Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

Little electrical problem

Posts

Little electrical problem

#1

Little electrical problem

Ray Thompson - Middletown,IN

>Haven't been in the shop in a couple of days, procrastination you know, I went up there today and while getting out the spray gun I looked at the wall and saw this looking back. There was a dehumidifier plugged in the lower left side but nothing in the right two outlets. Circuit breaker was not tripped and the hot wire was completely intact as was the ground wires to both outlets. The neutral was completely fried. I am assuming something failed internally in the outlet

Ray


img

Re: Little electrical problem

#2

Back side

Ray Thompson - Middletown,IN

>The wire is the hot feed from the one on the right to the left one. Ground screws are intact, but the neutral seems to be missing something.

Ray


img

Re: Little electrical problem

#3

Re: Little electrical problem

Bill Howatt

>You likely had a bad connection probably where the neutral wire was under a screw. A dehumidifier is a fairly high-current device so there was enough heat generated in the bad connection to the damage shown. Once the connection starts to go bad (get more resistance) it always gets worse, never better since the heat causes more oxidation of the components.

Your example is also one of the ones that fuses/breakers don't protect against because the breaker is not seeing excessive current -the current is in the normal range but is heating up the wrong pieces.

Bill

Re: Little electrical problem

#4

Re: Little electrical problem

Todd O. Cronkhite Maine Native, Presently Away

>HOLY BURNT TOAST BATMAN!! That's SCARY! I am so glad that your shop didn't burn down. I dunno what caused this situation, and I don't understand why the breaker didn't trip, but you can bet that I'll be showing this to my electrician friend on Monday.

Ray, the Gods smiled upon you by not burning down your shop, so make sure to thank them---often!

T.O.

Re: Little electrical problem

#5

Wow!

John in New Mexico

>You are one lucky guy!

I wonder if an arc fault breaker would have caught it.

John

Re: Little electrical problem

#6

Re: Little electrical problem

Bill Howatt

>Breaker didn't trip because excessive current wasn't drawn and this is the only thing that trips a regular breaker. My theory is a bad connection caused severe overheating in a localized area which causes a high temperature rise resulting in the damage shown.

If you estimate (guess) a resistance at the bad connection of 0.5 ohms instead of the virtually 0 ohms of a good connection and if the dehumidifier draws 10A then there is 50 Watts of heating being applied to the screw terminal. Since the bad resistance is in series with the load it causes no increased current draw the breaker would see and a drop of only 5V across the bad connection so the humidifier could continue to operate for a while. The heating would have oxidized the connection causing the resistance to go even higher resulting in even more heating until the wire melted off.

I think an Arc Fault breaker as considered by John in New Mexico likely would have tripped at some point in the overheating.

Bill

Re: Little electrical problem

#7

Re: Little electrical problem

Jim Swank

>You say the dehumidifier was plugged into the left outlet. Did the power wires run to the right and then jump over to the left? If so, current to the dehumidifier passed through the right outlet terminals on the way to the left. My guess is loike the others - a loose neutral wire on the right outlet.

While I'm rattling on, I never use the quick connect slip-in holes, always use the screws, and always wrap the wire so the cut off end runs clockwise around the screw. Every burned outlet I've seen was wired with those push-in holes and the contact lost tension, making a loose connection.

Re: Little electrical problem

#8

I'm wondering.....hmmmm....

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ontario

>Did you notice any smoke Ray?

:-)

Take care,

Jim

Re: Little electrical problem

#9

Um.....

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>That's seriously SCARY!

I'm glad you didn't walk in on flames and smoke!

:(

Re: Little electrical problem

#10

Re: Little electrical problem

Ray Newman

>"...never use the quick connect slip-in holes, always use the screws, and always wrap the wire so the cut off end runs clockwise around the screw. Every burned outlet I've seen was wired with those push-in holes and the contact lost tension, making a loose connection."

BINGO!

Re: Little electrical problem

#11

Scary stuff Ray

Dave Peebles Lyons, Ohio!

>I am so happy I am not reading an Ellis story.

I am very interested in hearing all the details when you figure it out.

P.S. Buy a lotto ticket tomorrow. :)

Dave

Re: Little electrical problem

#12

Re: Little electrical problem

Randy Johnson Connersville, IN

>Considering how much of the NEC is aimed at preventing one in a million problems, it's kind of amazing that quick connect outlets and switches haven't been banned.

Re: Little electrical problem

#13

Re: Little electrical problem

john lucas

>Wow RAy I'm scared to death of having a fire and try to clean everything but the fact that it can happen just because a wire get's oxidized is really scary.

Re: Little electrical problem

#14

Re: Little electrical problem

Jim Swank

>"Considering how much of the NEC is aimed at preventing one in a million problems, it's kind of amazing that quick connect outlets and switches haven't been banned."

The NEC only addresses wiring, not wiring devices. The devices themselves are covered by Underwriters Labarotaries (UL listed). My employer does make outlets, switches, etc, but in a different division than mine. I'm not sure what those standards require. I'm sure all manufacturers comply with them and have records to prove it.

From previous experience and talking to other "old" electricians, there are lots of ways to screw up these quick connects, usually in removing a wire.

I've seen some pretty shoddy connections made using the screw terminals. At least those connections are visible, leaving no excuses other than ignorance and sloth.

Re: Little electrical problem

#15

Bit more info.

Ray Thompson - Middletown,IN

>The shop was built about 10 years ago and the wiring was installed then. The dehumidifier has been running in that location for about 3 years and the burned outlet is rarely used. Wires were wrapped around the terminal screws, crimped, and tightened. I never use the quick connects, never did trust them. All of the quad outlets but one were GFCI protected (guess which one)--- it is now.

I think Bill has the right answer, it just took a long time to manifest itself. Everything did its job, the box contained everything, however one side of it softened and buckled.

Ray

Re: Little electrical problem

#16

For my own future reference . . .

s.mackay@worldnet.att.net

>I don't understand that single, lone wire between the fixtures. I've always just done all in sequence along the run individualy. Are things safer with this set-up ?

Re: Little electrical problem

#17

Plastic box or metal?

John in New Mexico

>If plastic, I'm impressed!

John

Re: Little electrical problem

#18

Re: Um.....

Bill Howatt

>Your response made me think of perhaps a deficiency in the overall shop security - no smoke detector. The message seems to indicate a shop independent of the house but apparently there are detectors that do remote alarming.

Bill

Re: Little electrical problem

#19

Bit more info.

Ray Thompson - Middletown,IN

>Yep, they are plastic. First time I ever used them, although the side nearest the problem softened and buckled, it held its ground nicely.

Ray

Re: Little electrical problem

#20

Interesting thought

Ray Thompson - Middletown,IN

>The shop is about 400 feet from the house and near nothing. I didn't put in detectors because no one would be alerted. Now if I could have one send a signal back to the house we might be in business.

Ray

Re: Little electrical problem

#21

Re: For my own future reference . . .

Ray Thompson - Middletown,IN

>I just left that one on to keep them together. I took off everything else.

Ray

Re: Little electrical problem

#22

I think you can...

John in New Mexico

>Modern smoke detectors are supposed to be inter-wired so that when one goes off in a house, they all go off. Could be as simple as having an additional detector in your house with a wire out to the shop. I haven't gotten far along enough yet to hook ours up, but the rough in required 14-3 between all three of them -- of course thats also for power.

John

Re: Little electrical problem

#23

Wish it were that easy.

Ray Thompson - Middletown,IN

>The house and shop are on separate meter bases, thus not interconnected.

I do have cat 5 and cat 6 lines running from the house to the shop doing nothing right now so I'm going to do some reasearch on what kind of detectors are available.

Ray

Re: Little electrical problem

#24

Re: Little electrical problem

Tom MacGregor

>Many different grades of outlets and switches are available, from $.89 cent cheapos (we used to call them "trailer tinder") to $20.00+ hospital grade. I generally use spec. grade or better from an electrical supply store in the $4 to $5 range. They're heavier duty and safer with less chance of malfunction. Well worth the price.

Re: Little electrical problem

#25

Re: Sure glad the damage was limited to the

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>outlet & wire. Ray - if you find a way to hookup remote detectors, please let me know. My shop is detached, though close to the house, there would be no way I could hear a detector. If you find a method I will probably install some in my shop.