Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

Please help choosing new planer...

Posts

Please help choosing new planer...

#1

Please help choosing new planer...

Michael Caldwell

>I've had the faithful Delta 12 1/2" since the early 90's. Bout worn it out. Thought I try to upgrade, but kind of affraid to. Ratings on both the Delta 13 1/3" and the DeWalt 735 are poor. I'd like a new benchtop. Can you all give me some suggestions?

Thank you so much,

Mike

Re: Please help choosing new planer...

#2

Re: Please help choosing new planer...

Bob Fawcett

>I like my Delta. I have the 2 speed 13" model. Mine hasn't worked as hard as your older one, but I have no complaints.

Re: Please help choosing new planer...

#3

Re: Please help choosing new planer...

Michael Caldwell

>I've read lots of complaints about slipping while feeding the lumber?

Re: Please help choosing new planer...

#4

Re: Please help choosing new planer...

Dave's Not Here

>I'm not sure where you've seen bad ratings on the DeWalt DW735 but in the year and a half that I've had mine it's performance has been exceptional.

About the only negatives I've read about are that it's a little on the noisy side and premature dulling of the knives.

The noise issue is totally unrelated as to how well the planer performs so I consider that a non-issue. A pair of ear muffs takes care of the noise for me.

As to the premature dulling of the knives, I'm not so sure that some of that can't be blamed on the users trying to hog of too much material per pass through the planer. I've not experienced any issues with the knives on my planer. I've read where some people claim that DeWalt has addressed this issue and made some type of changes to the knives but I've yet to read or see anything official from DeWalt that that has happened.

Re: Please help choosing new planer...

#5

Hey....Thank you very much

Michael Caldwell

>I hold much more stock in the opions of the WoodCentral folks.

Again, thank you for clearing up the conception of the DeWalt.

Mike

Re: Please help choosing new planer...

#6

Re: Please help choosing new planer...

Clay Foster

>Michael,

I've had the Delta 13" two speed and was very satisfied with it. Ran a couple of thousand board feet of white oak through it on one job without a problem. I now have the Dewalt 735 and a Grizzly 24" I inherited. For working thick stock down in a hurry, I use the Grizzly. For a finer finish, I use the Dewalt. The Dewalt has more cuts per inch than the Delta so is a smoother finish, but at alomost 100 lbs, is barely portable. And it sounds like a jet engine. I'd buy either the Delta or Dewalt again, depending on what kind of deal I could get and how much I had to spend. The problems I've heard that people had with them I don't think could be attributed to the quality of the machine.

Re: Please help choosing new planer...

#7

Re: Please help choosing new planer...

Ells in Boulder

>Keeping the rollers clean helps a lot. See recent post on this.

Ells

Re: Please help choosing new planer...

#8

Re: Please help choosing new planer...

Todd from San Jose

>Mike,

In the lunch-box class of planers, the DW735 is a terrific design. I sold mine to a friend, because I got a larger planer. But the engineering on that DW735 is really first-rate. The auto cutterhead lock really reduces snipe (on my unit, it was usually negligible). Lots of little details that make it a pleasure to use. Great surface finish, and very little tearout, thanks to the 179 cuts/inch (best in class). 2-speed gearbox, for more efficient planing.

I had one of the early ones that had a weak point in the design, where the drive roller stopped functioning after 3 months of light use. They've since beefed up the design, and sent me a brand new one with this design improvement. My friend now owns it, and it's doing great.

If I were to get another lunchbox, the DW735 would be my choice again. I've also heard good things about the Rigid and the Delta.

Todd

Re: Please help choosing new planer...

#9

Thank you all so much

Michael Caldwell

>Again, thank you for your valuable insight. Thank you for the time you spent writing your experiences.

Thanks for the help,

Mike Caldwell

Re: Please help choosing new planer...

#10

Re: Please help choosing new planer...

arw01

>I bought the DW735 in June 2004. I've run likely over a 1000bf through it by now, most of that in small passes. There was a large run of air dried bull pine that became a deck on a trailer where I was hogging off quite a bit per pass on high speed.

My initial set of knives is still in the planer. There are a couple of knicks on one side, but I try to use the bed evenly each time I use it. Those ridges take literly seconds to sand down with 220, or a couple passes with a hand scrapper.

The machine is noisy, but I wear some earmuffs for that. The fan assisted dust collection definetly helps as well. My only issue is I need to clean my rollers, and some pitch built up on the dust shroud which can lead to some chips laying on the bed.

Someday I will win a set of knives on ebay for CHEAP and then I will rotate my original set of knives.

As a another side note, a friend of mine has one as well which survived WAY for wood than mine sees. It took a nail to the cutter head one day. The head and knives were destroyed, but they were replaceable for less than 1/2 the cost of the planer.

Alan

Re: Please help choosing new planer...

#11

Thanks...Glad to hear your experience

Michael Caldwell

>

Re: Please help choosing new planer...

#12

Re: Please help choosing new planer...

Tony - Memphis

>I have the DeWalt 735 and have had no issues with it. I really like it. It's a heavy thing! Works good and the knives are easy to change. makes really nice surfaces with almost zero snipe.

Tony