Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

Website Critique? *LINK*

Posts

Website Critique? *LINK*

#1

Website Critique? *LINK*

Brian in Sandusky, OH

>Hey all,

I'm in the process of putting together a website for pens.

I'm about 95% there...a couple of edits, additions, double check links, and I'm ready.

After working on this for quite a while, perhaps I've got some tunnel vision....lost my objective eye.

If you wouldn't mind, I would appreciate any critiques...flow, design, wording, etc...

Thanks in advance.

Brian


Pencraft

Re: Website Critique? *LINK*

#2

Re: Website Critique?

Robert Henderson

>Very nice. Easy to navigate. A+

Re: Website Critique? *LINK*

#3

Re: Website Critique?

Mike Circo

>Excellent, beautiful, easy to look at and easy to use. (The same holds true for your pens!)

However, the calendar and bar on the right is distracting for the casual visitor. Does the calendar serve a purpose? The other things may be useful for a frequent visitor, but distract for the casual shopper. Perhaps move them to a tab or shrink somewhat.

Just my opinion. Still, better than anything I could do.

Re: Website Critique? *LINK*

#4

Re: Website Critique?

Bartee ( Metro Atlanta )

>Very nice....

I am also a ColdFusion programmer and have used BlogCFC. You have done a very nice job creating a complete website from that software.

My only comment is a pet peave that results from clicking on an image and not have a "back" icon or something to get me back to the previous page.

I would also suggest a small space between photos when you have more thatn on large photo on a page.

Other than those two VERY small items, I would say you have done an excellent job. Nice layout and colors.

Good luck with your new business....

Re: Website Critique? *LINK*

#5

Re: Website Critique?

Al Stokka - Cambrige, Iowa

>Brian,

I didn't go through all the pages, but

Under the "Process" heading, you wrote:

A sanding sealer is then applied to fill any cracks and pores before applying the final finish.


For the non-woodworker/pen maker it might be better to say "natural voids" rather than "cracks", which suggests that you are using inferior materials.

For what its worth,

Al

Re: Website Critique? *LINK*

#6

Steven Antonucci

great overall!

steve antonucci

>I agreed with the other poster about the calendar, although I think I get your intent (trying to make it look like a desk pad?) I like the idea, but I think you give up too much real estate with that content, and it provides no value to your effort. What else could you do over there that helps guide the overall mission- selling pens?

A second thing thatjumped out at me was the "other work"- it's beautiful, but it's unrelated. Unless you expect to cross sell a writing desk with the pen, I'd consider putting it on a second site and focusing on the pens.

That's my 2 cents

Steve

Re: Website Critique? *LINK*

#7

Regarding the calendar...

Brian in Sandusky, OH

>I appreciate the comments everyone...please keep them coming...

In regard to the calendar (and all the content) on the right hand side...

Everything over on the right is a tool for the blog. The calendar not only tells you the day, but by clicking on a day, it will take you to the entry for that day.

That being said...will I be blogging every day? Lord, I hope not!

So I understand the comments, but really, the site is intended to be a blog, and all of those tools over on the right are for the blog.

So yes, I agree....maybe I'm forfeiting some real estate space on the right, but it all goes into the format of the site.

I'm kinda torn, because the blog format will give me subscribers...people sign in their emails, and whenever I have a new blog entry (new pen style, found a new exotic wood, or even just something fun), they will be directed back to the site to see what is new.

So yes, the right hand side may not look great on the site, but if I get 50 subscribers, it will be worth it.

If I get hardly any subscribers, I'll reconsider.

(so sign up!!!) :)

Re: Website Critique? *LINK*

#8

Re: Website Critique?

bill tindal, E.TN

>I found the site attractive, and the text loaded promptly with my dial-up connection. It took 30 seconds for the pictures to completely load which bordered on too slow. It was easy to find relevant material on the site. I wondered about the calender though. It didn't add value to me so If something related to your business could replace it that would be better.

Re: Website Critique? *LINK*

#9

Re: Website Critique?

Howard Norman-Prescott, AZ

>I have one problem with your website. The color you used for the embedded links is difficult to read for my old eyes. I don't know if this problem is unique to my eyesight or if others might have the same problem.

Howard

Re: Website Critique? *LINK*

#10

But.....

Robert Englebrecht

>how many surfers are going to blog about a pen? What am I missing?

Re: Website Critique? *LINK*

#11

Yeah, I know....

Brian in Sandusky, OH

>I'm thinking that the calendar comes down...

Thanks.

bg

Re: Website Critique? *LINK*

#12

Re: Website Critique? Disgusting display of...

Ray Carson in Lawrenceville, NJ

>excellent work. I mean, come on......do you you have to flash your incredibly great looking pens all over the internet? Some people...

I'm joking. Repeat joking.

Your pens are outstanding and the website is well done. I kinda like the calendar but agree that it does take up real estate.

Ray

Re: Website Critique? *LINK*

#13

Doesn't look right in Firefox

Curly Smith

>It doesn't appear to load quite right in Firefox (vrs 1.5.0.11).

The menu on the left overlaps with the center section (for example I see "Gallery of Sold" with the "d" appearing of the left edge of the center frame. By moving my mouse I can see "Gallery of Sold Work" as it highlights).

Additionally, the "..............." extend into the picture, which is rather annoying.

I didn't load IE Explorer for a comparison.

As some others have said, I don't particularly like the brown/gold/tan text. A darker color or one with more contrast would be better with your ivory background IMO. The red "Welcome to Pencraft!" is much more readable than the brown/gold/tan "Welcome!".

Re: Website Critique? *LINK*

#14

Re: Doesn't look right in Firefox

Brian in Sandusky, OH

>I use Firefox version 2.0.0.3, and the site displays fine on it.

Thanks for the comments about the text colors...it looks fine on my browser, but enough people have something that I should do something about it.

thanks

Re: Website Critique? *LINK*

#15

Looks OK to me

Jerry Nicholson

>I am using Firefox 2.0.0.2 and the site looks the same to me in Firefox and IE 6.

Jerry

Re: Website Critique? *LINK*

#16

Re: Website Critique?

Joe Dusel (Vista, CA)

>I also say you did a nice job on the site. I especially like the fact that there is no flash to deal with.

Joe

Re: Website Critique? *LINK*

#17

Re: Website Critique?

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>The site looks great and so do the pens. At first I thought I was looking at Jim Shaver's pens, as that's exactly how he has been photographing his pens for a few years, with the case proping them up.

Jen

Re: Website Critique? *LINK*

#18

Re: Website Critique?

Brian in Sandusky, OH

>Funny you mention the photo background, Jennifer.

Jim is a buddy of mine, and that's exactly where I got my inspiration for the photo backgrounds...I asked his permission, of course.

bg

Re: Website Critique? *LINK*

#19

Re: Website Critique?

Brian in Sandusky, OH

>Thanks, everybody!!!

I've compiled everyone's comments and I will be making some changes this weekend.

I really appreciate it. Sometimes when you work real hard on one particular project, you can't step away and get a fresh eye for it.

Your comments were very helpful!

Brian Gray