Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

Joint questions

Posts

Joint questions

#1

Joint questions

jeff

>Hi all

A bunch of questions for you experts out there.

1) Anyone know how strong a simple miter (without re-inforcement) joint is for small boxes. Like the kind used in a jewelry box.

No glued bottom.

2) Same question, but with glued bottom.

3) On a box or drawer, a dovetail is stronger due to the locking ability (mechanical strength) then a box joint. But, since the joint is glued, how much stronger?

4) Also, anyone make a blind box joint and the easiest way to do so.

5) Also, how much stronger or weaker is a blind joinr, box or dovetail?

Part of this is just plain curiosity.

But some relates to my work, building stuff.

Jeff

Re: Joint questions

#2

Re: Joint questions

bill tindal, E.TN

>A bunch of questions for you experts out there.

1) Anyone know how strong a simple miter (without re-inforcement) joint is for small boxes. ..... I was taught that stuff should hold itself together and the glue was there to provide stiffness. If you build with that philosophy your stuff may last. Use splines on these joints.

2) with glued bottom. it will be stronger unless cross grain gluing destroys it.

3) On a box or drawer, a dovetail is stronger due to the locking ability (mechanical strength) then a box joint...... If this was true then why were commercial duty rugged boxes made with a box joint. I'm betting a well made box joint is much stronger for shipping lead bricks and the like, if that is the need. There are dovetail drawers holding up just nicely in 300 year old furniture.

4) 5) don't know

Re: Joint questions

#3

Re: Joint questions

Jim Dillon

>Jeff,

Here are just some thoughts with absolutely no data at hand to support the conclusions 8-).

"1) Anyone know how strong a simple miter (without re-inforcement) joint is for small boxes. Like the kind used in a jewelry box.

No glued bottom."

A simple miter is basically an end grain to end grain glue up. Generally speaking, not the strongest. Most pictures that I have seen of small quality-built boxes were reinforced either with corner miter keys or internal splines. Picture frames are another example where a miter key reinforcement really helps because of the stress that can be placed on the frame especially if accidentally stood on its miter edge.

"2) Same question, but with glued bottom"

Much stronger at least when you use plywood where you can glue all the way around. But, depending on the height of the box, may provide insufficient strength near the top of the box where the miter might separate if stressed.

"3) On a box or drawer, a dovetail is stronger due to the locking ability (mechanical strength) then a box joint. But, since the joint is glued, how much stronger?"

My understanding is that a glued box joint is very strong due to the large surface area of the box joint (and the smaller distances between box joints compared to dovetails). I'm guessing here, but I would say that the strength of the glue interface per se is nearly as strong as a dovetail glue joint (if the surface areas are equal), but the mechanical interlocking of the dovetail give it the edge if the glue interface fails.

Jim

Re: Joint questions

#4

Re: Joint questions

Al Stokka - Cambridge, Iowa

>Jeff,

3) On a box or drawer, a dovetail is stronger due to the locking ability (mechanical strength) than a box joint. But, since the joint is glued, how much stronger?

Although I've seen no emperical data, I think the box joint is stronger than a dovetail joint.

4) Also, anyone make a blind box joint and the easiest way to do so.

A mitered box joint appears to be a simple miter joint and is much stronger than a miter joint. Heck, nearly anything is stronger than an unreinforced miter joint.

5) Also, how much stronger or weaker is a blind joinr, box or dovetail?

Again, no empirical data, but I'd rate the joints, from weakest to strongest:

Blind (mitered) box joint

Dovetail

Box Joint

All of the above opinions are based upon all joints being well-made.

Al

Re: Joint questions

#5

some answers

Ian (in Sydney, Australia)

>Jeff

In answer to your questions, I don't claim to be an expert

BUT assuming you're using a cross linking PVA or similar and not hide glue:

1) How strong is a simple miter joint (without re-inforcement). Like the kind used in a small jewelry box. No glued bottom.

plenty strong enough

I've seen test results where even after soaking for a week, the wood failed

2) Same question, but with a glued bottom.

ditto

3) On a box or drawer, a dovetail is stronger due to the locking ability (mechanical strength) then a box joint. But, since the joint is glued, how much stronger?

the forces on a drawer front come from the fact that everytime you open a drawer you are trying to pull the front away from the sides. The relative strength of box vs dovetail joint then will relate to the glue area of the box joint vs the slope used for the DT joint, how many pins and how fine they are. There will be a point beyond which the pins are too fine and/or too far apart to compete with a box joint for strength.

4) Also, anyone make a blind box joint and the easiest way to do so.

no

do you mean full blind or half blind?

easiest way for half blind would be a router with straight cutter and a (Leigh ?) jig

for full blind, you also need to cut a mitre � a shoulder plane is probably the easiest for this.

5) Also, how much stronger or weaker is a blind joinr, box or dovetail?

my answer is the one with teh larger glue area is strongest.

Re: Joint questions

#6

Blind Box Joints

Charles Sharp

>I made some blind box joints on accident once.

I was making drawer boxes out of baltic birch ply. After the glue-up I used a belt sander to sand the fingers flush to the surface of the ply. In doing so I cut through the first layer of the ply. What's kind of strange is that I only did this in the fronts of the boxes where it would show. I glued some veneer on the front and that solved the problem and hid the joint from the front.

Re: Joint questions

#7

Anotehr joint to consider

Lee Schierer, McKean, PA

>There are many ways to build boxes. The other folks have given a pretty fair description of strength.

Here's another joint to consider. A locking rabbet joint. You can cut these on a table saw. It does take a bit of thinking to figure them out the first time, but they don't require any jigs. If you keep the fit fairly tight, these joints are mechanically strong. They also don't look bad either. Here's a box I made for a friend. If you look closely you can see the joint detail in the front right corner.

Lee


img

Re: Joint questions

#8

I forgot about that joint

jeff

>I never thought to use that on a small box.

I have used it on drawers.

Takes me a few minutes to get it right.

Jeff