Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Maple or Cherry -- Need Advise

Posts

Maple or Cherry -- Need Advise

#1

Maple or Cherry -- Need Advise

Monrovia Mom

>I was directed to this site to get some advise on wood -- We are remodeling our kitchen & are interested in Maple -- although my cabinetmaker has indicated that maple does not stain consistently & would require a glazing process. The other option is cherry -- although I have heard that cherry darkens over time. We are interested in a medium, honey color & do not prefer the red tones. Any advise would be welcomed.

Re: Maple or Cherry -- Need Advise

#2

Re: Maple or Cherry -- Need Advise

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ontario

>Hi,

Cherry is not going to work for you. Going with a honey colour dye and a water based top coat would be my choice...maybe some glazing if you like a toned look on top of the dye.

Take care,

Jim

Re: Maple or Cherry -- Need Advise

#3

Re: Maple or Cherry -- Need Advise

Monrovia Mom

>Thanks for your words of wisdom, Jim -- but why won't cherry work? Also, I don't want to mess with glazing (gets really $$$), but my cabinetmaker is pushing that the staining of the maple (with/out glazing) will cause "pooling". Thoughts?

Re: Maple or Cherry -- Need Advise

#4

Maple dyes just dandy

Bob McGovern

>While it can blotch under a pigmented stain, maple takes waterbased 'analine' dyes exceptionally well -- nice & even color, with intensity easy to control. But note bene! Semi-rotary-cut birch plywood is often used as a maple emulator in cabinet boxes; it is cheaper and easier to obtain than maple veneered ply, and only a sharp eye can tell them apart. Until you try to dye or stain them. The birch ply is quite porous & gets much darker than either solid maple or maple ply.

That said, you might steer your cabinetmaker to Jeff Jewett's outstanding line of waterbased dyes from Homestead Finishes. Both the Transtint and Transfast lines give excellent results & are easy to use. I like Homestead's Honey Amber for a very light 'aging'; judicious doses of Golden or Medium Brown can add more warmth.

Good surface prep is essential for any dye or stain job: cross grain scratches will leap out, and fillers or glue drips may reject the color. Maple should not be sanded too finely; the sugars can burnish the wood & lead to blotching. But cherry will do the same thing. 180 grit is plenty fine enuf. Waterbased dyes can cause grain raising; a sealer coat & gentle scuff sand will shear off the whiskers.

Finally, any coloring operation (stain, dye, or glaze/toner) may add to the cost of the job. I charge about a $700 premium for dyeing, and it never seems to cover the added time imposed. Even plain old maple will amber quite a bit over the years, as ambient light does its trick.

Best of luck, & stick with maple if you like it.

Re: Maple or Cherry -- Need Advise

#5

Agree with Jim

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>I agree with Jim. Cherry will darken in a way that you will not be sure of the final outcome color-wise. Have your maker use anyline dye to color the maple to the desired color. Maple will color fine with dye. I do it all the time.

Tom

Re: Maple or Cherry -- Need Advise

#6

Re: Maple or Cherry -- Need Advise

Steve Schoene

>The problem, given the preference you expressed, is that cherry will darken considerably over time. If anything, it will alos become more red. There isn't any way to avoid that. It also has staining problems similar to maple,

Cherry is also considerably more expensive than maple. Typically, there is a 20% (or the like) upcharge for cherry cabinets.

As has been said, maple does take dye well.

If you are looking for a fairly light color, maple can be stained over a "conditioner" or "wash coat" that will reduce blotching. Color can also be added evenly by spraying on "toner", which is tinted finish. If kept modest, and not used to make really dark shades, a sprayed toner can look good. (Too much toner and you get a "Bombay" almost painted look.) Also be aware that maple will darken a bit over time--not nearly as much as cherry--but enough to be noticable.

Ask your cabinet maker for a sample door in the finish you are about to agree on. That's about the only way to know how it really will turn out.

Re: Maple or Cherry -- Need Advise

#7

Re: Maple or Cherry -- Need Advise *LINK*

David Yoho

>I'll add another vote for maple. If you cabinet maker doesn't use or isn't familiar with dyes, maybe you need to look for one that does/is. Maple has a very tight grain and pigmented stains will not color it effectively, since there are no pores in the wood for the pigment to slip into.

I like TransTint #6002 - Golden Brown dye on maple. However, the #6001 - Honey Amber may be more to your liking. As already stated, maple will turn an amber color on its own over time. This should be factored in when choosing a dye color.

Below is a link to the Homestead Finishing TransTint dye page with color samples on maple for you to see.


Homestead Finishing TransTint

Re: Maple or Cherry -- Need Advise

#8

A Bit Late.... Examples

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ontario

>Hi,

The others beat me too it, :-)

Cherry is my favorite wood to make furniture with, I LIVE for the aging process of my works.

You received advice in line with what I would offer as my own as well.

I use analine dyes often on maple, mostly to kick up the look of figured maple.

This is an example of using two different analine dyes to create an antique look on maple.

Photo Sharing and Video Hosting at Photobucket

Photo Sharing and Video Hosting at Photobucket

Photo Sharing and Video Hosting at Photobucket

Photo Sharing and Video Hosting at Photobucket

Take care,

Jim

Re: Maple or Cherry -- Need Advise

#9

Re: Bob McGovern!?! -- as in wyomingbob???

Dave Mount

>Is that Bob from Badger Pond days? Where've you been? Maybe I just haven't been paying attention, but I don't think I've heard anything from you since BP went the way of the dinos! Are you still in Laramie and still scratching out a living in the shop?

Welcome back, good to hear your "voice". My apologies if you've been around and I just didn't notice. . .or if you're not the same Bob McGovern!

Dave

Re: Maple or Cherry -- Need Advise

#10

Oak is a better choice

Curly Smith

>Given your desired color, golden honey, I'd use oak. And, I'd probably use Minwax stain #210B "Golden Oak" (actually I did use that stain when I refinished my kitchen cabinets).

Cherry is too red, maple is likely too light. Not to sound like Goldilocks but oak is just right.

Re: Maple or Cherry -- Need Advise

#11

Wyoming Bob????!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Hey Bob ,

I saw your name in lights before reading Dave's post above. Where have you been? "Its GOOD to have you Home Again". BTW, your answer was as thorough as ever. Hope we see and read more posts with your name on them. Welcome back.

George

Re: Maple or Cherry -- Need Advise

#12

Re: A Bit Late.... Examples

Dennis Yoder

>Jim, Do you remember what colors you used on the clock? It is fabulous. Dennis

Re: Maple or Cherry -- Need Advise

#13

Re: Oh my gosh

Dave Arbuckle, Plano, TX

>Bob, great to see your post! :-)

And the advice is spot-on, too, wouldn't change a thing.

Re: Maple or Cherry -- Need Advise

#14

other options

Tom Sontag - St. Louis

>You have gotten accurate advise so far: cherry will turn a color you said you do not want, so maple is left. There are other light woods often used in cabinetry that can give you the golden color you seek: hickory is very often found in cabinets. Birch. Ash oak and hackberry are light domestic hardwoods with a more pronounced grain which may or may not appeal to you.

Your cabinetmaker should be able to offer you more than two alternatives, one of which he knows you do not want.

Re: Maple or Cherry -- Need Advise

#15

More agreement and examples

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>Here is what unstained cherry will look like after aging.


This is red oak with a Min Wax Golden Oak stain:



This is red oak with no stain:


There is no way to get cherry to be light brown and stay that way. The "pooling" or blotching as some call it on Maple can be greatly reduced if not totally eliminated by the uyse of a pre-stain conditioner or through the use of trans tint dyes.

Hope this helps

Lee

Re: Maple or Cherry -- Need Advise

#16

White Oak

Dave Bair, Eaton Rapids, MI

>If you want a wood that looks like wood and has it's own honey color with nothing but a few coats of poly, white oak is an obvious choice.

Re: Maple or Cherry -- Need Advise

#17

Hi folks

Bob McGovern

>*bows* Good to see so many familiar names. Been scrambling to build a house, a shop, and the biz (& living without internet) the last four years or so. Just got a satellite service last week. Still in Wyoming, only more so.

Re: Maple or Cherry -- Need Advise

#18

Re: Hi folks

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ontario

>Hi Bob,

I am SO happy to see that this is YOU!!!

Wow, it's been a few miles, eh!!

:-)

Take care,

Jim

Really glad you are back!

Re: Maple or Cherry -- Need Advise

#19

HELLO WYOMING BOB...!

HC Sakman

>Where the heck have you been man?

Good to see you! Don't disappear this time, will YA?

Chico....

Re: Maple or Cherry -- Need Advise

#20

Darn, I'm embarrassed…

Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach

>I didn't pick up on the “Bob McGovern”, but as soon as I saw George's “Wyoming Bob” the memories came flooding back. It sure is nice to hear from you again.

Rod
Think woodbutcher and you'll net the site
Nah, I don't have to do that anymore over here. Just thought it might help you recognize me.

Re: Maple or Cherry -- Need Advise

#21

Re: Maple or Cherry -- Need Advise

Patrick Schupbach

>Have you considered alder??

Re: Maple or Cherry -- Need Advise

#22

Watch This, Ellis

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>The water level is rising. About all we need now is for Wayne to drop by and the Pond will be back to wading depth!

Welcome, Mr. Bob! Jeez, has it been 4 YEARS? Yikes!

mm

Re: Maple or Cherry -- Need Advise

#23

Re: Maple or Cherry -- Need Advise

Jim Dillon

>Hi Monrovia Mom,

Here is a pic of some hickory (along with the sapwood) kitchen cabinets I built about 5 years ago. Hickory has a nice color - warmer than maple, but not as red as cherry - but is tough to work with. The finish is a oil/varnish mix. The color doesn't seem to have changed over time. We like it a lot. Good luck.

Jim


img

Re: Maple or Cherry -- Need Advise

#24

Sounds like Bob...

Ellis Walentine, Host

>...was one of the mainstays at BP. I am honored to have his wisdom here.

Cheers,

Ellis

Re: Maple or Cherry -- Need Advise

#25

Welcome Back!

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>Hi Bob,

Nice to see your name pop up. Hope all is well. It sounds like you've been more than busy.

Kick your feet up and stay a while :)

Jennifer