Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

What this place needs...

Posts

What this place needs...

#1

What this place needs...

Bri in Mtl

>...an OFF-Topic forum.

At this point in time there are more OT posts than woodworking posts.

Probably been brought up before but when one has to scroll through the headings looking for ww'ing related posts...I dunno, doesn't seem to fit the purpose of a quote unquote "woodworking" forum.

Don't get me wrong, and I know I can go someplace else if I don't like it but there are quite a few ww'ers in here that I admire and enjoy their posts and work. It's the volume of OT posts one sees, especially if you haven't visited in a few days. And FWIW other ww related forums usually do have an OT forum.

Just my thoughts.

Re: What this place needs...

#2

Many times over the years...

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>has this issue been discussed... If I recall correctly the consensus was to keep the OT posts where they are, as it gives participants the sense that we do other stuff than woodworking in our lives. That, and the fact that there are specialists in many "OT" categories among our midst, gives us a sense of community that is very valuable.

I for one probably would not bother browsing a separate OT forum, yet I enjoy for the most part the OT posts. In the end, all it does is make the person not interested in OT topics scroll a bit more.

My $0.02,

DC

Re: What this place needs...

#3

I disagree

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>

Re: What this place needs...

#4

I very strongly disagree! I like it like it is..

Mike in Paradise

>The Canadian woodworking forum has been ruined in my opinion by the excess moving and classification of posts and I almost never read it anymore! I wonder who was responsible for that!

Re: What this place needs...

#5

Re: I very strongly disagree! I like it like it is

Bill Howatt

>I agree. Having the OT posts in a separate area did nothing to enhance that forum at all. I also dislike the finishing questions being put into their own forum as well.

I would much sooner just ignore the posts I don't want to read based on the subject line. Too bad there wasn't a way to get people to provide meaningful subject lines instead of things like "A question", "what would you do", " Is this the best way". BTW I just made these up, I didn't go looking for acutal examples but you get the idea.

I consider this forum more than just WW and am happy to help out with other problems my forum-friends have and if I can't help I certainly learn from them.

Bill

Re: What this place needs...

#6

Another thought on the other forum

Bill Howatt

>I just re-read my post and I think I have only gone onto the other forum's Finishing forum a couple of times at most. So for the entire time the new format has been in place I have learned virtually zero about finishing from it. If I had a problem I could indeed go on it but I find I learn a lot just by grazing through the posts!

Bill

Re: What this place needs...

#7

Disagree

Howard In Toronto

>I just pass by the posts that aren't relevant to my skills, thoughts and awareness.

Creating a separate OT spot just diminishes the community feel of this forum.

So..... I disagree..... strongly.

My 2C.

Howard

Re: What this place needs...

#8

Re: What this place needs...

Howard Norman-Prescott, AZ

>As Denis has said the subject of a OT forum has come up many times over the years. I much prefer the present format. I certainly don't read all of the threads that are here but I find the OT threads some of the most interesting and informative.

Howard

Re: What this place needs...

#9

Steven Antonucci

I thinkit's fine as is.

steve antonucci

>I don't read every post, but I do read quite a few OT's just to get a sense of what makes people tick.

Steve

Re: What this place needs...

#10

Partially agree there..

Bri in Mtl

>...with the too many woodworking sub-topics. I never saw the point of that. Though you can usually simply click on "New Posts" and see all posts since your last visit.

Re: What this place needs...

#11

Why then..

Bri in Mtl

>...are there Turning, Hand tools, and carving sub-boards?

Re: What this place needs...

#12

Ahhhh...

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>But you will see OT posts in these boards too...

DC

Re: What this place needs...

#13

you forgot to include "OT"

Tom Sontag - St. Louis

>

Re: What this place needs...

#14

Not the point...

Bri in Mtl

>...but you knew/know that ;)

Re: What this place needs...

#15

Ever visit WN's OT forum?

Tony Sade (Charleston, WV)

>The inane heavily leavened with the venal. Not that folks who frequent Ellis' island would be at all inclined to sink to those depths, but why even think of heading in that direction? The OT posts here are like TV channels for me--if I don't wanna watch, I turn on something else.

My $.02.

Tony

Re: What this place needs...

#16

Re: What this place DOESN'T need - long...

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>are people second guessing Ellis> :~) I really feel he has a very acute vision of what this forum should be. He has done an exceptional job since starting this site - both attracting and keeping "regular members" and visitors. I know he has conducted surveys to help him establish the style and layout of the site. With his background as an Editor of a very successful (when he was there) woodworking magazine, he has a good knowledge of both layout and content. I for one - and know many agree - would like to keep this wonderful site just as it is --- If Ellis decides he wants to change / improve the site, I will continue to support him as any changes he makes will be well thought out and will please the majority of the regulars and visitors. I really enjoy the OT's when I have time to read them. If I'm busy I can ignore them as MOST people properly identify them as Off Topic. I do visit the hand tool, turning, carving and other forums as often as I have time for, but subdivisions were necessary as most people do not have time to read all the text. This way OT's on each site are identified. Prior to the division all the separate forums were on topic and that did create almost endless pages of messages - I could not read them all. Now I read the general messageboard and the others when I have time.

Re: What this place needs...

#17

I rarely visit those forums either...

Mike in Paradise

>I don't think that i have ever visited the hand tools or carving forums here and have only gone into the turning forum 3-4 times a year.

I probably miss a lot of stuff that would interest me but I cannot be bothered going to a variety of forums...

Re: What this place needs...

#18

Re: Aren't we doing what each of us wants

Guy Kroll

>Take a look at all the replys to this one simple thought. I think we are doing exactly what Ellis had/has in mind. A open discussion with others of a similar like. We are all wood workers at heart but with in our lives, we have other things going on. If you look at most of the non wood working questions/post, they somehow relate to everyone of us. Sure they may not involve a piece of lumber or some fancy new machine, but they sure do bring us all together and keep us knowing that we are not alone in our everyday lives.

I like it just the way it is.

Just my .02

Guy

Re: What this place needs...

#19

Re: I very strongly disagree! I like it like it is

Rob Stokes in North Vancouver

>In fairness Bri, there were (and are) other persistent and contributing factors to the demise in quality of that CDN forum.

I wonder though if some of this has to do with the actual forum layout? On this forum, I prefer all the messages bundled together. I use the preview pane and set it up to show "new messages since my last visit". I find it extremely efficient.

But on the other forum format it's more of a segmented way of thinking and the other format does a pretty decent job of it.

I know when we set up the "other" other CDN forum we gave a lot of thought to exactly this issue and ended up with a separate OT area, but with the exception of a separate turning forum, elected to keep all the subcategories of woodworking in one pot. To date there's been zero complaints...

I like this place for it's dependability and comfy "arm chair" feeling. Like some others I rarely venture to the other forums (over there, on the left) here on WC and that's a tribute to the way this place is set up. One stop shopping.

Rob

Re: What this place needs...

#20

Re: I disagree.

Al Stokka - Cambrige, Iowa

>

Re: What this place needs...

#21

Oops!

Rob Stokes in North Vancouver

>woops! In my last, read "Bri" but pronounce it "Mike".

My apologies to both..

Rob

Re: What this place needs...

#22

Sometimes I like to...

Jim Dillon

>... buck the establishment (becoming more rare these days 8-)), but in this case Brian, I have to go with the majority. I really enjoy some of the OTs and have learned a lot from the very experienced folks out there. And as Tony said, if one doesn't like the "channel", just move on to the next topic. While I must admit that it does take a bit of time to go through all the posts if you have been away for a day or so, that is the price to pay for Ellis running an ever increasingly (it seems from the number of posts and new posters) popular web site. I also think (maybe wrongly) that a woodworker is probably at the other end of that OT post and is looking for an answer to something important to them. And many woodworkers are into home-improvement type projects as well, so I (as a home-improvement type of guy) find those type of posts valuable. For now, I think there is a good mix of OTs and woodworking posts. If that ratio were to drastically change, then I would view things differently. For now, I think Ellis is doing a great job piloting the good ship WoodCentral.

Jim

Re: What this place needs...

#23

Ellis Walentine

As someone mentioned....

Ellis Walentine

>...we've been around this block a few times before and this is where we've always ended up, not that that is not subject to change. I appreciate Larry's confidence in my vision, such as it is, but it's really your collective voice that calls the shots around here. Personally, I lean toward the less-variety-is-best solution most of the time, because I really do believe that; but I am open to anything that works for the majority of you.

When Jim Cummins and I were just getting started with WoodCentral -- it'll be nine years ago this October -- we debated how many forums to have. Jim was an advocate of variety and I took the opposite position. I didn't want to confuse people or make them hop around to several different forums to read all the latest posts. That's one of the reasons we picked the amorphous term "Messages" as the name for our main board.

As a couple other folks mentioned, off-topic stuff is part and parcel of any community. I tend to keep on topic most of the time, but when I need to know about deer fencing, guess where I post? The "OT" designation is a real time saver for me, too, because I know at a glance that those posts aren't going to be about woodworking.

It's good for you to bring issues like this to the table, Bri, so everyone can join the discussion. That's always been our mission here and it always will be: it's all by and for you.

Cheers,

Ellis

Re: What this place needs...

#24

Partially Agree With Everybody

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>

Re: What this place needs...

#25

Re: I very strongly disagree! I like it like it is

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ontario

>Hi Mike,

I had some problems at first and was not happy when the CWW was reformatted, I was not comfortable with the change in the look or it�s mechanics, I have always liked the way it appears here on WC. But with some time and realizing a different view I slowly became comfortable with it (still not 100%). It's also a very common format for most forums now. If you think the CWW is segmented you should see the Pen Forum I participate on, there are spaces on that forum I have never explored.

Like others I find this format my first preference, I enjoy being able to see the whole page at a glance and select the posts I like to read or skip.

Now, knowing how much work goes on behind the scenes I respect what takes to keep a public space moving along smoothly, they can not be Everything to Every one, those that don't care for what they are reading or the direction often move somewhere else to find others who enjoy what they like.

In response to Bri�s initial post I like having the OT on the main page by the way, I find I post OT's and know there are kind helpful people who will respond here. What I have seen on some forums with dedicated OT sections are a tendency to sometimes become Rant focused, not always factual or helpful...just what I have seen.

Take care,

Jim