my too small shop.

Chuck's setup is certainly simpler and easier to fabricate that mine. I imagine it is nearly as effective. If I were doing it over, I might do it that way.

One thing I did do is bring the DC hose out the front. I use the blast gates that have the micro switches on the doors that turn the DC on. The gate is handy and near the switch for the saw.

I have some pictures if you are interested, but I have posted them before, they may be archived somewhere.

From the standpoint of your health, it is more important that you collect the very fine dust. The coarse stuff you can see really has little effect on your health. So an over the blade pick up might be a really good Idea.

Re: Contractor Saw DC IDEA

#18

Re: Contractor Saw DC IDEA

Chuck Lenz

>Don't bet on mine being simpler to fabricate. The dust chute is harder than you think.

Re: Contractor Saw DC IDEA

#19

Re: Contractor Saw DC IDEA

Chuck Lenz

>After working on my modifications, seeing others modifications, and reading alot of peoples replies about DC modifications on these types of saws. I get the impression that the general public feels that if even if NASA engineers researched it for 100 years and came up with a design, still nobody would be sold on the idea, just because IT's A CONTRACTOR's SAW ! I really find it troubleing.

Re: Contractor Saw DC IDEA

#20

Re: Contractor Saw DC IDEA

Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL

>Well folks, I have an old Craftsman. I put a piece of plywood across the bottom with a 4" dust port in the middle. I have a piece of pegboard across the motor/belt opening.

I have a 1800cfm ClearVue, and when I run it with the table saw, you can cut wood for an hour, and not have 4 Tablespoons of dust in the whole interior. The only real dust I get, is off the back of the TS blade hitting the wood, and I intend to cure that with an blade guard hose as well (got to make that some day.

As someone above said: you have to have air flow - too little is as bad as too much.

As soon as I move my whole system to 6" ducting, I will change the TS as well. Try and get those last 4 tablespoons of dust.

Mark

Re: Contractor Saw DC IDEA

#21

Re: Contractor Saw DC IDEA

Barry Irby

>When I started my DC system I tried to do it on the cheap. I had a single car garage full of tools and no DC at all. I threw down the gauntlet and said to myself "If I can buy a 1300 CFM unit from Delta for under $300 I will do this DC thing". Soon after WoodCraft put them on sale for $299 and knocked off 10% for my birthday. The challenge was on.

They did not have the unit in stock. At the time they sold for about $360 and when they hit $299 they got snapped up. So while mine was on order I built an exterior closet for it and started working on the TS. Since it was a Contractor's saw, I figured it would be the hardest of my tools. I looked at the bottom tray thing like Mark did and thought "Too Easy", got to be a better (harder) way. So I built cardboard mock ups of a chute that would replace the little half chute that came in the saw that directed the dust straight down. Then I made two metal versions. The final one is mounted on the saw arbor and is stationary in a vertical sense, but angles with the blade. The blade can tilt a full forty five. As I mentioned, the hose comes out the front and the blast gate that turns the DC on are right at the saw's switch. The lower portion of the chute is hinged so that the hose does not crash into the legs of the saw when you tilt the arbor.

I with Mark and Chuck. I think I over thunck it. I have gotten it down to the point you can't weigh what falls out the bottom on a postal scale (Ripped a two by four eight feet Long for that test.) What I need now is an over the blade pick up. Way more comes off the top than the bottom.

I have finally gotten to read some of Bill Pentz's site. (Go there now). I should be more concerned with the micro fine dust. Not sure Any DC system will ever be perfect on a shop wide basis. I did not even try to put DC on my lathe. It throws more crap in a minute and the TS throws in a week, literlally. I still have hand tools and portable power tools that don't have DC.

What I am trying to say is to read the parts of Bill's site about creating suction toward the tool and away from the the operator so that the micro fine stuff is drawn into the DC and away from you. If an occasional big hunk escapes, Hey! shops are messy and there will be clean up, but you will not inhale anything you can see. The point is to keep the AIR clean. I doubt you will be snorting the dust off the horizontal surfaces.

Yesterday, a neighbor used my RAS. It has a chute behind it that catches the dust. How do I know it works? He opened the blast gate and cut a 1 X 6 about eight times. He was a happy wood worker. Then he decided to make one more cut and forgot the blast gate. You should have seen his face screw up and watched as he twisted away from the cloud of dust. And to think I used to cut with it all the time like that.

Re: Contractor Saw DC IDEA

#22

Re: CS Dust Collection

Phil Thien

>Chuck, when you're explaining to woodworkers you have to act like you're explaining something to my mom. That is, you have to look her straight in the face and tell her ten times.

Don't give up. Eventually people will get it.

Re: Contractor Saw DC IDEA

#23

Re: CS Dust Collection

Chuck Lenz

>Thanks for the pep talk Phil. I just can't figure out why some people would think the the generic plastic dust hood would work just as good. I had the generic plastic hood, I know it doesn't work as good.