Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

Kitchen Countertop Material choices

Posts

Kitchen Countertop Material choices

#1

Kitchen Countertop Material choices

Dan Manturi

>Hello. Got some good feedback here on my kid's Mahogany walls in his new home - I'll try again on redoing kitchen counters. He is not on a big budget but does not want Formica - I actually think laminate is underrated, but it is no longer fashionable. We need to be cost effective. I hear bad things about Corian's durability, and Granite and soapstone are quite expensive. Tile is a maintenance pain (I have it!). He doe not want butcherblock.

I hear good things about Stainless steel and also polished concrete - never saw that though.

Any ideas would be most welcome.

Invaluable forum!

Dan M.

Re: Kitchen Countertop Material choices

#2

Re: Kitchen Countertop Material choices

Ted Wong

>Stainless steel would be my choice if I could afford it. Concrete is a durable material but is high maintenance (frequent waxing) and the possibilities with it are limited only by your creativity. The downside of fabricating a concrete countertop yourself is the time and space commitment. Not to mention the expenses especially if you plan to grind it and polish it. There are a couple of books out there on the topic I'd check out if you're truely interested.

Re: Kitchen Countertop Material choices

#3

Re: Kitchen Countertop Material choices

Jim Dillon

>Morning Dan,

While I am partial to corian (having used it for over 10 years; and yes, I realize it is no longer the fashionable thing to have), it is hard to beat laminate for good value IMO. Rather than write it off, you might want to check out what is now available - the selection is far more extensive than what it used to be. And with the addition of a nice wood edge trim, it can look pretty spiffy. Regarding corians durability, we've had absolutely no problem and our counter includes a corian sink. It is recommended to run hot water into the sink before dumping boiling water into the sink, but that is no big deal. Plus corian is easy to clean, repair and no continued maintenance (sealing) is needed. Plus it "feels" good. Granite, marble, slate etc. are in style right now but I have no direct experience with them so I won't comment. Good luck.

Jim

Re: Kitchen Countertop Material choices

#4

Re: Kitchen Countertop Material choices

Tom Stockton

>Check the big box stores for prices on stone, they sometimes run some pretty good deals .

Tom

Re: Kitchen Countertop Material choices

#5

Re: Kitchen Countertop Material choices

JackLane

>Dan

Take a look at Quartz....DuPont Zodiac, CaesarStone etc.

Lots of my customers have been buying this and it seems to me to be a superior product. It works/installs just like granite although it doesn't have the pourousness that granite has. The granite installers I know say it doesn't break as easily as granite but I personally can't confirm that. Reports are it's much safer (bacteria) and doesn't have to be sealed repeatedly. It's a little pricey, but no more expensive than Corian or higher end granite. I'm a cabinet maker and sell them all...HPL, SS, granite etc. If I had new cabinets going into my house this is the product I would buy.

On the other hand, I agree with you about high pressure laminate. It's out of style, but there's no question it's the best overall value. Now don't go tell any of my customers I said that :-) All the best

Jack

Re: Kitchen Countertop Material choices

#6

How about two surfaces?

Curly Smith

>Granite and soapstone are indeed pricey (don't know about the manmade stuff - quartzite?) and can be cost prohibitive if the entire kitchen is done. How about using the pricey stuff in the active areas and a nice wood surface in the low traffic areas? Most of my countertop doesn't see much use outside of a tabletop for eating and unloading groceries. It doesn't really need the durability of stone.

Re: Kitchen Countertop Material choices

#7

Where did granite get this reputation for porosity

John in New Mexico

>Seems like I see that mentioned in every discussion.

Sandstones are porous, marbles and travertines will etch and stain. Granite (other igneous rocks included for the sake of simplicity) is zero maintenance. Salesmen tell you to seal it- they're just covering their posteriors out of ignorance.

That said, I also like Corian & related products for the ease of building in seamless sinks and dish-drains. Manufactured stone products (like Silestone) are crushed rock or glass epoxied together, and they also have their place. Probably aren't as easy to break as granite, but granite isn't that easy to break anyhow. They make some excellent looking substitutes for stones that actually are porous- like sandstones and some volcanics- that coincidentally, you never see put to use as countertops.

Laminates are nice and a reasonable price if you can find them "off the rack" at the local borg. I can't say as I was impressed the one time I priced a custom laminate (price was 3/4 of the granite price).

John

(Geologist and bain of countertop salesmen :) :) :) )

Re: Kitchen Countertop Material choices

#8

Re: How about an edging of hardwoord...

Al Stokka - Cambrige, Iowa

>...and a work surface of tempered hardboard (Masonite�)? When the hardboard begins to look tacky, just replace it.

Hey, if it's good enough for a workbench...

Al

Re: Kitchen Countertop Material choices

#9

Re: Kitchen Countertop Material choices

Dan Manturi

>Lots of suggestions here. Me? I'd go with the Laminate for now. Saw some Corian today and it actually looked pretty nice. Will price some of the composites and balance against Corian and Laminate. My kid has champagne taste, and will soon find out that, as a new home owner, Beer starts tasting real good...

Thanks all!

Re: Kitchen Countertop Material choices

#10

concrete

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

>I've made a couple of concrete counter tops. They are inexpensive in materials but heavy on labor. the posibilities are endless as someone already mentioned. My recipe looks like honed limestone or honed slate depending on the color. I use an acrylic polymer and viny coated choped fiberglass which allow me to make a countertop that is 1" thick. I make it in a mold and can incorperate a bullnose or ogee edge detail and I also cast the hole for the sink and fawcet. I have a grinder/polisher but you can get satisfactory results with a ROS and standard hook and loop paper. not really necessary to go past 400 or so.

If you are truely interested in concrete look at the books and feel free to contact me for more info.

Robin Corell

Re: Kitchen Countertop Material choices

#11

Re: Where did granite get this reputation for poro

Jim Dillon

>Morning John,

OK, I'll bite. As a geologist, are you saying that a "hard" natural stone like granite - when used as a countertop - does NOT benefit from a yearly sealing? Are the hundreds (possibly thousands) of web sites touting the advantage of preventive maintenance (sealing) for granite (and other natural stone surfaces) all been drinking from the same Kool-Aid and are leading us astray? Just trying to understand your viewpoint.

Jim

Re: Kitchen Countertop Material choices

#12

Re: concrete

Dan Manturi

>Thanks much. I think it sounds very interesting. The labor part is a little scary. The older I get, the more my time it worth - and the less I have of it! However, I saw a concrete countertop on a TV show, not in person, and it did have a certain look that was impressive, but that was on TV..

Thanks again.

Re: Kitchen Countertop Material choices

#13

Well, yeah...

John in New Mexico

>Sealing granite is roughly like sealing stainless. There are hard natural stones that will benifit from sealing- like sandstones. There are also granites and other igneous rocks with lots of little fractures that would benifit from sealing, but they'd probably make lousy countertops (break easily). It won't harm any counter to seal it, its just a pointless endevor with some.

John

Re: Kitchen Countertop Material choices

#14

Re: concrete

ScottS

>I was thinking about concrete counters, so I took the time to make a 2'x2' test slab. I'd suggest anyone thinking about trying to make their own concrete counters do the same...

While the materials can be inexpensive, they often aren't. If you want a fancy color, interesting aggregates, or need to start with white cement rather than grey cement prices start to add up quickly! As do the costs for the specialized tools (mixers, wet grinders, vibrators) that you'll inevitably want to buy or rent to help with the construction.

In the end, I found that concrete stains easily and requires more maintenance than you might think. I divided my test slab into a couple of different test sections and sealed each one differently. I then spilled common kitchen liquids (wine, vinegar, lemon juice, Coca Cola, etc) on each section and watched as all but one of the sections stained (admittedly: some sections took longer than others to stain). The one that didn't stain at all had multiple coats of sealer followed by a coat or two of wax; more maintenance than I'd want to deal with on a regular basis!

Re: Kitchen Countertop Material choices

#15

Not really...

Ryan Stagg - Cincinnati

>John, you're really generalizing on a topic that has many, many facets.

Some slabs marketed as 'granite' require sealing, others don't. In my experience, the truly bullet-proof ones aren't really granite.

Absolute black granite comes to mind. It won't oil-stain, etch, and is very hard, but it isn't even granite - it's gabbro or dolemite. Sealers on this surface can actually make the surface look bad - because it sits on top and forms a bad-looking film.

Other stones are extremely porous and need to be sealed or oil and wine (and other things) will leave very visible stains.

Saying 'no granite needs to be sealed' is like saying 'all marble is bad for kitchens'. You just can't generalize an industry with so many choices.

And I'm sure as Jim might be able to tell us - even a given stone can very *greatly* in porosity from sample to sample. Including many true granites. Getting a sample from your slab and doing the old 'ketsup/wine/oil' test is key.

Re: Kitchen Countertop Material choices

#16

I think you meant diorite...

John in New Mexico

>Dolemite is a sedimentary rock, similar to limestone, but with magnesium substituting for some of the calcium.

Most true granites will react to sealer as you describe with the gabbro (black granite), as they are very impermiable. Most black granites I've seen sold as countertops and tiles are more correctly called diabase.

If you can find a polished igneous rock that will be stained by common household products, I'd love to see it.

John

Re: Kitchen Countertop Material choices

#17

Re: Not really...

Jim Dillon

>Ryan (and Jessie),

What I understand, from my very limited reading, is that "granite" is indeed very varied, very hard, yet still porous enough to absorb (not adsorb) 0.1-3% water depending on the type of granite. Polished granite (like a countertop) is said to absorb roughly 30% less water. Not a lot of water to be sure (compared to more porous materials), but enough to lead me to conclude that "sealing" might provide some benefit and is worth doing. However, because granite is so hard and only has minimum porosity, a PENETRATING-type sealer is recommended by some, rather than a film-forming type sealer. Granite is indeed special. It is also my understanding that a penetrating-type sealer will NOT protect the surface of the granite per se. But it will minimize the penetration of a stain into the pores of the granite making it easier to clean the actual surface of the granite. As an aside, I read where the polishing process for granite actually depends on the porous nature of the granite to create the slurry that eventually yields the nice shiny stuff that looks so great.

Here is, hopefully, a table from a presentation given by Geof Quick, CSIRO (I have absolutely no idea what that stands for 8-)) Building, Construction and Engineering, Australia listing water absorption values for different materials. These values were measured using ASTM methods. I am not a shill for the sealer industry and am frankly appalled at the price of the sealers and the snake-oil advertising - at least to me - by some. Nonetheless, their yearly use seems to make sense to me, but YMMV.

Jim


img

Re: Kitchen Countertop Material choices

#18

John, not Jessie. Sorry!

Jim Dillon

>

Re: Kitchen Countertop Material choices

#19

Re: concrete

Dan Manturi

>Maintenance. Not a good word. Never thought of that. Yes, It would readily stain.

Interesting that since I started this thread, I learned, to my surprise, as someone suggested, that Corian is NOT that much less expensive than Corian.

In any case, I have had some food for thought here and thanks, all!

Dan

Re: Kitchen Countertop Material choices

#20

One point....

John in New Mexico

>The percentages listed are wt%. Since we're discussing absorbtion of liquids, and rocks tend to be roughly 2.5 more dense than water, a volumetric percentage would be more meaningful. Put more simply, what volume of water will these pores hold as a percentage of the volume of the rock? Answer, devide those percentages by 2.5.

I don't suspect you of being a sealer shill ;), and if people sleep better at night sealing their granite counters, by all means go ahead. I've just heard this chestnut over and over, and it doesn't hold water in my experience.

What I'd really like to see a granite supplier do is take some scraps of different rocks and try to stain them. I may have to start collecting offcuts!

John

Re: Kitchen Countertop Material choices

#21

Good point John...

Jim Dillon

>... and it would help compensate for the differences in pore structure. Thanks for pointing that out.

Jim (who still cannot tell one rock from another - but loves his Corian 8-)).