Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Home Depot Made Another Lasting Impression

Posts

Home Depot Made Another Lasting Impression

#1

Home Depot Made Another Lasting Impression

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Evening Friends,

I have to hand it to the people at Home Depot. They have a knack for getting me angry. I bought a single 1/4" sheet of luan ply which I needed for dust panels between drawers of a chest-on-chest I am building for our new bedroom suite. I took the cut sheet with me and asked them to rip and crosscut a piece which I would further cut into five dust panels. I thought the young man at the panel saw was a little too fast in his set up and reiterated the dimensions I wanted. I discovered he crosscut 5/16" shy after I got the plywood home and down into my basement shop. That was on Friday afternoon, and I did a real slow burn, called the store and their Customer Service sent me back to the lumber people. I explained the error and they agreed to give me another piece of plywood. "Just bring it back." I said I would, but I advised them it was somewhat less "easy" for a handicapped person. Their representative, Dave by name, told me just to bring in the receipt, see him, and he'd cut the ply himself, and give me a replacement piece. I determined Dave would be there on Sunday. On Sunday I went back to the store. Nobody ever heard of Dave and they refused to give me the plywood unless I brought the original sheet back. I asked for the store manager and he was not available. I asked them to call the person in charge of the store and I would deal with them. The lumber people refused to do that. I went to customer service very angry and related the incident to them, and customer service sent me back to lumber where I was told about how grossly inaccurate the panel saw was, and that I didn't allow enough for the blade kerf! Somehow the panel saw cut to my dimensions, and I took the replacement plywood home. Customer Service put things right, but the whole experience makes me want to avoid HD in the future. The ignorant attitude of some of their workers must cost them a lot of lost sales, and it is sure to affect my future purchases. All this for a $9.00+ piece of plywood.

George

Re: Home Depot Made Another Lasting Impression

#2

Re: Home Depot Made Another Lasting Impression

Robert R Clough - Thorncraft

>That's very interesting, George. So far, and I repeat so far, I have had no trouble at the HD I patronize in West Allis. There are others in the Milw area but I have no knowledge of how they work. Your problems remind me of those some of us have had with Menards, again, depending upon the store.

Robert

Re: Home Depot Made Another Lasting Impression

#3

Re: Home Depot Made Another Lasting Impression

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>Sorry to hear of your bad experience with HD. At Lafayette Indiana, I have found the HD store to be Head and Shoulders (and stomach and knees etc.) above the competing Menard's store. In fact I have had great help and courtesy there. On the other hand I have had several very bad experiences with Menard's - enough that it is the last place I buy. Lowe's also has a store there and I have had very few issues there either, although I find the HD has more people willing to help - and easier to find.

Re: Home Depot Made Another Lasting Impression

#4

Re: Home Depot Made Another Lasting Impression

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

>I have a letter from a VP at HD corporate. When the tires on my new garden cart would not hold air for more than two days, they told me that I was abusing the cart by taking it off of LEVEL pavement.

Bill who lives in the MOUNTAINS!!!!

Re: Home Depot Made Another Lasting Impression

#5

You gotta love a company...

DWR

>... that only has their "self service" check stands running so you can do the work for them and still pay full price! All the while, several orange aprons are standing around discussing the weekend.

At one time, the HD CEO offered up a link to anyone that wanted to e-mail him with issues, as an attempt to shore up falling share prices due to declining sales... wonder how that went.

I drive 5 miles farther to a hardware store the actually has cheaper prices and 10 times the selection.

Re: Home Depot Made Another Lasting Impression

#6

Re: Home Depot Made Another Lasting Impression

Scott in Eastern Iowa

>Sorry to hear about your unfortunate experience George....obviously they had no idea they were brushing off an internet forum celebrity !!!

Anyhoo, heres what I'd do if they want their sheet of useless plywood back.

Just a warning, but this will take some courage on your part to carry out.

Grab a small garbage sack, head to your dust collector of choice.... (shop vac, bag collector, cyclone....it really wont matter).... and proceed to fill this sack to the point you would still be able to carry it back to those lumber or customer service boneheads.

Bring the real or even a dummy receipt with you as well.

When they ask if you have the return sheet of plywood with you, dump said bag of sawdust at their feet, rip up the receipt and advise them your off to their competitor for a replacement.

You'll still be out 9 bucks.....but you'll be grinning all the way out the door .....and then some!!!

Re: Home Depot Made Another Lasting Impression

#7

A couple of suggestions

Charles R. Smith from Victoria

>George,

Your experience is not good. May I make a couple of suggestions?

First, you can fill out an on-line customer report using the number and password at the bottom of your receipt. It is my understanding that each of these is read by the store management. In my experience, they work. The only time I had a complaint, I filled out the customer survey and got a phone call back from the manager, along with a small gift card.

The second thing you can do is send your information/complaint to the Atlanta folks, at customercare@homedepot.com or phone them at 1-800-430-3376. In the past, there was a mythical person who used to handle all the complaints. I think his name was 'Ben Hill' or something like that. He was mythical, inasmuch as he was named for a district in Atlanta. But a call to that number also got results.

When I have a problem with a big box store like HD, I give them a couple of chances to fix the problem. I figure that if it was me, I'd like to have one more chance to swing at the ball and get it right before being called out on strikes.

I am not trying to cover for their mistake. But I think you would do them a favour by letting them have another chance to make amends.

Charles in Victoria (who lives near an HD store with a nice manager)

Re: Home Depot Made Another Lasting Impression

#8

And a third one.

Charles R. Smith from Victoria

>Maybe you could give them Rob Lee's name, and suggest that they take a course from Lee Valley in providing customer service.

If Home Depot ever started treating people the way that LV does, it would be a winner for certain. I'd like to buy shares in a company that treated people properly.

Charles (who is still hoping for a LV store to come to Victoria)

Re: Home Depot Made Another Lasting Impression

#9

And a fourth one

nailshooter

>This may sound a little bitter and mean, but here goes. I figure that most of the guys that work at these places are either not the most intelligent, or are just passing through the system. Like most employees, they have little interest in what they do, they are just passing time.

As a contractor I work with many vendors, and over the years I have developed a "good offense is the best defense" mentality. I wouldn't expect someone in one of those stores to accurately cut a piece of material for me. If I was in a terrible pinch and had my guys waiting for me and had to have something as accurate as possible, I have the saw man initial my dimensions, then I measure his attempt after he cuts. Not close enough? I don't take it.

There is a reason that so many of us contractors walk around with a tape on our belt. Screws aren't the proper length, wood isn't the proper dimension, trims are the wrong sized (even with the same profile), sheet goods aren't square, and on an on.

Ever since all processes and products at these big boxes became totally price driven, quality has nose dived beyond measure. And since most of the public doesn't know the difference (how many folks size their plywood before using?) between good material and a couple of shades off, these guys have been living on the differnce.

For illustration, say "almost square" plywood (which they sell at HD)is $6 less than actually square (which they have on occasion). I can see in my own mind's eye guys loading plywood saying "what kind of idiot would pay more of the same stuff?"

We all know WE would pay the difference, but most wouldn't. The box guys have been living on the "I just need this for a couple of shelves" plywood buyer for so long it is their norm. They are the cousins of the "I just need a circular saw for this project" guys that build one or two things a year.

I was sorry to read about your bad experience, but you will be more careful and measure next time I have no doubt. But for someone to maliciously make up a name and set a time for you to be there is unacceptable on every level. I would have been bleeding to death from my eyeballs if they didn't explode first.

I sure hope you follow that up with the national complaint/help line.

Robert

Re: Home Depot Made Another Lasting Impression

#10

Re: Home Depot Made Another Lasting Impression

Chuck Lenz

>First of all I'm not going to say what George went through was right. But I worked in a hardware store for about a year recently and it's hardly what I'd call a respectable paying job that anyone could live off of with much dignity. Your not going to get trained proffessionals running for those jobs. I knew more about the products in the store than the manager and the rest of the employees did. One example was they had fish tapes in plumbing. Working with some of the public is another story. People expecting a lifetime warrantee on a Harbor Frieght quality $2 frameing hammer after they have beat the crap out of it on concrete, sometimes with the claw of the hammer.

Re: Home Depot Made Another Lasting Impression

#11

Re: Home Depot Made Another Lasting Impression

Glenn Clabo - RI

>George,

I've noticed some very signifcant changes in my local HD since the new CEO took over. Many employees have said they are under some strict orders to straighten things out.

Send an email to this address explaining what happened...see what happens. You may be surprised...

wehearyou@homedepot.com

Re: Home Depot Made Another Lasting Impression

#12

Lowes - #1 in my book.

Terry Alexander

>

Re: Home Depot Made Another Lasting Impression

#13

Anybody see this little gem in yesterday's news *LINK*

Chad Pearson

>Apparently HD has a policy that no employee is supposed to chase a shoplifter. An employee did so and got fired as a result.

Must be why the prices are so high.


HD employee fired for catching thief

Re: Home Depot Made Another Lasting Impression

#14

Re: Anybody see this little gem in yesterday's new

Barry Irby

>Friend and I went to HD. Wandered around and picked up stuff to buy. We were chatting and not paying much attention and tried to take our stuff to the Return Desk instead of check-out. Wandered through the security scanner and set off the alarms. Standing there with armloads of stuff and the alarms sounding. No one said anything to us. Even the Returns Clerk just looked at us. A customer realized what we had done and said, "I think you want to be over there" pointing to check-out. Somehow, did not even feel foolish.

At self check out they always have a clerk there and they do it for you. I guess they figure that eventually you will learn how and they can let the clerk go.

I hate that they try to make you come in through one door and go out through another. Never a good parking place. Either a long walk in or a long walk out.

Re: Home Depot Made Another Lasting Impression

#15

Re: Home Depot Made Another Lasting Impression

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>Good morning Colonel,

Thanks for the head's up. It's good to learn that Home Depot uses a 5/16" kerf blade on their panel saws. ;-)

Tom

Re: Home Depot Made Another Lasting Impression

#16

Re: Home Depot Made Another Lasting Impression

David

>I've found a lot of variation store to store. The HD closest to me in northern Virginia sounds a lot like the one George visited. Can't find anyone; when you do, they either don't speak English, don't know the stock or both; and customer service is a foreign concept. A few miles further it's a completely different story. People in orange aprons ask if they can help. A young man helped me load a 3/4" sheet of MDF on my cart, take it to the panel saw, triple checked the measurements and helped carry the pieces to my car. Based on that I returned a couple of days later to get some pipes for pipe clamps. Same story. I was escorted to the right place in the store; the pipes were cut to the length I wanted; and threaded on the spot. I did have to carry them to my car, but what the heck. Wage rates have got to be the same. I chalk it up to management and local training. Guess which store I go to now!

Re: Home Depot Made Another Lasting Impression

#17

Management makes all the difference.

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>Different stores in the same chain with different customer service experiences. You have to blame the store manager for that. I found out a long time ago that the employees will treat the customers the same way they are treated by their supervisors. The supervisors will treat their employees the same way they are treated by their boss.

Gary

Re: Home Depot Made Another Lasting Impression

#18

You're LUCKY ! At least . . .

s.mackay@worldnet.att.net

>you could argue in English. I just get Mexican and a blank look at HD !

Re: Home Depot Made Another Lasting Impression

#19

You know this already George, but....

Dave Anderson Chester, NH

>Given your background, I really don't have to tell you that the issue is all about leadership. If a store manager leads by example and demands excellence, with the proper of his employees.training he will get it.

Re: Home Depot Made Another Lasting Impression

#20

Re: Home Depot Made Another Lasting Impression

Ernie Miller

>George I'm sorry to hear of you problem that is why I go to a lumber yard instead of a box when possable wood is better prices might be a little higher hear and there but survice is great. but a couple hundred dollars of stuff and it is delivered free not $75 and the people are nice and helpfull. I guess it also helps that it is closer to my side of town.

Re: Home Depot Made Another Lasting Impression

#21

Re: Home Depot Made Another Lasting Impression

Bart Castleberry

>The HD here in Christiansburg VA stopped offering contractor discounts to at least 90% of thier contractor accounts (per one of the contractor sales reps) Unless you bought several hundred thousand a year, they did not want to talk to you. I was spending quite a bit there (a lot on a lot of large projects and never less than 1k at a time). Now I go to Lowes, they happily offer a discount to true contractors. I was told this too was due to the new management at HD. I won't patronize a business any more that screws over small buisness owners like that.

Re: Home Depot Made Another Lasting Impression

#22

Partially a matter of perspective!

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>I'm not trying to defend the HD people, because I have had my own shortfalls in service; however, you have to remember their frame of reference. Approximately 99% of their trade is with contractors and DIY people doing "carpentry". Maybe 1% of their trade is dealing with folks like us who are cabinet makers. The HD hiring practices and training would be toward carpentry and not cabinet making, so they have little understanding of the needs of our craft. While I would always hope to hire a carpenter who can cut wood to closer than 5/16" of the desired size. That error is probably not unforgiveable in most carpentry situations. Just center the piece up in the space and leave a 5/32" gap on the sides, no big deal.

That same error is totally unacceptable in most cabinet projects.

When dealing with folks you have to keep in mind that their frame of reference may not be the same as yours.

I'm glad it all worked out in the end for you George and you also have an on hand supply of plywood for small boxes at no extra charge.

Lee

Re: Home Depot Made Another Lasting Impression

#23

Re: Home Depot Made Another Lasting Impression

Lee Ohmart

>I know how you feel. There is nothing worse than feeling like you've been lied to and treated like dirt when you've spent your "hard earned." Even if it is a store that supposedly offers lower prices, you expect to get what you pay for. And again, I agree with those who point out the reduction in quality. A Home Depot employee in the area of my camp was helping me with plumbing fittings and bemoaned how the stuff he was selling as not up to the level of quality he would like. Having spent some time in retail, I agree with the responses about how the store manager sets the tone. Here in Bangor, we apparently have a gem. For the most part, I've found the personnel at that store to be very helpful and knowledgable. Many of them are former owners of stores who decided to retire. Therein lies the key. Look for the "Fudds" (i.e. fuddy duddies like in Elmer Fudd) and I proudly include myself in that number. The kids are, for the most part, clueless, as it should be. Let's be honest here. When we were kids, did we have anywhere near the collected experience we have now? Yeah, yeah, I know there are a few former or present wunderkinders out there but, for the most part, we came by our knowledge the hard way. Fudds of the world unite!

Re: Home Depot Made Another Lasting Impression

#24

That's ironic.

Jason Roehl in Mulberry, IN

>Last year I painted an apartment complex (1 bldg of 34 units and 4 bldgs of 4-6 units, total 54 units). The developer took over the construction management part way into the project and started buying all the materials from HD. They had told him that they could take care of him. Unfortunately, I don't think he was giving them any heads up, as he would call for 100-200 interior doors, wanting them the next day, and they would end up taking 2-3 weeks. Or they would have some poor schmoe drive around to a bunch of stores collecting them. I ended up talking to the HD rep managing the account, and he said HD was not set up to supply more than a house or two at a time (like a small builder would need).

Jason

Re: Home Depot Made Another Lasting Impression

#25

Re: Home Depot Made Another Lasting Impression

Scott Greaves in Blackfoot Idaho

>Hi George! Sorry to hear that HD spoiled your day! A little bit of care and caution on their part would have avoided this.

I actually had a surprisingly positive experience with HD about a week ago. Last fall we installed some faucets in our cabin about two weeks before we closed it up for the winter. We don't heat it over the winter so it gets way below zero sometimes. Well, this spring we opened it up and turned on the water, and one of the faucets started spouting all over.

The faucet was an American Standard from Home Depot. We'd had it about eight months, no box, no receipt. I took it in to Customer service at HD, and they said to get a new one off the shelf. They gave us the new one, put the broke one in the box, and said Have a Nice Day! Scarey!!! ;-)

Scott.