Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

OT - Cost to have a chandelier installed?

Posts

OT - Cost to have a chandelier installed?

#1

Bart Goldberg

OT - Cost to have a chandelier installed?

Bart Goldberg

>I am planning to replace the chandelier in my two story foyer. I'm also going to have one of those chandelier lifts installed cause I don't like getting up on the 14 ft ladder every time I need to change a bulb.

I would do the install myself, but I don't do heights. Seems like a 4-5 hour job for an experience electrician. So what rates are electricians charging where you live.

I got two estimates - one for $500.00 (seems reasonable), the other is $1354.00 (seems outrageous). Note that this is for just the installation. I'm supplying the chandelier and the lift.

I would have expected to pay an electrician between 50-80/hr. $300+/hr seems a little steep for what looks to be a fairly basic sort of install.

Re: OT - Cost to have a chandelier installed?

#2

Re: OT - Cost to have a chandelier installed?

Nat Robison

>The $500 doesn't shock me. The cost might depend on whether the electrician would elect to do the work on a ladder vs. scaffolding. I wouldn't want to do that job on a A-frame ladder, but I'm not an electrician. Remember, you're paying a chunk for the guy's tools, van, insurance, etc.

Re: OT - Cost to have a chandelier installed?

#3

Bart Goldberg

Re: OT - Cost to have a chandelier installed?

Bart Goldberg

>The $500.00 wasn't the shock - the $1,350.00 was.

Bart

Re: OT - Cost to have a chandelier installed?

#4

Re: OT - Cost to have a chandelier installed?

Dave Arbuckle, Plano, TX

>I have no idea what it would cost, and Plano prices probably don't translate to where you are anyway, but what I would certainly do is ask the higher priced electrician why his price is so much more. Not in a confrontational way, but in a "You impressed me when I met you, but another guy who seems alright quoted a price that's a third of yours. Why the difference?"

I've learned some pretty interesting things with questions like that, and occasionally decided the higher price was the better deal (and occasionally not).

Re: OT - Cost to have a chandelier installed?

#5

Re: OT - Cost to have a chandelier installed?

Neal in San Jose

>On the lower bid, you may have bumped into his minimum. When I had a construction co., There was a minimun size of job that just didn't work. By the time I did the small job, there wasn't enough time left in the day to be productive anywhere else. I would never take a job of less than one full day, and when I was really busy (most of the time), my minumum was two days.

As to why the prices are so different, I'd ask the higher bidder, as someone else suggested. Is this union vs non-union, did the higher priced guy catch something, etc? I also wouldn't be opposed to ask the lower priced guy why he is so low. Is he planning on hitting you with a change order for something "not covered"?

Re: OT - Cost to have a chandelier installed?

#6

Re: OT - Cost to have a chandelier installed?

Mark Nowicki

>The more expensive one is a better businessman that the cheap guy.

By supplying the chandelier and the lift yourself you are cutting out his markup. He is trying to recover it through the installation charge. The markup covers the risk of having to buy a replacement chandelier if he drops or damages the the first one.

He knows that even though you are suppling the parts at first sign of trouble he will get a call because "it has to be an installation problem"

He charges more for high work because of additional risks, setup time, and because he is not afraid of heights.

At $40 to $50 per hour no electrician will stay in business very long.

Mark Nowicki

P.S. How did you arrive at 4 to 5 hours?

Re: OT - Cost to have a chandelier installed?

#7

Bart Goldberg

Re: OT - Cost to have a chandelier installed?

Bart Goldberg

>Mark,

Interesting reply to my posting - Please allow me to respond.

I don't agree that by providing an electrician with merchandise to be installed, I'm cutting out his income. Since when are electricians supposed to increase their hourly rate cause I didn't purchase the fixture from them. Last time I checked, they are not in the Chandelier sales business.

As far as charging more for working heights - I also disagree. If your trade is to perform these tasks, you better be prepared to deal with it. If I wasn't afraid of heights, he would not get a dime cause I would do all the work myself. I don't think that setting up a ladder constitutes "additional set up time". Besides, I'm more than willing to pay for a reasonable hourly rate - I certainly think $75.00/hr is more than fair. This isn't exactly rocket science.

At $1,350.00 for this job, the rate come out to more like over $300.00/hr - thats outrageous.

How did I come up with 4-5 hours? Easy answer - I looked at the instruction manual. I've done more than my share of wiring - I'm an electrical engineer and have done just about every form of residential wiring you can name. A pro should be able to work even fast than me and I can do this job in about 4 hours.

Bart

Re: OT - Cost to have a chandelier installed?

#8

A difference in workloads

Curly Smith

>Your job may fit the lower price guy's schedule, maybe he's between big jobs, but the high price guy already has all the work that he can handle. He's fully booked BUT he'll take your job if the price is right. It's a fairly common practice and it's why it pays to be flexible in scheduling the work, to the extent that you can be flexible anyway.

Maybe it's just the difference between routine work and an "emergency" installation.

Re: OT - Cost to have a chandelier installed?

#9

Bart Goldberg

Re: A difference in workloads

Bart Goldberg

>I agree - I think this is a typical strategy used by many contractors in pricing their work.

Bart

Re: OT - Cost to have a chandelier installed?

#10

What really stinks...

Jason Roehl in Mulberry, IN

>...is when you bid a job real high because you don't want it...then get it anyway. BTDT.

I'd get yet another bid--my guess is that it will confirm that the low bid is indeed a reasonable one. Either that or the guy's not busy and there could be a reason for it. I bet whoever does gets it done in something more like an hour--including set-up and break-down.

I also don't know too many electricians around here who bill at more than about $50/hr for labor. Plumbers get about $60/hr.

Jason