Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Bedroom set, Walnut or Cherry

Posts

Bedroom set, Walnut or Cherry

#1

Bedroom set, Walnut or Cherry

Scott S.

>I am going to be making a bedroom set for us. A new head and foot board, dresserw/ mirror, 2 nightstands and perhaps a stand alone mirror. My wife would like it made out of WALNUT. Which I love. But is that too much dark colored wood. I was thinking cherry. But I don't want what everybody else has. Maybe cherry with hard maple, or walnut and hard maple. Or oak and walnut. Or use walnut with some white sapwood in it, which I personally like. Not sure what to do. let me know your suggestions.

I am alos looking for some pics of bedroom sets as well.

Scott

Re: Bedroom set, Walnut or Cherry

#2

Re: Bedroom set, Walnut or Cherry

Andy Lincoln,In Dearborn MI

>Scott,

Walnut doesn't have to always be real dark.I like using boiled linseed oil and then several coats of orange shellac.Although somewhat dark it's not cave dark.Cherry will also get darker over time,which is a consideration as well.Here's a pic of a walnut dresser I currently share with my wife,I built it,she filled it,That's sharing right?:-)

Andy


img

Re: Bedroom set, Walnut or Cherry

#3

Re: Bedroom set, Walnut or Cherry

Ron Hildreth, Alta, Iowa

>Scott,

Keep in mind that cherry might start it's life as a bedroom set light in color, but as it ages, could actually turn darker than the walnut your wife wants you to build it out of to begin with, and that's even without stain. Although a dark wood, walnut can be lightened several ways. Pickled comes to mind, as does bleaching it if a lighter wood is desired.

You also mentioned maple. Why not design something with all three woods you mentioned incorporated into it, as in inlays of cherry and maple within a walnut headboard, and then design everything else, night stands and the like, around it. Lots of options!

Ron in Iowa

Re: Bedroom set, Walnut or Cherry

#4

Re: Bedroom set, Walnut or Cherry

Jesse in New Mexico

>There's no wrong answer to that question! Can't go wrong with either path.

BTW, I just made a dining table from walnut with some sapwood. Applied solar lux yellow dye followed by burnt amber glaze, then rockhard varnish. The dyes made the sapwood a nice golden color. If you want to go with walnut (and doing what LOYL asks is always a good idea), make several pieces of scrap before you start finishing and test a few combinations till you find something you both like.


img

Re: Bedroom set, Walnut or Cherry

#5

JL

Re: Bedroom set, Walnut or Cherry

JL

>We have a cherry bedroom set from Ethan Allan that we've had for years. Looks good. But the thought of a walnut set with some nice hard maple accents sounds really appealling.

Re: Bedroom set, Walnut or Cherry

#6

Consider Butternut

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>

Re: Bedroom set, Walnut or Cherry

#7

Re: Bedroom set, Walnut or Cherry

David

>Cherry and walnut is one of my favorite combinations. Currently designing a bedroom set my wife wants with a oriental flavor. Will use walnut for the tops and legs and cherry for the body and drawers. Still mostly in my head so no pictures yet!

Re: Bedroom set, Walnut or Cherry

#8

Re: Consider Butternut

Yonak

>Is real furniture made out of butternut ? Isn't it kind of soft ?

Re: Bedroom set, Walnut or Cherry

#9

Re: Consider Butternut

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Morning Yonak,

Butternut has similar grain characteristics as walnut but with a significantly lighter overall color. It works like walnut. I've used it in furniture, tables actually. I never researched the relative hardness as compared to walnut. Its certainly hard enough.

George