Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

OT: GPS Opinions

Posts

OT: GPS Opinions

#1

OT: GPS Opinions

Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL

>I could not find a thread on Car GPS units. If some one finds one, point me to it.

Otherwise, I would like to hear opinions on GPS units for the car. I am using one Garmin) in a rental car while on a business trip. Got me thinking....My daughter's fiance will graduate from Virginia Tech, be commissioned in the Navy, and head off to flight school. I think that a GPS will be a good present for him. Maybe one for my daughter some day, she is the one that gets lost.

Mark

Re: OT: GPS Opinions

#2

Re: OT: GPS Opinions

Howard Norman-Prescott, AZ

>Mark, the Garmin units get good reviews. I have a built in one in my Honda which is very good. The Honda/Acura ones are made by Alpine. Don't know if they have an after market one or not but it they do I would certainly look at that also.

Regards,

Howard

Re: OT: GPS Opinions

#3

Desirable features

Tom Dunlap

>Thanks for starting this thread.

After going to a couple of stores and being thoroughly confused by sales people I have no clue what to put on the "Must-Have" list.

What features are desirable to have in a GPS unit?

Re: OT: GPS Opinions

#4

Like and Dislike

Dustmaker Mike

>I have two different GPS's one for my LOML and one for me. The one I have is on my PDA so the Maps and area are smaller then the store bought ones that stand alone.

What I looked for

Tell me which side of the street the address is on.

Covers the whole US and Canada

Small enough to put in your pocket

Carry between cars

Easy touch screen operations

No Small Buttons

Easy Upgradeable Maps

Tell you the next two turns so you know which lane to be in before you get there

I have a Tom Tom and a Garmin The Tom Tom dosn't tell me which side of the street the address is on or the next two turns. I use this one for work and have all the maps of Europe on it so I keep it. (Worked payed for it)

I have a Garmin Nuvi 650 and Love it. It does all the above plus MP3 Player JPEG viewer. The 660 adds Blue Tooth for some reason plus a little exta cost. I would buy another NUVI 650 if I could find one for a good price.

Re: OT: GPS Opinions

#5

Re: OT: GPS Opinions

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>I've seen the Garmin driving units and they seem to be similar to the older units. We've used GOS for several years now on Lake Erie and my buddy and I each have units. Mine is a Garmin GOS III and his is a Magellan Color track. We have had the units operating side by side in our boats and when it starts getting cloudy or thunder storms begin to move in, the Magellan always loses its signal first. Not exactly what you would want to have happen when you are about to need the GPS the most.

I think Bill Grumbine has a Garmin and when he was here, he really liked it.

Lee

Re: OT: GPS Opinions

#6

Re: Desirable features

Howard Norman-Prescott, AZ

>IMHO, the most desirable feature is a good set of up to date maps of the area(s) where you are going to be using the GPS. Be prepared to update the maps about every two years to keep currant.

After that, a decent display with audible prompts for turns and exits.

The ability to either maximize or minimize the use of freeways.

The Alpine made unit on my Honda, although one of the most highly rated that I know of, still is not perfect. It has errors in the audible directions at times, for example it says it exit at marker 252 on I17 to go to Prescott. The actual marker is 262.

Howard

Re: OT: GPS Opinions

#7

Re: OT: GPS Opinions

Credns

>Scroll to near bottom of page at www.graybeardoutdoors.com. There is a thread pertaining to GPS and this subject is currently being discussed.

Re: OT: GPS Opinions

#8

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Re: OT: GPS Opinions

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

>I have the Garmin 2720, and really like it. I seldom leave town without it.

Jim D.

Re: OT: GPS Opinions

#9

Re: OT: GPS Opinions

Ed Snow

>I had the n-route from garmin which used my laptop it got a bit cumbersome, great screen though. Previously, I had a smaller garmin handheld unit it was nice too; a gps v. Recently, I bought a new car and went to an in dash after market from kenwood which uses the garmin receiver and software. I am not sure if my garmin topo maps are compatible with the new unit. For keeping it in my car, I find this a much better solution.

I would recommend staying with garmin as they have very accurate base maps and update them often. As well the maps typically work for more than one receiver unit, hand held or whatever.

Re: OT: GPS Opinions

#10

Re: OT: GPS Opinions - addendum

Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL

>The model that I am using right now is a 330. 3.5" screen, voice directions, etc.

The only thing I have found (sometimes) disturbing is the voice telling me to turn comes when I am right on top of the turn. Once I know that, I can be more cautious.

Mark

Re: OT: GPS Opinions

#11

Jesper, Denmark

Re: OT: N�vi 660

Jesper, Denmark

>I use a N�vi 660 for travelling all over Europe and am very pleased with it. Since most cities here are very old and not laid out in grid formations like many US cities, finding your way can be troublesome at times.

The extra antenna for receiving warnings of road congestions and roadworks works well, but I am not sure you have that system in the USA - it works with a special radio signal that turns your radio up when there is a road bulletin.

The Bluetooth allows the GPS to function as a hands free cell phone when you have the actual phone in your pocket. My phone does not have Bluetooth, so I have not tried it.

It was chosen because of the large screen - easier to see than the small ones.

Re: OT: GPS Opinions

#12

Re: OT: GPS Opinions - addendum

Paul Woolson

>Isn't that what a wife is for? "Oh by the way, you have 10 feet to get over 4 lanes and make that right turn."

I know this isn't what you guys are looking for but I have a little Garmin 101. Wrist watch size that reads mileage, altitude, as well as what combinations of those I want on the screen at any time (max, min average, etc. ) No maps are available for it as it's not a "when you get lost" gps but a record keeping gps.

Re: OT: GPS Opinions

#13

Re: OT: GPS Opinions

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Bought my wife a Garmin NUVI 660 for x-mas. Works very well with a clear and very readable display.

She does have a problem, however. . . . Getting used to somebody else telling HER where to go! |;-}}}}}

mm

Re: OT: GPS Opinions

#14

Re: OT: GPS Opinions

Barry Irby

>Mark, I know this is not what you asked, but some of the cell phone companies are offering a GPS service with turn by turn voice directions. Verizon has it and my son uses it. Nextel has it and I checked on it, but I have not done it. It was cheap, about ten bucks a month, and that seemed good compared to buying a unit and upgrading maps etc. What stopped me was the cell phone service seems to crap out right when I need it and it does not work if you don't have a cell signal. The cell phone is just barely a phone, they have to send the dogs after me if I tried to use it for anything else.

Re: OT: GPS Opinions

#15

Re: OT: GPS Opinions

ScottS

>I love the Honda/Acura navigation system! It's clearly one of the best available. Unfortunately, when I sold my Acura and bought a Subaru, I found that Acura didn't seem to be selling anything similar to the public! I ended up buying a similar system from Kenwood. It's not as easy to use as the system in my Acura, but works pretty well.

The big thing the Kenwood is missing is POI (Point Of Interest) look-up. The Acura made it extremely easy to find the nearest ATM, gas station, or fast-food restaurant of your choice. The Kenwood makes this a realy chore, which is a shame because I always seem to run low on gas when I'm in unfamiliar areas!

Re: OT: GPS Opinions

#16

Re: OT: GPS Opinions - addendum - addendum

Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL

>The other funny thing, is to my ear, the woman speaking sounds like she grew up with Fat Albert. She is always saying "Turn Bla-Left" or "Turn Bla-Right".

Someone told me that there are celebrity voice down loads so that you have have Mr. T tell you "Turn Left, Fool!!"

Mark

Re: OT: GPS Opinions

#17

GPS - what I would look for *LINK*

wudwork

>Most GPS units today have "auto-routing" capability, you want that. Some units have ability to update maps, you want that. Some units have memory card/stick that you can remove and put into computer, you want that. These store the trip and display breadcrumb track on computer screen. More importantly you can plan a trip on your desktop comptuer, complete with stopover points etc. and "just" save to memory stick and put into GPS. Some GPS units have removable memory that stores the maps. Presently, Navtech maps that cover all North America are ~ 1.45gig. If you get a 2gig memory chip you can store the entire map with EVERY detail. Downloading this much data to memory stick (via USB) takes ~ 4 hours. Downloading this much data directly to USB port on GPS will take ~ 20 hours. Some allow external antenna, you want that. Some can be connected to your car stereo, for audio, this is a very nice feature but might be an issue getting setup in your car/truck. Some units only work on cig. lighter (not battery). This is not always good since you cannot use the unit in hotel room or outside of car without purchasing the $15 adapter. Check out link below and find endless reading. Good luck, Tom


GPS forums, very active