Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

When and why did a 2x4 become a 1 1/2 x 3 1/2?

Posts

Re: When and why did a 2x4 become a 1 1/2 x 3 1/2?

#26

When its good, its good...

John in New Mexico

>I like the chart too, some interesting trends. I don't really dis-like wikipedia -- even edit some of the geology articles, it just seems very ironic to have an encyclopedia where the user might have to check facts independently when the sound implausible.

People still seem to have a hard time realizing that buying power of any currency is not fixed, hence the gold example.

John

Re: When and why did a 2x4 become a 1 1/2 x 3 1/2?

#27

The problem is…

Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach

>…any article is only as good (read reliable) as its most recent edit. Therefore the scope of efficacy at any moment can range from utterly useless to maybe pretty good—it's a crap shoot—and unless you're already conversant in the subject, you can't know. That's bad enough, but when you begin to examine some of the internal workings, including administrators who may only be 14 years old and super-admins with a long record of unfettered abuse and bias, and see how twisted some of the ostensibly good product can be, it's the emperor's clothes personified.

I spent an intensive four or five months editing before I discovered how really questionable the whole process can be. As a result, I now add “-wikipedia” to every search I make. The internet can be unreliable enough as a source of information without injecting an inherently faulty process masquerading as a legitimate resource into the mix.

Your comment, “it just seems very ironic to have an encyclopedia where the user might have to check facts independently when the sound implausible.” really says it all. It makes my point better than I could.

Rod

Re: When and why did a 2x4 become a 1 1/2 x 3 1/2?

#28

Re: When and why did a 2x4 become a 1 1/2 x 3 1/2? *LINK*

Bob Falk, FPL wood engineer

>Hi, I am a wood engineer at the USDA Forest Products Lab and I believe I have the answer...here is a sidebar that I wrote for a recent Fine Homebuilding book I wrote...they didn't include it, however I think you might find it informative.

Why a 2x4 isn�t 2 inches x 4 inches?

Answering this question requires a bit of history about the evolution of lumber standards. As our country developed during the 18th and 19th centuries, sawmills sprang up to satisfy local demand for construction lumber. This lumber was not kiln dried (called green) and was supplied roughly sawn from the mill.

Lumber sizes varied by region because mills produced lumber based on local building customs and demand. Before 1895, no standards existed for the grading and sizing of lumber, though two inches had evolved over time as the most common rough thickness for joists, rafters, and studs and one inch as the most common thickness for boards.

During the second half of the 19th century, the wood products industry realized that they could broaden their markets geographically using the rapidly developing railroad system, which forced them to produce sizes matching the distant markets they supplied. Also, they realized that shipping green lumber (which was much heavier) was much costlier than shipping dry lumber. So, kiln drying of lumber became more common.

Like a cotton T-shirt, lumber shrinks with drying, and the once rough, green, full-sized 2 x 4 becomes smaller. Though dry lumber has the added advantage of staying straighter at the jobsite, the different drying rates of the various species of lumber being shipped around meant that there was still considerable variability in lumber sizes. The advent of surface milling, or planning, helped the move towards a more uniform (though smaller) size and easier-to-handle lumber (a smooth surface meant less splinters for carpenters). However, it wasn�t until 1969 that the U.S. Department of Commerce once and for all unified lumber sizes across the country. So, the once full-sized 2x4 was reduced to today�s 1-1/2� x 3-1/2� through a combination of drying, machining, as well as unifying the wide variety of species used to make the ubiquitous 2x4. Bob Falk


http://www.fpl.fs.fed.us/

Re: When and why did a 2x4 become a 1 1/2 x 3 1/2?

#29

Thanks for that.

Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach

>Nice to hear things from the horse's mouth now and again.

Rod

Re: When and why did a 2x4 become a 1 1/2 x 3 1/2?

#30

That's right, Gary. They were cut down to 1 5/8"

Henthorn

>X 3 5/8" years before they were further cut down to 1 1/2" X 3 1/2". There is no explanation for that but getting more pieces out of a log.

Re: When and why did a 2x4 become a 1 1/2 x 3 1/2?

#31

Re: Improved testing?

Al Stokka - Cambridge, Iowa

>I have been of the mind that improved strength-testing ability allowed those-who-set-the size-of-structural-lumber to realize that the size of 2x4's could be reduced without sacrificing needed strength. Who knows?

Al

Re: When and why did a 2x4 become a 1 1/2 x 3 1/2?

#32

Re: Improved testing?

Steve Schoene

>My bet that the wood manufacturers scammed the code writers along the same lines that they did with plywood.

"Oh, dear--we need more tolerance on the sizes so we don't have charge more for precision to keep the wood at exactly the right dimension."

Then with the tolerances set a bit wider, the manufacturing process was adjusted to quite precisely make the smaller sizes to get more finished lumber from each log.