Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

Woodworking Physics Lesson

Posts

Woodworking Physics Lesson

#1

Woodworking Physics Lesson

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>After years of research I have concluded that glue (any type) has the ability to change the physical nature of wood...sometimes quite a bit.

My research is based upon the phenomenon I observe during complex glue-ups of projects. I will dry fit test an assembly...sometimes more than once, and everything will come together quite nicely. I will prepare myself with open clamps and even rehearse the clamping so I know just how the clamps need to be applied. Then, when totally ready, I apply the glue and proceed with the glue up.

This is where, before my very eyes, the same assembly that fit together beautifully 20 minutes earlier now cannot possibly seem to come together without frantic pounding with a mallet and tremendous torquing of the clamp handles....along with a mad dash for more and more clamps.

Explanation? There appears to be no obvious explanation other than changes occurring at the sub-atomic level....or Murphy's Law....or both.

Tom

Re: Woodworking Physics Lesson

#2

Re: Woodworking Physics Lesson

Dave Mount

>Morning Tom--

The reason is not so exotic. Moisture in the glue swells the wood and changes the fit between dry fitting and the real glue-up. Second factor is that as soon as you put the glued surfaces together, some degree of adhesion starts. When you're dry fitting, you can go back and tap everything home long after you first put tab A in slot B with no change in resistance. If you're gluing and you slide two pieces together most, but not all of the way, it's much more difficult to go back later and move the joint together that last little bit to close it.

Tip: Do big assemblies in stages. Go ahead and glue some of the joints, but not all, then dry assemble the rest of the assembly (this makes sure that the glued joints are in the right orientation as they set). After the initial set on those you glued, disassemble and reglue the rest of the piece (or another portion of it).

Best,

Dave, who has been in the position of wishing he had followed his own advice. . .

Re: Woodworking Physics Lesson

#3

Re: Woodworking Physics Lesson

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>Dave,

This is waaaaay beyond moisture! I'm talking about parts changing sizes, mortises moving to new locations, parts changing thicknesses, and in general a complete morphing of every component.

And of course my post is issued in jest!

Tom

Re: Woodworking Physics Lesson

#4

Re: Woodworking Physics Lesson

Bill White

>And don't forget to get the spare arms and hands out of the closet. They are the one that you really need for the complex stuff.

Bill

Re: Woodworking Physics Lesson

#5

Re: Sorry, my bad. . .

Dave Mount

>Sorry Tom -- must be too early. I thought that was a funny question coming from you. Nothing wrecks a good joke like some numbnut that doesn't realize it's a joke.

If you're talking about *that* kind of morphing, I do know what you mean. Just last weekend, I was putting a recess into a box to serve as a fingerhold to open to lid. After I'd finished, I realized that somehow Skaggs law had caused the box front and back to mysteriously transpose, and I had just finished carving the lid lift in the back side of the box. . .

Best,

Dave

Re: Woodworking Physics Lesson

#6

Can an Octopus be trained....

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>...to be a shop assistant? ;-)

T.

Re: Woodworking Physics Lesson

#7

Yes! Exactly!

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>Dave, no harm no foul. NOW you know what I'm getting at! :-) As you referred to...those moments where the glue is applied, the parts are trying to fit together and you suddenly start questioning if they are actually the same parts you just successfully fit together just an hour ago???

It has to be a sub-atomic thing, I swear!

Tommy

Re: Woodworking Physics Lesson

#8

I would think so...

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>I once saw a Nova program in which an octopus screwed the top off a Mason jar to get a fish inside it.

bruce

Re: Woodworking Physics Lesson

#9

Most Recent Research Shows

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>that wood indeed has memory, Tommy.

We've both seen a glued-up curved lamination spring back slightly once the clamps are removed from the form. The degree of springback differs, but is an important clue in the subject of wood movement. The wood cells remember how nice everything was up until the time when they were attacked with sharp objects, buzz and band saws, and beaten into submission. And the only reward would be to be covered by foul smelling toxic goo/liquid later on. Naturally, the wood movement you complain about during glue up is wood's natural retaliation. It is P.O.ed It is getting back at you. To complain about it is, well..........like de-barking up the wrong tree. :<)

George

Re: Woodworking Physics Lesson

#10

Wrong Subject!

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>Good Morning Colonel,

You are right! I've been looking at it all wrong. This is not a phyisics problem, this is a biology problem!

Thank you for scientifically enlightening me. ;-)

Tom

Re: Woodworking Physics Lesson

#11

Re: Woodworking Physics Lesson

Don Pierson

>Rather than doing a dry fit before final assembly you might try dampening the joints with a wet cloth, spray, or wet brush. If the parts go together moist I would think they have a better chance going together with glue. I have not tried this so it is just a thought on my part. While moisture may not be the only factor I would guess it the major factor.

Re: Woodworking Physics Lesson

#12

Use detergent to remove the dirt....

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>There was a good thread here last week on the subject. But for some reason my response went largely unnoticed. What a shame.

I'm sure that it's the dirt in the wood, not on the surface but right IN the wood, that not only makes it brittle and prone to cracking, but also causes these problems.

I mentioned that it's a little like rust. How easy it is to just snap off a pickup truck's bumper when it's rusty. Use a little detergent to remove the rust, and once the rust is gone, so is the problem bumper.... literally ;)

So if dirt and rust causes things to become brittle, using detergent on the wood, especially prior to turning the wood, improves it dramaitcally. Forget all the polymer chemical atoms altering the strucutre of the wood fibers. It's just plain dirt that makes the wood brittle. Clean it with detergent and it's not brittle anymore. No more cracks.

This is EXACTLY the same thing during glue ups. Have you ever tried to assemble a rusty shaft or axle on a car? Motorbike? Lawnmower? Darn rusty thing never fits. But if you remove the rust..... CLEAN off the rust, and it fits well. Clean off the dirt and it also fits well.

So the problem that both you and I have during glue ups, is that the dirt interferes with it and it no longer fits. It's the dirt I tell you.

Have you ever seen Scoth tape residue on a surface? Or duct tape residue? The sticky stuff. See how quickly that attracts dirt? THe glue is sticky too, isn't it? So the glue attracts the dirt. And the dirt, like rust, causes things not to fit.

So to solve you problem, you must use detergent, not glue, on your wood projects.

No, no, no... don't thank me. It's my pleasure.

Happy Woodworking!

Re: Woodworking Physics Lesson

#13

Re: Yes! - Hey, I've even had the grain

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>change direction. I KNOW I matched the panels up so they looked good together and the cathedrals were all going the same direction. Then just about the time the tenons locked into the mortise's - THEY CHANGED Direction!!

Re: Woodworking Physics Lesson

#14

Re: Use detergent to remove the dirt.... *LINK*

Bill Hammond, Oregon Coast

>>>> I mentioned that it's a little like rust.

Hey, I just read that you can remove rust by electrolysis, perhaps if you can both remove that dirty rust (or is that rusty dirt?) and shock the wood into submission.


Electrolytic Rust Removal

Re: Woodworking Physics Lesson

#15

Re: Use detergent to remove the dirt....

Bill White

>Totally out of hand.....I think that I will start freezing all the "male" components, and putting all the "female" components in a heated oven. Works on all British motorcycles. Don't see why it wouldn't work on my wood projects. Whaddayathink?

Bill

Re: Woodworking Physics Lesson

#16

YOU REALLY NEED TO

Ken Oakley-Sunny St. Cloud, Fla.

>run for some Federal Government elected office. You already have the experience as to how things are going to work so you could really keep the nation on the right path from the GITGO. You have my vote

Re: Woodworking Physics Lesson

#17

Fastest Indian.......

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>Yes, good idea. Reminds me of the movie The Fastest Indian.

Except he was a New Zealander, not British, and he was building/racing American motorbikes, not British, bikes.

But it reminded me of the movie, never the less.

Happy Woodworking!

Re: Woodworking Physics Lesson

#18

Re: Woodworking Physics Lesson

Jesse in New Mexico

>You got it Tommy! I thought that only happened to me!!

Titebond and the others should put a warning label on the glue bottles

"Caution, this product may move your mortises and change the grain direction if used according to directions."

Re: Woodworking Physics Lesson

#19

Re: Woodworking Physics Lesson

Larry in NW Ohio

>The same thing happens to me also. A few years agomI made a baby bed for our first grandchild. I put it all together at home after finising, and left it set a couple days, some people wanted to look at it. Ok after a few days it still looked great. So I took it apart and marked EVERY piece so everything would go into the same hole, I even put screws into all places the were supposeto go. I did this with the changing table that went with it. I loaded it all in the car, since it was to go 700 miles west to Kansas City. So my son and I drove to my sons house, got everything out and when they went to work the next day my som and I began to put things together. If I ever get ahold of the person that changed my markings I`m going to do something to them not nice. I don`t think anything went in the same place. No amount of beatting,redrilling or cussing helped at all. Butr we finally got it together and everything finally worked. I just don`t know what happened. Must have something to do with crossing the Mississippi and the Missouri Rivers. Larry in Ohio

Re: Woodworking Physics Lesson

#20

Solution to all 'fit' problems.

Basil

>A bigger hammer.

Hey, it worked on heavy equipment.

Re: Woodworking Physics Lesson

#21

Re: Woodworking Physics Lesson *LINK*

Jim Dillon

>Thomas,

All (yes, all!) of your observations can be readily explained by Maxwell's Demon. Just in case you didn't know (or, agast, had never heard of this woodworking "helper"), Maxwell's Demon resides in all woodworking joints, but sometimes wanders about looking for other ways to lend assistance. How does he (assuming it is a "he") accomplish this you might ask. Simple. He decreases the entropy of the joint, grain orientation, tenon size, mortise size, any perfect dry-fit joint etc. Thermodynamically speaking, this doesn't make sense, but who can argue with your direct observation of his "presence" at work. And for you naysayers out there (Mark G.?), I've included a link that fills in the gaps here and there.


Maxwellian Demon

Re: Woodworking Physics Lesson

#22

Tommy, Tommy, Tommy!

Joanne Adler in Pt. Pleasant, PA

>It's not the parts changing on you, it's your wife sneaking in, when you aren't looking, to swap the parts out for ones that don't fit. She's trying to remind you to take a break every so often, to take her out to dinner, a movie, a museum, or just "visit" with her. Without a pencil and paper and layout in your hand. She can only be a saint for just so long. ;-)

Re: Woodworking Physics Lesson

#23

You gotta think bigger.....

Terry Alexander

>For example.....I have on my desk a beautiful pen an pencil holder. To describe it best, it is 3 pieces of 1" stock, 3" wide and 4" tall. I have glued 4 of these together and drilled 9 holes in the top to hole 9 pens or pencils.

HOWEVER....this project started off as a gun cabinet ;-)

Terry Alexander....no job is finished until the blood is spilled!

Re: Woodworking Physics Lesson

#24

I Knew It!

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>That certainly explains it! Demons...and quantum physical ones to boot! It just had to be. Now I can sleep tonight....or can I? ;-)

Tommy

Re: Woodworking Physics Lesson

#25

Re: Woodworking Physics Lesson

Peter Leach

>Are you familiar with the Portanailer? Possibly not - well it is an ingenious tool designed for nailing tongue-and-groove flooring. It comes with a big BIG hammer with one steel face and one large rubber face. I simply show this hammer to the piece to be assembled, and if that fails to have the desired effect I USE it!