Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Tablesaw choice?

Posts

Tablesaw choice?

#1

Ellis Walentine

Tablesaw choice?

Ellis Walentine

>An old friend called me yesterday because he's remodeling his home and needs a tablesaw and jointer. He likes the look of the Grizzly 3-hp cabinet saw, but he has a line on a two-year-old Delta Unisaw for $1200, and he wonders which saw he should get. Anyone care to discuss the pros and cons of these two saws?

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: Tablesaw choice?

#2

Slight side track......

Barry Irby

>I have a friend who is always buying and selling tools. (not a profession for him, he just likes wheeling and dealing on them and buys a few for himself) He told me a few years ago you could buy and older Unisaw for $600. I could ask him again, but it might pay your friend to shop around a bit. OTOH this might be ancient saws that have three phase motors and shafts that were bent from being thrown off a WWII air craft carrier. Still might pay to check with a used tool dealer.

Re: Tablesaw choice?

#3

Re: Tablesaw choice?

Larry in NW Ohio

>Ellis I have had the Delta Unisaw for about 3 years now and really like it. Can`t say to much about the grizzly, but did look at them when I stopped at The Springfield, Miss. and didn`t care for them, especially compared to my Unisaw. Probably a little prejidice. Larry in Ohio

Re: Tablesaw choice?

#4

Re: Tablesaw choice?

Grant Smith

>While the Grizzly may be every bit the saw that the Unisaw is these days, I'd opt for the Unisaw. If your friend may one day sell the saw when the project is done, the Unisaw will hold its value better to the masses, IMHO.

I would also choose the Unisaw because most jogs are made to fit it perfectly, while I am not sure (and someone can correct me if I'm wrong) that the Grizzly is laid out as universally.

That said, I'd take the griz with a good fence long before the Unisaw with a bad fence, though a 2 year old saw will most certainly have a great fence.

FWIW,

Grant in Iowa<---bought a used newer Unisaw a few years back and is very happy.

Re: Tablesaw choice?

#5

Re: Tablesaw choice?

Ken Oakley-Sunny St. Cloud, Fla.

>I used my first Unisaw in high school shop in 1948. In 1956 I started my career as a modelmaker-patternmaker and almost every shop I worked in had Unisaws. One shop did have a Grizzly. I purchased my own Unisaw 10 years ago w/ the 52' Unifence. No Contest. I'll take a Unisaw over Grizzly anyday. The Grizzly will get the job done but-----

Re: Tablesaw choice?

#6

Re: Tablesaw choice?

Mike Fitterling

>I have heard nothing but good reports on the Grizzly cabinet saws. If I was in the market for a new saw I would probably buy one myself (but the 12" with the riving knife). I think he could buy a new Grizzly for about the same price as the used saw. Either, I'm sure, would be good saws. I, personally, would look for an older Unisaw or equivalent; age makes little difference in these saws and older Unis were actually made in the USA if that makes a difference to your friend. I have found a 5hp Unisaw in the recent past here for about $800 and I bought my Jet cabinet saw for about the same, so better deals can be had if you are patient. Of course, if this Unisaw has all sorts of extras, like an overhead guard, sliding table, etc, etc. then it would blow comparisons out of the water.

Cheers,

Mike

Re: Tablesaw choice?

#7

Re: Tablesaw choice?

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>Ellis,

One of the reasons I chose the Uni was because parts, add-ons etc are so readily available and universally designed for the Uni.

My Griz owning friends tell me that service is spotty. Sometimes ok and sometimes not good at all. I have no personal experience there. But aside from hearing an occassional Delta service misfortune I have had excellent Delta service.

Just two more things to consider.

Tom

Re: Tablesaw choice?

#8

Alan Young

Re: Tablesaw choice?

Alan Young

>Ellis,

I have a 7 year old "Top of the Line" Grizzly Contractor Saw. It has served me well. I also have a 30 year old Unisaw. If I had no saw at all and someone handed me the Grizzly Cabinet Saw your friend is considering I'd take it and run( well call a bunch of friends and get them to lower it down into my shop) But the Unisaw is still the one. I will note that the shop fox fence that cam with the grizzly was a great fence. It's pluses were that it has a higher profile than the Biesemeyer I bought to go with the Unisaw. So I can rip thicker stock with a set of feather boards clamped to the fence. The Shop fox fence was dead on out of the box and kept it's alignment well. The Biesemeyer is fine-Advantage is that you can remove the entire fence quick as a wink when the saw need serve as something other than a cutting tool....

Alan

Re: Tablesaw choice?

#9

Re: Tablesaw choice?

Jesse in New Mexico

>I would advise your friend to make an offer for the Unisaw at a lower price, after inspecting it.

Re: Tablesaw choice?

#10

Re: Tablesaw choice?

Paul Dwight

>I have the Griz 3HP cabinet saw, the 1023S, with the Shop Fox Classic fence. Great saw, I've been extremely happy with it. It runs smooth, retains its settings/adjustments, cuts very accurately and has plenty of power. The only change I made to my saw was to add a 6" dust port on the back of the saw, in line with where the blade spits the saw dust. The 6" port does a much better job keeping the cabinet free of dust than the standard 4" port that was mounted on the side of the cabinet.

For those who wondered about compatibility of accessories, the Grizzly's arbor and miter gauge slots are Unisaw-standard -- anything that runs on the Unisaw's arbor or in its miter slots will fit the Griz just fine. Aftermarket splitters are widely available for both the left- and right-tilt versions of the Griz.

The Griz will be the last tablesaw I buy (unless I win the lottery and buy a Euro-style slider).

$1200 for a used Unisaw with 52" fence in good cosmetic and running condition is pretty much in line with what I see on the used tool market in Phoenix. I guess that makes it a fair price. It might be two-thirds the cost of a brand new Unisaw from Amazon (depending on shipping costs on the new saw and accessories included with the used saw), which is more than I personally would pay for a used tool. I must be in the minority, though, because folks seem to buy used Unisaws for similar prices all day long.

If your friend is nervous about buying the Grizzly, he might consider a Jet cabinet saw -- Amazon is offering the Jet w/ 52" Bies-style fence, 2 cast iron wings, table board and legs for $1500 ($1400 if you include the rebate from Jet).

Any of these saws -- the Unisaw, the Griz or the Jet -- would probably make your friend very happy and serve him well for many years.

Hope this helps. -- Paul

Re: Tablesaw choice?

#11

Re: Tablesaw choice?

Rob Stokes in North Vancouver

>Ellis:

If the Unisaw is two years old it's part of the off-shore design which means the components are lighter in order to reduce costs and compete with the other brand names. I'd also guess most of the castings are also machined green these days, though that's not the end of the world.

Personally, I'd stay away from a design that's trying to "slim down" to compete and would go with a design that's the underdog trying to give the best bang for the buck and topple the big guys in the mean time.

If the Unisaw was older (pre-Rockwell days) I'd be on it like a dirty shirt, but personally, I'd not spend $$ on a newer Unisaw - I just don't think they have an edge anymore and in fact would be concerned that they've been engineered close to the cost imposed lower limits.

Rob

Re: Tablesaw choice?

#12

Re: Tablesaw choice?

Hal Smith

>I have an "old" Enlon which is the predecessor of the Griz 1023 line(Griz bought them out as I understand). Don't know just how old, but old enough that it was made in Taiwan instead of China. Solid as a rock. Passes the nickel on edge test when started up. Has a Bies fence and 39"+ of rip capacity. I "stole" mine from the Woodworkers club in Green Valley, AZ for $300. If your friend could find one of these, he could probably get it at a good price and have a dandy saw. Unless it goes to h..l in a hand basket, it will be my last saw.

Re: Tablesaw choice?

#13

Re: Tablesaw choice?

Ray SW Ohio

>I passed on a 3 HP Grizzly cabinet saw for $250. It was well used and missing the miter guage. Didn't need 2. I have the Grizzly 1023 and have no complaints. My 2�.

Re: Tablesaw choice?

#14

Re: Tablesaw choice?

Ray Binnicker

>I have had my unisaw for almost 20 years. I don't know if its fair to compare the new-vs-old. I've heard some horror stories about the quality of the new Delta products. The new Grizzly may be on the same level with the new unisaws.

Ray

Re: Tablesaw choice?

#15

Re: Tablesaw choice?

Ed O'Neill

>Have had my Unisaw for 5 years with a Bies fence. Love It!! Ed

Re: Tablesaw choice?

#16

Re: Tablesaw choice?

McKay Sleight

>I explain to my students that your needs and your level of skill dictate what quality saw or tool you are to purchase. As a beginner, the Griz may be fine. As a journeyman, the Unisaw would be the minimum saw that I would ever consider. Over the years I have worked and maintained Davis/wells, Boise/Crane(sp), Unisaw, Laguna and Powermatic. I like the jet for the value and versatility, but I would not have one at a school. I have a Griz. edge belt sander, but because it is only used once-in-awhile, it is ok. I would not use a Griz. TS in the school, but for hobby use it would be fine.

Here at school, they are making us replace all of our TS with the saw stop. Our district alone had 22 saws replaced. The dealer here in Utah is selling the used saws with a new 1ph motor for $600 or less. Most are Unisaws. Salt Lake City districts have replaced even more, so I would assume that there are a number of used saws available. I have no idea what shipping would be.

Re: Tablesaw choice?

#17

Wow - 22 Saw Stop?

Verne in Northeast NJ

>That's a lot of tablesaws. It would seem to make sense from a liability standpoint.

I wonder if other tablesaw manufacturers are paying attention to this?

Re: Tablesaw choice?

#18

Re: Wow - 22 Saw Stop?

McKay

>In response to your comment, I believe it to be a knee jerk reaction to replace better quality saws with the sawstop. I like the saw stop ok, but again, I do feel that if people are properly trained and will LISTEN, then saw stop is not necessary. In five years, we will see if the stupid electronics cause problems as the electronics on my powermatic and woodfast lathes.

Re: Tablesaw choice?

#19

Aah but..

Bri in Mtl

>..we know they WON'T listen, don't we...

Re: Tablesaw choice?

#20

Re: Aah but..

Bart Leetch

>I always get a charge out of these discussions.

Guess what saw the Grizzly G1023 series is a copy of?

You guessed it the Unisaw.

There are many of them in commercial shops I know of at least 5 that have been in continous use for several years in commercial shops with very little or not problems at all.

Having said that I have a 1940 3 phase Unisaw why because I bought it for $250.00 & have about $900 in it including a new "Grizzly" single phase 3 HP motor that bolted right in & cost 2/3 of what the Delta motor would have it also has a Shopfox Biesmeyer style fence with the fence set for 40" to the right & 24" to the left & the Grizzly box style motor door. I don't believe that the current Unisaw castings & cabinet are of the same quality that my saw is. Delta got it right in the first years producing these saws my saw is living proof of that.


img

Re: Tablesaw choice?

#21

Re: Aah but..

Bart Leetch

>Oh I forgot the cost includes the extension table & the router table & M12V router & shop built fence built from Wood magazine plans.