Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

OT - Electrical question.?

Posts

OT - Electrical question.?

#1

OT - Electrical question.?

Ray Carson in Lawrenceville, NJ

>I've never heard of this being done nor have I ever done this.......but

I'm doing some electrical work on the ole' homestead and was wondering if you can have (2)-two feeds or two circuits come into a multiple gang box?

Something tells me that this is a bad idea.

Signed,

Ray....scratching his head in NJ. ????

Re: OT - Electrical question.?

#2

Re: OT - Electrical question.?

wilbur

>I wouldn't do it. You could probably wire it up safely, assuming that it meets code, but think of 5 years from now when you want to come back and change the circuit again, and have to figure out what it was that you did.

Besides, gang boxes are cheap.

Re: OT - Electrical question.?

#3

Re: OT - Electrical question.?

NickB

>There was a fairly extensive discussion on this a week or so ago. The upshot was, yes you can do it, provided that two circuits are disconected by the same breaker (you feed the hot for each circuit from the opposite legs of a 220v breaker). That way the power is shut off to both circuits (rendering the entire box cold) if either circuit is tripped (or if someone goes to the box to shut it off). It's how I have the 110v outlets my shop wired (double gang boxes, one circuit has white outlets and the others are grey).

Hope this helps,

Nick

ps. Addy protocol-not a licensed electrician, but I've read a bunch and I've wire two shops and a remodeled kitchen.

Re: OT - Electrical question.?

#4

Re: OT - Electrical question.?

Bill Howatt

>I don't believe his question is exactly the same if he is talking about 2 separate feed cables (not 4 conductors in a common sheath).

In that case I believe it is OK and I quote part of Mark Mandell's corrected message on this:

" E. Even if you have a 4-wire cable, you shall NOT split it into two discrete circuits with independent breakers on each branch. The breakers MUST be linked/bridged. To use two independent breakers, the present cable must be removed from the service panel and replaced with 2 separately sheathed cables."

I have a box with 2 separate 120V circuits in it but I did put in a ganged breaker since I just know I would forget that there was a second circuit in the box. I do have one in my shop wired with separate breakers but since the box is exposed on the studs I have a warning written on the box.

Bill

Re: OT - Electrical question.?

#5

Re: OT - Electrical question.?

Howard Norman-Prescott, AZ

>Yes, there was a long thread on this a couple of weeks ago.

The facts are that you can do this one of two ways. First and easiest is to run a three wire plus ground from a 220 volt breaker in the panel, common white one phase to one outlet using the black wire and one phase to the other breaker using the red wire. Since the power is controlled by a 220 v breaker the power will be off both circuits when the breaker is unenergized.

The second way that would work and it seems closer to what you want to do would be to run two separate 110 v circuits to the box and have the two breakers connected with a cross bar so that when one is turned off the other one is automatically turned off.

The first approach above is fairly commonly done. I have never personally seen the second approach done but it would be safe also.

Howard

Re: OT - Electrical question.?

#6

Re: OT - Electrical question.? Response to Ya'll.

Ray Carson in Lawrenceville, NJ

>To all,

I'm sorry I didn't see the long post a few of you are referring to. Yes, I was wondering if you can run two 110 circuits into a double gang box. I understand the 220 and the 110 "systems" you and the others are describing.

I think I'm going to error on the side of "better safe than sorry" motto and figure out how to run power for extra loads I'm going to add. Possibly splitting up an existing circuit and adding a new one to handle the new loads and half the existing ones.

Thanks everyone,

Ray

Re: OT - Electrical question.?

#7

JL

Re: OT - Electrical question.? Response to Ya'll.

JL

>The answer is yes it can be done. Upon occasion, people put two circuits in a single box. I put 2 separate 120V circuits in a multiple outlet box. The inspector said that it was fine (as did the electrician who tied my subpanel into my main panel).

Just document what you are doing.

Re: OT - Electrical question.?

#8

I Also Have This

Mike Fitterling

>When I built my shop I ran one 120 volt circuit and one 220 volt circuit into one box in most locations. I did the wiring myself but had a licensed electrician inspect the wiring before I called the city. Both he and the city approved that arrangement. The 120 and 220 are distinct circuits connected separately to two different outlets in the same box.

Re: OT - Electrical question.?

#9

Isn't that how it's SUPPOSED to be done??

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>In kitchens at least.

All the kitchen outlets in my current house (Atlanta) and my previous house (Toronto) have two completely different circuits in each outlet. The top half and the botton half are on different circuits and are fed by two seperate cables.

Yes, that means if the circuit is tripped in the upper outlet the lower outlet is still live, so you wouldn't want to be replacing the outlet with only one circuit breaker turned off. Did I mention that's HOW i discovered that there are two circuits in each outlet? Ouch!

I thought that was the way it was supposed to be done (according to code and/or city regularions) when it comes to kitchen outlets. So that if you blow the circuit with the mixer, you can continue making the cake without heading to the garage to reset the breaker. I guess it's really so you can have the toaster and mixer plugged in to the same outlet box and run at the same time.

If it's a requirement for kitchens then I can't see why it wouldn't be allowed elsewhere in the house.

Of course I'm not an electrician, but can help stir up the pot here just as well as anyone ;)

Happy Woodworking!

Re: OT - Electrical question.?

#10

Re: OT - Electrical question.?

Carol - Strawberry, AZ

>Another approach to having more circuits to spread the load. I ran them around the wall every 4 feet at 52 inches high. Every other outlet is one the same circuit. Adjacent outlets are on different circuits that way. Doesn't take any more wire so speak of and safer for this amateur electrician who actually once worked as an electrician. But I just did what I was told there, no decision making on my part as to what was code or not.

Re: OT - Electrical question.?

#11

You'll Find them ALL over your house!!!

Rick Christopherson

>People are confusing this with other issues, but simply having multiple circuits in the same junction box is not only acceptable, but you will find this throughout your house. Every 3-way light circuit will span multiple junction boxes scattered throughout the house, and therefore will also span multiple circuits in the process.

My house has so many 3-way and 4-way lighting circuits, that if I couldn't have multiple circuits entering the same junction box, I would litterally have to have the entire house lighting on a single circuit, with bathrooms and one bedroom being the sole execptions!

You are fine doing what you suggest.

Re: OT - Electrical question.?

#12

Re: Isn't that how it's SUPPOSED to be done??

Dan Donaldson

>The way to stop the "ouch" is to have the two circuits on a common trip.

Re: OT - Electrical question.?

#13

Defeats the purpose

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>Doesn't that defeat the purpose of the dual circuits in each outlet?

I mean if you go and trip the breaker with the mixer because the dough is too thick, and it trips both circuits at the same time, then you can't just plug into the second outlet and continue.

You'd still have to go to the garage or basement to flip the breakers, and that delay could ruin your dough ;)

Happy Woodworking!

Re: OT - Electrical question.?

#14

Re: Defeats the purpose

DB

>If you trip the breaker with the mixer because the dough is to thick what will keep it from tripping the second time?

The code calls for 2 appliance circuits in the kitchen. There are a couple of ways to do this. One way is just to have two sets of conductors going to seperate outlets. The other is to use a multi-wire branch circuit into common outlets which requires the use of a common trip circuit breaker.

The idea is to allow the use of a couple of appliances (ie: toaster, coffee maker) at the same time without tripping the breaker.

Re: OT - Electrical question.?

#15

Re: You'll Find them ALL over your house!!!

DB

>Hey Rick

I believe you are confused. I believe that the type of circuits that Ray was refering to starts at the breaker and goes to the outlets, switches and /or lights, not the cables between boxes. Almost every box will have at least 2 cables going into it. The 3 and 4 way switches are just part of the many lighting circuits in the house.

Re: OT - Electrical question.?

#16

It Doesn't Matter

Rick Christopherson

>It doesn't matter what the purpose of a circuit is, you can either have two circuits in the same junction box or not. It's not prohibited by the NEC and I chose a common situation to make that clear. If you still feel that I am mistaken, please provide the NEC reference so I may update my information.

Re: OT - Electrical question.?

#17

The waffle maker

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>"...If you trip the breaker with the mixer because the dough is to thick what will keep it from tripping the second time? ..."

The waffle maker which is on the same circuit as the mixer on the other wall ;)

We can't be the only family (lots of kids) where we have a toaster, waffle maker, mixer, and hand mixer all running at the same time ;)

WHen you think about the dozen empty outlets in the living room behind the couches, etc, it makes sense that there are so many circuits in the kitchen.

Then again I know someone who spent $30,000 on a kitchen renovation and they eat out 6-7 days a week and cook maybe twice a month ;)

Happy Woodworking!

Re: OT - Electrical question.?

#18

Yes, we have TWO waffle makers running at once ;)

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>

Re: OT - Electrical question.?

#19

Re: Isn't that how it's SUPPOSED to be done??

Mark Nowicki

>In Quebec the common name for what you describe is "counter plug"

The circuit is supplied by a 14/3 wire (red, black and white). The circuit is protected by a doubled-up 15 amp breaker. You break off a little tab on the hot side of the plug to separate the two circuits.

When the breaker blows it is supposed to disable both circuits. If yours didn't, it was probably wired by a hobby woodworker.

Regards

Mark

Re: OT - Electrical question.?

#20

Re: The waffle maker

Dan Donaldson

>I had space in the panel, so when I redid my kitchen, every plug in the kitchen is on a separate circuit. Got tired of the microwave and the toaster tripping the breakers if they were on at the same time. ;-)

Re: OT - Electrical question.?

#21

Re: Isn't that how it's SUPPOSED to be done??

Bill Howatt

>Yes, AFAIK, kitchen outlets configured in that manner must have a breaker that trips both poles.

Now with the rule, at least in Ontario, that requires GFI within 6' or whatever of the sink, it means that 20A receptacles will be used which IMO are a poorer alternative than the split 15A ones which have a total capacity of 15+15=30A per duplex receptacle.

Bill

Re: OT - Electrical question.?

#22

Re: Isn't that how it's SUPPOSED to be done??

Dan Donaldson

>You could still do it if you used GFI breakers rather than GFI outlets, but the cost would go up significantly.

Re: OT - Electrical question.?

#23

Slightly different solution.

Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach

>When I was rehabbing this house, I put in:

  • the required two GFCI protected circuits
  • a dishwasher circuit (I think that's also required)
  • a separate disposal circuit
  • a circuit for the fridge (tired of having lights dim whenever the compressor kicks on)
  • a circuit for the microwave
  • a circuit for the range hood
  • a circuit for the range
  • and a circuit for the lighting.
All but the range (60A) and lighting (15A) were 20A circuits. What's that, nine?

Rex Cauldwell, Taunton Press author of electrical how-to books, says that the kitchen is the most complex electrical system in the house.

Rod

Re: OT - Electrical question.?

#24

Did you manage...

Jason Roehl in Mulberry, IN

>...to get a receptacle over every counter section, too?

Last fall, we finished up a house, where there was a small counter section at the edge of the kitchen area (next to a porch door), where there was no outlet, and the owner didn't want one because of all the switches already there (and lots of support studs in the wall so there was no room, either). So, to pass inspection, they put in a combo switch/recep, then changed it back as soon as the county inspector left. Crazy.

My aged kitchen has maybe two circuits in it, and I am amazed at how much stuff can run before the breaker trips. (No disposal, no dishwasher, at least she doesn't run on electricity).

Jason

Re: OT - Electrical question.?

#25

Isn't that ironic

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>The two house I lived in Quebec were not wired like that but the Ontario and Georgia house were. Isn't that ironic.

I did, in fact, live in 5 huose in Quebec but the first three I was too young to know anything about electrical circuits, etc.

Happy Woodworking!