Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Are there different grades of Melamine?

Posts

Are there different grades of Melamine?

#1

Are there different grades of Melamine?

Stephen Roth, Chatham NJ

>I know this is heresy, but I am making a set of closet built-ins out of Melamine. The stuff at my local lumber yard and the borgs has a coating that is so thin it looks like paint. (The chipping on the edge of the new pieces sitting on the store shelves is terrible.) I was wondering if there were different grades of this stuff. Also, can you get MDF covered Melamine instead of particle board? I don't want to laminate it myself because the price and effort for that is almost the same as doing it in hardwood.

PS: I already bought mt Forrest Duraline AT blade. Wow, is that thing sharp!

Re: Are there different grades of Melamine?

#2

Re: Are there different grades of Melamine?

Keith Newton

>Without seeing pictures of your options, it would be hard to judge. However, a ragged edge is common for melamine. Usually there are areas of very sharp overhanging blade like edges that will cut your hands if you slide it along unexpectedly. Be sure to knock them off with coarse paper before you rip it, or it may bump you away from the fence, causing a bad first cut.

On the good side though, it is normally 49" x 97", so the bad edges can be cut off.

I never use the factory edge on the finished product.

I don't feel like I need to feel apologetic for using a material like melamine or other chip / byproduct materials if this means that there is less demand for what is left of our old-growth forest.

Re: Are there different grades of Melamine?

#3

Re: sort of

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

>It comes in carnation white and lilly white and one of the two has a thicker paper. I'm not making this up. I used to do work for a customer that specified the thicker one, unfortunately I cant remember which is thicker.

My supplier recieved their melamine from a plant in Lodi california so other plants may have diferent specs or diferent names for their colors. A good salesman will be able to tell you the thicknes of the melamine paper that is laminated to the particle board. I think the diference was only about .020" but for the particular application it really did make a huge diference.

Robin Corell

Re: Are there different grades of Melamine?

#4

Re: Are there different grades of Melamine?

frank shic

>melamine is a perfectly acceptable sheet product. it's much more stable than plywood, does not have voids and has consistent thickness from sheet to sheet. i've built three floor-to-ceiling built-ins all out of melamine and i think it's just the greatest - even more so now that i found a place that'll actually deliver it which offsets it's main disadvantage: weight. make sure you use a zero clearance insert with your blade to minimize chipping on the side facing down on the tablesaw. once you start getting chipping on the top surface, it's time to resharpen the blade.

Re: Are there different grades of Melamine?

#5

I am also considering colored MDF *LINK*

Stephen Roth, Chatham NJ

>Has anyone used this stuff? It is full-color-through MDF.


img

Design MDF

Re: Are there different grades of Melamine?

#6

I find it REALLY hard to believe

Derek

>that any company would use old-growth lumber for anything but premium lumber or veneer. That would be really stupid unless the wood was very poor quality to begin with. They would make much more profit with a premium product. Lumber is a commodity product and the companies which harvest it are very well aware of how to make the most profit from it.

On the bright side, we are growing 5 board-feet of lumber for every one harvested in this country.

Re: Are there different grades of Melamine?

#7

Re: I find it REALLY hard to believe

Keith Newton

>Derek, I was not suggesting that anybody was going to turn good logs into melamine, only that anything done to use lower grade fiber is a good thing in my book, in that it can lessen the demand of higher grades.

Re: Are there different grades of Melamine?

#8

Re: I am also considering colored MDF

frank shic

>stephen, have you ever tried cutting or routing MDF? DUST GALORE if you don't have a decent dust collection system and still quite a bit of leftover even if you do! that being said, i've used it to construct five piece raised panel doors and the stuff does machine well but since i usually paint my doors after sanding them down (yes, even MORE dust) i don't see a real need to color it. now if they could just make a version that looked just like the popular woods...

Re: Are there different grades of Melamine?

#9

Re: I am also considering colored MDF

Stephen Roth, Chatham NJ

>Frank:

How did the machined edge of the colored MDF look. If it is ragged, then I might as well go with the standard stuff and paint it. I assume it doesn't machine like solid surface material, but I was hoping to at least get a clean edge.

Re: Are there different grades of Melamine?

#10

Re: I am also considering colored MDF

frank shic

>stephen, i haven't used the colored MDF but the regular stuff has a fairly rough edge. you'll need to seal it with either oil based primer or something like drywall spackle and then sand it lightly.