Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

Windows XP Nightmares

Posts

Re: Windows XP Nightmares

#26

convenient statistics...

John in New Mexico

>but I don't buy it. I haven't used a mac since college, but I will say that in my limited experience, Windows is utter junk. The lack of software argument has been a non-starter for the last five years at least, with the exception of games and really specialized stuff. The everyday user can find anything he or she needs from mac or linux and still have better out of the box reliability and security- notice the caveat, out of the box. My one recent complaint with apple is their whole ipod/itunes business not being compatible with most of the rest of the market. No big deal though.

John

Re: Windows XP Nightmares

#27

6.1% market share

Ron in Drums PA

>

Re: Windows XP Nightmares

#29

Re: Mine Too . . .

Dan Donaldson

>There are a couple of programs that I use a lot and have come to depend on that do not have Mac or Linux versions. My decision is probably going to come when I replace this computer. From what I have seen so far, I am not sure that I want any part of Vista, so when this box dies, I am looking seriously about going either Mac or Linux. I have one Linux box running now, but need to take a bit more time to learn what I am doing. Part of my problem is comfort. I have been playing around with micros since before there were PC's (anyone remember the IMSAI or ALTAIR?, or even older, the old PDP8 in OCTAL;-) and am reasonably comfortable sorting out the foibles. New learning curve for a new system. ;-(

Will have to see what happens.

Re: Windows XP Nightmares

#30

Not arguing with the numbers...

John in New Mexico

>PT Barnham nailed it.

I'm just saying the three linux machines I maintain give me no headaches, and the two windows ones do. Mac has a good reputation for reliability also, windows does not. I run linux because I'm cheap. If I weren't cheap, I'd run a mac. I'd only run windows voluntarily if I took imense pleasure spending my time noodling with the silly thing.

John

Re: Windows XP Nightmares

#31

A Good Argument For...

David Yoho

>Gen's problem can probably be resolved by using the advise already mentioned here. XP has several tools available like System Restore and System File Checker that make these types of problems fixable without too much trouble.

However, this kind of thing sure makes another good case for having a dependable backup of your system. With a proper backup routine in place, a problem like this is easily resolved.

David

Re: Windows XP Nightmares

#32

Aren't we missing a major point?

Joe Pack

>I own Mac and PC. I use Mac and PC. Given my choice, I use Mac because I got tired of all the upkeep on the PC, and because of numerous "blue screens." Bonifides established.

More to the point, why should we have to do ANY of this cr** to keep a computer running?? Think about it...if you had a jointer, table saw, television, automobile, ANY piece of equipment that required consistent upkeep that is pretty much beyond most of us without a technical degree or equivilant, we would junk it and the manufacturer would be out of business in two months. Why, then, do we put up with what is available for us? Why should we have to buy backup software, dual drives, virus software, ad nauseum? This is akin to buying a new table saw, but having to upgrade the handwheels, change out the bearings, rewire the electronics every 6 months...You get the idea.

Maybe the problem is US. We accept an inferior setup, expecting to have to do all the "upgrades" and upkeep. Why should we have to put up with computers that don't work unless you are a techie, and then require more $$ to be spent?

Rant off.

Re: Windows XP Nightmares

#33

Re: Disagree

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

> I NEVER have the problems with my computer (Apple) that I read about so often on this forum.

I wonder if a lot of that has to do with the fact Macs make up such a small user base. What, something like 10% or less? I don't know, haven't read for a while.

I've been around Apples since the Apple II/III and the Mac 128, even had a Lisa - those were $10G when introduced. Remember those? Threw it in a dumpster about 10 years ago! :)

Both OS's have their place. Both have their issues. Neither is perfect. Some work better for some people. I bought my wife a Dell laptop for Christmas. I may have been smarter to look at a Mac for her. For her, the Mac may have been easier not being a 'computer' person.

Joe

Re: Windows XP Nightmares

#34

Re: Aren't we missing a major point?

Dan Donaldson

>Without getting into the relative merits of PC's vs Mac's, there are actually very good reasons that a PC is going to be less reliable than a tablesaw or a jointer. The major factor is complexity. How many parts are in a tablesaw? Several hundred? A PC has the equivalent of millions of parts in it. Even if you get space shuttle reliability, with that many parts, something is eventually going to fail. A hard drive works on tolerances that are almost beyond imagination. The heads float on a cushion of air above the disk with tolerances such that a spec of dust is like hitting a boulder with a car.

The software is also an issue. (regardless of which OS it is.) The complexity of modern software is almost beyond comprehension. I used to manage an OEM software activity, and one of the functions had to do with testing and reliability. If you wanted to get the absolute max in reliability, you would have to execute every possible path that the software could take, under all possible conditions. A modern OS has over 10 million lines of code in it. We once did a small study on what it would take to execute every path under all conditions and it turns out that there is not enough time in the lifetime of the universe to do it. ;-) The best that you can do is to try and make failures as invisible to the user as possible and have it recover to a known state. Software vendors accomplish this to varying degrees, which is why some are more reliable from a user standpoint. All software hiccups at times and all software has errors in it. In fact, you can take a piece of code, and knowing how many lines are in it, you can predict the number of errors in it. If you find less, that just means you did not find all of them. This number goes up geometrically with code size. In other words, code that is twice a big, is at least 4 times as complex. Take that to something with 10 or 20 million lines of code, and it is actually a wonder that it ever works at all ;-)

Re: Windows XP Nightmares

#35

"Security by obscurity" is a myth

wilbur

>Ron, many people have advocated that the reason that Macs aren't hit by viruses is because the market share of Macs is small. There are two reasons why this argument is not valid.

1. I can't believe there isn't a hacker out there that isn't just DYING to be the first one to write the first successful Mac virus. Think of the infamy that would bring. Many hackers are driven by ego. Given this, the fact that there hasn't been a successful, out-in-the-wild Mac virus tells me that it's just much much harder to write one. OX X has been out for 6 years now -- plenty of time for the hackers to come up with a virus.

2. One of the most successful viruses of all time was the Jerusalem virus, which came out in 1987. There were less PCs in the world then than there are Macs running OS X today. Even if the market share of Macs is small, there are plenty around to spread a virus, and the internet bandwidth is much faster today than in 1987.

Re: Windows XP Nightmares

#36

Lee Gordon

Re: Aren't we missing a major point?

Lee Gordon

>"if you had a jointer, table saw, television, automobile, ANY piece of equipment that required consistent upkeep that is pretty much beyond most of us without a technical degree or equivilant, we would junk it and the manufacturer would be out of business in two months. "

Now I realize why all the "get a Mac" responses to people asking about PC problems remind me so much of the "Get a SCMS" responses to people asking about radial arm saws. :-)

Re: Windows XP Nightmares

#37

Insurance

Curly Smith

>More to the point, why should we have to do ANY of this cr** to keep a computer running??

You don't have to. If your PC is running and stable then you don't need to do anything but install *some* security updates. You don't need to upgrade your software; in fact it's advisable not to upgrade unless you need the additional functionality. If the system works then leave it alone and let it work. You'll note that I said *some* security updates. If the update doesn't apply to your system then don't install it (it fixes a bug in software you don't have) and turn automatic updates off. The vast majority of updates are for a very small number of people but it's up to you to decide whether you need the carbide bandsaw blade or not.

Why should we have to buy backup software, dual drives, virus software, ad nauseum?

Do you lock your shop? The anti-virus software and firewall keep intruders out, the same as the lock on your shop. Do you change the oil in your car? Do you replace or sharpen dull blades? Hard drives are consumables, they have a finite life - the same as your grinding wheels, saw blades and even the motors on your shop equipment. They may last for years (and probably will) but they will ultimately fail. Backup software and backup drives are insurance against failure. It's no different than the fire insurance you have on your shop... you do have your shop insured don't you?

But I get your point. Computer problems are extremely frustrating. It used to be fairly easy to troubleshoot PC problems since you loaded the drivers and edited the configuration files. When it didn't work you knew what was wrong and how to fix it. Now all of that is automated, when it works it works well and makes the computer easy to use. When it doesn't work it's very difficult to isolate the problem.

The best insurance is to backup your DATA. You don't have to backup the programs - you can always reinstall them. Make regular backups of your data (it's advisable to have your programs store you data in a consistent directory structure like C:\data\word; C:\data\excel, etc and just burn the data subdirectory to a DVD every month or so, with important stuff burned to rewritable CD's on a more frequent basis (and to another hard drive)) and your worries will be few.

Re: Windows XP Nightmares

#38

Uhh, Jennifer's problem

Stuart Johnson

>was the main point of this thread. Was the problem resolved? The mac/pc thing ranks right along with Ford/Chevy or art/craft.

Re: Windows XP Nightmares

#39

remember the IMSAI or ALTAIR?,

Donald Pierson

>...didn't Gates come up with the FAT idea for one of them. Those were the days when we programmed computers...not languages. I wrote the software for Collin's Radio Area Navigation NCS-31 on the Rockwell PPS-4. The PPS-4 was a less than capable computer having four bit add and complement...no subtract, multiply, etc. All development was done by submitting a box of IBM cards to a mainframe and getting memory image printouts that were in hexadecimal...those were the good ole days?!?

Re: Windows XP Nightmares

#40

Re: NO Mac in my future.

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>A couple things people forget. When IBM "gave" their dos configuration to the public, many companies started producing sound cards, video cards, hard drives, monitors, keyboards, modems, and all the other interface cards used in the IBM style PC. Although Microsoft leaves a lot to be desired, they provide an operating system that ties all the various (very cheap) components together into a working system in 99.9% + of the time. Mac, staying proprietary (and expensive) faced none of these problems. The MS system is bloated - in most cases due to trying to interface the millions of various components / drivers used. I would like to see any car manufactures put out a vehicle that would use any brake shoes, alternator, trim strip, window, fuel pump, battery starter etc. built by any manufacturer without modification. I always build my own computers, and have built several for friends and family. I am truly amazed at the fact they work as well as they do considering all the combinations of components. I will put up with MS shortcomings as I do not wish to fatten the coffers of the Apple Kingdom. Try buying an Apple product and then adding a "cheap" storage drive, scanner etc. It is also obvious that virus target the window systems due to the sheer number available. Due to the open architecture needed by using MS for Internet use, vulnerability is increased. I remember the fiasco of the Betamax vs the open architecture of the VHS tapes. I had an expensive Beta system - yeah it had advantages, but the unit cost about $600, last VHS system I purchased was under $100 and did a great job. I really think apple will end up the same as Beta --- great but too expensive for the benefits.

Re: Windows XP Nightmares

#41

Re: Aren't we missing a major point?

Bill Howatt

>Yes, software complexity is a problem and in the comparatively loose PC world the amount of varying quality software and hardware puts a couple of more factors into the equation. The strength of the PC, large amounts of inexpensive hardware and software can also be its Achilles heel.

You read a thread like this one and if you didn't know better you would think that PCs are nothing but a disaster. On the other side of the coin:

I have 4 XP desktops and a laptop all networked and have never, and I mean never, had a BSOD on any one of them.

A couple of these machines have been running for over 4 yrs and I don't notice any slowdown and the OS has never been reinstalled on any of them. This was indeed a problem with Windows98.

I haven't seen hide nor hair of a virus for probably well over 3 yrs.

I'm very glad you MAC users are happy but I have no reason at all to change.

Bill

Re: Windows XP Nightmares

#42

Re: remember the IMSAI or ALTAIR?,

Dan Donaldson

>Ahh, the old cards. How I hated those;-) Do you remember the old Motorola 6800 development board with the Micbug ROM? We used one of those to control a train layout once. Had to load the program through paper tape we made up on an old ASR33. I wrote a simple OS for it, and then the program for the train. Did the whole thing in hand assembled assembler. We didn't have a cross assembler at the time. All of the jumps etc. were hand calculated, and every time you added a statement, you had to recalculate all of them ;-(. The whole thing was a bit over 2K, which is microscopic by todays standards, but by hand, in hex, it seemed huge.

Later, we got hold of a cross assembler for the 6800 that was written to run on a CDC computer. We took the program and modified it to run on the DEC-10 that we had at school. That was a trip because the machines had different word lengths and all of the bit packing routines had to be redone. We did get it working though.

Re: Windows XP Nightmares

#43

Re: Aren't we missing a major point?

Dan Donaldson

>Not a MAC user ;-) I don't like them, but it is mainly because I have been working with and programming in the PC world for so long and don't understand them very well. They have advantages from both a hardware and software standpoint, but I don't care for the proprietary nature of them nor to take the time to figure it out.

That said, I am thinking very seriously of leaving the MS domain when it becomes necessary to go to Vista. So far, I don't like what I see there. I may consider the Mac OS, since it looks like it will be able to run on the Intel platform (Just because I understand that hardware a bit more). I am also looking at Linux, which is a bit more attractive, although it has the same issue with the learning curve.

Ain't it fun ;-)

Re: Windows XP Nightmares

#44

Re: remember the IMSAI or ALTAIR?,

Donald Pierson

>As I recall the 6800 was a physically large chip. I don't know what I did with it but I decided to buy the Tektronics micro development system and it supported the 6800. I don't think I ever used it in an application. That was in the late 70's and I designed hardware and software of for a mil-spec Intel 8080 that controlled radar equipment on a F86 drone. It was my only hardware effort and I like math and software much more. The 8080 was a piece of cake after the Rockwell PPS4 and PPS8 micro. On the pps4 you had do the hand assembly and then bit by bit enter the changes into a ROM simulator.

Re: Windows XP Nightmares

#45

Re: Aren't we missing a major point?

Dave Arbuckle, Plano, TX

>I have 4 XP desktops and a laptop all networked and have never, and I mean never, had a BSOD on any one of them.

Same here, Bill. Except the numbers you cite are higher, I have more machines than that in my house, and of course quite a few I'm responsible for at work. Truly do not recall ever seeing a BSOD on XP. Have had to reinstall the OS twice, on a machine that I didn't want to admit had a hardware problem. ;-)

Dave

aware he's jinxed himself...

Re: Windows XP Nightmares

#46

Lots o' FUD.

Ryan Stagg - Cincinnati

>Larry -

Sorry to pick on you, but there's lots of misinformation here I need to clear up for those that might actually steer a buying decision by this thread.

I'll first say I develop software for the engineering industry on six different platforms - including Windows and Mac.

"Mac, staying proprietary (and expensive) faced none of these problems"

No. The x86 Mac OSX platform uses AGP/PCI video cards (in non-integrated systems), ddr dimm memory, USB, bluetooth, etc. And in truth, since the OS kernel is BSD, it is *much* less proprietary than anything sold by Microsoft.

"Try buying an Apple product and then adding a "cheap" storage drive, scanner etc"

Done and no problem. I use a $75 300MB USB Hard drive to hold all my media, served from a $500 Mac Mini.

"It is also obvious that virus target the window systems due to the sheer number available"

Obvious to whom? I see that bit of argument bantered around quite a bit, and I don't see the logic. If Mac is 6% of the installed base, I would expect to see 6% of the spyware and virii to be Mac-based. I don't. We don't run Mac antivirus software in a multimillion-dollar corporate environment where security is taken *very* seriously.

What is inarguable is that DOS, which every Windows OS up to Vista is largely based on, was never meant to be used in a shared environment, or even a windowing environment. Its very foundation is weak, and everything that it wasn't designed to do in the first place is made worse by the rampant crap-flood of useless functionality that MS adds to its product line.

Mac OSX/BSD/Linux/etc., on the other hand, is based on a now 30+ year-old architecture that was *designed*, from the ground up, for networked, shared environments, and time-slicing. It is open, secure, and time-tested. Vista, to help eliminate some its DOS hangups, is *60% new code*. This might sound good to some of you, but to those of us in the business, it's an eye-roller. It will be years and years before we see the kind of maturity in the Windows line that we have now in System V Unix-based platforms. If ever, assuming Microsoft's continued ineptitude.

"great but too expensive for the benefits"

I understand that people shy away from Mac given the average price over the equivalent Dell, because money is important. But I'm willing to pay a little extra money for a lot of my time in maintenence. I don't think this platform is going anywhere - the industry is huge, and there is always room for a premium product in a big market. Laguna Tools has done just fine in the much smaller woodworking market.

Re: Windows XP Nightmares

#47

Re: Aren't we missing a major point?

Dan Donaldson

>I actually got a BSOD with a spontaneous reset last night. Haven't figured out why. I wasn't doing anything weird, just the stuff I normally do. (of course, there are those that would say that is weird ;-) Running XP PRO SP2 with all of the latest updates.

Re: Windows XP Nightmares

#48

While on this, a question

Dan Donaldson

>As I said, when Vista becomes defacto required, I am probably going to change to something else. One question that I have is whether the Mac OS will support multiple button mice. I know the standard is with one button, but can it use multiples? (equivalent to right click, wheel, and maybe a few more) I use a mouse that has a bunch of programmable buttons and was wondering if the Mac would support that. Mouse and keyboard customization is going to play a big part in where I eventually go.

Re: Windows XP Nightmares

#49

I don't think so  *LINK*

Ron in Drums PA

>


http://www.macvirus.org/

Re: Windows XP Nightmares

#50

Re: Lots o' FUD.

Ron in Drums PA

>XP was the first Windows OS that was not based on dos