Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

Reversible motor question

Posts

Reversible motor question

#1

Reversible motor question

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>I installed a reversible motor in my Viel sander/grinder sold at LV

http://www.leevalley.com/wood/page.aspx?c=2&p=44884&cat=1,43072

To change motor direction on that motor, I only need to switch two leads in the motor. So I used a DPDT switch to do that, and I use a standard SPST switch to feed power to the motor.

Everything works as intended, and in order to avoid accidentally switching direction under power (I don't think the motor would like that) I've put a "locking device" on the direction switch. That works too.

But on the direction switch there's a "neutral" position where the two "direction" leads get no power. What would happen if I turned the power on without choosing a direction, i.e. switch in "neutral"? My guess would be that nothing will happen, but I don't feel like being proven wrong and blow up the motor, just to find out...

Would the answer be motor-specific?

Thnx,

DC

Wondering if I asked that question before

Re: Reversible motor question

#2

Re: Reversible motor question

Bill Howatt

>My guess is that if your DPDT switch is in the usual induction motor start-winding/capacitor circuit it would be out of the circuit when the switch is in neutral and the motor would not start. If so, you wouldn't want it to sit in that state for any period of time as it would overheat.

You can get DPDT switches without the neutral postion but do you think the risk is all that great (if my analysis is correct)? When you turn the motor off the DPDT switch will be left where it is when the motor was running. Even if it is in neutral, your operation is attended so you will notice right away that your motor didn't start when you turn it on.

Bill

Re: Reversible motor question

#3

Re: Reversible motor question

Rick Christopherson

>Denis,

This is outside of my area of expertise, but I believe there will be two alternatives. a) the circuit is not complete and absolutely nothing will happen. b) At least one winding is getting energized, but not enough to get the motor turning. This is the one you need to worry about.

If you turn on the main power switch and hear the motor hum but not turn, then turn the switch off immediately. As long as this is just for a second, the motor will be fine.

Re: Reversible motor question

#4

Re: Reversible motor question

Wayne in Topanga

>Dennis,

Changing the direction switch with the motor running would not affect the motor direction. The motor has to stop to engage the start winding. The starting winding conection relative to the running connection is what determines the starting direction. Once the motor comes up to speed the internal start winding switch disconnects which is why changing the direction switch while running will have no effect on motor operation.

Having the direction switch in the center off position would not be good and could damage the motor. The motor will just hum and draw high amperage but will not start. Be very careful to never leave the direction switch in the center off position or better yet replace it with one that doesn't have a center off position.

Hope this clears things up for you.

Wayne

Re: Reversible motor question

#5

No problem

Dan Donaldson

>I have a couple of motors wired that way and when the switch is in the center off position, nothing happens at all. It doesn't draw any current.

Re: Reversible motor question

#6

You would get halfway

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>You would get halfway between 1750 RPM clockwise and 1750 RPM counter-clockwise, which is 0.

If you wired it like I have in the diagrams on my website, when the switch is in the middle position, both poles are open, so the motor is getting no power from either hot (assuming 220V).

OF course that's assumin that you have a NO switch and not a NC switch, which I don't think applies to DPDT switches anyways.

Happy Woodworking!

Re: Reversible motor question

#7

No one asked why

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>No one asked WHY you are wanting to reverse the direction of that type of sander? Having used and made sanders I know that having the belt turn upwards is really good for launching wood and lauching other such things upwards.

Happy Woodworking!

Re: Reversible motor question

#8

Re: No one asked why

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>Here's why: I don't plan to use it as a sander. I'm hoping to use it as a replacement for my bench grinder to sharpen my tools. I'm not concerned about launching tools up, can't see that happening, but I can picture slicing belts with the tool in its "normal" mode of operation (belt going down).

I prefer a flat grind on my tools, which the grinder can't provide.

DC

Re: Reversible motor question

#9

Re: May burn up motor if left under power.

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>Reversing most induction (non brush type) motors is accomplished by changing the start winding poles positions in relation to the run windings poles in the motor. this is done by changing the start winding leads in relation to the run winding terminals. IE: label run winding terminals A & B, & start winding leads C & D, with A & C tied together and B & D tied together the motor will run CW. With A & D tied together and B & C tied together the motor will run CCW. In both cases power is applied to the A & B terminals. If power is applied to the run winding and the reversing switch you installed only provides the start winding connection / reversal, the motor will not start with the reversing switch in the neutral position (unless you spin it rapidly by hand). However, with the start switch on, power to the run winding will still be "on" and connected to the input power lines. A standard induction motor will draw high amperage in this "stalled" position and start heating rapidly. In a matter of less than one to a maximum of five minutes most motors will become hot enough to degrade or melt the insulation on the wiring. The windings will then short out and let the smoke out. Cooked motor. Some "reversing" switches also function as a start or "on" switch and interrupt power to all the motor windings in the neutral position. Those obviously are safe to leave in any position. By the way, once the motor is up to operating speed, you can put the reversing switch in any position without a problem as the starting winding switch (in the motor) disconnects the start windings once the motor is up to speed.

Re: Reversible motor question

#10

Re: Reversible motor question

Dave LaPine

>Funny thing- We just got done doing the same thing with a motor on a metal lathe. The answer for us was a reversing drum switch. It is a Dayton switch from Grainger part #2X440 about $40.00. It's much more comfortable to use than a small toggle switch. The wiring schematic that it has is simple to figure out. (If I can do it anyone can.) We were also afraid that the motor would reverse instantly but there must be a centrifugle switch that won't allow it unless it's almost stopped. It works perfect. Hope this may help you. Dave