Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

DC bag to cartridge conversion

Posts

DC bag to cartridge conversion

#1

DC bag to cartridge conversion

Joe Pack

>I have a PennState 250 DC that uses bags, but is too high for my basement ceiling; I have to fold over about 6" of the top bag. I am considering converting to a cartridge. I looked at the Wynn Environmental page and found a retro kit that would give me 250 sq. ft. of filter capacity, rated at 99.5% for .5 microns. My combined top and bottom 1 micron rated bags give me about 31 sq. ft.

I am wondering if anybody here has experience with these conversions. Would you do it again?

Lastly, an ignorant question...I saw how to do the conversion on the Wynn site, at least for the bottom of the cartridge, but what is the best way to seal the top of the cartridge to keept the pressure from blowing out the top? Sorry, just have brain fade here trying to figure out how to hook something to nothing.

Re: DC bag to cartridge conversion

#2

Re: DC bag to cartridge conversion

Pat Schupbach

>I think Penn State has cartridge conversions available.Dont know about your model.

Re: DC bag to cartridge conversion

#3

Re: DC bag to cartridge conversion

Rich Pearson

>I did the Wynn conversion to my Harbor Freight DC and the volume of air that it now moves is much greater. And the quality of the air in the shop is a LOT better.

I would use Wynn again..great service and knowledgeable advice when I called them.

Re: DC bag to cartridge conversion

#4

Re: DC bag to cartridge conversion

Gary Ratajczak

>Depens on which Wynn cartridge you purchase. The one I bought has one hole in the top, and I have an allthread rod going through it to hold the filter down.

If you are not going to use that configuration, just put in a bolt with a flat washer on each side.

I like the filter, but it does clog more frequently. That's the downside of this type of collector / filter combination. Still, well worth the conversion.

I believe the newer Wynn kit has mesh wire only on the outside. Mine has mesh both sides, and traps the larger chips.

I have a Jet DC1200, and also modified the inlet. Where the dust enters, I used sheet metal to form a ramp so that it forces the dust downward. Also, the hole from the bottom bag to the top filter was extended by about 12" using a sheet metal tube. This helps force dust downward, instead of just entering and going to the the filter cartridge.

It does help, but it's sure not a cyclone!! Going to move that direction pretty soon.

Hope this helps.

Re: DC bag to cartridge conversion

#5

Re: DC bag to cartridge conversion

Ted Wong

>The Wynn filters are efficient but they tend to clog easily in an application w/o a cyclone. The pleats are fairly tight

Re: DC bag to cartridge conversion

#6

Re: DC bag to cartridge conversion

Barry Irby

>I don't have a cartridge or pleated filter on my DC, I still use the bag that came with it, but my bet would be that the pleated filters would be amazing, for a little while. Until the pleated packed up with dust. It seems to me that in a very short time the pleats would pack up and the vast surface area would disappear, buried under a ton of dust.

My ancient shop vac has a pleated filter and it packs full in a hurry. When I empty it, I take the filter off and beat it against the side of the trash can, Holding My Breath, in a cloud of dust. It works better for a while. I don't think you would have the opportunity to clean your cartridges so thoroughly. I think the internal brushes would just brush over the ridges of the pleats and not do anything for the crap packed in the grooves. I think you would have to blow it back into the drum with high pressure air.

I found that removing the bag from My DC and turning it inside out and shaking it out had an amazing impact on performance/air flow. (Huge Cloud of Dust Again) It was a nasty but quick and easy job. Choose a windy day and stand on the up wind side. I suspect superior bags would give you better service in the long run. Ask Bob Dodge.

Re: DC bag to cartridge conversion

#7

Re:The JDC cartridge conversion..

Jamie Donaldson

>...for my DC works very well, and you can facilitate cleaning by blowing compressor air from the outside while rotating the paddle that hits the inside of the pleats. This dislodges a lot of the internal dust and greatly reduces the necessity to remove it for cleaning.

Re: DC bag to cartridge conversion

#8

Re: DC bag to cartridge conversion

Paul Dwight

>I retrofitted the Jet cartridge filter to my old Penn State DC. If I had it to do over again, I would save the money to put toward a cyclone.

The cartridge did improve airflow for a while, and then the pleats got packed with dust and the airflow went back down. The internal paddles do NOT adequately dislodge the dust that gets packed into the pleats. Blowing from the outside with compressed air also helps but was not enough, in my experience, to restore good airflow.

As an experiment, at the end of a day in the shop I used the flappers, blew the cartridge down with compressed air, and let it set overnight. The next morning, I removed the cartridge filter and took it outside for further inspection and cleaning. Packed sawdust was still plainly obvious in the pleats. I laid the filter on its side, beat the outside gently with my palm, and reached up inside with an old paint brush to dislodge the really stubborn areas. I collected as much of the dislodged dust as I could into a bucket. In the end, I ended up with about 1.5 gallons of dust in the bucket -- all of which had remained packed in the pleats after I used the flappers and blew it down with compressed air. The DC pulled pretty well after all that work ... for a day or two.

Cartridge filters are great, but they need an effective pre-separator ahead of them in the air stream. Like a cyclone. Which is what I have now.

If you can't accomodate a cyclone, I would recommend you find some high-quality fabric filter bags. Bob Dodge has posted a couple of times about sources for these bags.

Hope this helps! -- Paul

Re: DC bag to cartridge conversion

#9

I have a shop-made cyclone per Wood Magazine

Joe Pack

>