Suggestions from my experience.
Mac in Indy
>Ed,
Let me tell you what I did and see if you can get any ideas from it. about 5 years ago I built a new shop with a garage attached. about a thousand sq ft overall evenly split between the shop and garage. I knew I wanted wood floors in the shop and I wanted to keep the dust collection out of sight as much as possible to reduce the visual clutter, allowing for a more open feel to the shop. I also knew from the beginning that I wanted really good Air Conditioning so a small forced air system made the most sense for me.
What I came up with was a foundation block stem wall and slab for both areas. In the shop I put in a 2x8 floor joist supported at their ends by treated 2x4 sleepers. I ran 16" wide pipe chases around the perimeter of the shop and one down the middle. I installed plywood subflooring over everything leaving the pieces over the pipe chases removable. On top of that I installed 3/4 oak hardwood (durable and inexpensive floor covering if you stick with off cuts and seconds) again flooring my pipe chase covers with flooring such that they were removable. I reinforced the pipe chase covers with angle iron to keep them flat.
My cyclone is out in the garage area and the piping enters the pipechases through a hole in the block stem wall seperating the shop and the garage. It has a return air vent directly into the shop. The tools are plumbed with their DC up through holes in the pipe chase covers and the blast gates are all above the floor. I also have wiring for the tablesaw running through the pipe chase.
The HVAC unit and piping are all in the atic. I also put small awning windows up high on the south and west walls to admit as much natural light as possible.
Also consider a master switch that disconnects all the power tool circuits (not the lights or non tool outlets). I did this via what is called a contactor switch (here at work we call them relays). Talk to your electrician and he'll know what you are talking about. I like it from a safety and security standpoint. No body goes in my shop and accidently turns on a tool without turning on two switches, the master switch and the tool switch. I have 110 every 4 feet along the perimiter of the shop and a 220 circuit on each wall. If needed I can run circuits through the chase as I ran a couple of spare wires down there from the breaker box before closing in the walls. If I did it again I'd make it easier to add ciriuits up and down out of the box by making removable access panels.
For task lighting I am a big fan of track lighting like you get at the borg (Lowes, HD). I have color balanced florescent general lighting but I have two circuits of track lighting that run above all the tool and bench areas. I can add, move or eliminate task lighting as needed.
What I like about the setup I have is the flexibility I have built into the shop. While I have yet to do a major change I know it is not a problem since my lighting and dust collection can be moved with a little effort. The goal of low visual clutter has been achieved and everything works pretty much as I had envisioned. Let me know if you have any questions either here or via e-mail.
Mac