Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

What this place needs...

Posts

Re: What this place needs...

#26

Re: Why then..

Bill Howatt

>Woodcentral has a very large population interested in woodturning and the high-volume of posts really would get in the way.

I also never visit hand-tools, carving, trivia, etc.

There is indeed a benefit from categories but for a lot of us there is certainly no benefit in overdoing it.

BIll

Re: What this place needs...

#27

yet another disagreement, a better solution

Bill Tindal, E.TN

>I allot enough time to WC to check two Forum topics. If the OT's were separated I would never look at them.

A better solution is to clearly title what the post is about. Now that would save everyone time.

Re: What this place needs...

#28

Yes the point...

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>Woodcarving and wood turning are "specialties" in the sense that those involved in these disciplines tend to focus more on these and less on general woodworking. Same for hand tools, some can't be bothered with them, others love them. But in all these "specialty forums" communities develop, with many people participating in more than one. I don't follow turning and carving, but participate actively in the hand tool forum.

But in the end, specialty fora exist because there's sufficient interest in that particular field for people to have their own "sandbox". OT postings are a totally unrelated issue. Keeping them included and not separate just helps develop the community spirit.

In other fora that I participate in, I never check the OT section when it is kept separate from other postings. I'm glad to see them included here.

DC

Re: What this place needs...

#29

Why not make in a menu option?

Jim Rahbe, Bedford, TX

>Ellis,

How hard would it be to add a preference option that would just ignore OT posts, or a button like �frames� selection that would just allow you to turn them on or off. As long as �OT� was in the original post subject line, the post and all responses would simply just not show up, unless you wanted to see them?

Personally, I like them, but I can see how they could be annoying to others..

Jim R.

Re: What this place needs...

#30

Re: OT yet another disagreement, a better solution

Paul Leuba

>Clearly specified Subject lines would be a real benefit to all participants.

Embedded OT's do not cause a significant time delay if they are clearly marked in the subject line.

Paul in Hunt Valley

Re: What this place needs...

#31

Good points, Neighbor Larry!

Jason Roehl in Mulberry, IN

>

Re: What this place needs...

#32

Mark OT and clearly define subject; read or skip

Joe Pack

>

Re: What this place needs...

#33

Nice Catch Tom !

Scott in Eastern Iowa

>

Re: What this place needs...

#34

Yes?

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>

Re: What this place needs...

#35

Oh, Mark the verb, not Mark me ;)

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>

Re: What this place needs...

#36

YAWN..........ZZZZzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz

MountainMan

>don't care!!

Re: What this place needs...

#37

Ellis Walentine

If I had a Perl guru...

Ellis Walentine

>...he/she could probably figure out how to do that. It would be a great little feature. But, without one I'm sunk, and the guy who wrote our software originally has gone on to other things.

I'm intrigued by a "hack" like this though, and I may propose it to the keepers of the flame over at the site devoted to this software.

Thanks for a good suggestion.

Ellis