Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

Maple or Cherry -- Need Advise

Posts

Re: Maple or Cherry -- Need Advise

#26

Monrovia, Indiana?

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>Hi Mom :)

I'd go with the maple if you don't care for the darker color that the cherry will eventually give you.

Are you in Monrovia, Indiana by any chance? If so, do you know the Estel's? Sarah and Bill?

Jennifer

Re: Maple or Cherry -- Need Advise

#27

Monrovia, Michigan??

Jim Dillon

>

Re: Maple or Cherry -- Need Advise

#28

Re: Maple or Cherry -- Need Advice

Monrovia Mom

>Actually, Monrovia California --

Thank you all for your thoughts. My cabinetmaker is still holding tight on issues using Maple (without a glazing process of some kind). I think I need to choose a different cabinet guy or a different wood --

I think Alder is okay or even steamed beech... but is it on the softer side?

Re: Maple or Cherry -- Need Advise

#29

A Lot Softer Than Maple, Dents Easily

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>

Re: Maple or Cherry -- Need Advise

#30

My experiences with maple - kinda long

Derek

>I made my kitchen cabinets from maple (actually birds-eye maple). They came out beautifully. I used a solvent based lacquer with no dye and the lacquer has yellowed over time to a nice mellow color, as I expected. We love the color. I have made a number of things from maple with dye and also stain.

I have both dyed and stained maple. As others have told you dye works extremely well with maple and is very easy to do. Dye is not color fast and will lighten in UV light (sunlight or fluorescent lights) but stain usually is color fast. Staining maple REQUIRES you pre-condition it, according to the directions with stain (but not dye). I stained maple with and without the conditioner. You NEED the conditioner with stain to get an even color. It is also much ligher color with conditioner so a sample is advisable.

Stain (which is very different from dye) sits on the surface of the wood while dye soaks into the wood and goes below the surface. For maple to take dye reasonably, the maple should NOT be sanded too much (use no finer than 150 grit sandpaper, but experiment).

The top coat finish will change color over time unless you use a non-yellowing top coat. Most solvent base top-coats which will be tough enough for a kitchen will yellow but most water based products do not - check with the manufacturer. This will change the color over time as well.

Many woods and finish products will alter the color over time. Also, the light used to illuminate them changes the apparent color (this is called metamerism) and this effect can be quite dramatic!

Re: Maple or Cherry -- Need Advise

#31

Re: Maple or Cherry -- Need Advice

Bob McGovern

>Alder is nasty. Softer than poplar, with none of the character of maple nor the graceful aging of cherry. It's not even that cheap, considering its minimal virtues.

Both alder and steam beech have that reddish or pinkish color value you hinted you are averse to. They won't darken much, tho -- unlike cherry. Neither one takes dye well; beech also stains poorly.

I use boatloads of European steam beech -- building a kitchen in it (and another in hard maple) right now. Let me scare up the digital camera & I'll give you a couple glam shots of each. Beech is quite hard, extremely consistent in color and grain (maple can get pretty funky, from board to board), and quiet in a Japanese-minimalist sort of way. Warmer than birch or maple, but subdued. Beech is, however, famously unstable in large assemblies -- eg, wide door panels. Tends to twist due to wood movement. I've found Euro steam beech more stable than American beech, but I live in a place where wood doesn't move much, seasonally. Others may have different stories to tell. Photos to come.

Re: Maple or Cherry -- Need Advise

#32

Okay, some photos

Bob McGovern

>First is three random samples, in declining order of red color value. From left to right:

Cherry (dyed in the middle, not dyed around the edges)

Euro steam beech (no dye)

Hard maple (no dye)

------

Second, an undyed maple cabinet. Fairly white; it will amber in time. Note the wacky color and grain variation.

------

Finally, some dyed maple cabinets. This is a honey amber dye with a little red-brown added, and about three years of sunlight. True, dyes can fade, tho water-based are pretty stable; but as the dye is fading, the wood is darkening, so the dye just effectively ages the cabinets about ten years.

Re: Maple or Cherry -- Need Advise

#33

PS:

Bob McGovern

>Sounds like your cabinetmaker has some aversion to maple & is trying to talk you out of it. In my experience, clients' tastes break along two issues: open grain/closed grain, & red/not red. I'd guess you dislike the grainyness of woods like oak, ash, and hickory -- hence your affinity for maple, cherry and beech. But you'd prefer honey or amber (yellow bias) over the red bias of cherry.

Great. Wonderful. Maple or birch will suit you fine. So why won't your cabinetmaker entertain your preferences? Not familiar with dyes, wants to stick with pigmented stains? Pigment kills maple dead.

Every woodworker draws their own lines. I won't work in softwoods; I won't mess with knotty or reclaimed lumber. Just my personal boundaries. But I'm trying to grasp what sort of cabinetmaker recoils at maple, or at waterbased dye. The combination is, as Mister Shaver's photos show, one of life's true delights. Sheesh. Advise you get a second opinion from another craftsperson, then compare how well each fits your desires. It's your kitchen, after all. Don't settle for a wood you don't like.

Cheers!

Re: Maple or Cherry -- Need Advise

#34

Change Cabinetmaker (Long)

David Yoho

>I tend to agree with Bob's thinking, and actually hinted at this in my earlier response. This is the second time your post mentions your cabinetmaker wanting to use a glazing process for the finish on maple (if he is to use maple at all). I see two issues here.

First, this cabinetmaker's finishing technique of glazing benefits him because it's faster than putting on separate applications of dye and clear topcoat. Seems to me this guy is more concerned about the fastest way to the end result than doing what it takes to satisfy your choices.

Second, it also hints to me that he is either not familiar with dyes and finishing methods for maple or doesn't like working with maple for some reason. Personally, I don't care much for working with softwoods or red oak. However, if my customers want those woods, I work with them. I just price the job accordingly and their money spends just as well in the end - making both of us happy!

The bottom line - it sounds like maybe you should talk to some other cabinetmakers before proceeding with things. If you want maple or beech, that is what you should get - finished in a manner that will yield the results you desire. What you're asking for is not anything that should cause a quality cabinetmaker problems or make the price go up. I think the guy you've talked to has one way of doing things and to do anything different causes him a problem. Solve his problem by moving on to someone more interested in working with you and satisfying your choices.

David