Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

OT Question for a car Guy, About battery

Posts

OT Question for a car Guy, About battery

#1

OT Question for a car Guy, About battery

Barry Irby

>I have a Honda CRV. I have a Maglite rechargeable flashlight installed in the car. (use it in my work as a Home Inspector, Daily) I need for the flashlight to fully recharge so I hot wired it to a "live all the time" Lug in the fuse panel. I have don this in every car I have had for the last twenty years including my previous CRV. The flashlight pulls half and amp and has a smart charger that allows it to charge and then stop drawing power.

Two batteries in the car have died. The Dealer blames the flashlight. They gave me a new battery but refuse to warrant it. They last about 18 months. Does the flashlight hurt the battery or have I just gotten two poor batteries?

Re: OT Question for a car Guy, About battery

#2

Sounds like a "leak" somewhere...

John in New Mexico

>And they're really hard to find... I had a sticky emissions relay on a Toyota PU that would drain the battery overnight if I'd driven the truck long enough to get it to close the relay. Took weeks to figure that one out, and the mechanic I took it to early on was no help -- I suspect he knew it was going to be a time loosing proposition. I'd guess that has a lot to do with your dealer's position on this too.

Odds of getting two bad batteries like that are slim.

I'd suspect the flashlight too, IF you've had the car for several months before installing it with no problems. If you installed the flashlight right after buying the car, its possible there's a problem from the factory -- they make mistakes too. Kinda odd its killing the battery, though a discharge isn't good for a wet cell, it shouldn't kill a new one unless its quick enough to start a fire!

John

Re: OT Question for a car Guy, About battery

#3

Re: OT Question for a car Guy, About battery

Curly Smith

>How old is your rechargeable Maglite?

I'd consider two flashlight possibilities before I suspected something wrong with the car:

1) Is it possible that the flashlight batteries won't hold a recharge and are, thus, constantly recharging?

2) Is it possible that your smart recharger has failed and it's constantly recharging the flashlight?

The folks at Batteries Plus (or an equivalent store) should be able to tell you if there's anything wrong with the flashlight batteries, and sell you replacements if needed.

From your note you've used the rechargeable flashlight for over 3 years and killed two car batteries. Maybe it's time for a little flashlight PM? Or a new flashlight...

Re: OT Question for a car Guy, About battery

#4

Thanks John and Curly and more info.

Barry Irby

>I do change out the Magpie batteries from time to time. When I notice the lights "yellows" too quickly during the day, I get a new battery. But, I had not really considered that as a possibility.

One piece of info I left out is that sometimes I notice the ignition key gets hot. Almost to hot to touch. I have started to watch for it, because it does not do it all the time. The steering column is a night mare of wiring and has the "stalks" with the turn signals, and wipers and lights on hem sticking out. So, I am trying to figure out if the key is hot when the head lights are on or if the wipers are on or what. Or just at random. Last time I drove it was in daylight and the key was not hot.

Also, a few months after I got the car they recalled it and change some sort of module in the steering column. (air bags????) I drove in or the appointment, the guy walked out and took the bottom off the column and change some sort of plastic module with a number of wires connected. Took about five minutes. Now I am wondering if that is when all this started.

Getting two bad batteries in a row does sound unlikely, especially since they were 18 months apart. No chance they came out of one bad batch.

Re: OT Question for a car Guy, About battery

#5

Re: Thanks John and Curly and more info.

Bill Howatt

>You can remove the hot cable from the battery and put a DC ammeter between the terminal and the cable and see what the draw is with and without the flashlight in various stages of charge.

It is not unheard of to have a relay get stuck in the closed state which will run the battery down. Even though you don't mention the battery being dead when you try to start the car the cycling isn't good for a battery.

Bill

Re: OT Question for a car Guy, About battery

#6

Re: Thanks John and Curly and more info.

Barry Irby

>After about a year and a half, if the car sat for a couple of days the battery woudl be dead. If I ran it frequently it was OK, but in both cases they reported tha battery had a bad cell.

Thanks Bill.

Re: OT Question for a car Guy, About battery

#7

Re: OT Question for a car Guy, About battery

Larry in NW Ohio

>Barry Could you disconect what you put on for the flashlight and see if that has anything to do with it. It would mean charging your flashlight some other way or use some other light for awhile, Good luck Larry in Ohio

Re: OT Question for a car Guy, About battery

#8

Re: OT Question for a car Guy, About battery

GolfSteve in Calgary

>Hi Barry,

This may not be related to your problem at all, but I have a 2003 CRV and it has the weakest battery I've ever experienced. I still have the factory battery in the car (70,000 km on vehicle), and the battery will go dead if I park with the key in the auxiliary condition for 1/2 hour. I don't know if the factory battery is sub-standard or if my battery is getting a bit old, but I certainly don't trust it.

Get thee to a battery shop and put in the biggest battery you can buy. The Honda factory supplied battery has quite a small capacity (and according to my manual, Canadian vehicles get bigger batteries than US vehicles, so yours may be even punier).

I've always liked Sears branded batteries (Die-hard Gold; minimum 800 CCA), but they were bought out by Kal-tire a few years ago and I haven't tried their branded batteries.

On the other hand, my 2000 diesel golf has a huge battery (because of the diesel glow plugs). The battery is a "maintenance" type battery vs. the maintenance free sealed units, and I have found that if I keep the water levels topped up, it is a great factory battery. Seven years on and the battery seems almost as strong as new.

Re: OT Question for a car Guy, About battery

#9

Re: Thanks John and Curly and more info.

Curly Smith

>If your key is getting hot then you have a serious electrical problem. It could be a stuck relay, it could be a short somewhere in the wiring harness, it could be a problem with the flashlight, or it could have something to do with the way you wired the charger into the fuse block.

I'd disconnect the charger from the fuse block and see if the problem continues (either by the key getting hot, the battery draining after the car sits over the weekend, or connecting an ammeter and seeing a current drain with the car and all accessories turned off). From what you've said my guess would be that it's not the flashlight. However, I'd remove it just to rule out the possibility.

If your key is getting too hot to touch then you need to start worrying about an electrical fire. Rule out the flashlight and then take the car to the dealership.

Re: OT Question for a car Guy, About battery

#10

Remove the flashlight connection now

M. McNamee

>If there is an electrical problem, or worst - fire, this is a perfect excuse for the dealer to blame you.

Re: OT Question for a car Guy, About battery

#11

Re: OT Question for a car Guy, About battery

Barry Irby

>Thanks, as I mentioned I have had this or a similar flashlight in every car I have owned over the last twenty years. I think you are right. These are crappy batteries. I don't really have any complaint with the dealer. this is my third battery in about 90,000 miles. They replaced the factory one with a similar one about 18 months ago and they have done it again, but this time refused to warrant it. I pan to continue to track the hot key problem and when this battery craps out buy the biggest one that will fit. There is plenty of room in the tray for a bigger battery. They will have kept me in batteries for more than a 100,000 miles by then, so now the problem is trying to sort out the hot key thing.

Re: OT Question for a car Guy, About battery

#12

Re: OT Question for a car Guy, About battery

Woodenfish

>The maximum ignition off draw for most vehicles I know of is 35 milliamps. Most modern cars I work on time out and fall asleep in a matter of a minute or two after the key is removed and the doors are closed to a 10-15 mA draw which basically is the clock.

Your flashlight battery charger certainly seems to exceed that spec. You might want to change that power source back to a key on only and invest in a second set of rechargable batteries. Automotive batteries are not really designed to swing from being charged to drained continually just as the automotive charging systems are not designed for deep cycle type marine batteries.

Re: OT Question for a car Guy, About battery

#13

Thanks, Wonder what they do....

Barry Irby

>on Cop cars? This is baically a Cop flashlight and cops all have them in their cars, or similar ones. Do they beef up the electrical systems? With all the radios and stuff I bet they do.

What I should do is have two flashlights and put on in a house charger and rotate it out to the car every day. And I actually do have a house carger and a spare flashlight, but to cycle it through the house and back to the car everyday would require discipline and organization. So much easier to beat the car battery to death.

Re: OT Question for a car Guy, About battery

#14

Yes...

Jason Roehl in Mulberry, IN

>...they do typically beef up the electrical systems in police cruisers. Dual batteries and a high-output alternator are the main upgrades. Alternators these days are absolutely as small as possible to save cost.

Jason

Re: OT Question for a car Guy, About battery

#15

Re: Yes...

Sonny Asburry

>I am a retired Police Officer and the last 16 years a part of my job was vehicle maintance and operation. We had those flashlights in all 24 vehicles. We drove about 400 thousand miles a year with this fleet.

Some of these vehicles were not driven for days at a time: Crime scene van, investigator cars that were assigned to individuals, etc.

We did not do anything different to the electrical system (when a battery was replaced, it was with the largest one possible) and to my knowledge, we had no problems with this type trouble that you are having.

Sonny in Martinsville, Va.