Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

What projects do you want to see in Mags?

Posts

What projects do you want to see in Mags?

#1

What projects do you want to see in Mags?

Brian in Brighton

>I noted below that I am sick of seeing boxes in magazines too often. Are you? What kind of projects do you want to see more of in the magazines you subscribe to? Here is my list:

1) More classical large projects, dining sets and such spanning multiple issues.

2) Less knick-knack things.

3) More projects with carving accents.

4) More ways to use wood wisely.

5) More interviews with woodworkers and what they do and their tricks.

6) More highlights as how WC is the best woodworking website and how we all think Ellis is a demi-god :-)

Brian in Brighton

Re: What projects do you want to see in Mags?

#2

Re: What projects do you want to see in Mags?

Ken Oakley-Sunny St. Cloud, Fla.

>Long ago I let all my subscriptions to magazines expire. Reason-the Internet and websites such as this.There is more knowledge ,skill and talent on these sites then all the magazines. Of course after 67 years of woodworking both as a profession and a hobby bordering on a passion I don't find much new. Just recycled things.

Re: What projects do you want to see in Mags?

#3

Sorry to dash your hopes.....

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>....but you may never get your wish. The magazine publishers know the bottom line and that is to appeal to the broadest demographic possible. It's a dollars and cents issue. They use focus groups to determin the types of projects that get the broadest appeal.

Publishers feel that a magazine focussed on more advanced or unique projects is not financially viable...or at least they are not willing to take that chance. I have some personal insight in this subject.

Tom

Re: What projects do you want to see in Mags?

#4

Re: What projects do you want to see in Mags?

Mark in B'ham

>I would like to see more interesting designs. A lot of the time, I'm more interested in the pictures of pieces from shows that don't have any instructions on how to build them. I don't get a lot from the step by step stuff.

Re: What projects do you want to see in Mags?

#5

Re: What projects do you want to see in Mags?

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Afternoon Brian,

I did what Ken did. A friend bequeathed me scores of FWW and AWW mags from way back in the black and white days. These are depressing to read because of well thought-out layout and comprehensive content presentation. Another thing I don't like about the old mags is the glaring lack of advertising on every page, as well as an idiotic reverence and reliance for the proper use of hand tools. We have come so far so fast, and left that old stuff way back in history. About the only thing about the modern wood working mags which makes me feel better is throwing them out.

George

Re: What projects do you want to see in Mags?

#6

George - tell us what you REALLY think - please!!

Howard In Toronto

>

Re: What projects do you want to see in Mags?

#7

Well Howard,......................................

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>If the editorial staff of the current batch of wood working rags paid less attention to the bottom line and improved magazine content, people like me may just improve their the bottom line by increased newsstand and subscription buying. I believe a successful bottom line is perfectly consistent with well developed content, and cite VICTORIA SECRET as a prime example. :<)

George

Re: What projects do you want to see in Mags?

#8

Re: Sorry to dash your hopes.....

Ted Wong

>Pretty much right on target Thomas. I used to be a project designer for a fairly well known magazine. The projects always tend to be intermediate to novice in scope and are geared towards expediency in construction. I think the editors were afraid of long drawn out projects for fear of our readers loosing interest or patience. Loss of readers means loss of revenue which ultimately means someone is out of work and the company doesn't make money.

Re: What projects do you want to see in Mags?

#9

Re: What projects do you want to see in Mags?

mdclor

>So am I hearing this correctly, we should all cancel our magazine subscriptions and sent the annual subscription fees to Ellis? :-)

Merle

Re: What projects do you want to see in Mags?

#10

Re: What projects do you want to see in Mags?

Brian F Philipp

>Great thread. I vote for more large fine furniture projects and fewer boxes, trinkets, keepsakes, etc.....

- more tables, beds, chests, armoires, more curved furniture pieces

- of course, more bookcases, shop storage, and more jigs

- how about an article on furniture/cabinetry molding fabrications, so I can stop wasting money at the big box stores on their limited, expensive selections.

Just my 2 cents,I only subscribe to 3 mags now, down from 6. Kept my F. Woodworking, Wood, and Woodsmith subscriptions.

Brian

Re: What projects do you want to see in Mags?

#11

Re: Well Howard,..................................

Ken Oakley-Sunny St. Cloud, Fla.

>Nothing recycled in that publication

Re: What projects do you want to see in Mags?

#12

I think they should mix it up a bit.

Chad Pearson

>When I started gettting into woodworking I read a lot of magazines,...as well as this website. As my skills improved I have found less and less use for magazines. I used to buy most all of the wood rags. Now I don't subscribe to any. About once a month I get a cup of coffee at the bookstore and page through them all to see if there is a project inside that might be worth the price.

I understand that the family handyman is unlikely to publish complicated projects as it just isn't their target market. I would think however that some of the ones geared for those with more experience would try to mix in a complicated project or two next to the easier ones. If necessary make it span a couple of issues.

Re: What projects do you want to see in Mags?

#13

I'd rather see them on a Forum like this

Dave Morris

>The problem for experienced woodworkers with most of the woodworking publications currently offered to the masses has been covered in the above posts. True, we were all beginners once, and many of us still are. That said...

What if a woodworking forum started having monthly projects on it's web site? Start to finish, clear instructions, plans, input from the members on techniques and options in construction... kinda like the way a thread evolves here, but as a semi-official "Forum Project". The members could vote from a list of projects, and the members contribute to the collective Think Tank of knowledge. The projects could run the gamut of complexity, from beginner to experienced, with *no* additional cost to the running of the forum. Then they can be filed in a Forum "Projects" section for future access.

Gee, maybe it could even be called an "Articles" section, or something similar? ;-)

Dave--- tongue firmly planted in cheek

Re: What projects do you want to see in Mags?

#14

on dumb-down measurements..

Mike King, Sherwood Park, AB

>I watch magazines' dumbing-down rates. When a mag I subscribe to gets too dumbed-down I let 'em go.

I also watch the seasonal build projects. When I've got 40 or so designs of, say BBQ carts, or deck planters, then I collect hod rod mags for a while..;-)

Re: What projects do you want to see in Mags?

#15

MIMF used to do something like that *LINK*

Phil Joines Krum,TX

>Music Instrument Makers Forum that it. They used to ,and maybe still do, have instrument building ?classes?. A bunch of people would decide to build say a Les Paul guitar. A knowledgeable person would run the class. Each week they would post instructions and pics for the next part of the project. The students would ask any questions, and send pics if necessary, they had and do that part. It continued until the project was finished. The students paid some like $150 for the course. The forum got half and the instructor got half. There was a restricted access part of the forum for all this to take place.

I haven't been there in a couple of years, no aptitude for instruments (or music).


http://www.mimf.com

Re: What projects do you want to see in Mags?

#16

WHAT ARE THE MAG'S OBJECTIVES?

Greg Deavers

>I sub to FWW, WOODWORK, WOOD, SHOP NOTES (NO ADVERTS) mostly for "Ideas". I pick through the news stand for the others that I find articles that I want to read, etc. I hate having to skip through numerous pages to "FIND" the scattered pieces of my article. I know ads are required - BUT ARE THEY? Heck I pay for Shop Notes, and they are (for me) very informational. I am leaning toward picking up Woodturner Mag as well.

However, I am SICK AND TIRED of getting several mags all running the same old worn out articles (ex: HOW TO TUNE MY SAW), and they all run that article in various reworked iterations. I have STACKS OF MAGS with that exact same article!

I have followed numerous articles "start to finish" and made projects from their step by step instruction. Oddly enough, the MAJORITY of projects I have finished have been from WOOD MAG. Personally, I never read articles on "outside or lawn" furniture..... The Mags, cannot cater to everything for everyone.

Easy projects are something I can GET IN and GET OUT with the time I have available to "accomplish" something. Although, I would love to spend (for me) months working on an early American repro of a Highboy, I DO NOT HAVE TIME at this point in my life. However, when I am on the road, I READ ALL OF THESE ADVANCED ARTICLES I CAN FIND! Woodwork, one of my subs, presents Multiple issue projects. I WANT MORE INTERNET SUPPORT FOR THE ARTICLES IN TERMS OF VIDEO, PHOTOS, ETC!!!

Some sites are beginning this, but WHY cant we get more internet access for increased in-depth woodworking support?

I understand that MOST mags have to cater to the newbies, as I are still one, I am slowly becoming more sophisticated in terms of craftsmanship.

Anyway, just the rants of a salesman.... hope this helps.

You guyz are great - Keep up the good work!

Re: What projects do you want to see in Mags?

#17

Re: What projects do you want to see in Mags?

Stephen Kirk in Quakertown, PA

>The things I would like to see aren't so much projects as techniques. Very often I may want a technique which would work well on my current project, but I can't remember if it was the barrister bookcase, pencil post bed and ottoman with footrest that I saw the technique used in. I know this would hurt some magazines, as at the end of the article you haven't made much, but some magazines do this and it works well.

There was a post above about supporting more internet content, and I agree whole heartedly with that. Going along with the idea of techniques, full video (with accompanying pictures and text) could really make some of these things approachable.

Also, add in more text around the gotchas on projects and techniques. Areas where people commonly go wrong, or even where the staff went wrong building their projects. Mistakes are the single greatest learning tool ever.

I think more articles on design would be welcome as well. Here's a good one for the magazines, have articles on design that reference where different techniques could be used. Heck, you could get people looking for back issues then. For instance, this type of project would use rail and style with floating panels - see issues such and such for how to do this with router, table saw, hand tools, etc. Single types of projects could have lots of techniques referenced.

And to keep George happy, perhaps they could have more models in the pictures.

Re: What projects do you want to see in Mags?

#18

Re: Just like B&D tools

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>Doubt if you see much change. This is a lot like complaining about the current (lack of) quality of old tool names like Black & Decker and Skill. For every one of this group that buys quality tools - probably 500 to 1000 people go to Wally world or the borg and buy a $14.99 drill or $29.99 saw - Same thing occurs with the magazines. There are a lot of very experienced woodworkers on this site - and some a little less - like me. However for every one of us there are probably 500 beginning or novice woodworkers. I remember when I devoured the magazines when they arrived - several years ago. Now I still subscribe to a few - still find an article or two a month that interests me - but I've often read (and done) many of the projects and or tips - If you are and have been active on this site for long, odds are you have also been there. I'm not sure there are enough of us to support a magazine that has only pro - or semi-pro projects... The novice woodworkers would not buy a mag detailing a Highboy project or similar. I probably wouldn't have 20 ~ 30 years ago! The internet and specifically this site offer far more and better advice IMHO. Although I still subscribe to some Mags FW & PW and WWJ, I try to donate at least more than my mag subscription to Ellis every year. Shop shots has more ideas on design than any rag published, I can ask and receive the best tool reviews available anywhere, and I can solve any woodworking problems here. I will continue to receive mags as I will never stop learning till I die, but this is my primary education / enjoyment source on woodworking.

Re: What projects do you want to see in Mags?

#19

Well Said Larry!

Greg Deavers

>However, not possessing the casework & Finishing skills for a project like a Highboy, I would LOVE to get a hold of a mag with an in depth project of a High boy, or any really technical project, etc. In fact, as a future project, I purchased Norm's High, and low boy projects. They are awesome!

I don't have access to "Mentors" except for WC! I would love a magazine (or website) that would do a detailed project like some of the workbenches I see in books like "WORKBENCH" that have been done. One at the level of craftsmanship like the one that Ellis built.

As my next project, because I NEED it in order to work future projects. However, It scares me off the project because I don't clearly understand well enough the "tail vise" design, and implementation, etc.

So for me, I am not comfortable with getting that much money in materials and slam to a complete stop and find out I didn't "do it right", etc. Still working toward it though....

Thanks for your comments!

Re: What projects do you want to see in Mags?

#20

Re: What projects do you want to see in Mags?

Jim Toews - Walla Walla, WA

>I don't feel anyone should cancel (or subscribe) to any magazine based on someone elses impressions or to donate the saved revenue to any specific cause, however I do believe that if a person uses a service/website regularly and gains from that use they should concider donating at least the avarage cost of a magazine subscription to that site. I subscribe to many WW mags, and I try to remember to donate to this site as well, since I feel I get at least as much out of this site as from any of the magazines to which I subscribe. I can't afford to donate as much as it is probably worth in terms of knowledge gained as compared to any magazine, but I do try to do what I can.

As to what projects I'd like to see published, I agree with whomever it was that wanted more major, multi-issue projects. I seem to remember FWW doing a three issue project ( a highboy, if memmory serves) a while back; I wonder if they lost any subscribers over it. I rather doubt they did. I for one really appreciated the added complexity of the project and loved the added depth they could go into on it.

Just my 2 cents worth.

Cheers!

Jim

Re: What projects do you want to see in Mags?

#21

Re: What projects do you want to see in Mags?

arw01

>Currently I subscribe to:

Wood, Popular Woodworking, American Woodworking, Woodworker's Journal.

I will buy at the stands Woodsmith, Shop Notes, Woodworking, and Woodwork.

Number one thing I would like to see, is an expose or three on where our trees are going!

How can a chinese company buy our cherry logs, ship them to a lumber yard, cut them to fit containers, ship them around the world, ship them to another lumber yard, cut them to lumber, ship them to a furniture factory, make a piece of solid cherry furniture, break it down, ship it in a container to the port, ship that container to our port, ship that to a warehouse, ship that to a retailer, and sell that piece of furniture for LESS THAN I CAN BUY THE RAW LUMBER!

Now I just completed the group by that a couple of regulars on this board poo-poo'd for others to join into. Out here on the west coast cheapest rough cherry is routinely over $6.00 a board foot, yet I can buy finished cherry flooring INSTALLED for under $4.00 a sqft. Somebody explain that one.

The group buy split over 1500 bdft of lumber, mostly being cherry, from a small mill in West Virgina. I bought a lot of shorts in the #1 and #2 common ranges because I find I need VERY FEW boards over 3' long. Occassionally a board over 5'. My total was $805 for over 350bd ft with shipping. $685 for lumber, and $120 for my portion of the shipping.

Second I would like some magazines to go out and find hardwoods in some areas of the country besides the east coast. And not at local high profit lumber retailers. On a fall trip to Seattle, Wa. I stopped at Crosscut Hardwoods and Comptons. With my trusty tape I measured out the boards I was interested in, the prices were fair. However the bd ft on every single board was rounded up significantly! Therefore I did not buy. Prices that were fair became pretty outrageous after that roundup.

I would like to a see a follow-up to the investment in the Costa Rica lumber farms there.

Would like to see them go out to some arborist firms and get them to "give them" some of the wood. I called several locally and could not get a single call back. They are doing something with that wood, and I think it's a chipper out back. They CHARGE THE HOMEOWNERS for dump fees, and then I KNOW they are not taking it to the dump. Several times I have stopped while they chop up a conifer that would make some interesting lumber and they won't even give you a piece!

Pen turning is one of the bigest rages in years, but I don't recall any of my current magazines show how to do the fancy inlays, or even center bands! I would like to know if Monte Blanc pen refills write better than $3.00 for 20 pen refills from Office Depot. At $10.00 for a refill, I'm not buying one unless I KNOW it's a much better instrument.

I really LOVE the shop make overs, but they seemed to have stopped doing them.

For multiple issue stories, I agree reproductions of old styles would be a wonderfull addition. However, I believe most of us don't have a house that furniture would fit in! A highboy would be great fun to build, but I would have to either give it away, sell it, or move!

How about adapting a Jessem Routr'Slider to a home made WOOD style router fence?

A story on the woodwhisper from youtube would be interesting for a whole lot of folks. Buy that might compete with themselves.

A horror story of accidents section, perhaps a few fingers or cuts could be saved by example.

Stories or how not to be so cheap, or how being cheap REALLY cost you in the end.

A tutorial on sketchup, another one of the hot new items out there.

Now I think the internet and small scale woodworking DVD's are taking over the advanced portion of the market. I am sure that the instructors of woodworking are making much more money running classes to teach better skills than they ever made producing furniture. 6 or 7 students at $500 to $700 each every couple of weeks pays a very good wage in a years time. I took a Rob Cosman class with about 10 of us in it. At $700 each for tuition, that was $7000 gross to Rob and his helper. The class was easily 80 hours of instruction that week, and I loved every minute of it. Having access to that type of talent for under $10.00 an hour was worth every penny.

I'd like to see more magazine articles about the schools, and multi page issues about each day's project in depth.

Alan

Re: What projects do you want to see in Mags?

#22

Just proof read them!

Joe Piotrowski - Chicago Burb's

>why place measured drawings in a magazine if they always wrong.

it forces me to buy a new magazine that may not want but I need for teh correct dimensions, etc.

Re: What projects do you want to see in Mags?

#23

Re: What projects do you want to see in Mags?

Jim Moore

>Wouldn't it be great if the magazines could just take one project that is more advanced, and publish it - possible over several months. They could even put a section in along the lines for "more advanced woodworkers." I think not only would this provide entertainment and insight for those wanting more advanced projects, but it would serve as a guide for those less advanced woodworkers. It would encourage them to try new things, make new projects that challenge their skills, and most importantly, give them a greater level of woodworking to shoot for. As it is now, you only go so far, then there are no more skills or difficult projects to learn from.

Re: What projects do you want to see in Mags?

#24

Re: Just proof read them!

Tim Caley - North Little Rock

>Did you proof read your message before posting? Or was that done on purpose?

Re: What projects do you want to see in Mags?

#25

Re: At some point...

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>...we go past what a magazine is really good for, and get into a more durable, more focused publication. It used to be a book - could now be a video- or web-based publication, but the intent was/is a more focused audience, and a longer shelf life.

The better ones don't show up unrequested in the mailbox, in my experience.

And the content has applicability for decades of users.