Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

Is this allowed?

Posts

Is this allowed?

#1

Is this allowed?

Sawdust Everywhere!

>Hi all, fairly new woodworker here. seeking adivce ;)

John's post about his new OArouter/shaper got me thinking about this electrical connection.

I have a 3-1/4hp router and want to mount it in a router cabinet. Would like to connect ut up to a dedicated shopvac for dust collection.

So, I have several 220V (1 phase) electrical connection in the shop. Would it be illegal (non-code specified) or unsafe to wire the router to one pole of the 220v and the shop vac to the other pole of the "double circuit"?

I was thinking of installing a 220v magnetic switch upsream from the recptacle box so that I could theoretically turn both router and shop vac on/off with just one press of the button.

Any comments guys?

Thanks,

Julian

Re: Is this allowed?

#2

Re: Is this allowed?

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>Well, you will need a neutral wire (using the ground is a no-no to my knowledge), but other than that I think you should be OK. Appliances like electric ranges and clothes dryers use both 110 and 220V within the appliance, so I don't see why not do what you plan.

In any case, I'd wait for a qualified person (which I am not) to respond, just to make sure...

DC

Re: Is this allowed?

#3

Maybe

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>But only if your 220 circuit is 4-wire [black, white, red, and bare ground]. You can split a 220 circuit into a pair of 110's, however, you MUST ALWAYS always have an independant ground for the circuit. Therefore you cannot use the bare ground wire in a 3-wire cable (b/w/g) to replace the commom lead. You also must have separate recepticles for each branch as separate circuits may not "share" a recepticle or device. DO NOT try to wire a sepatate "circuit" to each side of a single duplex in a small box, even with the "bridge" pieces removed; you're asking to get fried that way.

If you have a 4-wire cable on your 220 line, I would recommend that you go to the service panel and change the 220 breaker out for a pair of 110 breakers of the correct amerape. That way, each of your circuits has an independant measure of safety. With a single 220 breaker, if a fault occurred in half (say the shopvac shorts out), the other side of the breaker would prevent a trip and the entire circuit would remain hot, likely causing a fire and serious personal injury!

You idea for a single upstream rated switch can function to interrupt a 220 line, however if you change the breakers to a pair of 110's you cannot use one switch device to interrupt two circuits; it's that "no sharing" thing again.

Be careful, that stuff will kill you if you give it a chance!

mm

Re: Is this allowed?

#4

Re: Maybe

Ted Wong

>Mark, Why is wiring a single duplex with two different circuits a no-no? I was replacing an outlet in my kitchen last week and it was wired that way. I'd never seen anything like it before but I'm not an electrician either. Anyways I just replaced the outlet and wired it as it was. so far everything is okay. Is the procedure against code?

Re: Is this allowed?

#5

Re: Maybe

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>Mark, I am not sure of the code on this issue, however your statement that one side of a 220v breaker will prevent the other from breaking if there is a short is wrong. It may be a problem because BOTH circuits will be interrupted when one doesn't have a problem but it will trip if any overload is present on either leg. Many

appliances utilize a 220V breaker and feed 110V to the light - some window air conditioners used a 110v to the air circulating fan etc. These circuits are protected through the 220v breaker. I would also question your statement that it would be dangerous to wire one phase to each receptacle in a circuit - don't know if it is code but can't see where there would be any danger - especially if both circuits were under the control of the single 220 breaker. Again I am not sure of the code for the issues so am not arguing it should be done - just like to be practical about the actual effects of the wiring / breakers.

PS: I worked over 39 years as an Engineer at a facility that produced electrical controls (appliance timers) and switches - UL & CSA approved, and was responsible for wiring automated machines. I also contracted as a side job and wired commercial and residential.

Re: Is this allowed?

#6

Re: Maybe not

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Larry, I'll be happy to stand corrected for, while I've fair experience with home electrical systems, the "rest" of what I "know" comes from what has been told to me by various electricians over the years. A fault on only one of the hot leads should, indeed, trip a 220 breaker, but I was told that where a "split" circuit is involved, it may not properly trip the other branch, hense the advice to split the breakers as well. I'll certainly defer to your superior knowledge on this one!

|;-}}

Re: Is this allowed?

#7

Re: Maybe not

Jim Moore

>Gentleman, I believe the Code issue with having two circuits on one device has to do with Code only allowing one circuit on a "strap". That is the metal part of the device that receptacle uses to fasten to the box. If you think about it, it only makes sense. Someone not familiar with the wiring might kill the power to the top receptacle and wrongly assume that the whole device is now dead. I am at lunch so I don't have a Code book in front of me, but I am sure this is illegal. And it does not make good common sense anyway. Always think about what might happen if someone else other than yourself attempts to work on an electrical wiring.

Re: Is this allowed?

#8

Re: Maybe not also

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Ted, see my reply to Larry. I'm not a licensed Sparky, have never played one on TV, and usually steer clear of any motel with "Express" in its name.

Are you sure you had two discrete circuits wired into different sides of that single device? I have seen kitchen outlets where one receptical in a duplex was wired as part of a remote switch leg separate from the other, but the ones I've seen were still always part of the same circuit. Again, I've been "instructed" that two circuits can't share a device; reason is to make sure someone doesn't put 220 into what should only be a 110 device. The toaster might work at lightning spreed, but only once; just before the kitchen is toast! |;-}}

Just to be double safe, I'd carefully check to make sure you have two circuits in there, and, if so, then check with your local electrical inspecter about the issue. There really should not be a need to wire thing that way. If he/she says it's fine, It's Fine, and I'll stand corrected [again]. |;-}}}

I'll double check this question in my area and will look forward to hearing what you find out so do let me know either on this board or by e-mail [drop the "2"].

mm

mm

Re: Is this allowed?

#9

Re: Is this allowed? *LINK*

peter smith

>Try this product they work great just for this type of problem. Can't go wrong fo r $30.00.....

Regards.


http://www.woodcraft.com/family.aspx?familyid=5855

Re: Is this allowed?

#10

Re: Maybe

Rick Christopherson

>Because this setup is using a single 2-pole switch as well as a 2-pole breaker, there is nothing wrong with having both halves of this multi-wire circuit on the same yoke (i.e. split duplex outlet) if that is what the OP wants.

However, if this is done, then the outlet must be a 20-amp outlet (assuming 20-amp breaker), and not the normal 15-amp outlet that is permitted on most other 20-amp circuits. The breaker must also be a 2-pole breaker.

As the original poster described this setup, it is acceptable and legal with the only caveat that the circuit must be 4-wire to include the neutral.

Re: Is this allowed?

#11

Re: Is this Magic?

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Peter,

Can I assume from looking at the picture that the thingy plugs into both sockets of a duplex outlet? There's no cord shown and all I see is where to plug in the tools, not how to get electricity from the power company to the box. Don't think it's pulling 15 amps out of the air, right? |;-}}}

mm

Re: Is this allowed?

#12

Re: Is this Magic?

peter smith

>Back of box has 1 Three prong plug that works with any standard 15Amp, 125 Volt house outlet.

Re: Is this allowed?

#13

Re: Is this allowed?

Sawdust Everywhere!

>Peter,

I thought of that gadget too. But if my riyter is drawing almost 15A (it's a 3-1/4 hp), and the vav will pull at least 4.5A (Ridgid 5hp shopvac), then won't it trip the circuit breaker orcome so close to the current limit even with a 20A circuit?

Thanks

Re: Is this allowed?

#14

Gotcha

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>So then it does cover up both outlets in a duplex receptical. Would make sense to do so for safety, but I bet there will be those that will plug it into the end of an extension cord; hopefully one of more than 16ga. wire, and hopefully on a circuit using 12ga. wire in the wall.

|;-}

Re: Is this allowed?

#15

Re: Maybe

sawdustdan

>Maybe Im not understanding something...but even if there is a seperate neutral that should not be used to carry the current of 2 circuits.

Re: Is this allowed?

#16

Option No. 2

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Your current wiring for the 220 line can be used for a single 110 circuit by changing out the 220 breaker in the service panel for a pair of single breakers at say 20amps. You wire the hot black to one, the white to the common box bar, leave the ground where it belongs, and have the unused breaker switched off for future use. If you have a 4-wire circuit, simply dress off the red lead inside the service panel as an unused wire. You need the unused breaker to cover the hole in the panel and prevent contact with the main box buss.

Then you can put a single duplex outlet, rated for 20amps, in the wall box and your 110/20+amp switch upstream. Now you're all legal and safe with plenty of juice under your original proposal!

mm

Re: Is this allowed?

#17

Re: Is this allowed?

Larry in NW Ohio

>Sears has had that same kind of device for years. I`ve been using them for 5-6 years and they work great. Also they DO NOT cover the whole receptical unless you want it to. Larry in Ohio

Re: Is this allowed?

#18

Re: Maybe

Jerry Nicholson

>The neutral will never carry more than the current in one leg. If the current flow in each leg is the same (ignoring reactance) the current in the neutral would be zero because the two hot legs are 180 degrees out of phase with each other.

Jerry

Re: Is this allowed?

#19

Re: Maybe not also

Kneale Brownson in Northern MI

>What about where one of the outlets in a duplex is switched, such as to turn on a lamp?

Re: Is this allowed?

#20

Re: Maybe not also

Dan Donaldson

>They are usually on the same circuit.

Re: Is this allowed?

#21

Re: Is this allowed?

Peter Smith

>i checke it out last night...I-socket is the same it does not cover both plugs unless you want it to.....

Re: Is this allowed?

#22

Re: Is this allowed?

Peter Smith

>you may want to send an emial to the copmpany with your specs the will tell you if it works... e-mail: dgc@dgcproducts.com

Re: Is this allowed?

#23

Re: Is this allowed?

Sawdust Everywhere!

>Thank you for all your input guys.

Will mull about it and let you know what I eventually do.

Re: Is this allowed?

#24

Maybe Again - MUST READ!!!!

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Well, Mr. Everywhere, I spoke to my local Code Dude and an electrician who I trust, and here's what I got back:

A. The 4-wire cable is, as before, absolutely REQUIRED for your double 110 setup.

B. You can switch the 220 circuit cable "upstream" with a Single-Throw-Double-Pole switch as long as it is disconnecting both hot leads of a single circuit and the switch is rated for the same or greater amperage as the circuit breaker.

C. You can have 2 circuits wired to separate halves of the same recepticle PROVIDED that both hot leads are controlled by a single breaker IN THE SERVICE PANEL, i.e. 2 breakers that are "bridged" like a 220 breaker, and the conductor tabs on the duplex ARE REMOVED to separate the 2 sockets from one another.

D. If the duplex recepticle being used is the only one on the circuit, it's rating must match the total amp load of the circuit breaker. So, if the 220 circuit's breaker is a 20 amp, then the duplex receptical at the end of the line MUST be rated for 20 amps.

E. Even if you have a 4-wire cable, you shall NOT split it into two discrete circuits with independent breakers on each branch. The breakers MUST be linked/bridged. To use two independent breakers, the present cable must be removed from the service panel and replaced with 2 separately sheathed cables.

I think that corrects all the incorrect information I posted earlier.

mm