Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

Semi OT - Lexan or Acrylic?

Posts

Semi OT - Lexan or Acrylic?

#1

Semi OT - Lexan or Acrylic?

Jim in Lakewood, OH

>Folks:

Again I call upon your collective wisdom to help me determine the best material to use for my situation.

I am planning to build some storm windows for my basement (shop)windows. Security is not an issue because each of the windows has burglar bars built in to the frame. I have been considering using either Lexan or Acrylic. I'm leaning towards Acrylic because of the cost, but I am willing to pay for the Lexan if there is a good reason to use it rather than the Acrylic. Both are supposed to be warranted against yellowing for 10 years, and both are highly resistant to breaking (although the Lexan is much more so.) And I understand that the Lexan has vastly superior fire resistance qualities (although if conditions are such that the windows must withstand a fire, I have much bigger problems than whether the plastic in my basement storm windows will survive!)

So what say you all? Are there properties of Lexan or reasons not considered that argue in favor of Lexan? Or, for my purposes, will the Acrylic serve just as well? Oh, and one more question - Can I use regular Glazing putty, or is there something else that I should use? Ladies & gentlemen of the jury, what is your verdict?

Thanks,

Jim

Re: Semi OT - Lexan or Acrylic?

#2

JL

Re: Semi OT - Lexan or Acrylic?

JL

>Look at the UV ratings on both materials. If this is a storm window, it'll be outside, getting lots of UV.

Some acrylates and polycarbonates breakdown after prolonged exposure - they weaken. Get whichever has a better UV resistance.

You said that both were non-yellowing and they both had similar impact resistance.

Re: Semi OT - Lexan or Acrylic?

#3

Re: Semi OT - Lexan or Acrylic?

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>I have clear Lexan corrigated panels with a UV inhibitor roofing my back porch. In the ten-plus years there has been no discernable yellowing. That said, I would go with the acrylic in your application unless there's a heck-of-a-lot of sun exposure, which would make it hazy and brittle over time. Acrylic is much less expensive. If the total cost difference is less than $50, do Lexan.

Clint

Re: Semi OT - Lexan or Acrylic?

#4

Re: Semi OT - Lexan or Acrylic?

Pete LaBelle

>Lexan and Plexiglas are trade names for Polycarbonate and Acrylic plastics. Acrylic is a little harder, stiffer, and easier to clean. Polycarbonate is softer, more flexible, and very tough to fracture. For baaement windows, that would the the stuff I would use, ad it will probably survive a rock from a lawnmower impact much better than teh Acrylic.

UV stabilizers are critical for any plastic that will be in contact with the sun.

Re: Semi OT - Lexan or Acrylic?

#5

Thanks!

Jim in Lakewood, OH

>On two sides of my house the sun is not a problem. And on the all sides of the house, I still have the original glass in the windows and the house is 100+ years old, so apparently stones have not been a problem to this point. I figure that the price difference between the two would be about $100, so I think I'll stick with my original thought and go with the Acrylic.

Thanks for helping me make this decision.

Jim

Re: Semi OT - Lexan or Acrylic?

#6

Re: Acrylic

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>I have used both Lexan (polycarbonate) and acrylic extensively prior to my retirement as an Engineer. Although more expensive and advertised as the answer to all problems, Lexan is not without several faults. The advantages to Lexan are its toughness and flexibility. In sufficient thickness it will stop bullets. However it is VERY susceptible to damage by solvents � some that are used to normally clean windows or areas around windows. See this link for a list of solvents not to be used : http://www.grote.com/tech/maintenance/cleaning_materials.html

Note: I have used Lexan as shields for assembly equipment, several of the shields cracked and some actually fell off the machines. After investigation we found a solvent used over 25 foot away in a closed tank was responsible. The very low concentration of the vapors were causing the Lexan to stress crack over a short period of time.

Another problem with using polycarbonate is its softness and scratch resistance, Acrylic is far better in these properties and will retain its transparency and appearance much better over time. The only place I would use Lexan is where I needed the resistance to impact or cutting � to deter burglars or bullets. The cost factor is another incentive to use Acrylic - but I would use Acrylic in your case even if it cost more.