Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

faking antiques

Posts

faking antiques

#1

faking antiques

Phil Joines Krum, TX

>I�ve been asked to do a talk to our local historic society about faking antiques. I�ve done some reproductions but never tried to make them look �old�. Are there any good sites on how to identify a fake?

Re: faking antiques

#2

Don't know, but...

John in New Mexico

>I remember there was a FWW article way back (color though, not B&W) that mentioned some of Eugene Landon's techniques for making period pieces look old and really period. The distinction between this and fake comes down to the seller, and as far as I know, Mr. Landon has always been quite open about how he makes pieces look so genuine - so I mean to cast no reflection of any kind on his character. But any info like that would be technique, rather than how to spot them.

Conservators are also typically pretty intrigued by this sort of subject (my sister is one, though paper & photos, not furniture), so that might be a direction to look in.

If you find a good source, post a link. I'm sure a lot of us would be interested.

John

Re: faking antiques

#3

Re: faking antiques

Rick Haverstock

>Phil,

Back in the bad old days I used to refinish furniture for a local antique dealer. One of the best books on the subject was "The Furniture Doctor" by George Grotz, which was both funny and informative. In either this book (or another in his series) there was a chapter or two devoted to faking antiques. Very worthwhile reading and probably in your local library. Checked on Amazon and it's still in print after all these years. Nope, I never faked them.

Good luck.

Rick Haverstock

Re: faking antiques

#4

" The Evil Twins " . . . PBS.

s.mackay@worldnet.att.net

>

Re: faking antiques

#5

Re: faking antiques

Ron

>A book called "Antique or Fake" By Charles Haywood ISBN 0-442-26415-1 which should be available used for a low price or perhaps at your local library system will give you some help in this area.

Re: faking antiques

#6

now that you have some books

Michael Dresdner

>Now that you have some books recommended, if you need some specific advice about a particular look you want, email me. I used to be heavily in the business of making fake antiques as well as convincing antique reproductions.

Re: faking antiques

#7

Thanks

Phil Joines Krum, TX

>I'll check out the books. I think most of these people want to know how to tell the difference between real and fake at a store or auction. I know, study the known pieces and things like hardware and construction methods. There aren't many places in this cultural wasteland to see the real thing.

Considering the amount of furniture made in any one period and the amount for sale now I think the chances are about 1 to 200 against a piece without proven provenance being real. Neither LOML of I am "into" antiques but we do browse occasionally. I'm amazed and amused by all the Spanish and Italian stuff for sale. I wonder where it's really made.

Re: faking antiques

#8

My wife and nephew were into antiques and I spent

Don Henthorn

>many week ends with them at auctions looking at the many pieces of furniture. One auctioneer often brought in huge trucks of furniture from England. Each piece looked different than any other piece, but when I really looked closely I could see units in different pieces that were obviously the same. A block of cubicles, or a couple of drawers, or some other feature that were exactly the same in construction, size and materials. It was obvious some factory somewhere was making "furniture from England" and doing very well at it because the antiquers were buying it like crazy.

Re: faking antiques

#9

More books

Ed Mulligan, Cape Cod

>Fake, Fraud or Genuine? by Myrna Kaye.

The Gentle Art of Faking Furniture by Herbert Cesinsky. Mostly European forms.

Old Furniture by Nancy A. Smith

Re: faking antiques

#10

faking antiques or one into three does go

Ian (in Sydney, Australia)

>As I understand the ethics of the antique market...

start with an antique table

1) place the legs under a new but distressed top

2) place top on new but distressed legs

voila!! you have two antique tables

If you're really enterprising, each leg doth an antique table make

with chest of drawers...

at the very least, each bank of drawers can go into a newly created antique chest

Somewhere I have an article on a local (to Australia) maker who specialises in repairing antiques, in particular replacing missing components. His greatest challenge is replicating the splits found in 150 year old drawer bottoms.

given this, I don't think you can spot a good fake, without using carbon dating.

Re: faking antiques

#11

Re: faking antiques

alton long

>When looking at a authentic antique you see a flat or dull sheen on the wood and hardware. The only finish for wood before varnish was shellac. It did not protect the wood very well and would soon wear off. You can still buy that old look with orange shellac flakes mixed with denatured alcohol and making only the amount you will use. To do a repair on a exposed area, I have cut a piece of wood off of a hidden area to do a perfect wood matching repair and used another wood to repair the hidden area with glaze thinned down and rubbed on. Glaze is a subsutute for years of dirt and discoloration. I use battery acid applied to the hardware with a flux brush . This really kills the shine, but it must be done out doors with eye, breathing and skin protection equipment.You can rub some brown shoe polish on ,if the hardware is to dull.

Re: faking antiques

#12

Re: faking antiques

Sgian Dubh

> "The only finish for wood before varnish was shellac," which only takes us back to roughly the late 1700's or early 1800's, alton: and before that the finishes available in western workshops were mostly restricted to oils and waxes along with natural dyes and things like brick dust. Slainte.

Re: faking antiques

#13

what???

Joe Piotrowski - Chicago Burb's

>

Re: faking antiques

#14

Off by four thousand years

Michael Dresdner

>"The only finish for wood before varnish was shellac."

I suppose one could argue that shellac predates varnish since it is made by insects and not by humans, but there is earlier evidence of varnish usage by humans. Varnishes show up in the tombs of pharohs, more than 4500 years ago, and mentions of varnish show up in writings as early as the ninth century. One could also argue that the paint used in the Lasceaux caves some 15,000 years ago was a type of colored varnish, but at very least I would be comfortable saying that the implication that varnish is only a couple hundred years old is considerably off the mark.